California says crime is down. But officials know the data is flawed
The California Department of Justice this week published a major report, and a corresponding press release, touting a drop in violent crime across the state. But the data underlying the report is substantially flawed — thanks to a big mistake that the DOJ was made aware of last year after Chronicle reporting, but did not fix.
In last year's Crime in California report, the Chronicle found that Oakland had logged an improbably high violent crime spike in 2023, fueled by a reported 138% jump in aggravated assaults — a number that did not match Oakland's own year-end report.
After the Chronicle inquired, Oakland police said the anomaly was due to 'human error.' When the newspaper brought the problem to the head of the DOJ, Attorney General Rob Bonta, a spokesperson pinned the blame on Oakland. The office did not issue any correction to the statewide numbers in the report.
This year, the state again used the faulty numbers in its report, despite knowing they were incorrect. The office did not respond to questions about why it did not correct the known error in the data. In the report, it pointed users to Oakland's website, saying to 'use caution' in comparing 2023 numbers to any other year.
But the state did not heed that advice in its own press release, citing a 6% decrease in violent crime in the state between 2023 and 2024. Had the state corrected the 2023 numbers using the Oakland police data that it linked to, violent crime statewide would have decreased by 2%, according to a Chronicle analysis.
The error distracts from what are otherwise promising long-term trends in California crime rates. Even after correcting for the flaw, levels of both reported violent and property crime are well below the historic highs of the 1980s and 90s, and continued to trend downwards in 2024. Homicides across the state have come back down from pandemic-era surges and have continued to decline this year, according to the Real-Time Crime Index, which compiles data from local agencies. San Francisco reported a 60-year low in killings last year.
Asked last year whether the state checks to ensure the accuracy of data in its reports, the attorney general's office said staff members ask local police departments about anomalous data if they notice it, but that they do not have the responsibility to do so.
'The onus is on every police department to report accurate data. Our role is to publish a comprehensive report based on what each of the 500+ agencies are responsible for reporting to us,' a spokesperson said in an email last year. 'Any discrepancy is the responsibility of the local agency.'
But on the fourth page of the report, the DOJ notes that the role of the Criminal Justice Statistics Center, which compiles the report, is to 'collect, analyze, and report statistical data that provide valid measures of crime, to 'examine these data on an ongoing basis to better describe crime' and to 'promote the responsible presentation and use of crime statistics.'
Researchers and advocates rely on the state's crime data reports to analyze trends, measure the impact of policy changes and make criminal justice recommendations. In the press release that came alongside the reports, Bonta's office pointed to them as 'vital' information that can be used to 'support informed policy choices.'
Magnus Lofstrom, the criminal justice policy director at the Public Policy Institute of California, said that the flawed report 'is of concern.' But he noted that the DOJ provided several caveats with the data, which included this year's note cautioning people against using 2023 as a comparison.
Lofstrom said that, in addition to the Oakland mistake, the number of agencies that reported incomplete data was 'unusually high' in 2023.
What that means is that, for every report based on the state data, Lofstrom and his team must manually correct several of the numbers on the individual agency level in its analyses, substituting in estimates based on the averages and shares of crimes in other months.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
Jeanine Pirro claps back at reporters over D.C. crime questions at Justice Department press event
U.S. Attorney for D.C. Jeanine Pirro schooled the media Tuesday during a heated exchange during a Department of Justice press conference.
