West Virginia's foster care mess spills over into court system; House will try to address it
West Virginia's foster care system is in crisis, and it has spilled over into the state's court system.
As the House of Delegates Judiciary Committee gaveled in for the first time this year, new chairman Del. J.B. Akers set a priority for members: helping the court systems deal with an overwhelming number of child abuse and neglect cases.
There aren't enough attorneys or child protective services workers to help the cases move along, and judges believe kids are falling through the cracks.
'It is the most pressing matter in the judicial system in the state of West Virginia,' said Akers, R-Kanawha, a lawyer whose wife serves as circuit judge in his county.
'This was a huge challenge for the state of West Virginia, but I thought it was important symbolically to make this a day one issue,' he continued. 'I'm not going to promise folks that we're going to solve this, because it's probably too big of a problem … to solve them in one legislative session. But I want folks to know that it is a focus of the work we're doing.'
Tackling the problem will take money, Akers said. It could be a challenge as Gov. Patrick Morrisey and the Republican-led Legislature are trying to figure out the reality of the governor's projected $400 million deficit and how it could impact spending.
Last year, 5,449 children entered the abuse and neglect system — a 2.6% increase from 2023, according to Cindy Largent-Hill, director of the state Supreme Court of Appeals Division of Children's Services. Many of the cases involved adult substance abuse; allegations of child abuse involving drug endangerment are four times higher in West Virginia than the national average.
There were 5,286 child abuse and neglect cases filed in circuit courts in 2023, about 13% of the total case filings that year. At the Supreme Court, there were 251 abuse and neglect appeals filed in 2023, around 43% of the total filings.
Largent-Hill told lawmakers that there aren't near enough attorneys for child abuse cases, and availbale ones are assigned to a child's case as a guardian ad litem for at least one year. They deserve 'the one constant' in a child's life during that time, she noted.
'On any given day we have under 200 attorneys who have agreed to do this kind of work,' said Largent-Hill, adding that most guardian ad litems cover 12 counties.'Compensation is an issue. Currently, they make $60 an hour for out of court work and $80 for in court. That's much less than attorneys can make doing other work.'
Stacey Fragile, chief public defender in Raleigh County, explained to lawmakers how difficult the work as a guardian ad litem can be.
'I was at a [West Virginia University] football game, and I got a call that one of the children I was representing had been kidnapped. Burnout is real,' she said.
Del. Adam Burkhammer, R-Lewis, a foster parent, has introduced a bill that would establish a three-year 'guardian ad litem pilot program' in three judicial circuits to provide needed legal counsel. The program could employ full-time attorneys, part-time attorneys or 'whatever combination that the public guardian ad litem corporation deems most cost effective.'
Akers noted that the bill would have a fiscal note, which isn't yet available, meaning that he couldn't make any promises on its passage but said his committee would at least consider the measure.
'I know that the governor's office has been extremely conservative with the budget, and I agree that we should be careful with taxpayer dollars. But I also want to make sure that there's some things that are more important than money,' Akers said. 'I think we need to this year, you don't wait until you have the money.'
The state's shortage of CPS workers continues despite the Department of Human Services' work to address the problem, and the problem has contributed to cases being held up in the judicial system.
The worker shortage prompted Third Circuit Court Judge Timothy Sweeney last week to order several DoHS officials to report to the Ritchie County Courthouse Feb. 20 to serve as CPS workers.
Judge Anita Harold Ashley, who serves the Fifth Judicial Circuit, also questioned how CPS was screening child abuse and neglect referalls as she has seen a notbale drop of in the number of cases in her district. DoHS last year changed how it screens referrals and manages cases involving child abuse and neglect following questions of how DoHS handled the high-profile case of the apparent starvation death of 14-year-old Kyneddi Miller.
Ashley said that so far this year, CPS had filed only four cases in Roane County, and the number had continued to drop from 136 cases filed in 2016.
'There's something wrong,' she said.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
2 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
‘We're not going to back down': Leaders condemn Trump's attacks on Oakland
A group of Oakland elected officials and community leaders rallied Thursday to condemn recent remarks made by President Donald Trump portraying the city as poorly run and crime-ridden, and to pledge a steadfast response to any effort to deploy federal troops there. In a series of speeches at Oakland City Hall, Mayor Barbara Lee, City Council members and others said Trump's characterization of the city was a fear-mongering tactic to target U.S. cities with majority-Black populations or those led by Black mayors. On Monday, President Trump sent National Guard troops to Washington, D.C., a Black-led city, and named Oakland as one of several cities where he might do the same. In June, Trump deployed more than 4,000 National Guard troops to Los Angeles in response to protests against immigration raids in Southern California. Critics said Trump's rhetoric evoked a historic pattern in which politicians have painted predominantly or historically Black cities as crime-plagued. Crime nationwide is down in the first half of the year, according to a report by the Council on Criminal Justice. 'We have other cities also that are bad. Very bad,' Trump said during a White House news conference Monday, singling out Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, Baltimore and Oakland. Oakland leaders pointed to the city's notable drop in violent crime during the first half of the year, and the work they said officials were doing to revitalize the city. 'President Trump's characterization of Oakland is down-right wrong,' Lee said. 'We're not going to back down.' At Thursday's press conference, faith and community leaders joined city officials in denouncing Trump's attacks, saying Oakland's residents are resilient. 'We believe that Oakland is not on the decline, but on the rise,' said Pastor LJ Jennings of the Kingdom Builders Christian Fellowship in East Oakland. Council Member Carol Fife, who represents District Three, criticized Trump for being a convicted felon attempting to tarnish the city. Fife said the city has made progress on bringing down crime while acknowledging there was more work to do. 'If you care about law and order, you would know that the safest cities have the most resources, and those resources come in the tune of affordable housing,' Fife said. 'It comes from protecting our seniors, it comes from investing in education.' Danielle Motley-Lewis, president of the Oakland and Berkeley chapter of the Black Women Organized for Political Action group, encouraged people to share stories of the city's progress, unity and transformation.
