Exclusive: Medical journal rejects Kennedy's call for retraction of vaccine study
Kennedy has long promoted doubts about vaccines' safety and efficacy, and as health secretary has upended the federal government's process for recommending immunization. A recent media report said he has been considering whether to initiate a review of shots that contain aluminum, which he says are linked to autoimmune diseases and allergies.
The study, opens new tab, which was funded by the Danish government and published in July in the Annals of Internal Medicine, analyzed nationwide registry data for more than 1.2 million children over more than two decades. It did not find evidence that exposure to aluminum in vaccines had caused an increased risk for autoimmune, atopic or allergic, or neurodevelopmental disorders.
The work is by far the best available evidence on the question of the safety of aluminum in vaccines, said Adam Finn, a childhood vaccination expert in the UK and pediatrician at the University of Bristol, who was not involved in the study.
"It's solid, (a) massive dataset and high-quality data," he said.
Kennedy described the research as "a deceitful propaganda stunt by the pharmaceutical industry," and said the scientists who authored it had "meticulously designed it not to find harm" in a detailed Aug. 1 opinion piece on TrialSite News, an independent website focused on clinical research. He called on the journal to "immediately retract" the study.
"I see no reason for retraction," Dr. Christine Laine, editor in chief of the Annals and a professor of medicine at Thomas Jefferson University, said in an interview.
The journal plans to respond to criticism the article has received on its website, Laine said, but it does not intend to respond directly to Kennedy's piece, which was not submitted to the Annals.
The lead author of the study, Anders Peter Hviid, head of the epidemiology research department at the Statens Serum Institut in Denmark, defended the work in a response post to TrialSite. He wrote that none of the critiques put forward by Kennedy were substantive and he categorically denied any deceit as implied by the secretary.
"I am used to controversy around vaccine safety studies - especially those that relate to autism, but I have not been targeted by a political figurehead in this way before," Hviid said in an emailed response to Reuters. "I have confidence in our work and in our ability to reply to the critiques of our study."
Kennedy had a number of critiques, including the lack of a control group, that the study deliberately excluded different groups of children to avoid showing a link between aluminum and childhood health conditions - including those with the highest levels of exposure - and that it did not include the raw data.
Hviid responded to the criticisms on TrialSite. He said some of the points were related to study design choices that were reasonable to discuss but refuted others, including that the study was designed not to find a link. In fact he said, its design was based on a study led by Matthew Daley, opens new tab, a pediatrician at Kaiser Permanente Colorado, which did show a link, and which Kennedy cited in his article.
There was no control group because in Denmark, only 2% of children are unvaccinated, which is too small for meaningful comparison, Hviid added. The data is available for researchers to analyze, but individual-level data is not released under Danish law, he said.
Other prominent vaccine skeptics including those at the antivaccine organization Kennedy previously ran, Children's Health Defense, have similarly criticized the study on the Annals site.
TrialSite staff defended the study for its scale, data transparency and funding while acknowledging the limitations of its design, a view seconded by some outside scientists.
Laine said that while some of the issues Kennedy raised in his article may underscore acceptable limitations of the study, "they do not invalidate what they found, and there's no evidence of scientific misconduct."
An HHS spokesman said the department had "no further comment than what the secretary said."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
42 minutes ago
- The Guardian
That Alien, Sound review – super-kooky indie comedy puts sound-wave ET in woman's body
'You continue to play this alien part, and I'm fucking over it – I've had enough.' On that note, uptight boyfriend Shannon (Will Tranfo) kicks the woman he thought was his girlfriend out of the car – and perhaps echoes the audience's thoughts about this grindingly zany indie sci-fi comedy. And that's only 10 minutes into Brando Topp's directing debut, in which Mika (Mia Danelle) is rocking out to gnarly sounds on her headphones when her body is hijacked by an alien soundwave that was formerly stuck in space listening to the vibrations coming from Earth. That Alien, Sound plays out like a lo-fi LA sweding of The Man Who Fell to Earth. Stupefied at having a body, the wave – later dubbed Sound – bugs Shannon by chucking tissues around the car and trying to grab the steering wheel. Back at her bewildered parents' house, she marvels at the five senses and, excited by a fried breakfast, burns herself on the pan. Her brother Deyo (Deyo Forteza) takes her to his band's jam session; a chance for the once-disembodied oscillation to be in the presence of real live music. This cosmic body-swap scenario is infuriatingly loose, with no obvious reason for the soundwave gimmick other than the innate kookiness. Self-infatuated scenes sprawl out for too long with all the discipline of an Echo Park hipster improv group after a long night on the edibles. Sound, indignant at what she finds on terra firma, is increasingly gripped by outraged soliloquies about climate change and human megalomania; these are the kind of trite interventions that give wokeness a bad name. But matters do pick up in the film's final phase, as Sound, Shannon and Deyo head to a music festival to make a radio transmission that they hope will bring Mika back. As the story coalesces around her and Shannon's failing relationship, the alien conceit starts to make more sense in terms of a strangeness in his partner he feels threatened by, and the new identity she is seeking. Even some of the heavy quirk – turning up at the jamboree cosplaying as Mozart – starts to seem charming as Topp's directing locks into place around actual themes. It goes to show: inside every annoyingly tricksy indie comedy is a decent road movie trying to get out. That Alien, Sound is on digital platforms from 18 August.
