Give Sabah, Sarawak their own JACs, says assemblyman
PETALING JAYA : Sabah and Sarawak should have their own judicial appointments commission (JAC) to strengthen judicial independence, a Sarawak assemblyman suggested today.
Kota Sentosa assemblyman Wilfred Yap lamented the 'glaring underrepresentation of Sabah and Sarawak in the appointment process of our nation's judiciary'.
'Sabah and Sarawak should each have their own JAC, empowered to identify and propose qualified candidates for appointment as chief judge of Sabah and Sarawak, as well as other High Court positions within the states.
'This is essential to ensure that appointments are grounded in local context, professional merit and the aspirations of local communities,' the Borneo Post quoted him as saying.
Yap also called for a statutory quota for Sabahan and Sarawakian representation in the federal and appellate courts, prescribed by law to reflect the states' equal constitutional standing.
'The current discretionary approach, where representation depends on executive appointments without clear statutory safeguards, is inadequate and incompatible with the letter and spirit of our founding agreements,' he said.
Yap said the lack of Sabahan representation in the JAC not only went against the Malaysia Agreement 1963's spirit of partnership, but also 'risks eroding public confidence in the impartiality and inclusiveness of the justice system'.
'The Federal Constitution itself acknowledges Sabah and Sarawak's special position.
'Article 122B(3) clearly requires that the prime minister consult the chief minister of the state concerned before advising the Yang di-Pertuan Agong on the appointment of the Chief Judge of the High Court in Sabah and Sarawak.
'While this consultation is not binding, it is intended to ensure the leadership of the judiciary in Sabah and Sarawak is not decided unilaterally by Putrajaya.'
The JAC is tasked with selecting suitable candidates to sit as judges in the superior courts – the Federal Court, the Court of Appeal, and the High Courts.
FMT reported last month that a senior judge had been summoned by the JAC to answer claims of interference in the appointment of judges dating back to last year.
Police are probing the allegations under the Official Secrets Act.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
a minute ago
- Malay Mail
‘I stick to my speech': Ex-judge Abdul Rahman Sebli stands by bombshell farewell claim of pressure on the bench
PUTRAJAYA, July 28 — Fresh off his retirement as Chief Judge of Sabah and Sarawak, Tan Sri Abdul Rahman Sebli today reaffirmed his claim that he was pressured by a senior judge during his time on the Federal Court bench. The allegation, first made during his farewell speech in Kuching, Sarawak on July 23, came just two days before his official retirement. 'I have nothing else to say. I stick to my speech,' Abdul Rahman told reporters when approached at the Palace of Justice after attending the swearing-in ceremony for his successor and other judicial appointments. Asked why he had only recently made the claim public, Abdul Rahman replied, 'I think this is the right time lah'. When questioned whether he was concerned about possible repercussions, he said: 'I am not worried. I am saying what is right'. In his speech, Abdul Rahman alleged that the pressure came while he was still a junior Federal Court judge, before his elevation to Chief Judge of Sabah and Sarawak. He was appointed a Federal Court judge on August 8, 2019, and later ascended to the role of Chief Judge on January 17, 2023. Recounting the incident, he said he had circulated a draft judgment to six other Federal Court judges, in line with court protocol. He claimed a senior judge responded via email, criticising his views on a constitutional issue in the case. Despite the alleged pressure, Abdul Rahman said he stood by his judgment. Three other judges agreed with his draft, forming the majority. The remaining three judges dissented. He did not name the senior judge involved, nor did he identify the specific case referenced in his remarks. Former chief justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, when approached by reporters today at the Palace of Justice, declined to engage in a direct back-and-forth over the remarks. 'I don't want to make this a contest of words,' she said, before offering context about her tenure. Tengku Maimun noted that she dissented in five out of 19 Federal Court cases involving constitutional issues during her six-year tenure as chief justice. She said this demonstrated judicial independence on the bench. 'Because if I had any influence on their decisions, then surely I would not be dissenting in five out of 19 cases involving especially constitutional law,' she said.
