Brother of woman who refused chemotherapy says mother ‘sacrificed' her daughter
Her mother, Kay 'Kate' Shemirani – who rose to prominence on social media while sharing Covid-19 conspiracy theories, is alleged to have been 'abusive' to her children and was involved in Paloma's alternative 'treatment programme'.
Paloma's twin brother, Gabriel Shemirani, told the inquest at Kent and Medway Coroners Court, in Maidstone: 'I blame my mother entirely for my sister's death', by 'obstructing' his sister from receiving treatment.
'In short I believe that she sacrificed Paloma's life for her own principles, I believe that she should be held accountable for Paloma's death,' said Mr Shemirani.
Ms Shemirani was struck off as a nurse in 2021, and a Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) committee found she had spread Covid-19 misinformation that 'put the public at a significant risk of harm'.
Mr Shemirani's parents split in 2014 after a relationship which had involved domestic abuse 'both ways', he told the court.
He alleged that he and his siblings 'felt unsafe' around their mother and that she had been 'emotionally distant' and physically abusive to them as children.
He further alleged during his evidence that his father, Doctor Faramarz Shemirani, was also physically abusive to him and his brother.
At the time of Paloma's cancer diagnosis in autumn 2023, she was estranged from her mother, who then advised her against conventional medicine, the court heard.
Mr Shemirani said: 'Paloma had a complicated relationship with our mother, maybe it is because she had a complicated relationship that she decided to rekindle that relationship when she became ill.
'In my opinion, Kay Shemirani directed her resentment that she held towards my other siblings and I towards Paloma.'
Mr Shemirani brought a High Court case to assess his sister's ability to exert her capacity to take medical decisions while living with her mother in April 2024.
He claimed that when Paloma was first diagnosed, she was considering chemotherapy, before their parents started to pressure her against it.
Her father sent a message to his daughter saying 'don't consent to anything from the doctors they try and kill you' and that Ms Shemirani had said 'I'm the only one that can help you, don't bite the hand that feeds', the inquest heard.
'There was no disagreement from her that this was cancer, she never expressed that to me and she never expressed it to doctors either,' said Mr Shemirani.
Paloma Shemirani (Gareth Fuller/PA)
His parents asked questions as interested persons which alleged that Mr Shemirani was influenced and funded by others to bring the High Court case and that his actions were a factor in Paloma's death during his evidence.
'My sister didn't die from stress from the court case, my sister died from cancer and I think that's clear,' said Mr Shemirani.
Before the High Court case, Mr Shemirani also referred the situation to social services but he felt they were 'slow moving', the court heard.
He added that his younger sister had been taken away from their mother when she was 16 and that the case was 'only driven by my love and concern for my twin sister'.
Dr Shemirani claimed his son was an 'irrational' and 'unreliable witness', and that his actions had been a 'major contributing' factor to her death.
'This is not a public forum to air grievances,' Coroner Catherine Wood said.
'I don't have any aggrievances, I don't have any aggrievances,' Dr Shemirani said.
'Sounds like it,' Mr Shemirani responded.
When his questions concluded, Dr Shemirani said: 'Finally may our lord almighty exercise you from the demons that possess you amen.'
Previously, Dr Ali Ajaz, a forensic psychiatrist, provided an assessment of Paloma during High Court proceedings which read: 'I have no concerns that Ms Shemirani has been coerced or unduly influenced by any individual when making a decision about her own medical treatment.'
Mr Shemirani asserted that Dr Ajaz's sessions with his sister were 'coloured by my mother's control', which the doctor said was speculation.
On Wednesday afternoon, Mr Shemirani told the court that his sister was terrified of cancer, but used gallows humour as a defence mechanism.
'Are you a psychologist Gabriel?' his mother asked him.
'Are you a nurse?' he replied.
