Utah Legislature files appeal to Utah Fits All ruling
In a 110-page interlocutory appeal filed to Utah's Supreme Court, the State Attorney General's office, on behalf of the State Legislature, list three reasons why the lower court decision should be overturned. These defendants claim that:
First, there isn't a cap on legislative power to create educational programs,
Second, the legislature wasn't required to designate Utah Fits All as an educational program by the constitution. And,
Finally, voters approved to expand the use of income tax to 'supplement children,' therefore income tax can be used for Utah Fits All because it involves children.
PREVIOUS: Judge finds 'Utah Fits All' scholarship unconstitutional, legislature to appeal
The appeal comes after a district judge found the Utah Fits All Scholarship Program, which is a voucher program for students who go to private schools, unconstitutional due to what the court saw as a lack of constitutional authority, and additionally the programs use of income tax revenue, which is earmarked exclusively for the state's education programs.
'The legislature does not have plenary authority to circumvent these constitutional requirements by simply declining to 'designate' the program as part of the public education system. And because there is no genuine dispute that the program fails to meet these 'open to all children' and 'free' requirements, it is unconstitutional under article X of the Utah Constitution,' the lower court decision read.
The state is seeking an immediate review of their appeal, arguing that the lower court's order has casted 'a shadow' over the program and all the families that currently rely on the program for their children's education.
'The district court's Order implicates the substantial rights of every Utah family with school-aged children. Without this Court's review, thousands of Utah children who currently rely on the Scholarship Program, and hundreds of thousands more who are eligible for it, will lose access to state-funded scholarships that allow them to afford educational options that best meet their needs,' the state's appeal reads.
It continues, 'The Order casts a shadow over the Program—but the district court reserved entry of judgment and a permanent injunction in order to keep the Program operating so that Parents and the other Defendants can seek interlocutory review in this Court. This Court should now grant review in order to remove that shadow and provide certainty that Utah families need as they make their educational plans for the coming school year and beyond.'
Currently the Utah Fits All Scholarship is still active and funds are flowing to parents in the state as litigation is ongoing. If the appeal is not taken up by the court, the lower court decision will stand, and the program's future is uncertain. However, if the Supreme Court upholds that the program is unconstitutional then the scholarship money would stop.
If the lower court's decision is overturned, then the program presumably could continue.
ABC4.com has reached out to the Attorney General's office for comment, to which they replied they do not comment on ongoing litigation. Additionally, the Utah Education Association has not yet replied to requests by ABC4.com.
This is a developing story. ABC4 will update this post as new information becomes available.
Lindsay Aerts contributed to this reporting.
House panel unveils tax portion of Trump agenda bill
Sunny skies with well-above average temperatures this weekend
Utah Legislature files appeal to Utah Fits All ruling
St. George set to host final IRONMAN race this weekend
Otter-ly adorable: Help name the new river otter pup at the Loveland Living Planet Aquarium
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
DC homeless camps cleared out in Trump takeover as Bondi replaces police commissioner with DEA chief
Homeless camps in Washington, D.C., have been cleared in President Donald Trump's crime-fighting takeover as Attorney General Pam Bondi replaced the city's police commissioner with the Drug Enforcement Administration chief. Trump announced Monday he was placing the D.C. police department under direct federal control and deploying the National Guard to 'rescue our nation's capital from crime, bloodshed, bedlam, and squalor, and worse,' despite violent crime declining in recent years. Mayor Muriel Bowser has criticized the federal takeover, calling the move 'unsettling and unprecedented,' and even 'authoritarian.' Troops started hitting the streets of Washington Tuesday evening, and by Thursday, all 800 soldiers that had been deployed were mobilized, The New York Times reported, citing the Pentagon. Also on Thursday, Bondi named DEA head Terry Cole as D.C.'s 'emergency police commissioner.' With Cole in this role, local police must get his approval before issuing any orders. Some of D.C.'s homeless population started to pack up their belongings Thursday as they braced for encampment sweeps. An earth mover was seen scooping away the remains of encampments near the Institute of Peace building, the Associated Press reported. Members of the city's Health and Human Services department began clearing an encampment near the Kennedy Center Thursday morning, perThe Washington Post. 'I'd like to invite the president to spend some time here in a tent with us,' William Wilson, 66, told the publication, adding, 'We're nice people.' On Sunday, Trump wrote on Truth Social, "The Homeless have to move out, IMMEDIATELY.' "We will give you places to stay, but FAR from the Capital. The Criminals, you don't have to move out. We're going to put you in jail where you belong,' he said. Roughly 70 homeless encampments in D.C. have been removed since March, according to White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt. Homelessness has decreased by 9 percent since 2024, according to a May press release from Bowser. While outreach workers have helped the homeless population pack up their belongings, issues are being raised about what happens next for these people. Amber Harding, executive director of the Washington Legal Clinic for the Homeless, told The Washington Post, 'Shelters have a two-bag maximum, so people might not want to go to a shelter if they don't want to throw away their stuff that can't fit into two bags.' Harding also pointed to the location of the government shelters as another issue, since they are not downtown. 'That means people will have to be transported there, which means moving away from where they are currently staying, from the people they know and the places where they are currently getting services,' she said.
