Auckland YMCA accommodation staff scared of job losses if restructure goes ahead
Photo:
Google Maps
YMCA North staff who work in the Auckland accommodation team say they're scared of losing their jobs, worry about their mental health deteriorating and safety being compromised, if a proposed restructure goes ahead.
The front-line accommodation staff at the Y's Pitt Street hostel and its City Lodge had a week to give feedback on a restructure proposal.
If the proposal goes ahead, workers called Guest Service Agents who have been working both across day and night shifts will only be able to work either in a day or night role.
Staff question how the proposal fits with the YMCA's key values.
Guest Service Agents are staff who deal with customers who are staying at the YMCA's hostel and lodge, manage security, cleanliness, bookings and billing.
Currently, they work both day and night shifts and are stationed at either the Pitt Street Hostel or the City Lodge.
In the proposal - these roles will be disestablished. Staff will now have to apply to be either a day worker or a night worker and will work across two different locations.
Night GSAs are the only reception and security staff on site - it means they must handle emergencies and security incidents by themselves.
A staff member who usually works night shifts at the City Lodge hostel told
Checkpoint
they did not feel prepared.
"All we had was a safeguarding training. The safeguarding is more related to protecting children and vulnerable people rather than yourself. So, in the security sense, we're not prepared."
They said the security company the YMCA contracts is not based on site, so GSAs must call a hotline if they face issues.
"I needed to evict an intruder that was in the building. A visitor there was not allowed to be there. He said, 'okay give me 40 minutes and I'll be there.' If we have a real emergency, real urgency, that's what we [are] dealing with.
"Probably we'll have to sort it out ourselves or call the police."
The worker said while they had been working people had tried to break in, the worker told
Checkpoint
they often carried a knife as they felt unsafe.
As part of their roles, on the night shift they must watch the entrances and exits and do hourly walk throughs of public areas.
"Night shifts are extra tough on health, on physical, mental health. You are extra tired even if you're just sitting on a chair [most] of the night."
As part of Auckland Council's service agreements, which started on 1 April this year, service partners must pay their workers the living wage.
Some Auckland Council leisure centres and pools are managed by the YMCA, meaning those YMCA staff must be paid the living wage.
However, because the YMCA's accommodation centres are not part of this service agreement, it means workers don't have to be paid the living wage.
The worker said after the restructure if they would only be working nights and the pay remained the same at $25 an hour, it would be unfair as they would be taking on more risk and a heavier workload.
"We are the ones who are taking aggressive customers, being on safety hazards, we are the ones taking the burden."
The worker said the way the proposal had been carried out went against the core values of the YMCA around Caring, Honesty, Respect and Responsibility.
If the proposal is confirmed to stay the same, there will be interviews held over the rest of July and staff will be told the outcomes of the interviews at the end of the month.
For staff who aren't selected for the new roles, if their current role is disestablished, they will be made redundant from 1 August.
If the worker loses their job, they're worried about the current job market and if they will be able to find work at all within the next couple of months.
"We live pay check by pay check, so I don't have any savings to my name. I should have like $10 to my name. It will be devastating, honestly, and I'm sure [it will] affect any area in my life financially, emotional, mental health wise."
On 15 July accommodation staff who work across the YMCA's City Lodge and Pitt Street hostel were sent a letter outlining the proposal.
The YMCA said it was because they were facing financial underperformance due to a mix of structural and market-related challenges.
They say the roles will give clarity to the workers' responsibilities and accountability.
YMCA North chief executive Rebecca Russell said in statement the proposed new structure would see greater streamlining across the two accommodation sites.
The YMCA is actively seeking feedback from affected staff and no final decisions have been made.
Security was a top priority, she said - with measures including mandatory door locking, pass cards and external security able to be called if needed.
