
Farce and fury as players rage against the machine at Wimbledon after line-calling technology was accidentally switched off in Sonay Kartal defeat
The 'electronic line calling' system employs banks of cameras in place of the uniformed judges who were once such a fine and distinctive part of Wimbledon, to state which side of the line a ball has dropped.
Perhaps the system works. Perhaps it doesn't.
Emma Raducanu and Jack Draper have made their doubts extremely clear these past few days. But it will certainly fail when somebody turns the machine off, which Wimbledon declared was the reason why a Sonay Kartal volley — sent a foot beyond the baseline at a vital moment towards the end of the first set of her match against Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova — elicited no call of 'out.'
In the absence of this most obvious verdict, Centre Court's audio system started demanding 'stop, stop' and so, at the same time, did German umpire Nico Helwerth. A bewildering and rather dystopian moment.
Pavlyuchenkova ought to have been walking to her seat, 5-4 to the good. She — and every advocate of common sense — anticipated an umpire's overrule.
Instead, Helwerth declared: 'We are going to check the system is up and running.' And, after a three-minute hiatus: 'The electronic line system is currently unable to replay the last point so we will replay.'
Summers in SW19 are supposed to offer respite from infernal VAR controversies, though this one was even more lamentable than that detested system football has come to know. At least football's referees are wired up to people who can see the video, or may walk to a screen to view it back themselves. Helwerth was unable to use his own initiative on the point in question.
Pavlyuchenkova sensed a British conspiracy when the point had been replayed and Kartal ended up winning the game. 'Because she is local, they can say whatever,' the Russian told Helwerth. 'They stole the game from me. They stole it.'
After six hours of deliberation, the All England Club finally issued a statement last night disclosing that 'operator error' had meant the AI system was 'deactivated' on Pavlyuchenkova's side of the net for one game, including the controversial point in question. Helwerth, they said, had 'followed the established process'.
After Pavlyuchenkova had won 7-6, 6-4, Helwerth admitted to her that he had seen the ball was out. 'I think he felt bad, a little bit,' she revealed.
Though some would argue that a Russian player should not even be here at a time when Putin's drones are inflicting untold horrors on Ukraine,
Pavlyuchenkova spoke for many when she urged tennis not to render its officials completely redundant.
'It's difficult for him,' she said of Helwerth's reaction. 'He probably was scared to take such a big decision. But they should take those decisions. That's why they're sitting on the chair. That's why we have a chair umpire. Otherwise, soon we'll just play without them and then we're going to have everything automatic. It becomes, like, robot-orientated.'
Kartal's struggle to capitalise on this opportunity belonged to the wider narrative of her match. She strode out in a storm —thunder booming overhead, rain hammering down on the Centre Court roof — and after a hesitant start, threw everything at the first set, despite having her right knee heavily strapped. Pavlyuchenkova struggled with the 23-year-old's mobility and heavy forehand spin. The age gap — Pavlyuchenkova is 34 — felt significant.
But Kartal could not seize her opportunities, winning only three of 10 break points in that first set. She will feel regret, despite collecting £240,000 in prize money which she says can transform her future preparations.
In Kartal's first-round game, her opponent Jelena Ostapenko had raged against AI, ironically clapping the cameras which foot-faulted her. Pavlyuchenkova has previously put this kind of behaviour down to the Latvian's combustible nature but now she's not so sure.
'At the beginning it was funny, but after I was getting her point a little bit,' Pavlyuchenkova said. 'Sometimes when we play, I'm thinking, 'Am I crazy?' I just feel like the ball is long, then nothing is happening. There is no automatic line calling.'