Politico
2 hours ago
- Politico
What William Bennett is doing for Qatar
With help from Daniel Lippman REPRESENTING QATAR: Former Education Secretary William Bennett registered as a foreign agent last month to provide the Qatari government with backup against accusations that it has funded antisemitic activity on college campuses. A filing with the Justice Department on Monday offers a glimpse at what exactly Bennett is doing for the Gulf nation. — 'I accepted this role so I could apply my experience and independent judgment to a growing body of accusations against Qatar,' the Reagan-era education chief wrote in a recent letter to current Education Secretary Linda McMahon, according to a copy filed with DOJ on Monday. The Qatari Embassy is paying Bennett a $30,000 monthly retainer for his work, DOJ filings show. — Foreign funding in U.S. academia — of which Qatar is a top provider — has become a major focus of congressional Republicans probing anti-Israel protests at colleges. It was the subject of an executive order signed by President Donald Trump in April. — Bennett refuted the notion that Qatar has sought to exert 'malign influence' or sought to foster antisemitism on campuses. Many of the gifts attributed to Qatar in federal disclosure databases are tied to satellite campuses in Doha operated by more than half a dozen U.S. colleges — a model that 'should be recognized as a constructive extension of American educational leadership,' he wrote. — Moreover, Bennett claimed his review found that some of the worst allegations about Qatari influence on campuses were the result of a 'coordinated campaign of distortion led primarily by third-party advocacy groups' such as the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy, 'whose motivations and funding sources deserve far more scrutiny than they have received.' — The think tank, which has previously received funding from the Israeli government, has been one of the top critics of Qatar's gifts to universities, with its leaders and research featured in numerous congressional hearings on the matter. — Bennett lauded McMahon's push for greater transparency into foreign influence in academia, repeatedly pointing to his own registration as a foreign agent as proof. But 'if the Department is to evaluate the influence of foreign funding in higher education,' he wrote, 'it should do so comprehensively and impartially, including examining the foreign ties, funding sources, and lobbying activities of those making the loudest accusations.' — 'Contrary to the false assertions by Mr. Bennett, ISGAP is an independent non-partisan high calibre research Centre,' Charles Asher Small, ISGAP's executive director, told PI in an email. 'Unlike Mr [Bennett], ISGAP does not work with, or for, foreign entities, like the Qatari Regime his client.' Small said that the group had received a $123,000 grant from the Israeli government in 2019 'for a university based academic programme,' but that it was the 'only occasion in ISGAPs history that we received a grant from a government.' — 'Mr. Bennett quotes false reports designed to dismiss our fact based research that points to the dangers of unreported foreign funding of American higher education by entities, like the undemocratic Qatari regime with … close relations to the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas and to other terror entities.' Happy Tuesday and welcome to PI. Keep sending influence tips and scoops from whichever waterside locale you're spending recess in. Add me on Signal at caitlinoprysko.17 and email me at coprysko@ and you can add Daniel on Signal at danielbarnes.13 and email Daniel at dbarnes@ And follow us on X: @caitlinoprysko and @dnlbrns. AFGE'S ADVOCACY SHOP GETS AN OVERHAUL: The largest union representing federal employees is retooling its advocacy operations amid the Trump administration's moves to slash and dramatically reshape the federal workforce. — The American Federation of Government Employees announced today that it's bringing together staffers working on political, grassroots, education, community relations and comms for the union under the umbrella of a newly formed 'Advocacy Department.' — Andrew Huddleston, who has led AFGE's comms team for the past seven years, will lead the new advocacy unit. Brittany Holder will move up to communications director, and AFGE's political and field staff will be led by an as-yet-unnamed director. — AFGE's lobbying arm will remain separate from the advocacy department. But the union tapped Daniel Horowitz, who's been heading up AFGE's Hill outreach on an interim basis since January, to fill the role permanently. — 'The idea is for AFGE to be ready to act fast when events break, while also pursuing our long-term goals: winning for our members, protecting the integrity of our government, building stronger partnerships with allies, and making AFGE more powerful and influential for decades to come,' Huddleston told PI of the reorg. — AFGE has been on the front lines of the Trump administration's war with the federal workforce as Elon Musk's DOGE cost-cutting initiative moved to shutter entire agencies, steamroll career employees and obtain access to