logo
Farce and fury as players rage against the machine at Wimbledon after line-calling technology was accidentally switched off in Sonay Kartal defeat

Farce and fury as players rage against the machine at Wimbledon after line-calling technology was accidentally switched off in Sonay Kartal defeat

Daily Mail​a day ago
The sight of a chair umpire ringing his superiors on something resembling a 1970s telephone, after AI technology had failed to make a blindingly obvious line call, took us deep into the realms of a farce which overshadowed one of the brightest British stories of this past week drawing to a close.
The 'electronic line calling' system employs banks of cameras in place of the uniformed judges who were once such a fine and distinctive part of Wimbledon, to state which side of the line a ball has dropped.
Perhaps the system works. Perhaps it doesn't.
Emma Raducanu and Jack Draper have made their doubts extremely clear these past few days. But it will certainly fail when somebody turns the machine off, which Wimbledon declared was the reason why a Sonay Kartal volley — sent a foot beyond the baseline at a vital moment towards the end of the first set of her match against Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova — elicited no call of 'out.'
In the absence of this most obvious verdict, Centre Court's audio system started demanding 'stop, stop' and so, at the same time, did German umpire Nico Helwerth. A bewildering and rather dystopian moment.
Pavlyuchenkova ought to have been walking to her seat, 5-4 to the good. She — and every advocate of common sense — anticipated an umpire's overrule.
Instead, Helwerth declared: 'We are going to check the system is up and running.' And, after a three-minute hiatus: 'The electronic line system is currently unable to replay the last point so we will replay.'
Summers in SW19 are supposed to offer respite from infernal VAR controversies, though this one was even more lamentable than that detested system football has come to know. At least football's referees are wired up to people who can see the video, or may walk to a screen to view it back themselves. Helwerth was unable to use his own initiative on the point in question.
Pavlyuchenkova sensed a British conspiracy when the point had been replayed and Kartal ended up winning the game. 'Because she is local, they can say whatever,' the Russian told Helwerth. 'They stole the game from me. They stole it.'
After six hours of deliberation, the All England Club finally issued a statement last night disclosing that 'operator error' had meant the AI system was 'deactivated' on Pavlyuchenkova's side of the net for one game, including the controversial point in question. Helwerth, they said, had 'followed the established process'.
After Pavlyuchenkova had won 7-6, 6-4, Helwerth admitted to her that he had seen the ball was out. 'I think he felt bad, a little bit,' she revealed.
Though some would argue that a Russian player should not even be here at a time when Putin's drones are inflicting untold horrors on Ukraine,
Pavlyuchenkova spoke for many when she urged tennis not to render its officials completely redundant.
'It's difficult for him,' she said of Helwerth's reaction. 'He probably was scared to take such a big decision. But they should take those decisions. That's why they're sitting on the chair. That's why we have a chair umpire. Otherwise, soon we'll just play without them and then we're going to have everything automatic. It becomes, like, robot-orientated.'
Kartal's struggle to capitalise on this opportunity belonged to the wider narrative of her match. She strode out in a storm —thunder booming overhead, rain hammering down on the Centre Court roof — and after a hesitant start, threw everything at the first set, despite having her right knee heavily strapped. Pavlyuchenkova struggled with the 23-year-old's mobility and heavy forehand spin. The age gap — Pavlyuchenkova is 34 — felt significant.
But Kartal could not seize her opportunities, winning only three of 10 break points in that first set. She will feel regret, despite collecting £240,000 in prize money which she says can transform her future preparations.
In Kartal's first-round game, her opponent Jelena Ostapenko had raged against AI, ironically clapping the cameras which foot-faulted her. Pavlyuchenkova has previously put this kind of behaviour down to the Latvian's combustible nature but now she's not so sure.
'At the beginning it was funny, but after I was getting her point a little bit,' Pavlyuchenkova said. 'Sometimes when we play, I'm thinking, 'Am I crazy?' I just feel like the ball is long, then nothing is happening. There is no automatic line calling.'
She is not the only one now demanding answers.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Novak Djokovic recovers from his worst first set at Wimbledon to reach quarters
Novak Djokovic recovers from his worst first set at Wimbledon to reach quarters

The Independent

time15 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Novak Djokovic recovers from his worst first set at Wimbledon to reach quarters

