'Can't win': Clarkson skeptical on Origin timing
Since taking over from Gillon McLachlan in 2023, AFL boss Andrew Dillon has made no secret of his desire to revive representative football.
After the successful return of the Indigenous All-Stars this year, Origin could be back next February, although the AFL are yet to make any official announcement.
Coaches such as Carlton's Michael Voss believe a pre-season window is the best time for representative matches.
Clarkson, in his third season in charge of North Melbourne following four flags at Hawthorn, rates Origin as a "great concept".
"The big challenge for the AFL and all the players is when during the season do you play it?," Clarkson said on Thursday.
"That's the most difficult part.
"From a club perspective and a player's perspective, the challenge with it if it's right at the start of the season, players don't want to risk getting significant injuries and then perhaps losing significant chunks of the season."
"That's why it was moved."
Clarkson also cautioned against staging any Origin games near finals as the best players wouldn't be available.
"You just can't win with it," he said.
"We all love the concept of State of Origin. We see just how popular it is in rugby league, but as we become a national game, it's been really difficult to work out where it fits into the schedule.
"We've all got enormous passion for it, but just working out where it fits has been the reason why it hasn't been in the program."
The last Origin game took place in 1999 when Victoria defeated South Australia in front of only 26,063 fans at the MCG.
Victoria played an All-Stars team to raise money for bushfire relief in 2020, while Victoria and a Dream Team clashed in 2008 to mark 150 years of Australian football.
Voss witnessed how important the Indigenous All-Stars match was to Zac Williams and Jesse Motlop.
"Any opportunity that our players get to be able to represent something is worthwhile doing," he said on Thursday.
"In principle, I would be hugely supportive of it because they're life experiences."
Richmond coach Adem Yze believes most players would rather represent their state than take part in a traditional pre-season hitout.
"You've got to play a game anyway so why wouldn't you want to play with the Big V jumper and use that as one of your practice games leading into the season," Yze said.
Captains of the 18 clubs were broadly in favour of Origin when pressed about it on the eve of the season.
Four-time premiership coach Alastair Clarkson believes squeezing State of Origin into an already packed calendar will be a difficult task for the AFL.
Since taking over from Gillon McLachlan in 2023, AFL boss Andrew Dillon has made no secret of his desire to revive representative football.
After the successful return of the Indigenous All-Stars this year, Origin could be back next February, although the AFL are yet to make any official announcement.
Coaches such as Carlton's Michael Voss believe a pre-season window is the best time for representative matches.
Clarkson, in his third season in charge of North Melbourne following four flags at Hawthorn, rates Origin as a "great concept".
"The big challenge for the AFL and all the players is when during the season do you play it?," Clarkson said on Thursday.
"That's the most difficult part.
"From a club perspective and a player's perspective, the challenge with it if it's right at the start of the season, players don't want to risk getting significant injuries and then perhaps losing significant chunks of the season."
"That's why it was moved."
Clarkson also cautioned against staging any Origin games near finals as the best players wouldn't be available.
"You just can't win with it," he said.
"We all love the concept of State of Origin. We see just how popular it is in rugby league, but as we become a national game, it's been really difficult to work out where it fits into the schedule.
"We've all got enormous passion for it, but just working out where it fits has been the reason why it hasn't been in the program."
The last Origin game took place in 1999 when Victoria defeated South Australia in front of only 26,063 fans at the MCG.
Victoria played an All-Stars team to raise money for bushfire relief in 2020, while Victoria and a Dream Team clashed in 2008 to mark 150 years of Australian football.
Voss witnessed how important the Indigenous All-Stars match was to Zac Williams and Jesse Motlop.
"Any opportunity that our players get to be able to represent something is worthwhile doing," he said on Thursday.
"In principle, I would be hugely supportive of it because they're life experiences."
Richmond coach Adem Yze believes most players would rather represent their state than take part in a traditional pre-season hitout.
"You've got to play a game anyway so why wouldn't you want to play with the Big V jumper and use that as one of your practice games leading into the season," Yze said.
