'Can't win': Clarkson skeptical on Origin timing
Four-time premiership coach Alastair Clarkson believes squeezing State of Origin into an already packed calendar will be a difficult task for the AFL.
Since taking over from Gillon McLachlan in 2023, AFL boss Andrew Dillon has made no secret of his desire to revive representative football.
After the successful return of the Indigenous All-Stars this year, Origin could be back next February, although the AFL are yet to make any official announcement.
Coaches such as Carlton's Michael Voss believe a pre-season window is the best time for representative matches.
Clarkson, in his third season in charge of North Melbourne following four flags at Hawthorn, rates Origin as a "great concept".
"The big challenge for the AFL and all the players is when during the season do you play it?," Clarkson said on Thursday.
"That's the most difficult part.
"From a club perspective and a player's perspective, the challenge with it if it's right at the start of the season, players don't want to risk getting significant injuries and then perhaps losing significant chunks of the season."
"That's why it was moved."
Clarkson also cautioned against staging any Origin games near finals as the best players wouldn't be available.
"You just can't win with it," he said.
"We all love the concept of State of Origin. We see just how popular it is in rugby league, but as we become a national game, it's been really difficult to work out where it fits into the schedule.
"We've all got enormous passion for it, but just working out where it fits has been the reason why it hasn't been in the program."
The last Origin game took place in 1999 when Victoria defeated South Australia in front of only 26,063 fans at the MCG.
Victoria played an All-Stars team to raise money for bushfire relief in 2020, while Victoria and a Dream Team clashed in 2008 to mark 150 years of Australian football.
Voss witnessed how important the Indigenous All-Stars match was to Zac Williams and Jesse Motlop.
"Any opportunity that our players get to be able to represent something is worthwhile doing," he said on Thursday.
"In principle, I would be hugely supportive of it because they're life experiences."
Richmond coach Adem Yze believes most players would rather represent their state than take part in a traditional pre-season hitout.
"You've got to play a game anyway so why wouldn't you want to play with the Big V jumper and use that as one of your practice games leading into the season," Yze said.
Captains of the 18 clubs were broadly in favour of Origin when pressed about it on the eve of the season.
Four-time premiership coach Alastair Clarkson believes squeezing State of Origin into an already packed calendar will be a difficult task for the AFL.
Since taking over from Gillon McLachlan in 2023, AFL boss Andrew Dillon has made no secret of his desire to revive representative football.
After the successful return of the Indigenous All-Stars this year, Origin could be back next February, although the AFL are yet to make any official announcement.
Coaches such as Carlton's Michael Voss believe a pre-season window is the best time for representative matches.
Clarkson, in his third season in charge of North Melbourne following four flags at Hawthorn, rates Origin as a "great concept".
"The big challenge for the AFL and all the players is when during the season do you play it?," Clarkson said on Thursday.
"That's the most difficult part.
"From a club perspective and a player's perspective, the challenge with it if it's right at the start of the season, players don't want to risk getting significant injuries and then perhaps losing significant chunks of the season."
"That's why it was moved."
Clarkson also cautioned against staging any Origin games near finals as the best players wouldn't be available.
"You just can't win with it," he said.
"We all love the concept of State of Origin. We see just how popular it is in rugby league, but as we become a national game, it's been really difficult to work out where it fits into the schedule.
"We've all got enormous passion for it, but just working out where it fits has been the reason why it hasn't been in the program."
The last Origin game took place in 1999 when Victoria defeated South Australia in front of only 26,063 fans at the MCG.
Victoria played an All-Stars team to raise money for bushfire relief in 2020, while Victoria and a Dream Team clashed in 2008 to mark 150 years of Australian football.
Voss witnessed how important the Indigenous All-Stars match was to Zac Williams and Jesse Motlop.
"Any opportunity that our players get to be able to represent something is worthwhile doing," he said on Thursday.
"In principle, I would be hugely supportive of it because they're life experiences."
Richmond coach Adem Yze believes most players would rather represent their state than take part in a traditional pre-season hitout.
"You've got to play a game anyway so why wouldn't you want to play with the Big V jumper and use that as one of your practice games leading into the season," Yze said.
Captains of the 18 clubs were broadly in favour of Origin when pressed about it on the eve of the season.
Four-time premiership coach Alastair Clarkson believes squeezing State of Origin into an already packed calendar will be a difficult task for the AFL.
Since taking over from Gillon McLachlan in 2023, AFL boss Andrew Dillon has made no secret of his desire to revive representative football.
After the successful return of the Indigenous All-Stars this year, Origin could be back next February, although the AFL are yet to make any official announcement.
Coaches such as Carlton's Michael Voss believe a pre-season window is the best time for representative matches.
Clarkson, in his third season in charge of North Melbourne following four flags at Hawthorn, rates Origin as a "great concept".
"The big challenge for the AFL and all the players is when during the season do you play it?," Clarkson said on Thursday.
"That's the most difficult part.