She is not the only one now demanding answers.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Glasgow Times
10 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Kate presents Wimbledon men's trophy on Centre Court
Sinner, who became the first Italian to win a Wimbledon singles title, came from behind to claim victory in three hours and four minutes on Sunday. After the match, the new Wimbledon champion met the royals and signed tennis balls for George and Charlotte. The Prince and Princess of Wales arrive with Princess Charlotte on day 14 of the 2025 Wimbledon Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club (Andrew Matthews/PA) Kate smiled as she presented the trophy on Centre Court to Sinner after giving the runner's up prize to Alcaraz. A spectator shouted 'I love you Kate' as the princess walked onto court, with Kate speaking to ball boys and girls as she made her way towards the trophy presentation. The royals were sat near King Felipe VI of Spain, who attended the match in support of Spaniard Alcaraz. In his post-match interview, Alcaraz said: 'For me it's just an honour to have you in the stand supporting, flying here to the final, so I'm just really grateful and thank you very much for coming.' Felipe then waved at Alcaraz and applauded the runner-up. Before entering Centre Court, the royals met 11-year-old Ambrose Caldecott, who has undergone chemotherapy over the last year and was chosen to perform the ceremonial coin toss before the final. Ambrose, who was diagnosed with bone cancer in March 2024, told Kate about his experiences, to which she replied: 'What a brave boy you've been. Prince George and Princess Charlotte in the Royal Box at Wimbledon (Adam Davy/PA) 'Good luck today, we'll be cheering you on.' The princess, who was diagnosed with cancer in 2024, confirmed she was free from the disease at the start of this year. Speaking about his conversation with Kate, Ambrose told the PA news agency: 'We spoke about tennis, our favourite sports, what I went through last year and how it affected me.' The 11-year-old added: 'She said she knew from her experience in my situation.' Ambrose was chosen to perform the coin toss to represent The Junction Elite Project, a Wandsworth-based charity that provides developmental sporting experiences to young people. Kate attended the championships in a striking royal blue dress, with William wearing a double-breasted blazer. George looked sharp in a black suit, and Charlotte wore a beige summer dress. The Princess of Wales meets Temi Johnson, one of The Wimbledon Foundation's Coin Toss nominees (Andrew Matthews/PA) The royals also met British pair Julian Cash and Lloyd Glasspool who made Wimbledon history on Saturday by winning the men's doubles title. The duo are the first all-British pairing to win the title since Pat Hughes and Raymond Tuckey lifted the trophy in 1936. Cash, 28, told the PA news agency: 'It was an absolute pleasure to meet them today. 'They're all fans of the tennis so it was really nice to meet them.' Asked about his conversation with the royals, Cash said: 'They asked about the final yesterday, how it felt to win at home and make history. 'They were asking about the heat as well, and a little bit about my celebrations.' Discussing his celebrations, Cash said: 'My head was a little bit sore this morning but it was a fantastic day. I loved having family and friends here. The Princess of Wales in the Royal Box (John Walton/PA) 'We play so many weeks on the road, so to have them here, to lift that trophy with them is really special.' The royals also met ball girl Sienna, 18, from Wimbledon High, and ball boy Dennis from Wilson's School. Dennis, 17, said it was a 'really unique experience' to meet the royals. Discussing the conversation, he added: 'They mainly asked us about training, how long it takes, how hard it is, and they told us to stay hydrated.' The royals also met television presenter Steve Backshall, who is a Wimbledon Ambassador and disability sports coach Temi Johnson, 28. Kate, who is patron of the All England Lawn Tennis Club, received a standing ovation when she arrived on Centre Court on Saturday to watch the women's singles final. The princess told runner-up Amanda Anisimova to keep her 'head high' after the American suffered a heavy defeat in Saturday's final. Michael and Carole Middleton in the Royal Box on day eight of the championships (Mike Egerton/PA) Kate consoled Anisimova, who was in tears, as she presented her runner-up prize. The princess then presented the trophy to Polish player Iga Swiatek, who won the title for the first time by beating Anisimova 6-0 6-0 in a final which lasted only 57 minutes. Last year, Kate presented the Wimbledon men's final trophy to Alcaraz in her second public engagement since she announced her cancer diagnosis. The Princess of Wales's parents, Carole and Michael Middleton, were seen in the Royal Box on Monday, with the Duchess of Edinburgh and the Duchess of Gloucester also in attendance.