Novak Djokovic was relieved to overcome a historically bad start – and the curse of Roger Federer – to reach a 16th Wimbledon quarter-final. The Serbian has not fallen before the final at the All England Club since 2017 but he will need to raise his level if he is to maintain that record after scrapping to a 1-6 6-4 6-4 6-4 victory over Alex De Minaur in three hours and 19 minutes. Djokovic cannot have played many worse sets at Wimbledon than the opening one here, with the Serbian making 16 unforced errors, including four double faults and dropping serve three times. It is the sixth time Djokovic has lost a set 6-1 at the All England Club but the first time he has done so in the first set. Watching from the Royal Box was the 38-year-old's long-time rival Federer, and Djokovic said at the end with a smile: 'Sometimes I wish I had the serve and volley and nice touch from the gentleman that is standing right there. That would help. 'This is probably the first time he is watching me and I have won the match. The last couple of times I lost, so it's good to break the curse. 'Obviously he's one of the greatest legends of our game in the history of tennis. So it always is extra special when he's in the stands.' Djokovic set about flipping the script at the start of the second set, breaking the De Minaur serve only for the Australian to hit back after an exhausting game lasting nearly 19 minutes. Ahead went Djokovic again, the Serbian putting his finger to his ear and whipping up the crowd after a 34-shot rally, and back came De Minaur, but the seven-time champion managed to hold on to his final break, resisting more pressure from the Australian. De Minaur was devastated to have to pull out of a quarter-final against Djokovic 12 months ago after hurting his hip, and he continued to cause problems for his opponent, opening up a 4-1 lead in the fourth set. But a chance to lead 5-1, and very likely force a decider, went begging and Djokovic reacted in ruthless fashion with five games in a row. Djokovic blamed nerves and a swirling wind for his poor start, saying: 'It was very challenging for me. I was not feeling good, not finding the right timing. He was obviously feeling that. 'Honestly big, big relief to finish the match in four sets. Credit to him for making me feel very uncomfortable on the court. Just fortunate to get through this one.' Next up, Djokovic finds an unexpected quarter-finalist facing him in the shape of 22nd seed Flavio Cobolli – although he is not even the first person in his family to take on the Italian this fortnight. Djokovic revealed his 10-year-old son Stefan has hit with Cobolli on the practice courts, and the sixth seed joked: 'Of course, I'll have a conversation with my son and see what he has noticed in the game of Cobolli the other day. 'He (Cobolli) is a big fighter. We get along well. We practise whenever we can. We just had a hug. I definitely need to work on my game and start the match better than I did today.' De Minaur, who was cheered on by fiancee Katie Boulter, is still looking for his big grand slam breakthrough, and he said: 'In the bigger moments today I think my level dipped, and I didn't rise up to the occasion as I needed to if I wanted to beat someone as good as him.' Cobolli dropped his first set of the tournament but saw off former finalist Marin Cilic 6-4 6-4 6-7 (4) 7-6 (3) to reach his first slam quarter-final. Cilic complained afterwards about being scheduled first on court, saying: 'I feel bitter because why is there a need to play at 11am?' American Ben Shelton, meanwhile, had the familiar feeling of beating Italian Lorenzo Sonego having now done so at three grand slams in a row. They are the first pair to meet in singles at the opening three majors in a year since Jimmy Connors and John McEnroe back in 1984, with Shelton triumphing 3-6 6-1 7-6 (1) 7-5.

Norrie giving nothing away ahead of Alcaraz showdown
Norrie giving nothing away ahead of Alcaraz showdown

South Wales Argus

time16 minutes ago

  • South Wales Argus

Norrie giving nothing away ahead of Alcaraz showdown

Cameron Norrie relaxes between Wimbledon matches by playing cards with his support team. He's certainly got a good poker face. If the sole remaining British player in the singles competition was feeling any nerves, he did an excellent job of concealing them, laughing and smiling throughout his practice session on Monday. It was a marked contrast to the Norrie who once appeared weighed down by the sudden expectations that followed his breakthrough into the world's top ten three years ago. Slipping outside the world's top 50 may not do wonders for the bank balance, but it could well be a tonic for the soul. Norrie began his campaign on the fringes of the grounds, on Court 18, but has since played his last three matches on his favoured No 1 Court. However, a quarter-final meeting with Carlos Alcaraz means a return to Centre Court. It is also a reminder that the last time he faced a defending champion there, Novak Djokovic in the 2022 semi-finals, he was beaten in four sets. 'It only gets tougher from now,' he said. 'I've played a lot of tough matches already but there are still many more to come, and plenty still to be won. 'I'll just keep playing point by point as always. I'm really happy with how I pulled up after the last match. My body feels good, and I'm in a good place. I've been striking the ball well. 'I'm enjoying having the crowd behind me, but I also know Carlos is a very popular player here. 'I'm not too concerned about being the last Brit standing, or whether others are still in. It would be nice to have a few more to share the spotlight and give the fans more players to support. 'In future years, I think that will be the case, but right now I'm just focused on my job.' All eyes on Centre Court tomorrow 👀 Previewing @cam_norrie vs Carlos Alcaraz at @Wimbledon ⬇️ — LTA (@the_LTA) July 7, 2025 Norrie's coach and friend, Facundo Lugones, often warns anyone considering challenging his player to a fitness contest to think again. The Briton's aerobic capacity is the stuff of legend. Even after a four-and-a-half-hour, five-set battle in the fourth round against Chile's Nicolás Jarry, he barely looked like he had broken sweat. The countless hours in the gym, 10km hill runs and open-water swims are clearly paying off. Even as he approaches 30, Lugones remains astounded by Norrie's endurance. The Brit is capable of maintaining a 'red zone' heart rate of 200 beats per minute for extended periods during training and matches. 'When I was in college, someone once tested my lungs one summer. They said I must be a deep-sea diver or something, because they were huge,' Norrie said. 'Since then, I've just had massive confidence in my cardio. It means I back myself in the longer rallies. I don't know if it's false confidence, but I'll take it.' 'I'm just enjoying my tennis' 😁 How Cam Norrie is getting back to his best to reach his second Wimbledon quarter-final ↓ — LTA (@the_LTA) July 7, 2025 Still, it takes more than big lungs to beat Alcaraz at Wimbledon. His 18-match winning streak at SW19 is proof of a player with real grit and determination. The Spaniard has faced Norrie six times, winning four. However, they have not played since the Brit pulled off a surprise victory on clay in the ATP 500 final in Rio de Janeiro more than two years ago. 'For me, facing him is a nightmare, to be honest,' said Alcaraz, the defending champion. 'He's a very difficult opponent, and we've already had some tough battles. 'I'm not surprised to see him in the quarter-finals. I saw him practising. He lost at Queen's and then spent five days on the courts here, morning, afternoon and night. 'He's playing at home with the crowd on his side, and that means I need to be very strong mentally.' Alcaraz, who was looking for a left-handed practice partner on Wimbledon's Aorangi Park courts, admits that southpaws often pose problems. He lost to Jack Draper at Queen's last year and was pushed to four sets by Ugo Humbert on the way to last year's final at SW19. 'I've always found it tricky against lefties, especially with their slice serve to the advantage court,' he said. 'We know what to expect. Cameron is going to be really tough from the baseline. My team and I will discuss the tactics and work them into practice.' For the latest action on the British summer grass court season, check out the LTA website.