"From a club perspective and a player's perspective, the challenge with it if it's right at the start of the season, players don't want to risk getting significant injuries and then perhaps losing significant chunks of the season."
"That's why it was moved."
Clarkson also cautioned against staging any Origin games near finals as the best players wouldn't be available.
"You just can't win with it," he said.
"We all love the concept of State of Origin. We see just how popular it is in rugby league, but as we become a national game, it's been really difficult to work out where it fits into the schedule.
"We've all got enormous passion for it, but just working out where it fits has been the reason why it hasn't been in the program."
The last Origin game took place in 1999 when Victoria defeated South Australia in front of only 26,063 fans at the MCG.
Victoria played an All-Stars team to raise money for bushfire relief in 2020, while Victoria and a Dream Team clashed in 2008 to mark 150 years of Australian football.
Voss witnessed how important the Indigenous All-Stars match was to Zac Williams and Jesse Motlop.
"Any opportunity that our players get to be able to represent something is worthwhile doing," he said on Thursday.
"In principle, I would be hugely supportive of it because they're life experiences."
Richmond coach Adem Yze believes most players would rather represent their state than take part in a traditional pre-season hitout.
"You've got to play a game anyway so why wouldn't you want to play with the Big V jumper and use that as one of your practice games leading into the season," Yze said.
Captains of the 18 clubs were broadly in favour of Origin when pressed about it on the eve of the season.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
25 minutes ago
- Perth Now
Teen schoolgirl awestruck after winning unexpected Australian title
An emotional 16-year-old schoolgirl is being hailed as the future of Australian swimming after earning world championship selection. Sienna Toohey left seasoned campaigners including Kaylee McKeown and Cate Campbell in awe with a stunning swim at Australia's selection trials in Adelaide on Tuesday night. The Albury teen, who only started swimming because she wanted to play water polo, triumphed in the women's 100m breaststroke. Toohey's victory, in a personal best time of one minute 6.55 seconds, secured her berth at the world titles in Singapore from July 27 to August 3. 'All of these people being my idols, now I get to be on the team with them,' Toohey said. 'These are people that I was watching two years ago, saying I want to be like them.' The daughter of the relieving principal at Albury High School, Toohey initially wanted to be a water polo player. 'My parents told me that I couldn't do water polo if I didn't swim, so I started swimming,' she said. 'And then my water polo progressed and my swimming was too at the same time. I got to the point where I had to choose swimming or water polo. Obviously, I chose swimming — it was the right choice.' Cate Campbell comforts Sienna Toohey after the awesome feat. Credit: AAP Five-time Olympic gold medallist McKeown was among those impressed with Toohey's feat at the South Australian Aquatic Centre. 'I was 16 when I made my first team and it really taught me a lot being with the older guys,' McKeown said after winning the 100m backstroke final on Tuesday night. 'I'm excited to see young swimmers coming through the ranks. 'The more experience that they can get leading into LA (the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics), we have a really good chance of doing Australia proud.' McKeown, who has told of the mental toll during her decorated career, offered some advice to the precocious Toohey. 'Just to enjoy yourself,' McKeown said. 'The more you be serious, the more you're harsh on yourself, you keep just digging yourself in a bit of a hole and it's quite hard to get out of.' For Toohey, she now will revise plans which had centred on the goal of swimming at the 2032 Brisbane Olympics. 'The team I was first aiming to get on was definitely that one,' she said. 'Now that I've made this one, we'll have to push up the timeline a bit more.' Also on Tuesday night, Alex Perkins threatened the national women's 50m butterfly record by clocking 25.36 seconds, 0.05 shy of Holly Barratt's benchmark set six years ago. Injury-plagued Ed Sommerville, 20, made his first senior long-course national team by winning the men's 200m freestyle in 1:44.93 ahead of Sam Short (1:45.71). Joshua Edwards-Smith prevailed in the men's 100m backstroke in 54.28 and and Matt Temple took out the men's 100m butterfly in 51.00.