sensitive government data. The administration has also taken aim at federal workers' rights to unionize altogether and last week moved to cancel collective bargaining agreements for EPA employees. — But the administration attacks on the federal bureaucracy have already hit the union hard, and AFGE announced in April that it would lay off more than half of its own workforce. CREDIT UNIONS TAP NUSSLE'S SUCCESSOR: America's Credit Unions has picked Scott Simpson as the next president and chief executive of the trade group. Simpson will take over in November from former Rep. Jim Nussle, who announced his retirement in April. Simpson is currently president and CEO of the California Credit Union League and Nevada's Credit Unions in addition to serving as CEO of Utah's Credit Union Association. — At America's Credit Unions, which formed last year as the result of a merger between the two leading trade groups for credit unions, the Credit Union National Association and the National Association of Federally-Insured Credit Unions, Simpson has served on the group's legislative action council and led its national advocacy fund. BLUESKY LOBBIES UP: Bluesky Social, the upstart microblogging platform angling to dethrone Musk's X, has hired its first federal lobbyists. The Vogel Group began working last month to provide 'general awareness and education building about decentralized platforms' like Bluesky, according to a newly filed disclosure. Republican lobbyist and firm founder Alex Vogel is working on the account along with Ali Khimji, Gabby Smith and Isabelle Drayer. — Bluesky was started in 2019 as a research project by Twitter architect and then-CEO Jack Dorsey to explore decentralization, which allows users to store their data on independent servers rather than ones owned by the company. Bluesky launched its social media app years later after spinning off from Twitter before Musk's takeover. — It has shown more staying power than some of the other social networks competing to replace Dorsey's old site, and saw another surge of new users following Trump's election last year. But X remains dominant over Bluesky Social and Meta Platforms' copycat site Threads, TechCrunch reported last month. ANNALS OF DARK MONEY: New DNC Chair Ken Martin 'is taking a symbolic step toward curbing the influence of undisclosed and corporate funds in his party's 2028 presidential primary,' The New York Times' Reid Epstein reports, 'a move that is likely to instigate a broader conversation about the role of big money in Democratic politics.' — Martin's plans include tasking a new reform committee with coming up with 'real, enforceable steps the D.N.C. can take to eliminate unlimited corporate and dark money in its 2028 presidential primary process' by next summer. — 'The move is the first significant maneuver from Mr. Martin to shape the party's next presidential nominating process,' the Times writes. But 'how much bite the effort has will be determined in large part by the enforcement mechanism the party seeks to implement,' especially as some Democrats have called for going toe to toe against the GOP in other political arenas like redistricting. SPOTTED on Saturday at the Edgartown home of April Miller Boise and David Willbrand for a fundraiser benefiting the DSCC and Sens. Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-Del.), Cory Booker (D-N.J.), Raphael Warnock (D-Ga.) and Angela Alsobrooks (D-Md.), per a tipster: Sens. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) and Mark Warner (D-Va.), Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas), Maryland Gov. Wes Moore, Michigan Lt. Gov. Garlin Gilchrist, co-hosts Paul and Sonya Brathwaite of Federal Street Strategies; Art Collins of TheGROUP, Larry Parks of Forethought Advisors, Hasoni Pratts of the National Urban League, former Domestic Policy Council Director Susan Rice, Dawn Smalls of Jenner & Block, Bert Smyers of New Heights Research, Robyn Minter Smyers of Thompson Hine and Crystal Wagar of The Southern Group and TSG Advocates; Mo Cowan of Devoted Health, former Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms, Veronica Duron of Booker's office, Joy Russell of Alsobrooks' office, Will Washington of Blunt Rochester's office and Meredith Lilly of Warnock's office. Jobs report — Elliott Echols is now senior vice president at Frontline Government Relations. He previously was national political director at the RNC. — Stephanie Waties is returning to APCO as a senior director in D.C. She was previously a senior vice president at LSG and previously spent almost eight years at APCO. — Tatiana Rice is being elevated to the senior director role for the Future of Privacy Forum's U.S. legislation team, per Morning Tech. She was previously the team's director, and has been at the company for nearly four years. — Todd Breasseale is now chief communications and brand officer at Brighton Marine, Inc. He's a former Biden DoD and Obama DHS spokesperson. — The Plastics Industry Association has added Hodayah Finman as senior director of regulatory affairs and Ivy Brittain as regional director of state government affairs. Finman was previously the acting director of EPA's Office