Raise taxes or gas bills to save net zero, Miliband urged
Ed Miliband must consider raising taxes or gas bills if the UK is to have any hope of hitting net zero, the Government's climate change quango has warned.
To ensure his flagship policy succeeds, the Climate Change Committee (CCC) said the Energy Secretary needs to remove green levies from household power costs.
However, to pay for this, it said the levies should be shifted onto gas bills or covered by general taxation. The quango stopped short of saying which one it preferred.
The recommendation was part of a new report demanding a rethink of power bills across the UK amid mounting scrutiny of Mr Miliband's bid to hit net zero by 2050.
The quango said it was concerned that high electricity prices were preventing households from buying heat pumps and electric cars, which in turn was holding back the green energy transition.
As a result, it said ministers 'should remove policy costs and levies from electricity bills' and shift the burden elsewhere.
Green levies have proven increasingly controversial in recent years as they have been added to bills to help support wind, solar and other renewables projects.
Independent estimates suggest there are around a dozen levies adding £18bn a year to power bills, with the CCC claiming they must be removed to help ease the financial burden on consumers.
It said: 'Making electricity cheaper, through rebalancing prices to remove policy levies from electricity bills, is a key recommendation the committee have made to the UK Government.'
The request forms part of a broader warning that the UK is making too little progress on meeting its carbon emission reduction targets.
This is a particular problem in Scotland, which has set itself a target of hitting net zero by 2045 – five years before the rest of the UK.
To achieve, the CCC said that 1m Scottish homeowners must be persuaded to replace their oil and gas boilers with heat pumps by 2035
Over the same period, it said 1.8m Scottish drivers also needed to replace their petrol and diesel cars or vans with electric vehicles.
Similar adoption rates are also required in the rest of the UK, as the CCC said that by 2040, half of UK homes should have a heat pump, compared to around 1pc in 2023.
'This requires the annual rate of heat pump installations in existing residential properties to rise from 60,000 in 2023 to nearly 450,000 by 2030 and around 1.5m by 2035,' it said.
However, the CCC said this transition will never happen unless levies are removed from power bills.
The cost of those levies was totted up for the first time in two reports published this month, one by energy analyst Kathryn Porter and the other by the Renewable Energy Foundation (REF), a charity.
Ms Porter calculated that 10 subsidies were adding £18bn to bills, while REF reached a total of £12bn.
Ms Porter said: 'Ed Miliband claims that renewables are cheap and will lead to lower bills. This sounds great, but unfortunately is not true.
'The UK has the highest industrial electricity prices in the world and the fourth highest domestic electricity prices, with many of the costs paid by consumers resulting from policy choices [levies] designed to support renewable generation.'
The CCC said it had modelled two alternative ways of replacing the levies on power bills.
One would be to move the charges solely on to gas bills, which would drive up the running costs for gas boilers and cookers.
The second approach would see the cost of energy levies added to general taxation.
However, a spokesman stressed that it did not have a preference on the best way of raising money: 'We aren't policy prescriptive about where these costs go – there are lots of different ways this could be done.
'The overall point we're making is that cheaper electricity will mean that using electric products – for both households and businesses – will become cheaper.'
Critics say the better solution would be to cut subsidies overall.
John Constable, director of REF, said: 'The CCC proposes to 'make electricity cheaper' by moving subsidy costs from energy bills to taxes.
'Of course, this does not actually make electricity cheaper, it just forces somebody else to pay, in this case taxpayers who are already at breaking point. The economically and morally correct solution is to cut the subsidies to renewable generators.'
Richard Tice, Reform energy spokesman, added: 'The great renewable con is rapidly being exposed as more expensive.'
A government spokesman said: 'Our clean power mission is the route to energy security, protecting families by bringing bills down for good and creating good jobs.