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
The TV host questioned the push by Johnson to award the 19-year-old the Medal of Freedom.
MAGA YouTuber Benny Johnson dedicated a segment of his show on Thursday to rage against Jen Psaki after the MSNBC host called him out on her program. Johnson claimed Psaki had a 'hysterical meltdown' live on air while discussing the topic of Edward 'Big Balls' Coristine. He also claimed his comments 'broke' her. At one point, the YouTuber played memes of Psaki, including dancing to one with her head on Gwen Stefani's body parodying the 'Hollaback Girl' video. The outburst came after Psaki on Wednesday criticized Johnson's appearance at a White House press briefing to criticize crime in D.C.
CNN
23 minutes ago
- CNN
Obama praises Texas Democrats and calls state redistricting effort ‘a systematic assault on democracy'
Former President Barack Obama waded into the debate over redistricting in a zoom call with Texas House Democrats on Thursday, warning of a 'systematic assault on democracy' spurred by Republican efforts to redraw congressional maps in Texas. In a video of the 30-minute conversation obtained by CNN, Obama praised the Texas Democrats for standing up to the Republican push to tweak congressional maps in their state to net as many as five GOP US House seats. 'What we all recognize is we can't let a systematic assault on democracy just happen and stand by,' Obama said. 'And so, because of your actions, because of your courage, what you've seen is California responding, other states looking at what they can do to offset this mid-decade gerrymandering that is highly irregular and is not what we should be doing, to balance out the maps for this upcoming election.' 'And my hope is that rather than have a race to the bottom where every district is predetermined based on how it's drawn, that over time, the American people, ideally with the help of the courts, realizes that there's a better way,' he continued. The former president's comments mark his most extensive remarks to date on the redistricting campaigns now unfolding across the country. ABC News was first to report on the contents of the call. Republican leaders in Texas are preparing to push through new congressional maps once Texas House Democrats return home after thwarting the GOP's plans to do so in a special session. California Gov. Gavin Newsom and senior Democrats in the state have also started the process to enact new maps for next year's midterm elections and put them up for a voter referendum in November. In his call with Texas Democrats, Obama expressed his initial preference that any redistricting be addressed 'in a non-biased way that an independent commission or some sort of neutral approach was taken so that Democrats and Republicans compete fairly' but argued Republicans have changed the calculus. 'The problem that we've been seeing, not just recently, but this goes back a while, is that the Republicans increasingly recognize their ideas won't sell, so we've got to fix the game a little bit, and by drawing maps that splinter democratic voting blocs, by packing in Democrats into one district so that they don't have influence in other districts,' he said. 'That's not fair. That's not how democracy is supposed to work,' added Obama, who was joined on the call by former Attorney General Eric Holder, the chairman of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee. Though he did not mention President Donald Trump by name, Obama cautioned that what is happening under the current administration, including the 'militarization of cities,' should be of concern. 'We're in a moment right now where not just gerrymandering, but efforts at voter suppression, efforts at questioning the results of elections, efforts at the executive branch, unilaterally doing things that bypass Congress and the people's representatives, militarization of cities, politicization of our justice departments and our military,' he said. 'Those are trend lines that remind us this precious democracy that we've got is not a given. It's not self- executed. It requires us to fight for it. It requires us to stand up for it.' 'And when we have fair voting rights, and we have fair maps, and we're fairly competing, that's good for everybody, not just one side,' he said. 'And that's what we should be aspiring to over the long term, is a situation in which there are rules that are fair for everybody, and then we compete.' Obama has spoken selectively since Trump returned to the White House in January. At a private fundraiser in July, he urged Democrats to 'toughen up' in their pushback against the current administration. And he accused Republicans in Texas of waging a 'power grab that undermines our democracy' as the redistricting fight took hold last week. He is expected to continue speaking about redistricting issues next week when he headlines a Martha's Vineyard fundraiser for the NDRC. On Thursday, Texas Democrats signaled they intend to bring the nearly two week standoff over redistricting to a close soon, paving the way for the state legislature to approve the Trump-backed maps. 'I want all of you to be returning feeling invigorated and know that you have helped to lead what is going to be a long struggle,' Obama told the group. 'You've helped set the tone for that, and I'm grateful for it.'
