Appeal for 12 Hong Kong activists concludes amid unfair trial claims
HONG KONG - An appeal hearing for 12 pro-democracy activists convicted of subversion under Hong Kong's national security law ended earlier than expected on July 17, with two defence lawyers arguing that their clients had not received a fair trial.
The appeal stems from the "47 democrats" case, named for the number of activists who were arrested and charged with conspiracy to commit subversion in 2021.
Forty five of the defendants were jailed last year for holding an unofficial primary election in July 2020, soon after Beijing imposed a sweeping national security law in response to pro-democracy protests the year before.
Their sentences ranged between four to 10 years. Two were acquitted, while 12 appealed the conviction on July 14.
Judge Jeremy Poon said on July 17 that the judgment would be made within nine months given the case's complexity. After that, it would still be possible to seek an appeal to Hong Kong's highest court.
Government prosecutor Andy Lo said on July 17 that the case involved "an unprecedented conspiracy".
Erik Shum, representing former lawmakers Helena Wong and Lam Cheuk-ting, said "the court sentencing process was wrong in principle, and hence the ultimate sentence was incorrect and it should be toned down". Wong was sentenced to 6 years and 6 months while Lam was sentenced to 6 years and nine months.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore Fatal abuse of Myanmar maid in Bishan: Traffic Police officer sentenced to 10 years' jail
Singapore Man charged over manufacturing DIY Kpods at Yishun home; first such case in Singapore
Singapore HSA launches anti-vaping checks near 5 institutes of higher learning
Singapore $7,000 fine for eatery chain involved in ByteDance food poisoning case
Singapore Bicycle wheel-inspired care model used to improve trauma outcomes in central S'pore
Life 11 new entries on Singapore's Bib Gourmand list, including three re-entries at Old Airport Road
Singapore NEA monitoring E. coli at Sentosa beaches after elevated bacteria levels delay World Aquatics events
Singapore 15 under police probe for sharing Singpass credentials used in scams
During the four-day hearing, two defence lawyers argued on July 16 that the three judges who presided over the earlier trial had frequently interrupted some defendants during cross-examination.
"The trial court was interventionist from very early on," said Robert Pang, a lawyer for unionist Winnie Yu. He said that the court repeatedly disallowed questions on grounds of irrelevance.
Lawyer Steven Kwan said his client, activist Owen Chow did not receive a fair trial as "his evidence was disbelieved very early on". He also said the judges posed 45 per cent of all the questions put to Chow, who was later sentenced to 7 years and 9 months.
Prosecutor Derek Lau said judges had the right to ask questions, noting it was not a jury trial.
"There is no unfairness that can be observed, that is to the prejudice of the defender in these questions," Mr Lau said.
Prosecutors had said the defendants sought to paralyse the government and force the city's leader to resign by securing a legislative majority to indiscriminately veto budget proposals.
Under Article 52 of Hong Kong's mini-constitution, the Basic Law, the chief executive must step down if the legislature twice rejects the government's budget.
Lawyer Trevor Beel, representing activist Gwyneth Ho, said on July 16 that legislators had a duty to use whatever legitimate means to negotiate with the government and that the Basic Law allows for a budget not to be passed.
Hong Kong was handed back to China by Britain in 1997 with a promise of freedom and autonomy under the "one country, two systems" framework, and eventual universal suffrage under the Basic Law.
If Ms Ho wanted to achieve dual universal suffrage and an effective legislature, then it "was not radical, and this is not against the principle of one country, two systems," Beel said. REUTERS
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


AsiaOne
6 hours ago
- AsiaOne
Daily roundup: Nasi padang chain Hjh Maimunah to introduce colour-coded price labels — and other top stories today, World News
Stay in the know with a recap of our top stories today. 1. Nasi padang chain Hjh Maimunah to introduce colour-coded price labels Popular nasi padang chain Hjh Maimunah will soon be launching colour-coded price labels for its dishes... » READ MORE 2. Etomidate found in blood of 2 people involved in fatal Punggol Road accident in May: HSA Etomidate has been detected in the blood samples of two people involved in a fatal road accident in Punggol Road in May, the Health Sciences Authority (HSA) said on July 25... » READ MORE 3. Michelin Guide Singapore 2025: Sushi Sakuta promoted to 2 stars, 1 restaurant earns its first star After the announcement of the Michelin Bib Gourmand results on July 17, it's now time for the full selection of the Michelin Guide Singapore 2025, now in its ninth edition... » READ MORE 4. Trump, McMahon and Undertaker pay tribute to Hulk Hogan Donald Trump and wrestlers Vince McMahon and The Undertaker have added to the flood of tributes to Hulk Hogan — as a frantic 911 call ahead of the WWE hero's death was released... » READ MORE editor@