'We will continue to work together with all the devolved governments to deliver our clean energy superpower mission and accelerate to net zero in a way that treads lightly on people's lives.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Reeves announces £6 billion to provide millions of NHS tests and procedures
Rachel Reeves has announced a £6 billion investment to speed up tests and treatment within the NHS, after setting out huge year-on-year rises in the health service's budget. New scanners, ambulances and urgent treatment centres are among the things which the additional cash will pay for, with the aim of providing up to four million more tests and procedures over the next five years. The announcement comes after the Chancellor put NHS funding at the heart of her spending review on Wednesday, raising its budget in a move worth £29 billion a year. This comes, however, at the expense of other areas of public spending. The new £6 billion funding will help to meet the Government's target of reducing NHS waiting lists in England, the Chancellor claimed. 'Over a decade of underinvestment from the previous government put the NHS on its knees, with people across the country unable to get the care they need. We are investing in Britain's renewal, and we will turn that around,' Ms Reeves said. She added: 'Part of our record investment will deliver four million tests, scans and procedures, so hard-working people can get the healthcare they and their families need. 'There is no strong economy without a strong NHS, and we'll deliver on our Plan for Change to end the hospital backlog, improve living standards and get more money in people's pockets.' The latest spending commitment will help patients get access to diagnostic scans and treatment in places such as shopping centres and high streets, speeding up their diagnoses. The Government hopes this will help to cut NHS waiting lists, meeting Labour's goal of ensuring the health service carries out 92% of routine operations within 18 weeks. Health Secretary Wes Streeting said: 'Since taking office we have been relentless in our drive to cut waiting times for patients, delivering over 3.6 million extra elective care appointments and reducing the overall waiting list by over 200,000. 'The £6 billion investment we are announcing today will generate millions more vital diagnostic tests, scans and procedures for patients across the country.' On Wednesday evening, Ms Reeves said the Government was 'confident' it could meet its pledge to reduce waiting lists after giving the NHS a 3% annual increase in funding at the spending review. Some health leaders are, however, sceptical that the Government will meet its target, despite the funding boost provided at the spending review. Matthew Taylor, chief executive of the NHS Confederation, which represents all health organisations, warned 'difficult decisions will still need to be made as this additional £29 billion won't be enough to cover the increasing cost of new treatments, with staff pay likely to account for a large proportion of it'. He added: 'So, on its own, this won't guarantee that waiting time targets are met.' Sarah Woolnough, chief executive of the King's Fund charity, said: 'The Chancellor said she wants the public to have an NHS there when they need it. 'It is hard to see how all the things she mentions: faster ambulance times, more GP appointments, and adequate mental health services and more can be met on this settlement alone. 'Particularly when large parts of this additional funding will be absorbed by existing rising costs, such as the higher cost of medicines, which are currently being negotiated, and covering staff pay deals.'


Bloomberg
an hour ago
- Bloomberg
RFK Jr. Picks Eight New Members of CDC Vaccine Panel
Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced on X the names of eight new members of an expert panel that advises the federal government on vaccine policy. Kennedy removed all 17 former members of the panel on Monday.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trump plans memorial to his mother on new Scottish golf course
Donald Trump is creating a memorial garden to his Scottish mother on the site of his new golf course in Aberdeenshire. The main feature of the garden will be a tribute carved in stone imported from Mary Anne Trump's birthplace, the Isle of Lewis in the Outer Hebrides. The announcement of Mr Trump's tribute to his mother came as Trump International Scotland unveiled the layout for a new course alongside the existing links course on his Menie estate. It is set to formally open this summer. Known officially as the Old and the New, the courses will combine to create what the company describes as ' the greatest 36 holes in golf' on the Aberdeenshire coast. The US president's mother was born Mary Anne MacLeod on Lewis, but emigrated to New York in 1930 when she was 18. She was one of tens of thousands of Scots who travelled to the US and Canada in the early years of the last century looking to escape economic hardship at home. She was hired as a domestic servant at the Carnegie Mansion on New York's Fifth Avenue and six years later married Frederick Trump, the successful property developer son of German migrants, and one of the most eligible men in New York. The US president was the fourth of the couple's five children. Mr Trump has spoken fondly of his mother, who died in 2000, aged 88. He said in an interview last year: 'The Scottish very great people, they're tough people. They're good fighters. [My mother] was funny, she had a great sense of humour.' Sarah Malone, the executive vice-president of Trump International, said: 'With the New course opening now fast approaching, we are delighted to share the final layout of this extraordinary links and the completion of The Greatest 36 Holes. 'It has been a phenomenal journey to create two truly exceptional world-class championship golf courses, across this magnificent stretch of North Sea coastline. 'The Trump family has a deep affection for Scotland, not only as the home of golf, but as the ancestral home of President Trump's beloved mother, Mary Anne MacLeod.' The plans for the second course were approved in 2019 alongside proposals for 550 new homes, shops, offices and restaurants. Planners received 2,921 valid representations from the public about the plan, 2,918 of which were objections and just 3 supported the Trump Organisation application. But despite the significant local opposition, Aberdeenshire council approved the £150 million plan. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.