Russell said she would be concerned if staff were having to arm themselves and this had not been raised with management. But anyone worried about safety should provide that feedback during the consultation, she said.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
6 hours ago
- RNZ News
Fire in roof of business in Christchurch
Photo: RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly Fire crews have put out an overnight fire in the roof of a commercial building in the Christchurch suburb of Wigram. Emergency services were called to the fire shortly after 11.30pm and six trucks, including a turntable ladder, were sent. The fire was put out around 2am on Wednesday. FENZ says a fire had spread from machinery.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Almost all sika deer culled in ambitious Russell Forest eradication project
Trailcam image of a sika hind at Ngaiotonga Reserve, south of Russell. Photo: DOC Just three sika deer remain in Russell Forest a year after an ambitious eradication project began, the Northland Regional Council says. Biosecurity group manager Don McKenzie said 64 deer had been removed so far along with about 500 goats. Any recoverable meat was distributed to local communities, he said. The Russell State Forest trial was launched in May 2024 at an estimated cost of $1.5 million. It was so far ahead of schedule and under budget. Critics have said local hunters should have been used, but McKenzie said experts with specialist equipment, such as thermal imaging drones, were required given the need to locate every last deer. The council earlier told RNZ the project, if successful in Russell Forest, could be expanded to the 13 other wild deer populations around Northland. A sika hind is captured by a trailcam in Russell State Forest. Photo: DOC Those populations were scattered between Kaiwaka, near the Auckland border, and the bush behind Kaitāia airport. The council said wild deer arrived in Northland in the 1980s and 1990s as a result of illegal releases and farm escapes. Unlike other parts of New Zealand, deer were not released in Northland by the acclimatisation societies of the 19th century, which meant numbers were still low enough to make eradication possible. Russell Forest had the region's only known population of sika deer, which were smaller and more elusive than the other species found around New Zealand. Earlier, Department of Conservation senior wild animal advisor Dave Carlton told RNZ deer had no natural predators in New Zealand, so numbers could grow rapidly. He said wild deer fed on forest plants, trees and seedlings, altering forest composition, removing food for native animals, and hindering regeneration. Carlton said Northland was the ideal region to aim for deer-free status because it was bordered by the sea on two sides and Auckland city on the other. Wild Deer Free Te Tai Tokerau is a partnership between the regional council, DOC, hapū and iwi - in this case Te Kapotai, Ngāti Kuta, Patukeha, Ngatiwai and hau kainga from Ngaiotonga - and the deer farming industry. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
Iwi support name change for St Arnaud to Rotoiti
Descendants of Rangitāne o Wairau at Lake Rotoiti. Photo: Supplied/Rangitāne o Wairau Three iwi at the top of the South Island have put their support behind a proposal to change the name of the village of St Arnaud to Rotoiti. The move is supported by the iwis Rangitāne o Wairau, Ngāti Kuia and Ngāti Apa ki te Rā Tō. New Zealand Geographic Board secretary Wendy Shaw confirmed the board had received the proposal. "The proposer has been advised that they must consult further with the local community before the proposal can be processed further," Shaw said. The village of St Arnaud has a permanent population of slightly more than 100 people. It sits at the northern end of Lake Rotoiti in the Nelson Lakes and takes its name from the nearby St Arnaud range, which in turn takes its name from the French soldier and marshal Jacques Leroy de Saint Arnaud. Rangitāne o Wairau General Manager Corey Hebberd said the three iwi, all descending from the waka Kurahaupō, have a strong and proud connection to Rotoiti and the surrounding area. It's a specific area mentioned in their Treaty settlements. "Providing support to the name was just a no-brainer for us really. We know that it's an area that our people have long frequented for kai, it's a place that they've been sustained, but it's also a place that's along an important journey for us in terms of heading between Wairau and the coast and other parts of the South Island," Hebberd said. It's not the first attempt to change St Arnaud's name, another proposal was rejected in 2009 according to the Nelson Mail. Hebberd said Rangitāne did some research and were able to find records that showed the use of the name Rotoiti for the area long before St Arnaud. "So, we were able to come across a letter that one of our tūpuna Paraone Taitua sent to Governer Eyre in 1851 in which he references Rotoiti as that place name," Hebberd said. Annette Walker is part of a small group which made the current name change proposal to the Geographic Board. She is optimistic the change will happen and said it would be a huge milestone for the village. Walker called Jacques Leroy de St Arnaud a "dreadful man" and believed some residents would support a change to Rotoiti. "It's like a festering sore that still arises every now and then from the old residents of Lake Rotoiti and they still call it Rotoiti," she said. Jacques Leroy de Saint-Arnaud's wartime exploits in Algeria included suffocating 500 Arab tribesmen in a cave by sealing its exits. Hebberd said it's important to acknowledge some of the actions of the man, but the name Rotoiti would also be more reflective of the area itself. Hebberd said he grew up in the Wairau region and would frequently head up to Lake Rotoiti and the area near the lake was simply referred to by many as Rotoiti. "It's very infrequent that I hear it referred to as St Arnaud. I respect the fact that there will be community members who do call it St Arnaud and who have an affinity with that name, but given the past associated with that name and also the fact that it's so close Lake Rotoiti, the township sits on Lake Rotoiti it makes sense for the area to carry that name." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