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
DC's highest crime neighborhoods have yet to see Trump crackdown
While Guardsmen were out in force on the tourist-friendly National Mall, there was little sign of troops and federal agents in some of Washington, DC's most crime-ridden neighborhoods. WASHINGTON – President Donald Trump's deployment of federal law enforcement and National Guard troops has produced Humvees on the National Mall and roving bands of agents in tourist areas as part of his stated effort to crack down on crime in the nation's capital. But many residents of the city's highest-crime neighborhoods say they haven't yet seen the results of Trump's surge in the places it is needed the most. "He probably doesn't even know where Anacostia is," Charles Wilson, whose neighborhood has one of DC's highest rates of murder and violent crime. Wilson says the low-income area in DC's Ward 8 has endured several shootouts in which bullets struck houses, cars and even lodged in children's bedrooms in recent years. "I think this is all pomp and circumstance,' Wilson says, 'to distract people from everything else he is doing." As part of Trump's Aug. 11 campaign to take 'our capital back" from crime and the homeless the federal government has also seized control of Washington's Metropolitan Police Department. Some Anacostia residents welcome crime-fighting help from Trump Like others interviewed in Anacostia by USA TODAY the afternoon and night of Aug. 13, Wilson said he would welcome the presence of more law enforcement – as long as they're trained in community policing and there to help his neighborhood reduce crime and violence. More: How DC's unique status let Trump take control of police, deploy National Guard Wilson, 49, has lived in the Southeast DC community for over 20 years. On July 18, 2024, he was awakened at about 2:30 a.m. by what sounded like a war on his hilly suburban street just around the corner from the historic Frederick Douglass estate. When he obtained a neighbor's doorbell camera footage and posted it online, the video of two men running up and down his street shooting at each other for nearly a minute went viral. 'Hearing it was one thing, but watching it was something else,' said Wilson, a longtime community activist and chair of the DC Democratic Party. He said the issue isn't a political one; Democratic and Republican neighbors alike want to see the benefits of what Trump claims is a new campaign to improve the city. So far, he said, 'Nothing's new here. I don't see anything different.' 'I don't see anything being done here,' said longtime Anacostia resident Tina Harris as she walked along Marion Barry Avenue, named after the former DC mayor. 'I think it's clearly a diversion from the real issues,' including Trump's budget cuts for local social services and police, she said. Trump announced his actions to "to rescue our nation's capital from crime, bloodshed, bedlam and squalor and worse," after a high-profile assault on a former staffer of the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), 19-year-old Edward Coristine, that occurred in the early morning hours of Aug. 3. during an attempted carjacking. Mayor Muriel Bowser disputed Trump's justification for declaring a crime emergency, calling it a 'so-called emergency' and noting that crime has been trending down after spiking in 2023. But crime in Ward 8 – including homicide, motor vehicle theft, robbery and assaults with dangerous weapons – have historically been nearly twice that of any other ward of the city. A few blocks from Wilson's house, a Metropolitan Police Department cruiser sat parked at an intersection with its lights slowly flashing. The officer inside, like two other officers interviewed by USA TODAY throughout the evening, said he was just making his regular rounds and that he'd seen no uptick in law enforcement or military presence there or in neighboring Ward 7, another high-crime zone. All three officers declined to give their names, saying they weren't authorized to talk publicly. One of the officers, however, said that as a DC resident, he welcomed the extra resources Trump has authorized, which have also been supported by the police union. One Anacostia resident, standing outside his home and watching the cruiser, confirmed that the officer was a neighborhood beat cop – and that he's seen no additional MPD officers, federal agents or National Guard troops since Trump made his announcement, despite nightly gunshots, carjackings and other crime. He too declined to give his name, citing a pending background check for a job. Darrell Gaston, the chef and founder of nearby Kitchen Savages, showed USA TODAY the front windows of his upscale restaurant that he had to replace after they were shattered by a recent gun battle between the occupants of two cars. The wild shootout sent a street light careening into the eatery. Gaston, a four-term Advisory Neighborhood Commission member, said he'd seen some evidence of an uptick in security, including a few Guard troops and federal agents a block away. What he'd like to see instead, Gaston said, was more DC police officers 'who specialize in community engagement and in protecting communities, which hopefully does lead to a decrease in crime.' 'Moreover, hopefully it doesn't lead to an increase in the rights of citizens being violated,' Gaston said of Trump's surge. 