Pope Francis' visit to Ireland called a ‘powerful moment' for abuse survivors
The pontiff's two-day trip, which included stops at Knock shrine in County Mayo and a homeless centre in Dublin, was his first to Ireland since becoming head of the Catholic Church, at a time when the country continued to grapple with the legacy of decades of abuse carried out in Church-run institutions.
While Pope Francis did meet with survivors and asked for 'forgiveness for the abuses in Ireland' during a Mass at Phoenix Park, some felt his words lacked the directness and accountability they had long hoped for.
READ MORE: What happens now after Pope Francis death? Period of mourning and how new Catholic leader is picked
READ MORE: Pope Francis dead aged 88 - updates as tributes paid to leader of Catholic Church
Among those critical of the Pope's address was Colm O'Gorman, a survivor of clerical abuse and former head of Amnesty International Ireland.
He organised a powerful demonstration at Dublin's Garden of Remembrance to coincide with the papal Mass.
'This was not about a protest,' he told the PA news agency. 'It's just about standing in solidarity with people who have been impacted or hurt in this way."
An estimated 15,000 to 20,000 people took part in the event, which concluded with a silent walk to Sean McDermott Street – the site of the last Magdalene Laundry to close.
The notorious laundries, run by religious orders, were known for incarcerating women and forcing them to work under harsh conditions.
O'Gorman described the silent walk as 'extraordinarily powerful'.
He said: 'I'll never forget that silent walk, it was just incredibly powerful. Walking down O'Connell Street and turning left to head up towards Sean McDermott Street. And I was walking by, there was a hotel there at the time, and I heard the clink of somebody's spoon going into a coffee cup.'
Despite moments of solemn reflection, he says the visit revealed the public's shifting relationship with the Church. 'There were massive gaps in the crowd,' he said of the Pope's motorcade. 'At points, there was nobody lining the route. It was an early sign that people weren't there waving flags like they used to.'
While O'Gorman praised Pope Francis for his compassion towards refugees and his more progressive tone on social issues, including women's rights and LGBT+ communities, he said the Church's failure to offer a full apology for abuse remains a serious failing.
O'Gorman believes the Vatican has yet to fully acknowledge its role in covering up abuse.
He said: He said: 'I have yet to see a papal apology for abuse anywhere, and it's always very frustrating when the statements that various Popes have made over the years are presented as an apology.
'What popes generally do – and that includes, sadly, Pope Francis – is they speak of their regret and sadness, or sorrow at the hurt caused to so many people. That's not an apology. It's an expression of sorrow.
'No Pope has ever done that. The Vatican has never, ever, ever acknowledged its central role in not just permitting these cover ups to happen, but in directing these cover ups.'
Seven years on, many survivors are still waiting for what they consider a true reckoning from the highest levels of the Church.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
4 hours ago
- Fox News
Rocks hurled through DC church's stained-glass windows, car destroyed as federal crime crackdown continues
In the midst of the Trump administration's effort to rein in crime in Washington, D.C., a vandal targeted a local church, hurling rocks through its stained-glass windows in broad daylight. The Metropolitan Police Department told Fox News Digital that just before 6:30 p.m. on Monday, officers responded to Mt. Olive Baptist Church on 6th Street Northeast and found rocks had been thrown through the church's windows. A nearby vehicle also had damage to the front window, back window, and both mirrors. By the time officers arrived, the suspect was gone, MPD said. The church is in the Capitol Hill area of Washington, D.C., just steps from Lincoln Park and a few blocks east of the Capitol building. It is situated between Pennsylvania Avenue NE and H Street NE, an area that struggled to recover after being damaged during the 1969 riots related to the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., according to the city's website. The investigation remains ongoing, according to police. FBI Director Kash Patel announced on Wednesday that federal partners have made more than 550 arrests in D.C. since President Donald Trump deployed federal agents to patrol the city on Aug. 8. On Tuesday night alone, federal agents made 66 arrests, according to Patel. The FBI joined partners in 41 of the arrests, recovering six illegal guns with eight drug seizures, he added. "Saving lives every day," he wrote in an X post. "Thanks to the men and women in the field." In addition to the citywide 11 p.m. curfew for minors under the age of 17, MPD announced on Wednesday it was establishing a "juvenile curfew zone" in the U Street corridor, which is about three miles northwest of Capitol Hill. Within the juvenile curfew zone, children under the age of 17 are prohibited from gathering in a group of nine or more in any public place or on the premises of any establishment unless engaged in certain exempted activities, according to police. The curfew zone will be in effect from 8 p.m. to 11 p.m. through the weekend. "The Juvenile Curfew Emergency Amendment Act of 2025 gives the Chief of the Metropolitan Police Department the authority to order a Juvenile Curfew Zone in an area where large groups of youths are gathering or intend to gather in a manner that poses a risk of substantial harm to public safety," MPD wrote in a statement. Mt. Olive Baptist Church did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment.
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Two Labour-run councils 'considering all options' to challenge migrant hotel use
Two Labour-run councils have said they are considering taking legal action to stop the use of hotels to house migrants in their areas after Epping council won a temporary injunction on Tuesday.
