Coalition accused of being 'epic wasters' in testy final Dáil sitting
During the final Leaders' Questions session before politicians finish up for the summer, Tánaiste Simon Harris, who was answering on behalf of government today, included testy back-and-forths between himself and his parliamentary colleagues.
On infrastructure, Whitmore said the coalition has failed invest in the critical infrastructure needed to care for the country's population.
The Wicklow TD said: 'You talk about the importance of infrastructure as if it has suddenly dawned on you, while Irish Water warns it will run out of capacity for new homes in Dublin in three years.
'We are on course to have zero – zero – offshore wind generated by 2030 and our electricity grid is on the verge of collapse.'
She said that the government had not promised to provide supports to public services, households or wide-ranging cost-of-living expenses in the upcoming budget either.
Whitmore added:
The reality is, this government, you're epic wasters.
'You've wasted time, you have wasted opportunity, and you have wasted a generational opportunity to invest in a better future, and you've wasted our money.'
Advertisement
Responding, Harris said Whitmore's party have previously demanded that more precisely targeted measures are introduced in the budget, which the government intends to do this year.
He rejected claims that government had wasted money and time.
The Tánaiste agreed with Whitmore on the challenges facing the delivery of infrastructure, and said that a 'very significant increase' in investment would be allocated in the revised National Development Plan for that.
During the debate Harris was interrupted by Sinn Féin's Pearse Doherty after claiming he was concerned over Sinn Féin's chairperson position on the Oireachtas Defence and National Security Committee.
Doherty demanded that Harris retract his statement, in which he claimed he did not think it was a 'good idea' for the party to chair the committee.
Sinn Féin TD Pearse Doherty demanded that Harris retract his remarks about his party.
Oireachtas.ie
Oireachtas.ie
'That is a disgrace. Disgraceful politics,' Doherty said, while on his feet in the Dáil.
'I don't think it's a particularly shocking position for the leader of Fine Gael to hold,' Harris responded.
Aontú TD Peadar Tóibín also critiqued the government's record during the session today. He accused the coalition of having poor attendance, failing to deal with issues in housing and healthcare and alleged that crime had risen as a result of their policies.
The Tánaiste rejected the Meath TD's assertions, and later added: 'I haven't had as long to write your report card as you've had to write ours. But here's my go at it. Name-calling and personalised attacks, top of the class. Peadar has excelled this term.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Post
8 hours ago
- Irish Post
Protest in Dublin following racially-motivated attack on Indian national in Tallaght
HUNDREDS of people took to the streets of Dublin on Saturday to protest against a racially-motivated attack on an Indian national in Tallaght last Saturday. The protestors gathered at City Hall before marching to the Dáil to highlight such attacks, which they say are growing in frequency but are under-reported. The event, organised by members of the migrant community in Ireland, saw demonstrators carrying placards reading 'Stop racist attacks' and 'Don't blame migrants, blame the system'. In a statement this week, gardaí said they were treating the incident, which occurred in Kilnamanagh, as racially-motivated. (Image: Leah Farrell / Footage of the bloodied victim has appeared online, alongside false claims that he had been acting inappropriately with children prior to the attack. "We are aware of misinformation and disinformation in circulation regarding the circumstances prior to this assault — this baseless speculation is completely false," added gardaí. The victim, who had only been in Ireland for a week, had reportedly been beaten and striped from the waist down after being set upon by a gang of teenagers. (Image: Leah Farrell / Saturday's protest was supported by numerous organisations including United Against Racism, Migrant Rights Centre Ireland, Migrant Nurses Ireland and Unite the Union. Ahead of the march, organisers attributed such attacks in Ireland to the rise of the far-right. "This Indian man came here to work in a multinational company," read a statement. "A huge contribution is made by migrant workers to Ireland's economy and society. (Image: Leah Farrell / "But the growth of racism and the far-right internationally is allowing hate, lies and division to spread and making these type of assaults more common. "This protest is about the entire migrant community in Ireland coming together — and of course we also appeal to Irish people, trade unions and community groups to come out in support so that we can send a powerful message to racists and build a strong united front against racism." On Friday, a silent protest was held at the Department of members of the Indian community in Ireland, while an anti-racism vigil was held later that evening in Tallaght. See More: Dublin, Kilnamanagh, Tallaght
RTÉ News
11 hours ago
- RTÉ News
First kite of pre-budget season flew over Leinster House