Captains of the 18 clubs were broadly in favour of Origin when pressed about it on the eve of the season.
Four-time premiership coach Alastair Clarkson believes squeezing State of Origin into an already packed calendar will be a difficult task for the AFL.
Since taking over from Gillon McLachlan in 2023, AFL boss Andrew Dillon has made no secret of his desire to revive representative football.
After the successful return of the Indigenous All-Stars this year, Origin could be back next February, although the AFL are yet to make any official announcement.
Coaches such as Carlton's Michael Voss believe a pre-season window is the best time for representative matches.
Clarkson, in his third season in charge of North Melbourne following four flags at Hawthorn, rates Origin as a "great concept".
"The big challenge for the AFL and all the players is when during the season do you play it?," Clarkson said on Thursday.
"That's the most difficult part.
"From a club perspective and a player's perspective, the challenge with it if it's right at the start of the season, players don't want to risk getting significant injuries and then perhaps losing significant chunks of the season."
"That's why it was moved."
Clarkson also cautioned against staging any Origin games near finals as the best players wouldn't be available.
"You just can't win with it," he said.
"We all love the concept of State of Origin. We see just how popular it is in rugby league, but as we become a national game, it's been really difficult to work out where it fits into the schedule.
"We've all got enormous passion for it, but just working out where it fits has been the reason why it hasn't been in the program."
The last Origin game took place in 1999 when Victoria defeated South Australia in front of only 26,063 fans at the MCG.
Victoria played an All-Stars team to raise money for bushfire relief in 2020, while Victoria and a Dream Team clashed in 2008 to mark 150 years of Australian football.
Voss witnessed how important the Indigenous All-Stars match was to Zac Williams and Jesse Motlop.
"Any opportunity that our players get to be able to represent something is worthwhile doing," he said on Thursday.
"In principle, I would be hugely supportive of it because they're life experiences."
Richmond coach Adem Yze believes most players would rather represent their state than take part in a traditional pre-season hitout.
"You've got to play a game anyway so why wouldn't you want to play with the Big V jumper and use that as one of your practice games leading into the season," Yze said.
Captains of the 18 clubs were broadly in favour of Origin when pressed about it on the eve of the season.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
an hour ago
- The Age
Saints star Wanganeen-Milera to become the AFL's first $2 million man after huge contract call
St Kilda star Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera is set to become the AFL's first $2 million man after re-signing with the Saints for two more years in a massive coup for the club. The 22-year-old had fielded huge offers from Port Adelaide and Adelaide to return to South Australia. Wanganeen-Milera's decision caused celebrations among St Kilda fans who have watched him become one of the best players in the competition in his contract year, but feared they would lose him to more lucrative offers from clubs in his home state. His decision to stay gives the Saints' rebuild fresh impetus with competition sources confirming he had been locked in on a deal worth at least $4 million over two years, which will make him the highest-paid player in the AFL. 'From the moment I arrived at St Kilda, the staff and my teammates have supported me in every way, not just to be a better footballer, but a better person,' said Wanganeen-Milera, who conjured the Saints' record comeback win against the Demons by winning the game almost off his own boot in round 20. He is also likely to be a contender for the Brownlow Medal. 'I know how special it is to pull on the red, white and black. Every time I run out, I'm representing my family, my culture and this club. That means everything to me. 'I've still got so much I want to improve in my game, and I know this is the right place for me to keep growing. I've got great people around me who push me to be better every day. 'I want to help create something long-lasting here. We've got a tight group and a clear direction, and I'm proud to be part of building that future.'
