First Nations call for Ontario environment minister to resign for trying to stop clean water bill
Debassige and several dozen First Nation chiefs met with Premier Doug Ford a few weeks ago to discuss Bill 5. Ford had said the day before that First Nations should stop coming to him 'hat in hand' if they don't get on board with Bill 5.
Article content
He then apologized to Debassige and those chiefs in a private meeting before repeating it at a news conference on live television.
Article content
Debassige and the chiefs accepted that apology and agreed to move forward with extensive consultations on the new law.
Article content
Debassige said Ford told them that day he was in full support of clean drinking water for all Ontario First Nations and was going to figure out a way to help. That issue is a federal one, though Ford hinted on radio recently the province might step up if the federal government does not.
Article content
'Everyone deserves fresh drinking water,' Ford said of First Nations on NewsTalk 1010.
Article content
Debassige still takes the premier's word and believes McCarthy had gone 'rogue.'
Article content
'To hear directly from the premier that he is in full support and then have one of his ministers turn around and ask the prime minister of Canada to essentially decommit in introducing C-61 is a complete show of disrespect, a show of incompetence and he's a loose cannon in my view,' said Debassige.
Article content
Article content
Ontario passed the Clean Water Act in 2006, which ensures the protection of municipal drinking water systems. That came in response to the deadly E. coli outbreak in Walkerton, Ont., that killed seven people and made more than 2,000 people sick.
Article content
But that Ontario bill does not extend to First Nations in the province because of jurisdictional issues.
Article content
The federal clean water bill is part of a court-ordered settlement over a class-action lawsuit First Nations won against Ottawa over this very issue.
Article content
Debassige helped draft that legislation, saying it was historic in many ways, including the fact the federal government worked with First Nations to write it.
Article content
'The process we went through and we were able to negotiate was a testament to the government's commitment to reconciliation,' she said.
Article content
'This is not reconciliation. I know the premier's office is very aware of our position and our response to these idiotic comments.'
Article content
The Ford government has been taking pains to assuage First Nations' concerns over Bill 5 in the last month, pledging extensive consultations and a say in how related regulations are drafted.
Article content
Article content
Neskantaga First Nation in northern Ontario has lived under a boil-water advisory for more than 30 years. The community says the water gives them lesions, eczema and a host of other skin issues if they shower or bathe in it. It leads to gastrointestinal issues if they drink from the taps and about half of the community has never lived at a time when the water was safe to drink.
Article content
The federal government flies in planeloads of bottled water to the remote First Nation several times every week.
Article content
McCarthy's letter was the latest 'slap in the face' from the province, said Neskantaga Chief Gary Quisess.
Article content
'It doesn't feel right to the poor people in Neskantaga,' he said. 'It's very disturbing.'
Article content
The community has been traumatized over decades of unsafe drinking water, he said.
Article content
'We have a mental health crisis and trauma that is very much related to the boil-water advisory, including suicides,' Quisess said. 'Life is very tough and there's no end in sight to the trauma here.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
3 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Settlement dollars paying for broken promises, missed opportunities, devastated lives
This week, the federal government agreed to a $99-million settlement with Muscowpetung Saulteaux Nation, a First Nation approximately 60 kilometres northeast of Regina, for Canada's failure to provide agricultural support and materials as promised under Treaty 4. That seems like a lot of money, but it's really not. And, far more important, is the profit from the opportunity gained when justice is finally served. Under Treaty 4, signed in 1874, 35 First Nations across what is now northwestern Manitoba, almost all of southern Saskatchewan and southeastern Alberta were promised farming tools including plows, seeds and animals to rebuild their lives after losing their traditional territories — and, indeed, their livelihoods — due to urbanization and settlement. The federal government didn't keep its promises, resulting in massive poverty, starvation and death as communities struggled to build economies, feed themselves and stave off sickness due to weakened immune systems. Add in the fact First Nations had to endure laws such as the Indian Act, which forbade movement, provided substandard education and prevented economic growth, and you get — in many cases — the dire situations that exist now. Farming is the financial and cultural bedrock of life in Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta, and First Nations didn't even get a chance to participate. So, how much does it cost to compensate 151 years of suffering and lost opportunities? Much more than $99 million. Meanwhile, the other 34 First Nations in Treaty 4 are owed the same thing. This week, alongside the agreement with Muscowpetung Saulteaux Nation, the federal government also announced settlements with two