Sudden braking on highway is negligence, says SC
A bench comprising Justices Suddhanshu Dhulia and Aravind Kumar on Tuesday observed that a driver's abrupt halt in the middle of a highway, even if triggered by a personal emergency, cannot be justified if it endangers other road users.
'On a highway, high speed of vehicles is expected and if a driver intends to stop his vehicle, he has a responsibility to give a warning or signal to other vehicles moving behind on the road," Justice Dhulia, who wrote the judgement for the bench, said.
The verdict came on a plea of S Mohammed Hakim, an engineering student whose left leg had to be amputated after a road accident in Coimbatore on January 7, 2017.
The incident occurred when Hakim's motorcycle collided with the rear of a car that had come to an unexpected stop.
As a result, Hakim fell onto the road and was run over by a bus approaching from behind.
The car driver had claimed that he applied brakes suddenly because his pregnant wife experienced a vomiting sensation.
However, the court rejected this explanation, stating, 'The explanation given by the car driver for suddenly stopping his car in the middle of a highway is not a reasonable explanation from any angle." Holding a car driver as 50 per cent liable in a road accident case, the bench did not agree to his contention that he had suddenly applied the brakes as his wife was pregnant and she had a vomiting sensation.
Allowing his plea for enhancement of compensation, the bench said, 'In our view, the concurrent finding that the appellant was definitely negligent in not maintaining a sufficient distance from the vehicle moving ahead and driving the motorcycle without a valid license is correct." But at the same time, the bench pointed out, it cannot be ignored that the root cause of the accident is the sudden brakes applied by the car driver.
'The explanation given by the car driver for suddenly stopping his car in the middle of a highway is not a reasonable explanation from any angle," the bench said.
The court held the appellant as liable for contributory negligence but only to the extent of 20 per cent, while making the car driver and bus driver as liable for negligence to the extent of 50 per cent and 30 per cent respectively.
The court computed the total amount of compensation as Rs 1.14 crore but reduced it by 20 per cent due to contributory negligence by the appellant, to be paid to him by the insurance companies of both the vehicles, within four weeks.
In the case, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal exonerated the car driver and determined the negligence of the appellant and the bus driver in the ratio of 20:80. It put the contributory negligence of 20 per cent on the appellant for not maintaining a sufficient distance from the car.
The Madras High Court, however, held the car driver and bus driver liable for negligence to the extent of 40 and 30 per cent respectively and made the appellant liable for 30 per cent contributory negligence. PTI SJK ZMN
view comments
First Published:
July 30, 2025, 15:30 IST
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Side hustle turns sour for Bengaluru techies as transport authority cracks down on private car rentals
Bengaluru: Instead of letting their swanky cars gather dust in basements while they worked from home, many techies in the city have hitched their vehicles to self-drive rental apps for a quick buck. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now But the wheels came off this side hustle this week when the transport department swooped in, stating it was illegal to rent out white-board cars! In a surprise crackdown, the Kasturinagar RTO (regional transport office) hauled away 21 private cars that were attached to Zoomcar, a self-drive car rental app. Transport officials maintained that these cars, some of them high-end SUVs, were being run commercially without valid permits. Regional transport officer (East) GP Krishnananda said his enforcement team of six carried out the drive across the city after repeated warnings were ignored. This was the first major crackdown by the department against white-board vehicles being run as rental cars in the last two years. Earlier, the Karnataka Transport Authority had pointed out that Zoomcar held a rent-a-motorcab licence, which expired in Jan last year. The allegation against the company is that it was hiring white-board vehicles in violation of motor vehicle rules. The Times of India tried reaching out to Zoomcar for comments, but in vain. In fact, Krishnananda and team carried out a special operation to identify such white-board cars by posing as customers. It all began Wednesday when officials approached the owners as regular customers and booked vehicles, claiming they were heading out on trips with friends. