logo
Teenager ‘grinned' before stabbing man in heart with Rambo knife, trial told

Teenager ‘grinned' before stabbing man in heart with Rambo knife, trial told

Glasgow Times15-07-2025
Jurors at Derby Crown Court heard that Charles Hartle, who was aged 17 at the time, allegedly carried out an 'utterly pointless killing' when he attacked Noah Smedley on a dark street in Ilkeston, Derbyshire, on the evening of December 28 last year with the knife he kept hidden in his tracksuit bottoms.
The defendant, now aged 18, sat in the dock on Tuesday wearing glasses, a black jacket and white shirt while Adrian Langdale KC opened the prosecution case.
Mr Langdale told the jury of seven women and five men: 'On December 28 2024 you will have been getting over Christmas and preparing for the new year – Charles Hartle was going out on the streets armed with a knife.
'He moved towards Noah, he grinned or smiled before deliberately aiming for and stabbing him in the chest.
'There is no dispute that this lethal weapon was in the hands of that young man Charlie Hartle.
'Noah Smedley, the Crown will say, did absolutely nothing wrong, he did nothing to deserve what happened to him. He wasn't himself armed… he did not offer any violence.
'The Crown will say it was an utterly pointless killing other than this defendant's unhealthy interest with knives and the fact he was, the Crown will say, a habitual carrier of knives.
'You will hear that the defendant was planning on meeting up with three of his friends who would later witness, and be feet away from, the murder.'
The court was told that Hartle and his friends arranged to meet Mr Smedley who arrived at the scene on an electric scooter and sold them cannabis before the fatal attack.
Mr Langdale continued: 'It was agreed to meet him at a bus stop on Heanor Road, Ilkeston, and so the defendant and his three mates are captured on CCTV shortly after 8pm going to meet the deceased.
'This defendant deliberately hangs back at the back of the group, whilst the others are chatting with Noah and he gives them the cannabis.
'All seemingly, in these matters of seconds, are in good spirits – there is no animosity.
'This defendant will pull his balaclava down over his face, he moves forward in the group to get closer to Noah and reaches into the back of his tracksuit.
'Hartle immediately takes one stride forward and in the same motion thrusts the knife forward and through Noah's heart.'
The jury heard that Hartle and his friends ran from the scene leaving Mr Smedley 'staggering and bleeding profusely'.
The knife penetrated the right ventricle of Mr Smedley's heart and his left lung causing internal bleeding and his lung to collapse, the prosecutor said.
Mr Langdale told the court: 'The defendant raises the idea of self-defence claiming to the police he had recently been threatened by others with knives. As a result of that he decided to take this knife out.
'The Crown say this is an entirely false account, instead it was the defendant who routinely carried a Rambo knife… and did so for the kudos and bravado.'
The prosecutor said Hartle carried the weapon to show others he was a 'big man'.
Jurors heard the defendant, of Station Road in Stanley, Derbyshire, pleaded guilty to possessing a bladed article in a public place but denies murder.
CCTV of the group was shown to the jury, including the moment Mr Smedley was fatally stabbed with a knife described to be 'eight to nine inches' long.
Hartle allegedly 'cleaned himself up' and disposed of his balaclava, knife and phone before his father drove him to Ilkeston Police Station, the court heard.
The jury was told that in a prepared statement given to police, Hartle said: 'Firstly, I accept responsibility for inflicting the injury on Noah Smedley.
'There is a history to this, and Noah and I did not get on. He has, in the past, made numerous threats to me and made disparaging comments. He has threatened me with violence.
'I was petrified that he was about to lunge at me. In that split second, I instinctively lashed out with the knife I had, in self-defence.'
The trial, which is expected to last two weeks, continues.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

White female boss dressed as Whoopi Goldberg for Oscars-themed work party
White female boss dressed as Whoopi Goldberg for Oscars-themed work party

Telegraph

timean hour ago

  • Telegraph

White female boss dressed as Whoopi Goldberg for Oscars-themed work party

A white female executive racially harassed her black colleague when she dressed up as Whoopi Goldberg from Sister Act at an Oscar-themed work party, a tribunal heard. Jerry Logo said he experienced an 'immediate rush of anxiety' when he saw Agnes Ganswindt wearing the costume from the 1992 comedy with her face painted black at the office Christmas get-together. The accounts manager told a tribunal that it made him think of the 'dehumanisation' of black people, which caused him to suffer a panic attack. A panel found that Miss Ganswindt, a customer service agent, was 'genuinely unaware' that a white woman dressing up as a black actress might be offensive to someone who is black. Mr Logo sued for racial harassment, but his case was dismissed because he had brought the case four years after the event took place. But after hearing how his employers themselves agreed the 'black-face' event did constitute harassment, an appeal judge has now ruled that the claim should be reheard. The employment appeal tribunal (EAT) heard that Mr Logo started working in the UK for German payments firm Payone in November 2016 as an accounts manager. Some four days after he started work, while at the company's Frankfurt office for induction training, the business held a Christmas party themed as Oscars night. The tribunal said: 'Miss Ganswindt, who is white, attended the event dressed as the character played by Whoopi Goldberg in the Sister Act films.' 'Immediate rush of anxiety' Mr Logo said he felt an 'immediate rush of anxiety' when he saw the person, who he later realised was Miss Ganswindt, in 'black face paint'. The earlier employment tribunal hearing, which took place in Watford in 2023, was overseen by employment Judge Judith George. She said that the panel accepted that not only had Miss Ganswindt chosen the costume before she met Mr Logo, but she was also not aware that he would be in attendance. The judge said the black-face did occur, adding: 'It is conceded by [PayOne] that this incident would amount to race-related harassment on the basis of the unwanted conduct causing the harassing effect, and we accept that it does. '[Mr Logo] argued that this incident was harassment because Miss Ganswindt had the purpose of creating the harassing effect. 'We accept, after careful consideration, that she was genuinely unaware that a black British person would be likely to associate a white woman dressed as a black actress with an offensive and demeaning portrayal of people based on race.'