New York Post
8 hours ago
- New York Post
Pope Leo must stand up to Muslim immigrants seeking to remake Europe
As Muslim migration roils Europe, some Catholic bishops are starting to notice. 'For decades, the Islamization of Europe has been progressing through mass immigration,' Polish Bishop Antoni Długosz said July 13, adding that illegal immigrants 'create serious problems in the countries they arrive in.' Bishop Athanasius Schneider of Kazakhstan spoke more bluntly in March: 'We're witnessing an invasion. They are not refugees. This is an invasion, a mass Islamization of Europe.' Advertisement Yet Pope Leo XIV lives in a different dimension. 'In a world darkened by war and injustice . . . migrants and refugees stand as messengers of hope,' Leo said July 25. 'Their courage and tenacity bear heroic testimony to a faith that sees beyond what our eyes can see and gives them the strength to defy death on the various contemporary migration routes.' Leo's comments express more than blissful sentimentality. They reveal the Vatican's role in encouraging open borders and exempting migrants from accountability. Advertisement In Europe's case, that involves deliberate blindness to the violent, totalitarian nature of Islam and many of its followers. This Catholic approach toward Islam reflects the ideas of Louis Massignon, a French scholar from the early 20th century. Massignon described Islam as 'the faith of Abraham revived with Muhammad,' and asserted that Muslims 'have the right to equality among the monotheisms descended from Abraham.' French Catholic scholar Alain Besançon described the results. 'An entire literature favorable to Islam has grown up in Europe, much of it the work of Catholic priests under the sway of Massignon's ideas,' he wrote. Advertisement Asylum seekers from Afghanistan set up tents inside of the Church of Saint John the Baptist at the Beguinage in Brussels on Jan. 7, 2014. REUTERS/Francois Lenoir Besançon attributed that posture to 'an underlying dissatisfaction with modernity, and with our liberal, capitalist, individualistic arrangements,' a dissatisfaction that the Vatican embodies. 'Alarmed by the ebbing of religious faith in the Christian West, and particularly in Europe,' Massignon's advocates 'cannot but admire Muslim devoutness,' Besançon wrote. 'Surely, they reason, it is better to believe in something than to believe in nothing, and since these Muslims believe in something, they must believe in the same thing we do.' Advertisement The Catholic Church officially embraced Massignon's ideas at the Second Vatican Council in two documents. One, Nostra Aetate, focused on the church's relationship with Judaism but additionally addressed Islam: 'The Church regards with esteem the Muslims. They adore the one God . . . they take pains to submit wholeheartedly to even His inscrutable decrees, just as Abraham, with whom the faith of Islam takes pleasure in linking itself, submitted to God. Though they do not acknowledge Jesus as God, they revere Him as a prophet.' The other, Lumen Gentium, declared that 'the plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator. In the first place among these there are the Muslims, who, professing to hold the faith of Abraham, along with us adore the one and merciful God.' That passage made the Catholic catechism. But what Besançon called 'indulgent ecumenicism' toward Islam goes beyond words. During John Paul II's papacy, the church embraced outright appeasement. Catholic bishops sold underutilized churches and schools to Muslim groups; many of the churches became mosques. In October 2006, the Capuchin Franciscan friars agreed to help the Union of Islamic Communities and Organizations in Italy (UCOII) build a mosque in Genoa next to a monastery. The friars even helped build the mosque's foundation. Advertisement But the UCOII — affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood — advocates 'an extremist version of the Quran, where Christians, Jews and Westerners are criminalized, as well as women and other Muslims who don't submit to their rule,' Magdi Allam, a convert to Catholicism from Islam, reported for Milan's Corriere della Sera. In 2006, the group also demanded Islamic schools, banks and clerical review of textbooks. Its president, Mohamed Nour Dachan, refused to sign a document pledging Muslims to accept Italy's constitution, denounce terrorism and recognize Israel's right to exist. Seven months earlier, a Vatican cardinal even suggested that Muslim students receive Islamic religious instruction in the hour reserved for Catholic instruction in Italian schools. Advertisement 'If there are 100 Muslim children in a school, I don't see why they shouldn't be taught their religion,' said the late Cardinal Renato Martino, then the president of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace. 'If we said 'no' until we saw equivalent treatment for the Christian minorities in Muslim countries, I would say that we were placing ourselves on their level.' In 2008, the Catholic bishops of England and Wales asked Catholic schools to reserve prayer rooms for Muslim students and to adapt bathroom facilities for ritual cleansing before prayer. But the worst example of appeasement took place in Belgium. As part of a campaign to force the government to grant amnesty, Belgium's Catholic bishops turned their churches into homes for Muslim migrants, making them squatters. An Afghan refugee seen at the altar of the Church of Saint John the Baptist at the Beguinage on Jan. 30, 2014. REUTERS Advertisement In May 2006, more than 30 Belgian churches served such a purpose. About 300 Africans occupied Antwerp's Magdalena Chapel. Other churches held as many as 700 squatters. At Our Lady of Succor Church in Brussels, squatters lived in small tents donated by Catholic relief agencies, conducted Muslim services, erected computer tables near the pulpit and even set fires on the floor. Friar Herwig Arts described a scene at Antwerp's Jesuit chapel: migrants 'removed the tabernacle [and] installed a television set and radios, depriving us of the opportunity to pray in our own chapel and say Mass.' He went on, 'For me, the place has been desecrated. I feel I cannot enter it anymore.' Advertisement Belgium's bishops were not amused. Arts was chided by Belgium's leading clergy. 'Solidarity cannot be limited to one's own nation, said the late Cardinal Godfried Danneels, then the country's leading prelate. Monsingor Luc van Looy, then the bishop of Ghent, even said 'illegal fugitives' were 'entitled to a good place in our society. Arts has been silent on the topic ever since. But two decades later, Kazakhstan's Bishop Schneider refuses to stay silent: 'This is a global political agenda by the powerful of the world to destroy Europe.' Leo thus faces an existential challenge, one that blissful sentimentality cannot answer: Will he allow a church that played a pivotal role in creating European civilization to perform a more decisive part in destroying it? This article first ran in The Spectator's US edition.