of International Affairs and Brittain most recently served as legislative affairs director for the Northern California Water Association. — Mollie Timmons is now a senior adviser for public affairs at NTIA. She previously was communications manager at the American Petroleum Institute and is a Morgan Griffith and Rob Portman alum. New Joint Fundraisers None. New PACs The 218 Project (Super PAC) Fight4Michigan (Super PAC) Golden State Voices United (Super PAC) Government That Works PAC (Hybrid PAC) Hispanic Next Generation PAC (Hybrid PAC) VOLUNTEER OHIO TO ELECT REPUBLICANS (Hybrid PAC) New Lobbying REGISTRATIONS C6 Strategies, LLC (Fka Ms. Dana W. Hudson): Distributed Spectrum Capitol Counsel LLC: Levin Management Corporation Capitol Hill Policy Group LLC: Odawi Law Pllc Obo National Haskell Board Of Regents Cfm Strategic Communications (Conkling Fiskum & Mccormick): Detroit Lake Foundation Dla Piper LLP (US): Ira Watchdog The Artemis Group, LLC (Oklahoma): Dawn Aerospace Thorn Run Partners: Ava Labs, Inc. Thorn Run Partners: Avalanche Bvi, Inc. Thorn Run Partners: Ledger Sas Thorn Run Partners: Makpar Corporation Thorn Run Partners: Metrika, Inc. Thorn Run Partners: Wisdomtree Digital Management New Lobbying Terminations Foley Federal & International Affairs, Inc.: National Federation Of Croatian Americans Saunders Global Diplomacy: Desert Mountain Energy Schools That Can: Schools That Can Thomas Marquez: Turbovets
San Francisco Chronicle
3 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Contrary to Trump's claims about crime in Oakland, the city saw a drop in violent crime
Even as President Donald Trump portrays Oakland as a crime-plagued city, Oakland recorded a significant drop in violent crime during the first half of the year, according to recently released police data. The decline includes a 21% drop in homicides in the first six months of the year compared to the same period in 2024. Both violent crime and property crime decreased — by more than 25% combined — although the exact percentage changes for most crime categories was not yet known because of a lag in reporting, especially for property crime. The drop in homicides aligned with a national trend: Homicides declined 19% among 68 large cities, including Oakland, during the first half of the year, according to data compiled by the Major Cities Chiefs Association. Oakland's decline in homicides also builds on a drop in 2024, when the city recorded 86 homicides, marking a 5-year low that put the city on track with pre-pandemic levels. Violent crime increased 6% overall in 2024, while property crime decreased 27%, according to a Chronicle analysis. The data offers a different picture than what Trump alluded to Monday when he announced that he will deploy National Guard troops to the streets of Washington, D.C. to combat crime. Trump indicated he might take similar action in other cities. 'We have other cities also that are bad. Very bad,' Trump said, singling out Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, Baltimore and Oakland. 'President Trump's characterization of Oakland is wrong and not grounded in facts, but in fear-mongering,' Oakland Mayor Barbara Lee said. 'This is not leadership — it's an attempt to score cheap political points by tearing down communities he doesn't understand.' Lee and other city leaders attributed the declines to both law enforcement and violence prevention efforts, including the city's Ceasefire strategy, which targets individuals who are most likely to get caught up in shootings, a significant driver of homicides. The strategy involves violence interrupters who try to medicate conflicts among gangs and other groups, life coaches who attempt to steer participants away from a life of violence and police officers who make arrests if participants commit crimes. The strategy, which fell apart in recent years, especially during the pandemic, was revived in January 2024 under former mayor Sheng Thao. 'When we address violence from multiple angles, we get the kind of results we're seeing today,' said Lee, who was sworn in May 20. The mayor also reinforced her commitment to boost the police force's staffing to 700 officers over several years under Measure NN, a parcel tax voters approved in November to fund police, fire and violence prevention services. Currently, the city budgets for 678 officers — and about 650 of the positions are filled. Lee also said she plans to crack down on sideshows and tow away abandoned cars from city streets. 'These results show that we're on the right track, but our work is far from done,' Lee said. Police Chief Floyd Mitchell said that in recent weeks, some residents told him they feel safer, a reflection of the positive trends. But the chief also acknowledged that not everyone reports crimes, particularly property crimes. He urged the public to report all crimes so the department can better identify crime patterns and deploy officers to curb the trends. He added: 'I understand that if you have been a victim of a crime it may not feel like crime is going down, but please know that our officers remain deeply committed to investigating and solving every case, including yours.'