Reuters
44 minutes ago
- Reuters
10 million Americans will go uninsured due to Trump tax and spend law, CBO estimates
WASHINGTON, Aug 11 (Reuters) - Ten million more Americans will be uninsured in the next decade due to changes in President Donald Trump's tax and spend law, according to an estimate by the Congressional Budget Office. The nonpartisan CBO analysis comes after the legislation became law in July and is an update from a previous analysis that estimated almost 11 million Americans would be uninsured from previous versions of the legislation. The tax and spending law was passed with only Republican votes, as Democrats said the bill was a giveaway to the rich at the expense of low-income Americans. To pay for extending tax cuts passed under Trump's first term and some new temporary tax cuts and other spending, the law has enacted some restrictions and requirements to access the low-income health insurance program, Medicaid. The CBO also estimated that income will decrease for the poorest Americans by $1,200 per year due to the law's tax and benefit changes, but increase for middle-income households from $800 to $1,200, as well as by more than $13,000 for the wealthiest Americans. "The changes in resources will not be evenly distributed among households. The agency estimates that, in general, resources will decrease for households toward the bottom of the income distribution, whereas resources will increase for households in the middle and toward the top of the income distribution," the report said.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Rabies outbreak feared as hundreds exposed at US vacation spot
Advertisement Health officials are tracking down hundreds of visitors to Wyoming 's Grand Teton National Park after discovering a 'suspected' bat colony inside a lodge. Since June 2, Grand Teton Lodge Company has received eight reports of overnight guests who may have been exposed to bats in those rooms while staying at the Jackson Jake Lodge. Dr Alexia Harrist, Wyoming's state health officer, said bats may have been in the rooms since the season started in May, which has seen more than 200 guests since. The National Park Service (NPS) said: 'As a precaution, the affected rooms are closed while public health professionals conduct further assessments and provide recommendations for mitigation.' Overnight exposure to bats is concerning because infected bats can transmit rabies through bites or scratches, which are often too small to notice. People who cannot communicate potential exposure, like children or deep sleepers, would be considered at-risk. While rabies can be prevented with post-exposure vaccines, it is always fatal once symptoms develop. Although healthy bats rarely bite humans, those infected with rabies often exhibit abnormal behavior, Harrist said. Grand Teton National Park in Wyoming sees over three million visitors annually. 'A suspected bat colony was recently discovered in an attic space above guest rooms 516, 518, 520, 522, 524, 526, 528 and 530 at the Jackson Lake Lodge,' the NPS alert stated. 'There is no immediate threat to the public.' Bat exposure to rabies is defined as a bite or scratch from a bat to a human, contact of bat saliva with an open cut or mucous membrane, or any direct physical contact with a bat. Exposure to bats raises particular concern because their teeth are small, and bites often do not bleed, cause pain, or leave visible marks. As a result, a person may be unaware that they have been exposed or may mistakenly believe that a minor bite or scratch does not require medical attention. 'State public health officials are reaching out to these guests directly to assess if they had exposure to a bat while staying in any of these rooms and determine if they meet the risk criteria for receiving rabies preventive treatment. 'Individuals who meet the risk criteria for a rabies exposure will be connected with the appropriate provider in their home state for preventive treatment.' Recently, a woman visiting the Glen Canyon National Recreation Area in Arizona shared her scary encounter with a bat. Erica Kahn was spending her vacation photographing the night sky last year when a bat flew right into her mouth. Her father, a doctor, insisted she get vaccinated for rabies, which can spread through an animal's saliva and is fatal almost 100 percent of the time unless treated before symptoms appear. But she didn't have health insurance. A generally healthy person, Kahn believed that after losing her job last summer, she could avoid paying hundreds to stay on her former employer's insurance plan before finding another job and getting insurance through work again. But knowing she now needed to get treatment as soon as possible, Kahn, 33, found a private health insurance policy outside of the Affordable Care Act marketplace, believing that she would be covered for the five shots she would need to get over the next two weeks. But last fall, she began receiving medical bills that said she owed $21,000. Believing she'd be covered as long as she got insurance before going to the hospital, Kahn said she purchased a policy online the day after the bat encounter, according to the Washington Post.