Bird watchers sometimes herald the sighting of the first swallow of the year as the start of spring. And, not to be outdone, political anoraks have a similar phrase too. The first kite of the pre-budget season flew high and mighty over a quieter than usual Leinster House this week, as the beginning of the Dáil's summer recess was interrupted by a potentially serious political row gliding into view. Not for the first time, it involved a once cast-iron pre-election promise whose carefully choreographed landing now risks becoming a victim of some not exactly unexpected post-election economic turbulence. And, not for the last time, the planned flight trajectory could yet be replaced by an all too public nose dive as the Coalition checks its political radar for signs of how to navigate its way between two competing financial priorities. Hospitality tax cut The reason for the situation is a Programme for Government promise which is now at real risk of being delayed. In the January document, which outlines what Government intends to do in power, the Fianna Fáil-Fine Gael-Independents Coalition confirmed that the existing 13.5% hospitality VAT rate would be reduced. That commitment, which was one of Fine Gael's key commitments in last November's General Election, was widely seen as indicating but did not explicitly point to this October's Budget as the moment the 13.5% rate would be cut to 9%. Such a move would support struggling restaurants, bars, cafes, pubs and hotels, and therefore help protect jobs. "Our Budget decisions could change depending on the economic environment we find ourselves in." But its near €1 billion price tag would mean less financial space for cost of living supports for the wider pubic, an issue that was made crystal clear as Government outlined its immediate economic plans this week. During a press conference at Government Buildings on Tuesday, Taoiseach Micheál Martin, Tánaiste Simon Harris, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers announced the Coalition's National Development Plan and Summer Economic Statement. The former outlined a €275bn capital projects war chest for the coming decade, including aspirational promises and dazzling numbers like €36bn for housing, €22bn for transport infrastructure such as the long-delayed Dublin Metro, and almost €10bn for health. But the latter was more pragmatic, detailing in practical terms how much money Government actually has to play with in its coffers right now - and, specifically, space for €1.5bn worth of tax cuts in Budget 2026. The figure may seem like a lot, and it is, but it still does not pay for everything voters want. And, inevitably, that means difficult choices for the coalition to make, including when it comes to promises previously given. Despite both Mr Martin and Mr Harris saying in recent months that the cut will happen, Mr Donohoe told reporters that the expected hospital VAT reduction from 13.5% to 9% was not as certain as previously indicated. Rarely one to misspeak, Minister Donohoe explained that if the hospitality VAT rate is reduced it is important "to be open" about the fact "trade offs" with other sections of society may be necessary. "I have always made clear my intention with regard to that [the hospitality VAT cut]," he said. His use of the word "intention" rather than anything stronger peaked the interest of attending reporters. "But I have also said there are trade offs, and there are consequences to that," he said. "And there are therefore other things that we are not going to be able to do. "If you were to bring forward a tax package that was to fund a full year measure that was in relation to the VAT, the cost of that would be nearly a €1bn." "And then if I was to add to that other measures we've done in the past, we would have a tax package that is far bigger than what I believe would be safe," he said. He added: "Our Budget decisions could change depending on the economic environment we find ourselves in." A pre-budget kite, in other words. And one that has caused if not a split, then certainly some friction, within the Coalition as competing political priorities have emerged. Internal Coalition friction While Minister Donohoe's comments were likely designed to point out the reality of the dilemma for Government rather than specifically rule out the hospitality tax cuts this year, they did open the door to the prospect within at least some sections of the coalition. By Wednesday, several Government sources had indicated privately that the cut should be delayed until July 2026, with Fianna Fáil members - including the wily long-time Limerick City TD Willie O'Dea - among those to publicly nudge forward the argument. Speaking on Friday on RTÉ's Morning Ireland programme, Deputy O'Dea said given the limited scope for tax reductions in the upcoming budget, he would "like to see it [the €1.5bn in available tax cuts] more equitably divided", with "an increase in tax credits and tax bands in line with inflation" his priority. Asked if this is because it would be difficult to convince voters to support helping the hospitality sector first, given a disputed reputation for price gouging by some businesses in that sector, Deputy O'Dea said: "It's not just a question of would it be hard to sell to the public, it's would it be good for the economy." Responding to suggestions of friction in the Coalition over the situation, he added: "I wouldn't describe it as friction, people have different views and that's what Coalition government is about." "I don't understand what kind of kites the Government are flying in relation to this cut for the hospitality industry, the Government are sewing massive seeds of confusion on this yet again." Deputy O'Dea's view was echoed privately by numerous Fianna Fáil TDs, and a smaller number of Fine Gael colleagues, who questioned how prioritising help for businesses instead of cost of living supports for the wider public might play out. And senior Government sources did little to kill off the suggestion when asked. But Fine Gael TD and Minister for Enterprise and Tourism Peter Burke - the politician responsible for the sector - had a different view during a hastily organised press briefing at Government Buildings on Thursday. Asked if he would acknowledge the hospitality VAT tax rate cut will now be delayed until next summer, Minister Burke responded: "Absolutely not acknowledging