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Once the booking was confirmed, they went to the owner's location, picked up the car to check if it bore a white board, and then drove it straight to the Kasturinagar RTO office. When the owners tracked the GPS and noticed their vehicles were at an unusual location, they called to find out what was happening. That's when officials dropped the bomb — the cars had been seized. Krishnananda told TOI: "Zoomcar still hasn't renewed its aggregator licence. Private vehicles cannot be used commercially — it's a clear loss to the govt and totally illegal. Of the 25 cars seized, most belonged to software engineers, some were from other states including BH-series, and one was even owned by a defence employee. Each vehicle now faces a fine of Rs 30,000 to Rs 35,000, while out-of-state cars must also pay Rs 5 lakh to Rs 7 lakh as lifetime tax. The vehicles will be released only after fines are cleared and the owners give an undertaking not to reattach them." The owners have been booked under Section 200 of the Motor Vehicles Act. Among the car models seized were Baleno, Glanza, Safari, Dzire, Kia, Tata, and Hyundai. Private cars only for personal use During the seizures, officials faced resistance from vehicle owners. The RTO stressed that anyone wanting to run a transport business must register their vehicle with a yellow board; only then can it be rented out legally. Officials confirmed that stringent measures would continue against such violations to curb the misuse of private registration for commercial purposes. "This is our second such drive: about six months ago, we issued notice after finding 15 vehicles, but despite warnings, people continued these activities," Krishnananda said.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Used stolen mobile phone, hopped cities: How man who stole gold worth Rs 13 lakh from associate evaded arrest for over a month
Prabh Singh (30), a jewellery trader, switched on a stolen mobile phone only when staying in a hotel as he moved across cities to avoid getting arrested. He would then use the hotel WiFi, and contact his family on Snapchat. For more than a month, he tried everything possible to cover his tracks and remain under the radar after he allegedly drugged his associate Pradeep Kumar (40) in Delhi's Paharganj on July 8 and stole over 1 kg of gold ornaments, worth nearly Rs 13 lakh, from him, and even the phone that he kept using. After nearly one month of trying to not get caught, his luck ran short on August 17 when he was nabbed from Aurangabad in Maharashtra, the Delhi Police said. Police had chased him in Delhi, Amritsar, and Jammu before he was finally apprehended. After the July 8 incident, the police first headed to Amritsar as both the accused and the complainant hail from the city. 'The team traced his family in Amritsar and conducted field raids. However, the accused could not be located. Further technical analysis then indicated his presence in a hotel in Jammu. A team was immediately dispatched, but by the time police reached, the accused had fled again,' DCP (Central) Nidhin Valsan said. Over the course of a month-and-a-half, the accused was changing hotels, and while using the stolen phone of Pradeep Kumar to contact his family on Snapchat, the police said. Whenever the police would zero in on a hotel, Singh would change cities again, the officer said. On August 17, Singh was tracked in Aurangabad and arrested following a quick raid. 'During questioning, the accused admitted to committing the crime and disclosed that he was under financial distress and greed prompted him to plan the theft,' DCP Valsan said. A police officer said that Singh allegedly accompanied Pradeep Kumar to the Capital after the latter mentioned a 'lucrative deal' he had struck with a Delhi client. Kumar told Singh that he had to carry the consignment to Delhi for the client, police said. Upon reaching Delhi, the duo checked in in a Paharganj hotel on the night of July 8. Singh spiked Kumar's dal curry with sleeping pills, the police said. 'Once the complainant fell asleep, he fled with all the gold, cash, and Kumar's mobile phone. He further disclosed that the stolen gold was hidden with his elder brother Pintu, who lives in Amritsar with the accused in the same house. The stolen gold ornaments weighing 1.290 kg were recovered,' DCP Valsan said. Following the alleged theft, an FIR was filed after a preliminary inquiry under sections 305 (a) (theft) and 123 (hurt by poison) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
After Sindoor, JeM begins drive for funds
JAMMU: After suffering major setbacks in Operation Sindoor, Pakistan-based Jaish-e-Muhammed (JeM) has launched a Rs 3.91 billion fundraising drive under the garb of building 313 mosques, mirroring Lashkar-e-Taiba's decentralisation model, security officials said. Backed by ISI, JeM is using digital wallets like EasyPaisa and Sadapay, controlled by founder Masood Azhar 's family, to bypass scrutiny by FATF. Several accounts are linked to Azhar's brother Talha Al Saif, son Abdullah Azhar, and other commanders. Over 250 wallets are reportedly active, with social media posters, videos and Azhar's letters urging donations. Officials said JeM aims to decentralise training camps and ensure long-term financing for ops.
