Scottish voters split over free tuition as university financial crisis deepens
Scottish voters are divided over Scotland's policy of free tuition for Scottish studentsas the crisis over university finances intensified.
A poll commissioned by the Carnegie Trust for the Universities of Scotland found that up to 48% of voters believe Scottish students who can afford it should pay for tuition, with 29% opposed.
A different multiple-choice question produced a closer result. It found 43% believed those who could afford to should pay, while 44% felt every student should get free tuition.
Scottish universities are among a growing number across the UK in deep financial peril, with Dundee expected to be the first to receive part of a £10m government bailout.
Free tuition for undergraduates was first introduced in 2008 by the Scottish National party, in a vote-winning move to scrap the graduate endowment tax then used to partly pay for tuition in Scotland.
However, free tuition has come under much greater scrutiny after Dundee University revealed it was on the brink of insolvency, while Edinburgh University plans to cut £140m to avoid going into deficit.
Scottish universities receive £7,610 per head to teach Scottish students, less than the £9,250 English and Welsh universities can charge, at a total cost of about £715m a year.
That means universities rely on foreign students paying full-cost fees to subsidise teaching costs for Scottish students. The number of overseas students coming to Scotland fell by 10,000 in 2023-24, adding to the financial pressures and increasing competition between universities.
The free tuition policy also means the Scottish government caps the number of Scottish students who can go to university, which prevents some Scots from getting the university places they want.
The trust, set up in 1901 by the Scottish-born US industrialist Andrew Carnegie, is establishing a citizens' jury to review how Scottish universities should be funded.
It will be formed in April with 22 participants of different backgrounds taking part in six online evidence sessions. It is due to report in January 2026, four months before the next Scottish parliament election.
Hannah Garrow, the trust's chief executive, said it believed there was an evidence gap about what voters really thought. 'We've known for some time that something needs to change. We need to have a more open and nuanced debate about it.'
A spokesperson for Universities Scotland, the sector's representative body, supported the move. 'For far too long Scotland's conversation about university funding has been in a binary loop of free versus fees. It's time to move beyond that,' she said.
The Scottish government said its commitment to free tuition would not change. 'Access to higher education should be based on the ability to learn – not the ability to pay,' a spokesperson said.
Sign up to First Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
'The commitment also ensures that Scottish students do not accrue additional tuition fee loan debt incurred by their peers in the rest of the UK.'
To widespread shock, Dundee revealed earlier in March it needed to sack 635 staff, sell off buildings and cut its teaching by 20% to save £35m, or face going bust.
Strike action is being discussed at Dundee, Edinburgh and a string of English universities also planning to cut costs by closing courses and laying off staff through non-replacement or redundancies.
On Thursday, strikes were held at the University of East Anglia, with University and College Union (UCU) members electing to strike again this week in protest at plans to cut 190 jobs in an effort to save £11m.
UCU members at Newcastle University will also strike for a week from Monday over the loss of about 300 jobs designed to shrink its wage bill by £20m. Staff at Brunel University of London will strike for three days to protest against more than 400 job cuts.
Although universities in England receive more tuition funding per student than their peers in Scotland, they receive less in direct grants from government, and the value of domestic fees has been sharply eroded by inflation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
10 minutes ago
- The National
SNP Government rule out Scottish independence convention
Culture Secretary Angus Robertson's explicit statement came after First Minister John Swinney poured cold water on the idea at the SNP's 2026 Holyrood campaign launch in May. That in turn followed SNP depute leader Keith Brown telling party conference in 2024 that the SNP supported an independence convention including 'all democratically elected representatives' from Yes-supporting parties ahead of the 2026 vote. Alba MSP Ash Regan asked the Scottish Government about plans to take that forward. Alba MSP Ash Regan (Image: free) Regan asked the Scottish Government if 'as part of its work to further the case for Scottish independence, whether it will consider holding an independence convention during summer 2025'. Responding, Robertson said: 'The Scottish Government is focused on delivering for people across the country and making the case for taking decisions in Scotland for Scotland with independence. 'The Scottish Government will publish further material on independence to give the people of Scotland the information they need to make an informed choice about their constitutional future. 'We are not planning an independence convention this summer.' The 'further material' referenced is understood to be the final document in the series of white papers on independence started under Nicola Sturgeon's government. Swinney has not published any since taking over as SNP leader. Documents revealed under Freedom of Information in January showed that Robertson was happy for the series to continue, but Swinney instead decided that only one further paper, 'badged as an overview', would be published. READ MORE: SNP Government to publish final 'overview' independence white paper Regan said it was time to break the 'constitutional logjam' and reconnect the political case for independence with what she described as the 'economic necessity' of delivering it. 'We are less than a year out from the Scottish elections but, for too many, independence is drifting into becoming an abstract concept – and in the Hamilton by-election we saw that when independence isn't talked up others will talk it down,' she said. 'An independence convention would bring energy back to the movement and allow for the constitutional imperative of independence to be reconnected to the economic necessity of delivering it as an immediate priority. "It is therefore bitterly disappointing that the Scottish Government have failed to see this opportunity and have instead outright rejected holding an independence convention this summer. 'The Scottish Government and Holyrood need to seize the political initiative on independence. An independence convention would do just that.'