7NEWS
29 minutes ago
- 7NEWS
Hall of Fame inductee Erin Phillips brings famous father Greg to tears in emotional speech
Australian football Hall of Fame inductee Erin Phillips brought her famous father to tears during an emotional acceptance speech on Tuesday night. Phillips became just the second woman inducted into the Hall of Fame — followed closely on the night by Daisy Pearce who was third — and completed the first father-daughter combination, joining dad and Port Adelaide great, Greg Phillips. WATCH THE VIDEO ABOVE: Erin Phillips delivers tear-jerking Hall of Fame speech. The two-time AFLW best and fairest, who won three premierships with Adelaide before crossing to Port Adelaide when they entered the competition, thanked her dad in a tear-jerking tribute. 'To Dad, I can't imagine how hard it would have been to tell your 13-year-old daughter that she couldn't play the game that she loves anymore,' she said, with emotion in her voice. 'And 27 years later, she's standing next to you in the Hall of Fame. 'Thank you for teaching me a game that I loved, and even though you knew it was never going to take me anywhere at the time, you still taught me anyway.' When she was turned away from footy, as all girls were at the time, Phillips turned to basketball, where she became one of Australia's greatest ever. She won two WNBA championships, a World Championship gold medal, and a WNBL championship, among a host of other accolades which already made her one of the country's most celebrated athletes, before her footy career even started. As it turned out, she was eventually able to chase her original footy dream when it became possible in 2017, for which she credited trailblazing women like Debbie Lee — the inaugural female inductee, four years ago — with making possible. 'You kicked down this door so others could walk through,' Phillips said. 'I'm so proud to be by your side and I can't wait to kick down more doors with you, Deb.' Phillips ended her stellar playing career at the end of 2022. The five-year player eligibility rule for the Hall of Fame was changed for women last year; AFLW players can now be inducted within a year of retirement and she was an obvious candidate. Her father, Port Adelaide great Greg, was inducted in 2020. Fos and Mark Williams, Hayden Bunton Sr and Jr, and umpires Jack McMurray Sr and Jr are the father-son inductees. Phillips was Adelaide's inaugural captain and the first women's best and fairest winner, playing in three Crows flags despite needing a knee reconstruction. She then switched to Port Adelaide when they joined the league in 2022. When the women's league started in 2017, marquee players such as Phillips were crucial for its profile and credibility. South Australian goalkicking machine Ken Farmer was elevated to legend status at Tuesday night's annual dinner in Melbourne. St Kilda great Nick Riewoldt, whose induction was delayed because of his family move to the United States, joined the Hall of Fame, along with four-time Hawthorn premiership hard nut Luke Hodge and former Melbourne captain Garry Lyon. South Adelaide ruckman Peter Darley, a key member of the club's most recent SANFL premiership in 1964, Tasmanian team of the century vice-captain John Leedham and seven-time East Perth premiership player George Owens are this year's historical inductees. Pearce's last AFLW game was the Melbourne 2022 grand final victory and she called it the best day of her life, even though her twin children Sylvie and Roy were in the room, hamming it up for the TV cameras. 'It's controversial to say this, as a mother ... don't get me wrong, they're the best thing that's ever happened to me, but on a technicality, the day itself is not that good,' she said. 'Give me grand final day every day of the week.' Pearce returned from having the twins in 2019 to captain Melbourne to the flag. Farmer, who died in 1982, is the SANFL's most prolific goalkicker, with 1417 for North Adelaide from 1929-41 in 224 games at an extraordinary average of 6.33 per game. He was never goalless in a game and coached the Roosters to two premierships. Riewolt went agonisingly close to a premiership, playing in St Kilda's draw and two losses across 2009-10. He said he had made his peace with not being able to help the Saints win their elusive second flag 'Rather than feeling like I walked away with the game still owing me something, I walk away feeling like the game gave me absolutely everything,' he said.
West Australian
40 minutes ago
- West Australian
Utoikamanu moves to make Origin mark after 2023 tease
Stefano Utoikamanu spent two years feeling so teased by 12 minutes of State of Origin that it prompted the front-rower to uproot his life and move to Melbourne. The one fresh face in the NSW team for Origin II in Perth next week, Utoikamanu has every right to feel like he is making his debut again. The 25-year-old played his sole Origin two years ago, playing 12 minutes for the Blues in their game-two loss that surrendered the series at Suncorp Stadium in 2023. It was enough time for six touches of the football and seven tackles, but hardly enough for the prop to feel like he'd been able to make his mark in the Origin arena. "I've thought about that a lot," Utoikamanu said. "I didn't really get a real taste of getting in there. I played 12 minutes and it's pretty hard coming off the bench, you've got to make an impact. "If you don't make an impact there's not really any point you being out there. "I'm happy I get another opportunity to go in there and show them what I can actually do. That first time I felt like I didn't do what I needed to do." Utoikamanu said he had "chilled" as a footballer since his Origin debut, having also represented Samoa since. But he has also made no secret of his desire to get back in a Blues jersey. It was a big part of the front-rower's thinking when he moved to Melbourne from Wests Tigers at the end of last year. Utoikamanu says "it's hard to say" if he would be playing this week had he stayed at the Tigers, as one of only two men to feature in Origin while at the club since 2018. Regardless, the Auckland-born talent knows the Storm move has helped, where he is now playing under NSW coach Laurie Daley's new adviser Craig Bellamy. "Coming to the Melbourne Storm has helped me a fair bit in trying to get back into this arena," Utoikamanu said. "It was one of the things I looked at when I was going to leave the Wests Tigers. "I feel like the Melbourne Storm have such a good system, and being in it now I'm happy I made the move. "There's a system there that's made a lot of players get better. A lot of players go there and become better, there's a lot of teams you can't say that (about). "Melbourne's one of those teams that when you go there you have to do the hard work, but when you do the hard work you're going to become a better player."