Australian state MP Gareth Ward found guilty of rape and indecent assault
Australian state MP Gareth Ward found guilty of rape and indecent assault

The Independent

time3 hours ago

  • The Independent

Australian state MP Gareth Ward found guilty of rape and indecent assault

An MP for New South Wales in Australia has been found guilty of raping a young man and sexually assaulting a teenager. Gareth Ward, 44, the independent MP for Kiama, was convicted by a jury at the Downing Centre District Court on Friday over separate incidents involving the two men in 2013 and 2015. The former Liberal minister had denied the allegations and pleaded not guilty to all counts. Ward was convicted on three counts of assault with an act of indecency against an 18-year-old man in 2013 and a count of intercourse without consent against a 24-year-old man in 2015. He will be sentenced at a later date. The prosecution argued the accounts of both men, who didn't know each other, were remarkably similar, while the defence claimed the allegations were false. "Similar behaviour, similar setting, same man, same conclusion. This is not a coincidence," crown prosecutor Monika Knowles said. The MP was accused of inviting the drunk teenager to his South Coast home in February 2013 and assaulting him three times in one night despite the young man's attempts to resist. Two years later, Ward raped an intoxicated staffer after an event at the NSW Parliament House. Ward claimed the 2015 rape never took place and that the other complainant was misremembering their encounter from 2013. Ward has been granted conditional bail to reside at one of his two homes. The Crown will make a detention application next Wednesday, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation reported. Ward was first elected to the state parliament as a Liberal MP in 2011 before being appointed parliamentary secretary in 2015. He went on to become the minister for families, communities and disability services after the 2019 election. Ward resigned from both the ministry and the Liberal Party in May 2021 after disclosing that he was the subject of a police investigation. He then moved to the crossbench as an independent. Two years later, he was re-elected as the independent MP for Kiama, narrowly defeating Labor nominee Katelin McInerney. Mark Speakman, leader of the opposition in the NSW assembly, said he would respect the verdict 'and the robust process which delivered it'. 'What any victim of sexual abuse endures is appalling and their strength in coming forward can't be overstated,' he said. 'There is no excuse for the criminal behaviour which the jury has found occurred beyond reasonable doubt – a complete abuse of power which has no place anywhere, let alone by those entrusted by the public to represent them.' Rape Crisis offers support for those affected by rape and sexual abuse. You can call them on 0808 802 9999 in England and Wales, 0808 801 0302 in Scotland, and 0800 0246 991 in Northern Ireland, or visit their website at If you are in the US, you can call Rainn on 800-656-HOPE (4673).

Bruce Lehrmann suffers legal defeat as he tries to halt rape trial in Toowoomba
Bruce Lehrmann suffers legal defeat as he tries to halt rape trial in Toowoomba

The Guardian

time6 hours ago

  • The Guardian

Bruce Lehrmann suffers legal defeat as he tries to halt rape trial in Toowoomba

Bruce Lehrmann has suffered a legal defeat in the first of multiple court battles aimed at halting a rape trial against him. Lehrmann's Sydney-based solicitor Zali Burrows on Friday took aim at Queensland police after withdrawing a bid to prove officers had illegally recorded two conversations between Lehrmann and his previous legal team. Burrows had also been seeking a court injunction to prevent police recording any future conversations with any of Lehrmann's legal representatives. Lehrmann, 30, appeared by phone on Friday when the matter was heard at Toowoomba district court. Judge Benedict Power dismissed the application after the claims were withdrawn by Burrows, who conceded her entire case would depend on proving officers had broken the law in Queensland. Outside court, Burrows told reporters she would never again speak to a Queensland police officer on the phone. 'All I can say is that it's another world in the state of Queensland,' she said. Burrows' application was part of a wider bid to seek a permanent stay on proceedings which, if granted, would halt a pending trial against Lehrmann on two counts of rape. Lehrmann, who is on bail, is accused of raping a woman twice during the morning of 10 October, 2021 after they allegedly met at a strip club the previous night in Toowoomba, west of Brisbane. The former ministerial staffer to the Liberal senator Linda Reynolds was charged in January 2023 and is yet to formally enter a plea. But his former solicitor had previously told a magistrate he intended to contest the charges. Burrows on Friday agreed with the judge's contention that the officers might have followed proper procedure for keeping accurate notes during the early stages of an investigation. 'You need to establish as a matter of law that what (the investigating detective) did was unlawful,' Power said. Burrows said police would have an 'unfair tactical advantage' if they had a recording of any conversation where a lawyer accidentally disclosed legally confidential material. Power said that would not be the fault of police and any of Lehrmann's solicitors could make a separate claim if there was confidential material. The Crown prosecutor Caroline Marco was not required to argue in court against Burrows except to agree with Power's proposed order to dismiss. She told Power the application to halt the trial could only be heard once all other applications were dealt with. Power told the lawyers they needed to be in a position by 31 July to nominate a date for when the trial might begin. Burrows told Power that while Lehrmann's previous solicitor had indicated he would make an application for a judge-only trial, her client no longer had a position on whether any trial should be heard by a jury. The matter will return to court on 28 August for a hearing concerning Burrows' efforts to subpoena the commissioner of Queensland police for access to all materials involved in the case.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store