that, any negotiations will form part of the budget. "We're now still in July and it's very important to note the Budget will consider all options in every different sector." Opposition criticism The opposition, it is fair to say, were less than impressed over the apparent confusion over whether the hospitality tax cut would still go ahead on 1 January or be delayed until at least next July. Labour TD Duncan Smith said bluntly: "I don't understand what kind of kites the Government are flying in relation to this cut for the hospitality industry, the Government are sewing massive seeds of confusion on this yet again." That view was shared by other opposition TDs, including Sinn Féin's Donnchadh O'Laoghaire who said the Coalition needs to find a way to help both the hospitality sector and the wider public through cost of living supports. And it was echoed too by non-political groups representing those in the sector, which became locked in a war of words over what should happen next. Responding to the watering down of the previous tax cut promise, Restaurants Association of Ireland Chief Executive Adrian Cummins said: "If the VAT rate doesn't reduce to 9% from January 1, you'll see more and more closures" and resulting job losses, noting more than 200 restaurants have already closed this year. However, the view was countered by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions general secretary Owen Reidy. "The proposal to cut the VAT rate at a time of huge economic uncertainty flies in the face of all available evidence, and would amount to nothing less than economic vandalism," he said. "The Government has identified many laudable priorities as part of its programme for Government: housing, reductions in child poverty, and investment in disability services. "Given that ministers have been giving serious warnings about economic uncertainty, why would they prioritise a corporate handout costing almost €1bn?" Government dilemma That latter point goes to the heart of the difficulty now facing Government, and in part helps to explain the early nature of this week's at times contradictory pre-budget kite flying. While there is a strong argument for the need to protect businesses, and therefore jobs, in the hospitality sector during a period of intense global financial uncertainty, few politicians would want to be seen to be doing so at the expense of supports for households during that same economic turbulence. In that context a calculated delay to the hospitality VAT rate cut plans makes some sense, as it would allow Government to continue to argue it will - eventually - keep its promise while giving itself more short-term financial space to protect the wider public. That plan, however, comes with a significant catch, in that the hospitality sector is insistent a delay to the tax cut will see people lose their jobs. But, more than one Government TD has privately noted this week, not delaying the tax cut in order to have more space for wider public cost of living supports would put households at risk and give opposition parties an obvious line of attack the coalition could do without. The first kite of the pre-budget season has now soared into view. Depending on which way the economic and public wind blows, it could yet lead to an unexpectedly bumpy political ride.
RTÉ News
13 hours ago
- RTÉ News
CMAT's housing single strikes a chord with young people
In the week when the Government made housing the focus of its revised National Development Plan, CMAT's newest single struck a chord with young people at the sharp end of the housing crisis. The Co Meath artist's single EURO-COUNTRY dropped on Tuesday - the same day the Taoiseach described housing as the "defining social challenge of our time". EURO-COUNTRY tells the story of the 2008 financial crash from CMAT's perspective as a child in a small town living through the consequences of the Celtic Tiger's collapse. The song includes the lyrics: "All the big boys/All the Berties/All the envelopes, yeah they hurt me/I was 12 when the das started killing themselves all around me/And it was normal/Building houses that stay empty even now." The track has hit home with people who were children when the Celtic Tiger came to an end and are now in their 20s and 30s. Many people have been posting on TikTok about how this 'anthem' resonates with them. "The anxieties that she has are anxieties that I often have living in Ireland," said Memphis Zuza, a 21-year-old student at NCAD. Darragh Greene is a content creator and musician living in Turkey. He said it's a bittersweet time to be a young person in Ireland. Darragh said he emigrated due to the cost of living here and the opportunities elsewhere. "I think this single is a good mix of emotions. The frustration, anger and unjust that young Irish people feel towards their government and the economy while also having a real love for the country," he said. "I don't see a future where I'm based in Ireland." Andrew Corkery, 26, works in retail. He said that young people feel neglected by the Government. Living in his family home, he said "he can't even fathom" moving out of his childhood bedroom. "As young people, we have been sidelined, shafted and completely neglected by the Government. "We are essentially locked out of having a sustainable future," Andrew said. Earlier this year, a major survey of 25-year-olds revealed the impact of the economic recession on their lives. The 'Growing Up in Ireland' survey found that more than six in ten (62%) young people were still living with parents for mostly financial reasons. Just over one third (34.2%) of respondents said they had difficulties making ends meet. One in eight of the people contacted to take part in the survey had emigrated. CMAT's single may be new but the issues it tackles have been in the minds of young Ireland for a while.