Glasgow Times
10 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Italy celebrates first Wimbledon singles winner after Jannik Sinner success
Sinner, the world number one, dethroned two-time defending champion Alcaraz with a 4-6 6-4 6-4 6-4 victory to become the first winner, male or female, from Italy. Prime minister Giorgia Meloni wrote on X: 'Another page of history for Italian sport: Un'altra pagina di storia per lo sport italiano: Jannik Sinner trionfa a Wimbledon e fa sognare un'intera Nazione. Orgogliosi di te, campione! — Giorgia Meloni (@GiorgiaMeloni) July 13, 2025 'Jannik Sinner triumphs at Wimbledon and makes an entire nation dream. Proud of you, champion!' A first Wimbledon title was sweet revenge for the 23-year-old, who lost an epic five-setter to Alcaraz in the French Open final lust last month. Former Wimbledon champion Marion Bartoli, commentating on BBC 5 Live, said: 'It's so rightly deserved. The Princess of Wales presents the trophy to Jannik Sinner (John Walton/PA) 'To be able to come back from that, play another grand slam final against the same opponent and be in the same situation, serving for the match and pull out the game he has put together – I can't imagine what they've been going through until this final.' Australian Pat Cash, the 1987 champion, felt Sinner's gameplan worked to perfection. 'A great performance. Just great serving, nullifying the drop shots of Alcaraz,' said the BBC pundit. What a winner from Carlos Alcaraz for the first set! 🔥👉👂 Incredible entertainment here at SW19 💫#Wimbledon — BBC Sport (@BBCSport) July 13, 2025 'Alcaraz was below par on his serve and that made a big difference.' Alcaraz's stunning shot to take the first set, a flicked backhand cross-court winner on the stretch, had former British number one Tim Henman purring. 'That was a moment of magic,' he said. 'Such a great rally at set point, the control of the racket face from Alcaraz to direct a winner from that position. There is no one else who has that athletic ability.' Two-time Wimbledon champion Rafael Nadal posted on his Instagram story: 'Congratulations Jannik Sinner. Special moments! 'I know it wont be an easy day, but congratulations Carlos Alcaraz for another new grand slam final and for the great season you are having.'


The Guardian
12 minutes ago
- The Guardian
West Ham eye move for Liverpool's Elliott and close on Slavia Prague's Diouf
West Ham are looking to ramp up their summer rebuild with an ambitious move for Liverpool's Harvey Elliott. The London club are close to completing the signing of the Slavia Prague left-back El Hadji Malick Diouf and want to make further additions after boosting their budget with the £54.5m sale of Mohammed Kudus to Tottenham. Kudus's departure leaves room for West Ham to bring in an attacking midfielder and they have identified Elliott as a key target. The 22-year-old starred for England Under-21s during their triumphant European Championship campaign last month, scoring five goals in six games, and has suggested that he may consider his future at Liverpool because of his lack of regular starts. West Ham are yet to submit a bid for Elliott and it remains to be seen how much Liverpool would want for the former Fulham player. Preparations for a move are being conducted, though, and there is optimism at West Ham that a deal will be possible. RB Leipzig have also been credited with an interest in Elliott, who can play in a range of positions across the front line. Liverpool may regard this as the right time to cash in on the player but there are obvious sensitivities around their transfer plans following the death of Diogo Jota. Potter, who was hired in January, is looking to freshen up his squad. West Ham's manager wants young, hungry, dynamic players and is also focusing on lifting the atmosphere in the dressing room. Kyle Macaulay is heading up the club's recruitment after joining from Chelsea and is looking to be creative with his signings. Elliott, who can play wide and in the middle, joined Liverpool in 2019 and has found it difficult to establish himself as a regular starter despite offering flashes of quality. Only two of his 18 appearances in the league last season were starts. Arne Slot has plenty of options in attack and has been unable to find an obvious spot for him. West Ham's current options on the flanks include Jarrod Bowen, Luis Guilherme and Crysencio Summerville, who is recovering from a hamstring injury. West Ham, who are also considering the Liverpool midfielder Tyler Morton, will also look further afield for signings. They opened talks with Slavia over Diouf last month and negotiations over a deal worth £22m plus £5m in add-ons are almost complete. Diouf, who can play as a left-back or a left wing-back, impressed for Senegal in their victory over England last month. The move for the 20-year-old will raise doubts over the future of Emerson Palmieri. Sign up to Football Daily Kick off your evenings with the Guardian's take on the world of football after newsletter promotion Potter is toying with the idea of using a 3-4-2-1 system, heightening the need for him to have defenders who can function as wing-backs. West Ham already have Aaron Wan-Bissaka on the opposite flank. West Ham had to sell to buy but are pushing on with their plans after losing Kudus. They will also look to bring in a goalkeeper, a left centre-back, two central midfielders and a striker. They are keen to make further sales and are open to offers for Nayef Aguerd, Edson Álvarez, Guido Rodríguez and Niclas Füllkrug.