other Treaty 4 communities: Big River First Nation ($208 million) and One Arrow First Nation ($124 million). The claims don't end at Treaty 4. Agricultural materials and opportunities were promised to virtually every First Nation from northwestern Ontario to B.C. to the Northwest Territories in what is often called the (11) 'numbered' treaties, negotiated between 1871 and 1921. Those promises weren't kept, either. In fact, more than 50 specific such 'cows and plows' claims against the federal government have now been negotiated with First Nations. The total so far is $6.9 billion. There are another 100 or so additional cases under negotiation and about 150 legitimate claims yet to come. In Manitoba, there are 24 in process, which leaves 39 more First Nations— including my home community of Peguis First Nation — with claims they can (and likely will) pursue. Most Manitoba claims are currently in the 'assessment' or 'negotiation' stage, according to information provided by the Government of Canada. Five Manitoba claims have been settled: Gambler First Nation, Pine Creek First Nation, Sapotaweyak Cree Nation, Tootinaowaziibeeng Treaty Reserve and Wuskwi Sipihk First Nation, each in the hundreds of millions of dollars. Don't get caught up in the numbers. It's about new opportunities. This is why many don't like the term 'cows and plows' when describing these agreements; treaty promises of agricultural materials and support wasn't about providing First Nations with one-time payments, but opportunities to grow their economies, thrive and live like anyone else. This is why some communities choose different paths when obtaining a settlement. In some cases, First Nations governments provide their members a 'per-capita' payment. Muscowpetung, for example, approved a $40,000 one-time payment for each member. Ironically, it's probably more a benefit passed on to Canadian businesses and citizens, as First Nations beneficiaries will spend their settlement dollars buying things for themselves and their families. Most First Nations governments have set up trust funds to pay for community infrastructure projects and programs — a long-missed opportunity to build the lives of residents, provide employment and facilitate the growth of educational and cultural paths. It's easy to get caught up in the money when it comes to settling legitimate claims First Nations have with the Canadian government over failed promises. What's harder to see are the opportunities that should have been, and the ones now possible when justice is finally served. Status report on specific claims Niigaan SinclairColumnist Niigaan Sinclair is Anishinaabe and is a columnist at the Winnipeg Free Press. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
CTV News
4 hours ago
- CTV News
Conestoga College reports a $121M surplus
Conestoga College is reporting a huge financial surplus. But, as CTV's Karis Mapp explains, it's almost half of what the school had the previous year. Conestoga College is reporting a huge financial surplus. But, as CTV's Karis Mapp explains, it's almost half of what the school had the previous year. Conestoga College is reporting a huge surplus, but that's far from good news for the Kitchener school. Colleges across Ontario were required to publicly release the data by 11:59 p.m. on July 31. While Conestoga College made the deadline, it was the last school in the province to do so. The report showed that in its most recent fiscal year, ending March 31, the school's surplus topped $121 million – a huge drop from the $252 million surplus they posted the previous year. Conestoga College said its revenue from tuition dropped to $563 million, $119 million less than it reported in 2024. The school also said it spent $436 million on salaries and benefits, an increase of $37 million from the year before. Seeking answers CTV News asked Conestoga College for an in-person interview, but the school said no one was available to comment on the surplus. In fact, CTV News has repeatedly reached out to Conestoga College for interviews on international student enrolment, as well as its financial and community impact. Each time, the school claimed no one was available. John Tibbits, the president of the college, has not agreed to any interview requests from CTV News since 2023. The school has only responded with written statements, sent by email, none of which have been attributed to Tibbits. According to the Ontario Sunshine List, Tibbits' salary soared alongside the increase in international student enrolment. In 2022, he earned $409,900 as the school's president. The following year it rose 20.7 per cent to $494,716. Tibbits' salary for 2024 was listed on the Ontario Sunshine List as $636,107. That was a year-over-year increase of 28.6 per cent. It also made Tibbits the highest-paid public sector worker in Waterloo Region. He earned more than the presidents of Wilfrid Laurier University, the University of Waterloo and the University of Guelph. The school's board of governors has extended Tibbits' contact until Aug. 31, 2025. He has been Conestoga College's president since 1987. Conestoga College's statement Conestoga College responded to CTV News' request for an interview with a statement sent, as per usual, by email. In it, the school blamed federal caps and changes to the international student program for 'significantly reduced' enrolment. They said it 'placed financial pressure on institutions across the province that rely on this revenue to support core programs and services.' They also cited what they called 'Canada's rapidly declining popularity as an international education destination.' 