Employee doesn't have right to promotion but consideration if not disqualified: SC

Time of India

02-05-2025

The
Supreme Court
on Friday said while an employee did not possess a right to promotion, they had the right to be considered for promotion unless disqualified. A bench of
Justices Sudhanshu Dhulia and K Vinod Chandran
was dealing with an appeal filed by a police constable in Tamil Nadu who was aggrieved by the denial of consideration of promotion for the sub-inspector's post.
#Pahalgam Terrorist Attack
Pakistan reopens Attari-Wagah border to allow stranded citizens in India to return
Key Jammu & Kashmir reservoirs' flushing to begin soon
Air India sees Pakistan airspace ban costing it $600 mn over 12 months
"It is trite that the employee has no right to be promoted but has a right to be considered, when selections for promotions are carried out, unless disqualified; which right has been impinged, unjustly, in the above case," it said.
The apex court observed he had faced both departmental and criminal action for allegedly thrashing a colleague during their posting at a check post.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Play War Thunder now for free
War Thunder
Play Now
Undo
While in the criminal case, the appellant was arrested but acquitted later, the government set aside the punishment stemming from the departmental proceedings in 2009, it noted.
However, the superintended of police said the appellant was not considered for promotion since he was disentitled in line with the rules for reason of a punishment of postponement of next increment for one year without cumulative effect, imposed in May 2005.
Live Events
The appellant's punishment, the bench said, was interfered with and was set aside in November 2009.
"In such circumstances, the appellant could not have been disentitled from a consideration in the year 2019," the bench's verdict said.
It added, "In the above circumstances we are of the opinion that the appellant must be considered for promotion, dehors any disentitlement due to his having become overaged."
The consideration will be made and if found eligible, he shall be promoted from 2019 and consequential benefits shall also be paid to him, since it was not his fault that the authority denied his
consideration for promotion
based on a punishment which was already set aside, the bench said.
The bench allowed the man's appeal challenging an order of the Madras High Court passed on October, 2023, dismissing his plea to consider him for promotion as an in-service candidate.
The apex court said he was initially appointed in March 2002 and was eligible for consideration in 2019 when a notification was issued for considering eligible constables for in-service promotion in 20 percent departmental quota.