'Because when MPD violates your rights, there's a protocol to follow for it to be addressed. If the FBI or the DEA violates your rights, who do you go to?' Ward 8 has seen an overall decline in violent crime this year, but homicides held steady at 38 compared with the same period in 2024, according to Metropolitan Police Department statistics. A swarm of federal agents closer to Capitol Hill Back across the Anacostia river near the Capitol, the rough-and-tumble H Street commercial and nightlife corridor appeared quiet the night of Aug. 13. It was the site of one of the attacks cited by Trump – the 2023 near-fatal stabbing of an aide to Republican Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky 'by a demented lunatic as he walked down the street just absolutely for no reason.' The only visible security presence was the occasional MPD cruiser driving by. But shop owners and barflies said the area has been swarmed by federal agents and police late at night since Trump's announcement. Johnny Lu showed USA TODAY a video he took of a team of seven FBI, ICE and DEA agents patrolling the area late the night of Aug. 12, questioning and even arresting people for drinking and smoking marijuana in public. Lu welcomed the surge, saying he sees frequent shootings, stabbings, carjackings and robberies outside his Tiki Gardens restaurant. 'MPD is okay, and we have a good relationship with them. But not the feds, especially ICE,' Lu said of the corridor's merchants and residents. 'We've got to be worried about them.'
Chicago Tribune
5 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
DC police chief agrees to deepen cooperation with federal immigration agents
WASHINGTON — The police chief of Washington, D.C., ordered an increase in cooperation between local officers and federal immigration agents on Thursday, a development that ramps up the stakes in an already tense environment after President Donald Trump's security crackdown put the city's police force under the command of the administration. The Executive Order, issued Thursday and signed by Metropolitan Police Department Chief Pamela Smith, establishes that MPD officers may now share information with immigration agencies regarding people not in custody —such as someone involved in a traffic stop or checkpoint. MPD officers may also provide 'transportation for federal immigration employees and detained subject,' the order states. The changes, which raise collaboration between the two forces in notable ways, are effective immediately. THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. AP's earlier story follows below. National Guard troops and Humvees guarded some Washington landmarks Thursday and advocacy organizations helped clear homeless encampments in advance of an anticipated crackdown as President Donald Trump's takeover of city police ramped up. The multiagency flood of federal law enforcement ordered by the Republican president to tackle crime in the nation's capital has become increasingly high profile, with officers setting up a checkpoint Wednesday night in one of D.C.'s popular nightlife areas, drawing protests. The White House said 45 arrests were made Wednesday night, including 29 arrests of people living in the country illegally, including for distribution or possession of drugs, carrying a concealed weapon and assaulting a federal officer. Troops were stationed outside the Union Station transportation hub as the 800 Guard members who have been activated by Trump start in on missions that include monument security, community safety patrols and beautification efforts, the Pentagon said. 'They will remain until law and order has been restored in the District as determined by the president, standing as the gatekeepers of our great nation's capital,' Pentagon press secretary Kingsley Wilson said. 'The National Guard is uniquely qualified for this mission as a community-based force with strong local ties and disciplined training.' Wilson said the troops won't be armed and declined to give more details on what the safety patrols or beautification efforts would entail or how many Guard members have already been sent out on the streets. National Guard Major Micah Maxwell said troops will assist law enforcement in a variety of roles, including traffic control posts and crowd control. The Guard members have been trained in deescalation tactics and crowd control equipment, Maxwell said. The White House said Thursday that Guard members aren't making arrests but are 'protecting federal assets, providing a safe environment for law enforcement officers to make arrests, and deterring violent crime with a visible law enforcement presence.' Meanwhile, about a dozen unhoused residents in Washington packed up their belongings with help from volunteers from some city agencies. Items largely were not forcibly thrown out by law enforcement, but a garbage truck idled nearby. Several protesters held signs close by, some critical of the Trump administration. Once the residents had left, a construction vehicle from a city agency cleared through the remains of the tents. Advocates expected law enforcement officers to fan out across D.C. later Thursday to take down any remaining homeless encampments. For two days, small groups of federal officers have been visible in scattered parts of the city. But more were present in high-profile locations Wednesday night, and troops were expected to start doing more missions Thursday. Agents from Homeland Security Investigations have patrolled the popular U Street corridor, while Drug Enforcement Administration officers were seen on the National Mall, with Guard members parked nearby. DEA agents also joined Metropolitan Police Department officers on patrol in the Navy Yard neighborhood, while FBI agents stood along the heavily trafficked Massachusetts Avenue.