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Ex-CJ Tengku Maimun says Federal Court was free of pressure during her tenure, cites dissenting decisions as proof
PUTRAJAYA, July 28 — Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat today dismissed the idea that she had influenced Federal Court decisions during her six-year tenure as the country's top judge. The recently retired judge pointed to her own dissenting judgments in constitutional cases as proof that judges had decided cases independently. 'For the past six years, the Federal Court had decided 19 cases involving various issues of constitutional law,' she told reporters at the Palace of Justice here, after the swearing-in ceremony of Datuk Abu Bakar Jais and Datuk Azizah Nawawi as the president of the Court of Appeal and the chief judge of Sabah and Sarawak respectively. 'And out of that 19 cases, I was dissenting in five cases. So I think statistically, five out of 19 represents about 25 per cent of the dissenting judgments.' Tengku Maimun said this showed judges were free from pressure, including from herself when she was chief justice. 'So I think that fact alone would manifest that judges decided independently without fear or favour, without external or internal pressure. 'Because if I had any influence on their decisions, then surely I would not be dissenting in five out of 19 cases involving especially constitutional law.' Tengku Maimun was asked about a recent speech by Tan Sri Abdul Rahman Sebli who recently retired as chief judge of Sabah and Sarawak and had alleged interference in a Federal Court case involving constitutional issues. 'Let's not make it a contest of words between two people or more than two people. Perhaps I can just share some facts,' she replied, before going on to cite the statistics where she had been the dissenting judge in about 25 per cent of constitutional cases at the Federal Court. Datuk Abdul Rahman Sebli is pictured during his swearing-in ceremony as a new chief judge of Sabah and Sarawak at the Palace of Justice in Putrajaya on January 17, 2023. — Picture by Yusof Mat Isa Just before his retirement on July 25, Abdul Rahman had on July 23 in a farewell event in Kuching, Sarawak alleged that a senior judge had put pressure on him by criticising his draft judgment when he was still relatively junior as a Federal Court judge, but did not name the purported judge. In that speech, Abdul Rahman said he had stood by his draft judgment and it became a majority judgment as it was supported by three other judges, while three judges dissented and disagreed with his decision in that constitutional case. Tengku Maimun retired earlier this month after serving as the first woman chief justice in Malaysia. She said her retirement has been 'good'. 'Alhamdulillah, feeling very free, enjoying quiet moments,' she said. She also congratulated those appointed to new roles in the judiciary today.
Borneo Post
2 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Sabah leaders secure key national roles in Malaysia-China Chamber of Commerce
Dexter, Coral and Lau. KOTA KINABALU (July 28): The Malaysia-China Chamber of Commerce (MCCC) has recently announced its latest national-level appointments, in which several representatives from the Sabah have successfully ascended to key central positions — fully showcasing the branch's growing prominence and strategic significance in the national business landscape. These appointments are not only a high-level recognition of the Sabah team's past efforts but also symbolize Sabah's deepening strategic role in driving bilateral trade and economic cooperation between Malaysia and China. In this round of appointments, MCCC Sabah President Datuk Dexter Lau has been elected as Chairman of the MCCC National Business Sectors Committee. He will spearhead efforts to lead national business players in exploring new blueprints for Malaysia-China collaboration, promoting more diversified, higher-quality, and forward-looking economic engagement. His appointment signifies that Sabah's representatives are no longer confined to regional roles but have now risen to become key leaders in shaping national business strategies. 'This appointment not only grants me a broader platform to serve and support the national business community, but more importantly, it allows me to bring Sabah onto wider domestic and international business networks — helping attract more resources and investment into the region. This will benefit not only Sabah but also radiate to Sarawak and Brunei. I will continue to advocate for East Malaysia, ensuring we have a strong voice in the country's economic landscape and contribute dynamic regional energy to Malaysia-China cooperation,' said Dexter. The post of Vice Chairperson of the Business Sectors Committee is held by Coral Chia, who will work closely with Dexter to elevate the committee into a more efficient, results-oriented collaboration platform. A leader in the building materials sector and an active MCCC member, Coral has served in the national council for many years and played a key role in decision-making. Notably, her mother is Dato' See Meng Geok, MCCC's current Vice President, who has long worked alongside Datuk Lau Kok Sing in national-level affairs. The strong collaboration between Coral and Dexter is expected to inject more innovation and synergy into the committee, enhancing its nationwide influence and effectiveness. Dexter's appointment, MCCC Sabah's Founding President and Honorary Life Adviser, Datuk Lau Kok Sing, continues his role as National Affairs Advisor. With his extensive experience in chamber affairs, he will continue offering visionary input and strategic counsel for the chamber's future direction, policy formulation, and organizational development. His longstanding contribution to the growth of Malaysia-China trade relations makes him a pillar of stability for the national organization. Josephine and Michael. Meanwhile, Datuk Michael Chin, also an Honorary Life Adviser and former MCCC Sabah President, has been appointed as a National Vice President of MCCC. This is a strong endorsement of his long-standing efforts in promoting Malaysia-China business exchanges, building business platforms, and advancing structured organizational governance. As a tireless advocate of Sabah-China cooperation, he has played a key role in fostering deep enterprise-level engagement between both sides — acting as a vital bridge between regional and international markets. Furthermore, senior Sabah member and legal representative JP Josephine Wan Wen Hadikusumo has been appointed as MCCC's National Internal Auditor. Her solid legal background and extensive professional expertise will help strengthen the chamber's overall financial governance mechanisms, enhance transparency and compliance, and ensure the organization maintains a high level of discipline and auditing standards while continuing to grow. Commenting on these appointments, Dexter stated, 'the fact that the Sabah team has taken up several key national positions is not just an honor, but a responsibility. We will continue to uphold our spirit of professionalism, unity, and progress — not only speaking up for Sabah, but also working hand in hand with our counterparts across Malaysia to harness the strength of the Malaysian business community, seize opportunities from China's vast market, and inject fresh momentum into bilateral economic cooperation.'