'No Ontario college has been able to achieve its allotted international enrolment,' the statement read. 'Most colleges have seen a reduction of 60-70 per cent. Conestoga expects a loss of approximately 20,000 international student enrolments for the fall 2025 term compared to the fall of 2023. This equates to a loss of approximately $450 million in revenue over the last two years.' The federal government announced in early 2024 it was slashing study permits for international students and Ontario's allotment was reduced by almost half. Schools were told applications could not exceed 2023 permit levels, and international permits must be less than 55 per cent of the school's first-year domestic enrolment. The province specifically called out Conestoga College, stating it would see the 'largest decline.' That was not surprising, since the school had one of the largest international student populations in the province. The college said its surplus, for the fiscal year ending March 31, was 'the result of careful planning and responsible financial management while balancing the impact of reduced international enrolment.' They added: 'This was not without its challenges, and we continue to navigate the biggest financial crisis in the history of the Ontario public post-secondary education system.' In a report, sent to students and staff on July 28, Conestoga College said 8,584 international students were enrolled in its 2025 spring semester. That marked a 62 per cent drop from the year before, when it totaled 22,633. Domestic student enrolment, however, rose 28 per cent to 3,498 during the spring semester. In the statement sent to CTV News, the school said they have 'taken steps to grow domestic enrolment by maintaining existing academic programming where possible, developing new programs that meet workforce needs, and strategically investing in building infrastructure, equipment and student support services.' Conestoga College also touted its renewed focus. 'Our investments have enabled the college to be one of the fastest-growing in domestic enrolment in the last year, seeing a three per cent increase in winter 2025 enrolment, a 7.5 per cent increase in the spring, and fall confirmations are up by almost 15 per cent,' they wrote. Tough decisions also had to be made, they explained, to address a projected fiscal deficit for 2025-2026. 'Through decisive action to reduce labour and operational costs, we will address these financial pressures and position the college for a stable and sustainable future,' they promised. The school previously offered early retirement packages to some employees, while others were laid off. Earlier this month, the college announced several of its senior administrators were no longer employed at the school. Cuts have also been made to programs, as well as campus consolidations in Kitchener and Brantford. Despite the projected fiscal deficit, Conestoga College said it is investing in its future. 'The college plans to invest $145 million in capital projects that include phase two of the Conestoga Skilled Trades Campus in Cambridge, phase two of the Waterloo campus renovation, renovations of the Tollgate Technological Skills Centre in Brantford to expand skilled trades programming and Doon campus renovations to accommodate new programming such as the animal care suite of programs,' the statement said. One project, however, has stalled. The college confirmed to CTV News it had paused work at its satellite campus in Guelph. The school purchased the building, at 130 Macdonell Street, in 2023. Conestoga College said plans for what comes next will be decided when 'student enrolment allows.' Reaction to surplus Vikki Poirier is the president of OPSEU Local 238, which represents full-time and part-time support staff at the college. She said the school's response is concerning. 'I don't see this as being rightsizing, or an international student issue,' Porier told CTV News. 'This is about deliberate underfunding and bad management choices.' She also questioned the school's focus on growth. 'Why are we not investing in our workforce? Our real resources of support staff and faculty, rather than brick and mortar.' Michael Harris is a regional councillor who has been critical of the college's large surplus, as well as the international student boom and its impact on regional services and planning. He shared his concerns with CTV News prior to the report's release. 'There was a tuition freeze happening provincially and colleges, frankly, exploited the monetary gain from international students,' Harris said. Poirier felt the school should have seen a change coming. 'I'm not going to say that we didn't need our international students, or we shouldn't have them, but this was only going to last for so long,' she explained. 'We were so saturated.' Poirier was also skeptical of the college's next steps. 'We haven't really received the full snapshot of what the erosion is,' she said. 'We saw a pretty picture that was sent out in a graph form, but we don't have the nitty gritty.' Harris, meanwhile, was cautiously optimistic about what lies ahead for the school and Waterloo Region. 'We'll continue to hopefully have that dialog with the college in terms of where they're going,' he said. 'But there's no doubt been a strain on regional resources over the last little while.'
CTV News
4 hours ago
- CTV News
CTV National News: Trump fires senior official over jobs numbers
CTV National News: Trump fires senior official over jobs numbers U.S. President Donald Trump has ordered the firing of the head of the Bureau of Labor Statistics after job numbers were lower than expected in July.