The Herald Scotland
11 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Police Scotland send 80 officers to Ulster as riots spread
Missiles were thrown at PSNI officers after a protest in Portadown last night continuing a trend that was sparked earlier in the week in Ballymena. It came after Mr Boutcher warned 'bigots and racists' behind earlier nights of unrest in the region that his officers will be coming after them. He said a young girl who was the victim of an alleged sexual assault in Ballymena at the weekend, an incident that triggered protests that descended into violence in the Co Antrim town, had been 'further traumatised' by the rioting since Monday. A person wears a Union Jack flag and stands near armed police, who are present in Portadown in Co Armagh, following three nights of disorder in Ballymena, Co Antrim. (Image: Brian Lawless/PA Wire) Forty-one PSNI officers have been injured in the unrest, which had resulted in 15 arrests by Thursday evening. Mr Boutcher, who met the girl's family earlier that day, spoke to the media in Belfast after a meeting with his oversight body, the Northern Ireland Policing Board. 'Stop this violence,' he said. 'We will come after you. We will arrest you. We will prosecute you successfully. It is not in any way a way for a civilised society to behave and it must stop now.' He said the family was 'mortified' by the disorder. 'This girl's family and this girl want it to end. Our communities want it to end. We need it to end. So please don't come out on the streets tonight. If you do, we will police you and we will deal with you through the criminal justice system.' After the warning, there were tense scenes in Portadown as masked individuals hurled masonry, fireworks and other objects at riot police late into the night. A total of 41 officers from the PSNI have been injured in the riots (Image: Brian Lawless) Officers moved to extinguish fires set on roads while residents worked to clear debris left over from clashes in the area around Jervis Street. Police units, supported by the presence of a water cannon, dispersed those gathered into other areas of the town towards midnight. However, the unrest in Northern Ireland appeared of a lower intensity than scenes earlier in the week. Some gatherings planned in other towns proceeded largely without any major disturbance by 9pm on Thursday. READ MORE: Starmer calls for de-escalation after Israel attacks Iran in overnight strikes Pioneering scientist and first black Scottish professor dies aged 85 SNP ministers reject proposal for major tax rise on second homes in tourist hotspots A significant police presence had been deployed to Ballymena but there was no initial repeat of the violence of previous nights. Police said a separate protest in east Belfast also ended early in the evening. The riotous behaviour earlier in the week saw vandalism, vehicles burned and arson attacks on a number of properties across several towns. Petrol bombs, fireworks, masonry and a hatchet were among items thrown at officers. Police responded with water cannon, dogs and plastic baton rounds in an attempt to disperse crowds during riots in Ballymena. Mr Boutcher said: 'I want to specifically mention the 41 police officers who've been injured. Each of those officers have put themselves in harm's way to protect our communities. 'And I want to send a very clear message to all our diverse communities: we stand absolutely shoulder to shoulder with you. We are here to protect you. 'We are your police service, and these bigots and racists will not win the day. This will be policed properly. We will deal with this, and we all know that in this room, but let's call an end to it now.' The PSNI chief said the initial lawful and legitimate process before unrest broke out was done in a way that was responsible and empathetic to the victim. However, he said the protest was subsequently 'hijacked' and turned into 'wanton, disgraceful criminal behaviour that is absolutely race motivated'. The chief said the service was under-resourced and needed to be funded 'properly' rather than 'disgracefully'. However, he said his officers would still bring people to justice: 'We've put our public order inquiry team together, we'll be releasing images of those responsible. We will be going after them.' Mr Boutcher described how PSNI members helped evacuate foreign national families who were hiding in attics and wardrobes in their homes in Ballymena as rioters went on the rampage on Monday. He said the families targeted had done nothing wrong. 'They are not criminals. They contribute positively to society here and are well integrated,' he said. 'Fire Service colleagues described how they went to the scenes to stop arson attacks at those addresses, and how they, in all their years in the Fire Service, have not seen levels of violence to that level, and told me specifically and directly of the bravery, the courage of a very thin green line of police officers that without doubt, in my view, saved lives that night.' Earlier, a judge said the courts would deal 'robustly' with those involved in the violence in Ballymena. District Judge Nigel Broderick said that young people who got involved were risking a significant custodial sentence, as three teenagers faced rioting charges at the town's magistrates' court on Thursday. Michael Elliot, 18, of Lanntara, Ballymena, and two youths, were the first defendants to appear in court since the sustained violence erupted on Monday. Meanwhile, two other teenage boys who were arrested during the disorder have been released on bail to allow for further police inquiries. Secretary of State Hilary Benn described the scenes as 'mindless racist thuggery' while Stormont Justice Minister Naomi Long said it has been a 'three-day festival of hate and destruction' which needs to stop before someone loses their life. There was an arson attack on a leisure centre in Larne, thirty minutes from Ballymena, after it was temporarily used as an emergency shelter for those in urgent need after disturbances in the town earlier in the week. Communities Minister Gordon Lyons, who highlighted the use of the building in a social media post, said all those who had been staying at the leisure centre are in the care of the Housing Executive and have been moved out of Larne. Northern Ireland's First Minister Michelle O'Neill said Mr Lyons should resign over the post, and the leader of the opposition in the Northern Ireland Assembly, SDLP MLA Matthew O'Toole, said he would refer the Communities Minister to the standards commission. Mr Benn also asked the minister to 'reflect upon his words' and 'not upon his position'. Mr Lyons has resisted calls for his resignation and said he would 'strongly hit back at any notion' that he had publicly revealed the facility was being used to house immigrant families who had been affected by violence in Ballymena.