The inquest continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
3 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
No more Covid jabs, millions are told - as experts hit out at 'reckless decision' to block all but one age group from further boosters
Health chiefs were today begged to re-examine the UK's Covid jab policy after ditching plans to offer the jabs to under 75s this winter. Invites won't be dished out to up to six million pensioners aged 65-74, who were eligible during the pandemic. Only those over the age of 75, those living in care homes and others who are immunosuppressed will be able to come forwards for a jab. Experts labelled the move a 'hugely concerning' and 'reckless decision' warning cases could shoot up before the vulnerable get their top-up jab. Scientists were alarmed last month after a new Covid variant dubbed 'Stratus' and believed to to be more infectious than previous Covid strains, soared to dominance in the UK. But the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI), which guides ministers on jab rollouts, argued that additional Covid doses provide 'very limited, if any, protection against infection' given the 'high population immunity' to the virus. Dr Leyla Hannbeck, chief executive of the Independent Pharmacies Association, said the JCVI's decision was a 'hugely concerning, a reckless decision'. She added: 'By restricting access to jabs this autumn ahead of peak Covid season, there is a serious risk that Covid cases in this age group increase compared to previous years putting even greater pressure on the NHS. 'Saving a few pounds by not giving a patient a jab could end now up leaving the NHS with a bill for thousands, if that patient ends up hospitalised with Covid later on. 'Many patients will feel they need to pay privately to get protection. 'We urge the JCVI and the government to think again and make everyone 65 and over in England eligible for an NHS COVID jab from their local pharmacy.' She also said it was 'madness' for the UK to restrict jabs, when other nations including Germany and the United States were still recommending the vaccines for all pensioners. 'To deny millions of seniors their COVID jab this year is to take an unacceptable risk with patient health and risks producing a winter crisis the NHS simply won't be able to cope with,' Dr Hannbeck added. A Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) spokesperson said: 'This decision is based on expert advice from the JCVI, which continuously monitor and evaluate emerging scientific evidence on Covid vaccines. 'The autumn 2025 vaccination programme will target people who are at the highest risk of serious illness to protect the most vulnerable. We encourage anyone who is eligible for Covid vaccination to come forward for vaccination this autumn.' Under the JCVI's advice, frontline NHS workers and care staff will also no longer be offered free jabs. 'In the current era of high population immunity to Covid, additional Covid doses provide very limited, if any, protection against infection and any subsequent onward transmission of infection,' they said. The vaccines are estimated to have saved tens of millions of lives globally from Covid, 1.6million in Europe and 3million in the US. They are also credited with helping end the series of paralyzing lockdowns brought on by the Covid pandemic. In the UK, ministers have repeatedly said they won't resort to imposing lockdowns unless a doomsday Covid variant appears. A wall of immunity among the population—built up by repeated waves of infection and vaccine rollouts—has given officials confidence to consign pandemic-era measures to history. Spikes in Covid cases can still cause mass illness across the country, sparking chaos in schools, the health service and public transport. But officials also no longer track the prevalence of the virus in the same way they used to, as part of the Government's ushering in of pre-Covid normalities.