The Australian
an hour ago
- The Australian
NPL club Heidelberg thrash Phoenix in Cup quarter-final
Heidelberg United's dream Australia Cup run continued at Olympic Village on Tuesday night, with the NPL Victoria club thrashing A-League outfit Wellington Phoenix 4-0 to advance to the competition's semi-finals for the first time. A week after beating another top-flight club, Western Sydney Wanderers, in a 3-0 round-of-16 upset at the same venue, the Bergers were again too good in the quarter-final boilover. The tone was set early, with winger Sabit Ngor forcing a save out of Phoenix goalkeeper Josh Oluwayemi in the first minute. The Phoenix offered little in attack and it was anything but a surprise when the hosts grabbed the lead in the 34th minute courtesy of an own goal from Wellington defender Isaac Hughes. Under pressure from Heidelberg midfielder Asahi Yokokawa, who was chasing a through ball from his captain Ben Collins, Hughes turned the ball into his net past the exposed Josh Oluwayemi. Heidelberg United players and staff celebrate the club's Australia Cup quarter-final win over Wellington Phoenix. Picture:Leading 1-0 at half-time, the home side put the game to bed with two more goals in the opening six minutes of the second-half. Winger Max Bisetto doubled Heidelberg's lead in the 46th minute with a stunning long-distance strike in the 47th minute, before Yokokawa sealed his team's place in a semi-final next month against either Sydney FC or Auckland FC with a well-timed finish after impressive work on the right by Ngor,' Replacement Chok Dau provided the icing on the cake in the 85th minute with Heidelberg's fourth goal in the 85th minute. 'I don't think anyone (in the team) thinks we can't go all the way,' Bisetto told Paramount Plus. 'If people don't believe it, then they should start. All credit to the boys, we were phenomenal tonight.' Marco Monteverde Sports reporter Marco Monteverde is a Brisbane-based sports reporter for NCA Newswire. He worked in a similar role for The Courier-Mail from 2007 to 2020. During a journalism career of more than 25 years, he has also worked for The Queensland Times, The Sunshine Coast Daily, The Fraser Coast Chronicle and The North West Star. He has covered three FIFA World Cups and the 2000 Sydney Olympics, as well as a host of other major sporting events in Australia and around the world. @marcothejourno Marco Monteverde
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Disappointed Crows await Rankine ban for slur
Adelaide's players and coaches would be disappointed in Izak Rankine as they await the star's ban for a homophobic slur, a former Crows coach says. Rankine on Wednesday will become the sixth AFL-listed player suspended for making a homophobic remark to an opponent since April last year. The Crow, regarded as among the AFL's most talented players, is bracing for a ban of between three and five games. Ladder-leaders Adelaide have one home-and-away game remaining and will then host two finals. The Crows have lobbied for a three-match ban which offers Rankine a glimmer of hope of playing later in the finals when the club returns to the playoffs for the first time since 2017. Scott Camporeale, Adelaide's caretaker head coach in 2015 after the death of Phil Walsh and an assistant coach at the club for nine years until 2019, was dismayed at Rankine's case. "You feel for the community, we're supposed to be standing up for these things," Camporeale told Adelaide radio station 5AA. "They are well-educated, these players ... they're the best-educated group in the country around race, gender, all those things. "And we continually keep having to go through these scenarios." Camporeale said in a pure football sense, Rankine's teammates and coaches would feel let down by the 25-year-old. "Matthew Nicks would be pretty disappointed as a senior coach," he said. "He is a September player, Izak Rankine ... he's the No.1 score involvement player for the Crows. "Can they still win it? I think they can, it's never just one player. "But he has got to be around the club, he has got to be supporting the group ... he needs to be there front and centre and support his teammates. "Most of them would be pretty disappointed because they know how integral he is to the team." Last month, West Coast's Jack Graham was banned for four games for making a homophobic remark to a GWS player. In April last year, Port Adelaide's Jeremy Finlayson banned for three games and, the next month, Gold Coast's Wil Powell was suspended for five matches, both for directing homophobic slurs are opponents. Two VFL players have also recently been banned for homophobic slurs. Sydney defender Riak Andrew last month was suspended for five matches for an anti-gay slur while playing for the Swans' reserves team against North Melbourne. And in July last year, St Kilda's Lance Collard was banned six games for homophobic comments while playing in the VFL for Sandringham against Williamstown.