The Herald Scotland
11 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
SNP reject proposal for tax rise on second homes in hotspots
The tax, known as the Additional Dwelling Supplement, is paid by the buyer in addition to the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax, the standard levy on home purchases. Currently it is 8% of the cost of the property but the Greens wanted it raised to 16% in areas where there is a housing shortage arguing that it made sense for the government to be able to change the tax in a targeted way in particular regions rather than having to make any change nationwide. Their demand was made more than a year after the Scottish Government declared a housing emergency. READ MORE: Analysis: Scottish Tories face 'existential crisis' as Reform support grows Badenoch, Findlay and For Women Scotland to speak at Scots Tory conference Councillors fined for safety failings after disabled swimmer almost drowned The Greens pointed to some communities such as Lochranza on Arran where more than a third of houses are holiday homes and that the situation pushes up housing costs and often forces young people to move out of their own communities in search of an affordable place to live. Ross Greer, the Scottish Greens' finance spokesman, who tabled the amendment to legislation going through Holyrood, told The Herald last month that a high number of holiday homes in some areas reduced housing supply for local people as he urged ministers and opposition parties to back his proposal when it was voted on at stage two of the parliamentary process. But the Scottish Government and the other parties rejected his calls. A spokesman for social justice secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville said decisions over the ADS levels were made at the Scottish Budget. 'A number of amendments to the Additional Dwelling Supplement (ADS) were put forward at Stage 2 of the Housing (Scotland) Bill. The amendments were not passed. Decisions on the rates and bands of Land and Buildings Transaction Tax, including the ADS, are taken centrally as part of the Scottish Budget process," he said. Mr Greer hit back accusing his political opponents of protecting the wealthy. 'Parliament voted to declare a housing emergency in Scotland last year, but now every other party has just voted against Scottish Green proposals to stop the richest people buying up homes they don't need in the communities with the worst housing shortages," he said. 'My proposals to increase the Additional Dwelling Supplement in rent control zones and National Parks would only have affected those wealthy enough to even consider buying a second or holiday home. The end result would have been to make it easier for first time buyers in particular to get a home in the community they've grown up in. 'It cannot be right that in a number of communities across Scotland up to half of the properties are either second homes or holiday lets, despite a housing crisis which has led to 10,000 children currently living in temporary accommodation. The wealthy have once again been protected at the expense of families desperately waiting for homes.' Since the 2021 election, the Scottish Government has doubled the Additional Dwelling Supplement from 4% to 8% and given councils the power to double council tax on holiday homes after coming under pressure from the Scottish Greens. The Greens say the reforms have reduced the sale of holiday home purchases, with 2455 fewer second homes bought last year than in 2023, the largest decrease in a decade. ADS will also raise more than a quarter of a billion pounds for public services in the current financial year, according to the party. Thirteen of Scotland's 32 councils have declared a housing emergency, beginning with Argyll and Bute Council in June 2023, with the most recent being East Lothian Council in November last year. A national housing emergency was announced by the Scottish Government for the whole country in May 2024. Experts believe the main driver of the emergency include pressures on homelessness services, high levels of people in temporary accommodation and a lack of affordable homes compared to high waiting lists. Mr Ross's proposals on ADS were among more than 400 amendments to the Housing Bill which were debated by MSPs on Holyrood's local government, housing and planning committee. The legislation will be voted on later at its final parliamentary stage - stage three - in the Holyrood chamber and if passed would allow councils to create rent control areas where rent is capped to certain levels. Ministers have tabled an amendment proposing that rent rises are capped to the rate of inflation plus 1% to a maximum of 6%. They have also set out exemptions to this rule. The Scottish Government has also set a target date for local authorities to make market assessments and recommendations on whether or not to introduce a rent control area. The new date is May 31 2027. Many in the property sector are opposed to rent controls arguing the root of the problem of high housing costs is an insufficient number of homes to buy or rent. They argue rent controls may make the problem worse by prompting landlords to sell up.
