Rotherham man mistaken for fraudster by AI software
He said he had been "really anxious" in the weeks it took to resolve the issue."There was a fear of my photo being in other shops where they might throw me out," he added."It caused embarrassment, it could cause reputational damage."
The software company, Facewatch, deleted Mr Hadley's image from its database after he had proven his identity to the company and the CCTV had been checked manually.Mr Hadley agreed the fraudster, who had been at the till at the same time he had been paying, "looked very similar" to him."I get it was a human error and people make mistakes," he said."But, when those mistakes can result in people who have done nothing wrong being put on a national database, there needs to be some more checks and balances."Madeleine Stone, from the civil liberties campaign group Big Brother Watch, said using software like Facewatch to deal with shoplifting was a "recipe for disaster"."You could be blacklisted from your local shops, placed on a secret watchlist, and that information is shared in all the shops in your area," she said."There is not necessarily any evidence of wrongdoing and there is no due process."Many people have been really impacted by this."A Facewatch representative told Mr Hadley that avoiding wrongly including individuals on its database was "of the highest importance" to the company.
Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Treasury ‘looking at' new property taxes to replace stamp duty
The Treasury is considering plans to raise money from a tax on the sale of homes worth more than £500,000, according to reports. Government officials are looking at a potential national property tax, which would replace stamp duty on owner-occupied homes, The Guardian reported. No final decision has been made, but it is thought this national tax could help build a model for local levies to replace council tax in the medium term. Buyers pay stamp duty under the existing framework, if they purchase property worth more than £125,000. The new levy would be paid by owner-occupiers on houses worth more than £500,000 when they sell their home, with the amount due determined by the value of the property and a rate set by the Government. A Treasury spokesperson said: 'As set out in the plan for change, the best way to strengthen public finances is by growing the economy – which is our focus. 'Changes to tax and spend policy are not the only ways of doing this, as seen with our planning reforms, which are expected to grow the economy by £6.8 billion and cut borrowing by £3.4 billion. 'We are committed to keeping taxes for working people as low as possible, which is why at last autumn's budget, we protected working people's payslips and kept our promise not to raise the basic, higher or additional rates of income tax, employee national insurance, or VAT.' Chancellor Rachel Reeves will unveil any changes to the Government's tax policy at a fiscal event, such as a budget. Former government adviser Tim Leunig has previously suggested replacing stamp duty land tax with a 'national proportional property tax' levied on house values greater than £500,000, in a paper published by the think tank Onward. At a rate of 0.54%, with a 0.278% supplement on values over £1 million, the levy 'would raise the same amount as stamp duty'. Sir Mel Stride, Conservative shadow chancellor, said: 'The Conservatives have warned that more taxes are coming and now reports are emerging that the family home is next in the firing line. 'This tax grab would punish families for aspiring to own their own home. 'Under Labour nothing is safe. Your home, your job, your pension – the Chancellor has all of it in her sights. 'Rachel Reeves will tax your future to pay for her failure.'
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Reeves considering new property tax on houses worth more than £500,000
The Treasury is examining plans for a new tax on the sale of homes worth more than £500,000 as part of a shake-up of stamp duty and council tax. Chancellor Rachel Reeves has asked officials to study how a new 'proportional' property tax could be introduced and to model its impact ahead of this autumn's budget. Ministers have already been briefed on the proposals, which could be rolled out during this parliament, The Guardian reports. Under one option, a national property levy would replace stamp duty on owner occupied homes. In the medium term, a second stage could see a local property tax replace council tax, a move designed to repair the finances of struggling local authorities. No final decisions have been made. Treasury sources stressed that while a national levy could be implemented in the coming years, reform of council tax would take longer and would likely depend on Labour winning a second term. The review reflects growing pressure on the chancellor to introduce more wealth based taxes. Labour's deputy leader, Angela Rayner, has urged Ms Reeves to consider measures that target property wealth. Ms Reeves is also under pressure to raise additional revenue without breaking Labour's pledge not to increase taxes on working people. If adopted, the new levy would be paid by owner occupiers when they sell a home worth more than £500,000. The amount would be based on the value of the property, with the rate set centrally and collected by HM Revenue and Customs. It would not replace stamp duty on second homes. The average house price in the UK stood at £272,664 in July, according to Nationwide. Current stamp duty receipts from primary residences vary significantly depending on the housing market, raising £11.6 billion last year. Treasury officials believe a national property tax would be a more stable source of income and would eventually raise a similar amount. Unlike stamp duty, which currently applies to around 60 per cent of home sales and is paid by buyers, the new levy would affect only about a fifth of transactions. The proposals are informed by a 48 page report published last year by the centre right think tank Onward. Written by Dr Tim Leunig, a former government adviser who helped devise the furlough scheme during the Covid pandemic, it set out a dual national and local 'proportional property tax' based on property values. Dr Leunig wrote: 'These proposals would make it easier and cheaper to move house, for a better job, or to be near family, as well as being fairer. It should not be the case that a terrace house in Burnley pays more than a mansion in Kensington – and it wouldn't be under these proposals.'
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Wayne Rooney: ‘Racially abused player cried on my chest'
Wayne Rooney has revealed how he consoled a former player who 'cried on his chest' after receiving racist abuse. He believes believes only tougher sanctions for racism in football, like points deductions, will prevent further incidents. Speaking on his new BBC podcast, The Wayne Rooney Show, former England and Manchester United captain Rooney reflected on what changes need to occur to help tackle discrimination. Last week saw two major incidents, with Antoine Semenyo of Bournemouth allegedly racially abused by a spectator in the crowd during their 4-2 loss at Liverpool and Tottenham forward Mathys Tel receiving racism online for a missed penalty in their Super Cup defeat to Paris St Germain. Ex-DC United boss Rooney said: 'I had it in DC with one of my players who got racially abused and he was crying on my chest. I was holding him as he was crying on my chest. 'I don't think people realise – they say it as a throwaway line that they think has no meaning behind it, but it hurts people. For people to see that and understand, there has to be more done to stop it.' Points deductions and education were put forward by Rooney as key deterrents to prevent racism. He added: 'There needs to be a strong campaign for society – for children, parents and grandparents – to be educated,' Rooney added. 'You have to hit the clubs because that's the only way it will stop. If there is ignorance, the fans will still do it. 'You have to hit the clubs by taking off points or hit them in the pocket and take money away from them. Otherwise, it will keep on going. 'Hopefully the right people sit down with the right organisations to try and get something serious in place.'
