More shark nets, drumlines, drones outlined in $88m government investment but legality of move questioned
But some are questioning if the move is even legal.
Over the next four years, the Queensland government will pour an additional $88.228 million into the Shark Control Management Plan 2025-2029.
It said the new plan "combines proven safety measures like shark nets and drumlines" with new tech including "drone surveillance and whale-deterrent measures", rolling out from July this year and to receive regular maintenance.
"The program includes increased servicing of shark control equipment to 365 days a year, weather permitting," Minister for Primary Industries Tony Perrett said on Sunday.
The minister said the investment was backed by science, however not-for-profit Sea Shepherd Australia described the move as "a dangerous escalation" of the program.
"Today's announcement is big and bold, it puts swimmer safety first," Mr Perrett said.
"I have said time and time again, the best science must inform our actions when it comes to [the Department of Agriculture and] Fisheries."
The investment follows two recent shark-related fatalities in Queensland, after school chaplain Luke Walford was killed while spearfishing at Humpy Island and 17-year-old surf life-saver Charlize Zmuda was injured while swimming at Bribie Island.
Mr Perrett said "striking the right balance between ensuring swimmer safety and maintaining a healthy marine environment" was vital to uphold the reputation of Queensland's $33 billion tourism industry "as a safe place to enjoy some of the best beaches in the world".
The new plan accepted recommendations made by an evaluation of the shark control program, which the government said had consulted marine experts.
"The report found it's likely shark control equipment, such as drumlines and nets, contributed to substantially lower shark attacks where it is operational," the minister's statement said.
More research will be undertaken as part of the plan, including how the control measures impact specific shark species.
However Sea Shepard Australia's Jonathan Clark said the new shark nets and drumlines would present dangers for "countless marine animals" and could also "increase risks to swimmers".
Mr Clark said the minister "is pushing a stone-age 'kill them all' approach that will devastate marine life".
The conservationist was alarmed by the new program, which he said "may breach federal law".
"Under Section 43B(3) of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999, any enlargement or intensification of the Queensland Shark Control Program could be deemed illegal," Mr Clark said.
When asked if Sea Shepherd Australia would be taking action legal against the Queensland government, he said "it's early days for us yet, but I certainly hope so".
He said two fatalities had occurred near drumlines in Queensland waters over the past five years, describing the equipment as attracting large sharks to shore and therefore increasing risk.
"These lethal methods don't protect people … Minister Perrett is ignoring the science, legal risks, and public safety, while intensifying a program that should have been phased out years ago," Mr Clark said.
"We can absolutely stand by our belief that those devices make beaches less safe — this view has been around for a long time and is supported by data and science.
"We need to have the shark nets removed, the drumlines ultimately have to go, and we have to get into the modern ideas of using that technology such as drones, shark barriers, and really good public education."
Mr Clark said drones and other new technology could be used to phase out older methods.
"We applaud the use of drones and any expansion in the use of drones because they do make beaches safer," he said.
The information provided by drones could help make informed decisions when it comes to entering the water, according to Mr Clark.
"But in effect, it means nothing while the government continues with shark nets and drumlines, and the whole point of developing the non-lethal technologies is to get rid of these antiquated shark culling devices," he said.
Potential locations for the expanded program have been identified based on the presence of Surf Life Saving Queensland, and data indicating a growth in beach use.
The Queensland government has identified seven possible beaches for traditional shark control measures, including:
For the expanded drone program over 2025-2026, six potential locations have been earmarked:
The beaches will now undergo further detailed assessment from "stakeholders and expert scientists", as well as community consultation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
SBS Australia
12 minutes ago
- SBS Australia
Kathleen Folbigg criticises compensation offer as "an insult"
Kathleen Folbigg criticises compensation offer as "an insult" Published 11 August 2025, 8:53 am NSW premier Chris Minns is refusing to reconsider a widely criticised $2 million compensation payment to a woman who was wrongfully imprisoned for 20 years for killing her four children. Kathleen Folbigg says it felt like a 'slap in the face' when she received the offer in a letter from the NSW government. Her solicitor described it as "woefully inadequate and ethically indefensible."
News.com.au
20 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Heartbreaking tributes for Zoe Walker, 38, found dead in Upper Ferntree Gully home
Tributes are flowing for a woman whose body was found in her home in Melbourne's eastern suburbs on Sunday morning. The body of Zoe Walker, 38, was found by police in her Upper Ferntree Gully home shortly before 8am. A 46-year-old Upper Ferntree Gully man was arrested at the scene and is assisting police with inquiries. Police allege he was known to Ms Walker. No charges have been laid at this stage. Speaking to 7News, Ms Walker's dad Robert said his daughter was a 'pioneer' in her field, launching her own house painting business after earning a certificate III in General Construction (Painting and Decorating) from Swinburne University of Technology. 'Qualified since 2014 through apprenticeships Australia!' she wrote on social media in July. 'How times have changed.' Mr Walker said his daughter was 'full of life'. 'She struggled on in her trade, which is hard for women to be in,' he told the outlet. 'Every job, even the ones she wasn't familiar with, she had to prove herself, whereas other males didn't have to and she had to struggle, but she did it.' Locals described Ms Walker as a 'lovely lady', and were 'shocked' by her death. Police have established a crime scene in the residential street, which locals said was 'quiet'. 'I have never seen a police car,' a resident of over a decade said. 'Never heard any noise. 'I never heard the police cars arrive. It was only when I went out about 3.30pm or 4pm that I saw the police cars were there with the tape.'