Mirra Andreeva oblivious to the fact she'd won after swatting aside Emma Navarro
Mirra Andreeva oblivious to the fact she'd won after swatting aside Emma Navarro

South Wales Argus

time17 minutes ago

  • South Wales Argus

Mirra Andreeva oblivious to the fact she'd won after swatting aside Emma Navarro

The Russian teenager became the youngest woman to reach the Wimbledon quarter-finals in 18 years by breezing through round four with a rapid 6-2 6-3 win over world number 10 Emma Navarro. But an unaware Andreeva was so focused on her performance – and trying not to look at Roger Federer in the Royal Box – she lined up to face another Navarro serve, rather than celebrate converting match point. Marvellous Mirra 🤩 The 18-year-old shines on her Centre Court debut, booking a place in the #Wimbledon QF — Wimbledon (@Wimbledon) July 7, 2025 With her American opponent waiting at the net to shake hands, the 18-year-old briefly looked bemused before jogging in from the baseline, to the amusement of spectators. Andreeva laughed off the incident in her on-court interview, saying: 'I kept telling myself I'm not the one who is up on the score, I am the one who is down. 'That helped me to stay focused and in the end I completely forgot the score. 'I'm happy that I did it because I think I would have been three times more nervous on a match point.' Aside from the humorous mix-up, Andreeva suffered no hiccups as she emphatically stayed on course to emulate coach Conchita Martinez – the 1994 Wimbledon champion. Mirra Andreeva practising with coach Conchita Martinez (John Walton/PA) She blitzed Navarro to clinch the opening set in just 33 minutes and, despite being broken twice in the second, was not unduly troubled. Aged 18 years and 75 days, Andreeva is exactly the same age as Czech player Nicole Vaidisova was when she progressed to the last eight in 2007. 'It is something crazy,' she said, after setting up a meeting with Belinda Bencic with victory in 75 minutes. 'I was super nervous before playing for the first time on Centre Court. 'I really tried my best not to look over there in the box because I knew as soon as I would look there I would completely lose my focus. "It's been one of my dreams to see you in real life." 🫶 Mirra Andreeva kept her nerve playing on Centre Court in front of Roger Federer #Wimbledon — Wimbledon (@Wimbledon) July 7, 2025 'I saw Roger and (his wife) Mirka and it means a lot that you came and watched my match. It has been one of my dreams to see you in real life.' Earlier, Bencic blew five match points on her own serve before bouncing back to reach the quarter-finals for the first time. The 2021 Olympic champion also saved three break points in a captivating ninth game of the second set against Ekaterina Alexandrova. Russian 18th seed Alexandrova eventually broke to prolong the Court One contest but Bencic responded immediately to progress 7-6 (4) 6-4. 'For you guys it was entertaining but for me it was a big stress,' Bencic said on court. 'It was a difficult moment. Belinda Bencic celebrates victory against Ekaterina Alexandrova (Ben Whitley/PA) 'I always got stuck in the fourth round. It was so important for me to breakthrough to the quarter-finals. It's a dream come true.' Bencic's best run in SW19 comes after she missed last year's Championships due to the birth of daughter Bella in April 2024. 'We did an amazing job coming back,' said the 28-year-old Swiss player. 'It's amazing to share the memories together as a family. I'm enjoying it more. I juggle it like every mum does.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store