logo
New study casts doubt on BART's fare evasion focus

New study casts doubt on BART's fare evasion focus

CBS News20-05-2025
As a transit agency that relies heavily on fare collection, BART is focusing on preventing fare evasion. But a new study casts doubt on the effectiveness of stopping freeloaders to improve public safety on the trains.
In 2020, BART asked the non-profit Center for Policing Equity to evaluate how well BART Police interacted with the ridership. Now, with BART spending $90 million in its quest to combat fare evasion as a way of increasing public safety, it paid for a new study. The results weren't exactly complimentary.
"Some folks will say, A plus B equals C. So, in this case, not paying the fare will result in loss of income and violence or disorder on the train," said CPE vice president Hans Menos. "Unfortunately, science needs more than that intuitive connection, right? We need a little bit more, and I don't think that's necessarily present. Our findings suggest that it isn't present."
On Monday, crews were installing the new evasion-resistant gates at the Pleasant Hill station, and they're already up and running in Lafayette. But the study, released last week, accuses BART of not having an accurate understanding of fare evasion, from both a financial and public safety perspective.
It concluded: "... BART's focus on fare evasion recovers minimal revenue, may be addressing an overstated problem, and is not effective at curbing incidents that make riders feel uneasy in the system." Menos said there also didn't appear to be any clear strategy behind BART's efforts.
"An unscientific, not clearly communicated approach that focuses on the idea that fare evaders are A, costing them a lot of money, which we did not find evidence on, and B, creating a lot of crime, which again we did not find evidence on. So, absent those two approaches, why they are doing this remains very unclear."
CPE, which focuses on social justice issues, said the big problem is not the gates, but the stepped-up efforts of BART police in fining or arresting people, often minorities, for evading the fares. One BART rider also sees a difference between crime and fare evasion, but he favors more enforcement.
"I still see people forcing themselves through the new gates at Civic Center. So, it doesn't matter what kind of gates they have. They still try their way to get in," said BART rider Junius Setiawan. "I think they're better off getting more people in the train, you know, checking tickets or whatnot, or ambassadors on the trains, rather than these gates. I don't see the point of these gates."
BART refused to go on camera on Monday, but in a statement, it said that despite the study findings, it doesn't plan to change its approach.
"These new gates serve as a powerful deterrent against fare evasion and as a result will reduce the number of interactions between BART PD and would-be fare evaders," the statement said. "We look forward to new fare gates being installed at all 50 BART stations by the end of this year."
In the past, BART has claimed that it loses $25 million a year to fare evasion, a number it backed away from on Monday. But BART insists the fare gates are working and claims a 17% drop in crime last year. If BART is concerned about people not paying to ride, they really won't like the suggestion of a rider named Irene from Martinez.
"It's another way of stopping people who need a service, who can't afford it, not to get it. You know, to make sure they don't get it," said Irene. "My opinion is that there are things that should be free. Housing should be free, food should be free, education should be free, transportation should be free."
That's not how BART sees it. And whether or not there's a scientific connection between fare evasion and bad behavior, it's something BART is willing to take on faith.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Secret Service issued suspensions for several agents involved in securing rally where Trump survived assassination attempt
Secret Service issued suspensions for several agents involved in securing rally where Trump survived assassination attempt

CNN

time19 minutes ago

  • CNN

Secret Service issued suspensions for several agents involved in securing rally where Trump survived assassination attempt

The US Secret Service has issued suspensions for several agents involved in securing the Pennsylvania rally last year where Donald Trump was hit in the ear and a rallygoer was killed by a would-be assassin, according to multiple sources. At least two of those agents are appealing their suspensions, sources with knowledge told CNN, and no Secret Service employees have served their suspension, the sources added. Several agents at the service's Pittsburgh field office, along with one agent on Trump's detail that day and a counter sniper, have each been issued suspensions ranging from a few weeks to over a month, sources familiar with the process told CNN. On July 13, 2024, gunman Thomas Matthew Crooks opened fire on Trump during the rally in Butler, Pennsylvania. The shooting left one rally attendee dead and two others in critical condition. Several Congressional investigations and federal reports, including the Secret Service's own analysis, found multiple failures that day including communication breakdowns with local police who spotted the shooter and confronted him on a nearby roof before he took aim at Trump. Members of Congress said that in their investigations, agents continued to place blame on one another and that no one person was in charge of decisions that day. Former and current law enforcement officials have expressed frustration in interviews with CNN that those in more senior leadership positions, specifically those in Trump's detail, have not been held accountable for the serious failures that day. 'None of those operational people have been held accountable, some were even promoted,' one former senior agency official told CNN. Former Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle abruptly resigned from the agency last year amid intense scrutiny of security lapses related to the assassination attempt.

Secret Service issued suspensions for several agents involved in securing rally where Trump survived assassination attempt
Secret Service issued suspensions for several agents involved in securing rally where Trump survived assassination attempt

CNN

time23 minutes ago

  • CNN

Secret Service issued suspensions for several agents involved in securing rally where Trump survived assassination attempt

The US Secret Service has issued suspensions for several agents involved in securing the Pennsylvania rally last year where Donald Trump was hit in the ear and a rallygoer was killed by a would-be assassin, according to multiple sources. At least two of those agents are appealing their suspensions, sources with knowledge told CNN, and no Secret Service employees have served their suspension, the sources added. Several agents at the service's Pittsburgh field office, along with one agent on Trump's detail that day and a counter sniper, have each been issued suspensions ranging from a few weeks to over a month, sources familiar with the process told CNN. On July 13, 2024, gunman Thomas Matthew Crooks opened fire on Trump during the rally in Butler, Pennsylvania. The shooting left one rally attendee dead and two others in critical condition. Several Congressional investigations and federal reports, including the Secret Service's own analysis, found multiple failures that day including communication breakdowns with local police who spotted the shooter and confronted him on a nearby roof before he took aim at Trump. Members of Congress said that in their investigations, agents continued to place blame on one another and that no one person was in charge of decisions that day. Former and current law enforcement officials have expressed frustration in interviews with CNN that those in more senior leadership positions, specifically those in Trump's detail, have not been held accountable for the serious failures that day. 'None of those operational people have been held accountable, some were even promoted,' one former senior agency official told CNN. Former Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle abruptly resigned from the agency last year amid intense scrutiny of security lapses related to the assassination attempt.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store