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Canberra drivers charged for trips on Sydney toll roads taken by drivers with similar licence plate numbers
Some drivers have been left out of pocket and frustrated after discovering they had been charged for trips on Sydney toll roads made by other people. Kim and David Lynch said they made two journeys to and from Newcastle from their home in Canberra last year. But in November, they noticed they'd been charged for multiple automatic $50 top-ups of their Linkt toll account. When they checked their account history, they discovered they had been charged for dozens of journeys across Sydney — sometimes on a daily basis. "I was surprised and annoyed," Mrs Lynch said. "We called [Linkt] and they said they'd get someone else to ring us back — which they didn't. "So we called again, and then we called again a couple of days later and they were going to get someone to call us back — and this went on for seven times." Mrs Lynch said it was only when she said that she was going to contact authorities that they finally were able to speak to a senior manager and were given their money back. It turns out Kim and David are not alone. They are among multiple ACT registered vehicle owners who have told the ABC they have been charged toll fees for journeys they did not make. "I once received an email to inform me that I was pinged on the Harbour Bridge, at a time when Canberra was in lockdown," one told ABC Radio Canberra. "I discovered I had been charged for multiple trips I hadn't done. My advice is to look carefully at the statements the toll companies send you for any inconsistencies," said another. The mix-up is apparently the result of some number plates bearing the same letter and number combination as others. The ACT's number plates are prefixed with the letter Y because of a decision made by the now defunct Australian Transport Advisory Council. In 1948, the council decided to allocate alpha-numeric number plates to all states and territories. Larger states were given a range of letters. New South Wales was allocated AAA-000 to FZZ-999. The ACT, with its much smaller population, was given just a single letter. Since then, the number of personal vehicles registered across the country has exceeded the limitations of that system, and multiple states — including NSW — have issued plates starting with a Y. Transport Minister Chris Steel has written a letter to toll operator Transurban "on behalf of ACT motorists, asking it to take immediate action "to address the unauthorised charging of ACT motor vehicle licence holders, with the same registration number as vehicles in NSW". "I request that all effort is made to identify ACT motorists wrongly charged and issue refunds as quickly as possible," Mr Steel said in the letter. "I also ask that Transurban urgently meets with Access Canberra (the ACT Road Transport Authority) to discuss the actions Transurban intends to take to prevent future unauthorised charging and its plan to compensate ACT motorists that have been affected." In the letter, Mr Steel said he had been advised ACT drivers trying to contact the operator to challenge unauthorised transactions had been finding it difficult. "I therefore request that a specific contact line and email is made available for those who may be affected," he said. "Access Canberra's website has also been updated to alert drivers to check their toll accounts and can be updated with further details." An ACT government spokesperson said in the ACT, authorised officers cross-referenced number plate and vehicle details against each vehicle appearing in an "evidentiary image" prior to an infringement being issued. The spokesperson also said while duplications of number plates did occur, a vehicle registration was not the only way a vehicle was identified. "The 'state or territory' identifier on the numberplate is also a critical element, as well the description of the vehicle colour, make and model," the spokesperson said. "Reissuing or replacing numberplates due to a duplicated registration number is not required." In a statement, a Transport for NSW spokesperson said NSW Government-owned toll road provider, E-Toll, was "aware of one ACT-registered vehicle being misidentified as a NSW-registered vehicle by its cameras". "This is a very rare occurrence in a system that processes millions of journeys every month. When this does happen, E-Toll acts to resolve issues promptly and provides refunds where appropriate," the spokesperson said. "When a vehicle travels on a NSW toll road, a photo is taken of its number plate including the state or territory of registration. This enables accurate identification where the same alphanumeric combinations are issued by different states or territories. "If the vehicle isn't recorded as having a tag and the image can't be read automatically, it is sent to an operator to manually review." The spokesperson said if a number plate is found to have been incorrectly detected, it will be "added to a 'watch list' that ensures any future trips by that number plate are manually reviewed by an operator". "Toll road camera providers have a performance target to ensure license plate numbers and state of registration are accurately determined, and we continuously review our business processes to ensure greater accuracy," the spokesperson said. "NSW Motorways has been established and it is recruiting a Customer Advocate responsible for making the system more motorist-orientated in areas including complaints and administration around toll notices. "Alphanumeric combinations on number plates are automatically issued sequentially, except in the case of personalised number plates." Linkt provider and toll road operator Transurban is yet to respond to the ABC's request for comment.