AsiaOne
10 hours ago
- AsiaOne
Etomidate found in blood of 2 people involved in fatal Punggol Road accident in May: HSA, Singapore News
SINGAPORE — Etomidate has been detected in the blood samples of two people involved in a fatal road accident in Punggol Road in May, the Health Sciences Authority (HSA) said on July 25. The pair were riding in a car that collided with a bus at about 2.50pm on May 13. The police discovered 42 e-vaporisers and more than 1,200 pods in the car, with some tested by HSA to contain etomidate, the authority said in a statement. The 30-year-old male driver was conscious when taken to hospital after the accident. His passenger, a 28-year-old woman, was taken unconscious to hospital where she subsequently died. "The driver is currently assisting the police and HSA in investigations regarding both the accident and e-vaporiser-related offences," the authority said. Etomidate, which is used as an anaesthetic agent, is allowed for use only in clinical settings and subject to strict conditions, according to HSA. On July 20, Health Minister Ong Ye Kung said the Health and Home Affairs ministries are working to list the substance under the Misuse of Drugs Act, amid a growing trend of e-vaporisers — or vapes — containing the drug. working to list the substance under the Misuse of Drugs Act, "The etomidate found in e-vaporisers or supplied in oil capsules or formulations to be inhaled directly into users' lungs are not medical products and are prohibited," HSA said in its statement. When used in vapes, etomidate can have serious adverse effects, it added. This includes causing involuntary movements or spasms of muscles, confusion, seizures and psychosis. It can also lead to physical dependence. Etomidate is currently listed under the Poisons Act. Under this law, abusers face a fine and sellers can face up to two years in jail. With etomidate listed as a Class C drug under the Misuse of Drugs Act in future, HSA said this will enable tougher actions against suppliers and users of vapes with etomidate. Users can be subject to supervision and mandatory participation in a rehabilitation programme or committed to drug rehabilitation centres, similar to drug abusers. Those who repeatedly reoffend or commit other serious offences can also be jailed for at least a year. "HSA strongly warns consumers who are using e-vaporisers to stop its use immediately," it said. Possessing, using or buying vapes carries a maximum fine of $2,000. Anyone who distributes, imports or sells vapes and their components can be jailed for up to six months and fined up to $10,000 for the first offence. Reoffenders can face up to a year in jail and fined up to $20,000. [[nid:718014]] This article was first published in The Straits Times . Permission required for reproduction.


New Paper
12 hours ago
- New Paper
Vape-linked anaesthetic drug detected in 2 people involved in fatal Punggol Road crash: HSA
Etomidate has been detected in the blood samples of two people involved in a fatal road accident in Punggol Road in May, the Health Sciences Authority (HSA) said on July 25. The pair were riding in a car that collided with a bus at about 2.50pm on May 13. The police discovered 42 e-vaporisers and more than 1,200 pods in the car, with some tested by HSA to contain etomidate, the authority said in a statement. The 30-year-old male driver was conscious when taken to the hospital after the accident. His passenger, a 28-year-old woman, was taken unconscious to the hospital where she subsequently died. "The driver is currently assisting the police and HSA in investigations regarding both the accident and e-vaporiser-related offences," HSA said. Etomidate, which is used as an anaesthetic agent, is only allowed for use in clinical settings and subject to strict conditions, according to the authority. On July 20, Health Minister Ong Ye Kung said that the Ministry of Health and Ministry of Home Affairs are working to list the substance under the Misuse of Drugs Act, amid a growing trend of e-vaporisers, or vapes, containing the drug. "The etomidate found in e-vaporisers or supplied in oil capsules or formulations to be inhaled directly into users' lungs are not medical products and are prohibited," HSA said in its statement. When used in vapes, etomidate can have serious adverse effects, it added. This includes causing involuntary movements or spasm of muscles, confusion, seizures and psychosis. It can also lead to physical dependence. Etomidate is currently listed under the Poisons Act. Under this law, abusers face a fine and sellers can face up to two years in jail. With etomidate listed as a Class C drug under the Misuse of Drugs Act in the future, HSA said that this will enable tougher actions against suppliers and users of vapes with etomidate. Users can be subject to supervision and mandatory participation in a rehabilitation programme, or committed to drug rehabilitation centres, similar with drug abusers. Those who repeatedly reoffend or commit other serious offences can also be jailed for at least a year. "HSA strongly warns consumers who are using e-vaporisers to stop its use immediately," it said. Possessing, using or buying vapes carries a maximum fine of $2,000. Anyone who distributes, imports or sells vapes and their components can be jailed for up to six months and fined up to $10,000 for the first offence. Reoffenders can face up to a year in jail and fined up to $20,000.