Utah Legislature files appeal to Utah Fits All ruling
SALT LAKE CITY (ABC4) — The Utah State Legislature has filed a petition to appeal a lower court ruling finding the Utah Fits All Scholarship unconstitutional.
In a 110-page interlocutory appeal filed to Utah's Supreme Court, the State Attorney General's office, on behalf of the State Legislature, list three reasons why the lower court decision should be overturned. These defendants claim that:
First, there isn't a cap on legislative power to create educational programs,
Second, the legislature wasn't required to designate Utah Fits All as an educational program by the constitution. And,
Finally, voters approved to expand the use of income tax to 'supplement children,' therefore income tax can be used for Utah Fits All because it involves children.
PREVIOUS: Judge finds 'Utah Fits All' scholarship unconstitutional, legislature to appeal
The appeal comes after a district judge found the Utah Fits All Scholarship Program, which is a voucher program for students who go to private schools, unconstitutional due to what the court saw as a lack of constitutional authority, and additionally the programs use of income tax revenue, which is earmarked exclusively for the state's education programs.
'The legislature does not have plenary authority to circumvent these constitutional requirements by simply declining to 'designate' the program as part of the public education system. And because there is no genuine dispute that the program fails to meet these 'open to all children' and 'free' requirements, it is unconstitutional under article X of the Utah Constitution,' the lower court decision read.
The state is seeking an immediate review of their appeal, arguing that the lower court's order has casted 'a shadow' over the program and all the families that currently rely on the program for their children's education.
'The district court's Order implicates the substantial rights of every Utah family with school-aged children. Without this Court's review, thousands of Utah children who currently rely on the Scholarship Program, and hundreds of thousands more who are eligible for it, will lose access to state-funded scholarships that allow them to afford educational options that best meet their needs,' the state's appeal reads.
It continues, 'The Order casts a shadow over the Program—but the district court reserved entry of judgment and a permanent injunction in order to keep the Program operating so that Parents and the other Defendants can seek interlocutory review in this Court. This Court should now grant review in order to remove that shadow and provide certainty that Utah families need as they make their educational plans for the coming school year and beyond.'
Currently the Utah Fits All Scholarship is still active and funds are flowing to parents in the state as litigation is ongoing. If the appeal is not taken up by the court, the lower court decision will stand, and the program's future is uncertain. However, if the Supreme Court upholds that the program is unconstitutional then the scholarship money would stop.
If the lower court's decision is overturned, then the program presumably could continue.
ABC4.com has reached out to the Attorney General's office for comment, to which they replied they do not comment on ongoing litigation. Additionally, the Utah Education Association has not yet replied to requests by ABC4.com.
This is a developing story. ABC4 will update this post as new information becomes available.
Lindsay Aerts contributed to this reporting.
House panel unveils tax portion of Trump agenda bill
Sunny skies with well-above average temperatures this weekend
Utah Legislature files appeal to Utah Fits All ruling
St. George set to host final IRONMAN race this weekend
Otter-ly adorable: Help name the new river otter pup at the Loveland Living Planet Aquarium
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Verge
16 minutes ago
- The Verge
Peter Thiel's Jeffrey Epstein connections.
Isn't it funny how all these tech and science men have ties to Epstein? I wonder why! Anyway, Epstein invested with Thiel's Valar Ventures — and that investment hasn't previously been disclosed. Guess what that means? 'There's a good chance much of the windfall will not go to any of the roughly 200 victims whom the disgraced financier abused when they were teenagers or young women.'
Associated Press
16 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Family of teen arrested on his way to volleyball practice asks immigration officials to release him
CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — The family of an 18-year-old Massachusetts high school student arrested on his way to volleyball practice pleaded with immigration officials to release him Wednesday. 'I love my son. We need Marcelo back home. It's no family without him,' João Paulo Gomes Pereira said in a video released by his son's attorney. 'We love America. Please, bring my son back.' Marcelo Gomes da Silva, who came to the U.S. from Brazil at age 7, was detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents Saturday. Authorities have said the agents were looking for the teenager's father, who owns the car Gomes da Silva was driving at the time. 'Like any local law enforcement officer, if you encounter someone that has a warrant or … he's here illegally, we will take action on it,' Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons told reporters Monday. Gomes da Silva initially entered the country on a visitor visa and was later issued a student visa that has since lapsed, said his attorney, Robin Nice. She described him as deeply rooted in his community and a dedicated member of both the Milford High School marching band and a band at his church. 'The actions by ICE do not make the community safer,' she said in a statement. 'They just sow fear through the immigrant community.' A federal judge considering Gomes da Silva's request to be released while the immigration case proceeds has given the government until June 16 to respond and has ordered that Gomes da Silva not be moved out of Massachusetts without 48 hours' notice given to the court. A hearing in immigration court is scheduled for Thursday. U.S. Department of Homeland Security spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin said ICE officers were targeting a 'known public safety threat' and that Gomes da Silva's father 'has a habit of reckless driving at speeds in excess of 100 miles per hour through residential areas.' 'While ICE officers never intended to apprehend Gomes da Silva, he was found to be in the United States illegally and subject to removal proceedings, so officers made the arrest,' she said in a statement. The video released Wednesday shows Gomes da Silva's parents and younger siblings in the teen's bedroom. His sister describes watching movies with her brother and enjoying food he cooks for her, including 'chicken nuggets in the air fryer.' 'I miss everything about him,' she said. 'When he gets back, I will give him a really big hug,' Gomes da Silva's younger brother says. 'But ICE, please get him out. Please.' The arrest has sparked outrage among Democratic officials, including Gov. Maura Healey, who demanded information about his location and whether he is being afforded due process. 'They need to let him go,' Healey said in a video posted Tuesday on the social platform X. 'Marcelo belongs in school, not in a detention center.' Other supporters wore white and packed the stands of the high school gymnasium Tuesday night, when the volleyball team dedicated a match to their missing teammate. 'We will continue to pray and fight for our brother,' the team said in an Instagram post ahead of the match.
CBS News
16 minutes ago
- CBS News
Boy, 15, charged with murder in shooting death of 13-year-old boy in Joliet
Joliet police said a 15-year-old boy has been arrested and charged with the murder of a 13-year-old boy shot to death in an alley Monday. Officers were called to the 300 block of South Desplaines Street in Joliet Monday shortly before 4:45 p.m. where they found the teen in an alley with gunshot wounds. He was pronounced dead at the scene. Wednesday, police arrested a 15-year-old boy who they said knew the victim and had been involved in an "ongoing personal dispute" with him. Police said they believe the 15-year-old confronted the 13-year-old as a part of this dispute and allegedly shot him twice during the confrontation. The teen was arrested Tuesday in the 600 block of Benton Street for aggravated battery, mob action and disorderly conduct from a separate incident on May 6, police said. While he was in custody, he was questioned about the shooting death of the 13-year-old. The Will County State's Attorney has charged the 15-year-old with three counts of first-degree murder and one count of unlawful possession of a weapon. The teen is currently in custody at the River Valley Justice Center. He has not been identified due to his age. The victim has also not been identified. It is not known when the 15-year-old is due in court. Please note: The above video is from a previous report