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
From folding in half to swollen hands – the 8 signs of killer virus in China sparking global outbreak fears
The virus gets its name from a word meaning 'that which bends up' or 'doubled-up', in reference to the stooped posture of victims hunched over in pain VIRAL ALERT From folding in half to swollen hands – the 8 signs of killer virus in China sparking global outbreak fears Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) HEALTH chiefs in China have reimposed strict, Covid-esque restrictions in a desperate bid to contain a virus that leaves victims disabled. More than 7,000 people have been struck down by the mosquito-borne chikungunya virus in China's biggest ever outbreak of the crippling disease, experts have warned. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 7 A worker sprays insecticide at a public housing estate following reports of imported cases of Chikungunya in Hong Kong, China Credit: Reuters 7 The majority of cases have been reported in Foshan, a city in southern Guangdong province. It is here where officials have rolled out Covid-style crackdowns in a bid to stop the virus from spiralling out of control. At least 12 other cities in the southern Guangdong province have also reported infections. On Monday, Hong Kong reported its first case - a 12-year-old boy who developed symptoms after travelling to Foshan in July. Although the disease is rarely fatal, it can cause excruciating joint pain, fever, rashes and swelling, especially in the hands and feet. In response, authorities in Foshan have launched emergency mosquito control operations, including mass insecticide spraying, public health alerts, and door-to-door inspections. Those with chikungunya must stay in hospital, where their beds will protected with mosquito nets. They can only be discharged after they test negative or at the end of a week-long stay. Here is what you need to know about the disease. What is chikungunya and what are the symptoms? Although rare in China, chikungunya outbreaks are common across South and South East Asia and parts of Africa. What is Chikungunya The virus, which is spread by the Aedes mosquito - also known as the tiger mosquito, was first identified in Tanzania in 1952 and has since been reported in over 110 countries. Most people who get bitten by an infected bug will develop symptoms within three to seven days. Dr César López-Camacho, from the Jenner Institute at the University of Oxford, said: "Although chikungunya rarely causes death, it can be extremely uncomfortable and disabling." Typical symptoms include: Excruciating joint pain, which can leave victims hunched or folded over in agony High fever Headache Muscle aches Nausea Fatigue Red, bumpy rash Swelling in the joints, particularly the hands and feet In severe cases, the joint pain can mimic arthritis, leaving sufferers temporarily disabled for months or even years. 7 Patient with joint deformities of the hands 6 years after confirmed chikungunya virus Credit: SehatHub 7 The virus is spread by the Aedes mosquito - also known as the tiger mosquito because of its stripy body Credit: Alamy The virus gets its name from a word meaning 'that which bends up' or 'doubled-up', in reference to the stooped posture of victims hunched over in pain. Most people recover within a week, but some may require hospital care, especially if complications like organ damage arise. The virus can attack vital organs including the brain, heart, liver, and kidneys, triggering dangerous inflammation and tissue damage. Its intense inflammatory response can also harm the lungs, skin, and joints, worsening symptoms and increasing the risk of serious complications. Those most at risk of severe illness include newborn babies, older adults, and people with underlying conditions such as heart disease or diabetes. Is there a treatment or vaccine? There is no specific treatment for chikungunya, but medics can treat the symptoms by giving medicines to lower fevers or ease muscle pain. Two chikungunya vaccines have recently been approved for use in the UK - although one is under safety review for older people. Those are mostly targeted at travellers and are not widely available in the countries most affected by chikungunya. Once someone has recovered from chikungunya, there is evidence to suggest they have lifelong immunity. Unlike malaria-carrying mosquitoes, called Anopheles, tiger mozzies are most active during the day, especially in the early morning and late afternoon. Experts warn that the best way to prevent its spread is to eliminate pools of stagnant water where mosquitoes breed, according to the World Health Organisation (WHO). Brits travelling to China amidst the outbreak should "be cautious", Dr César added. He continued: "The US Centre for Disease Control and Prevention has issued a Level 2 travel alert, recommending travellers use insect repellent, wear long sleeves, and stay in screened or air-conditioned accommodation. "Travellers returning from affected areas who develop fever and joint pain should seek medical attention and mention their recent travel." People travelling to high-risk areas where outbreaks of the virus often occur can get vaccinated against chikungunya at a travel clinic. 7 Insecticide being sprayed outside a Foshan hospital Credit: Getty 7 It is China's biggest outbreak of the disease Credit: Getty Is chikungunya in Europe? The WHO warned last month that chikungunya could soon affect billions across the globe - as it tears through parts of the Indian Ocean and edges closer to Europe. The health watchdog said it was seeing the same warning signs as in the last major outbreak two decades ago, when nearly half a million were infected worldwide. Dr Diana Rojas Alvarez, WHO's technical lead on the virus, said the bug is now spreading from Indian Ocean islands into Africa, Asia and Europe, and urged countries to act now to avoid billions falling ill. "We are seeing history repeating itself," she explained "Chikungunya is not a disease that is widely known, but it has been detected and transmitted in 119 countries globally, putting 5.6 billion people at risk," Dr Diana said. In Europe, officials are especially concerned about a spike in imported cases, and signs of the virus being transmitted locally. Since May 1, there have been around 800 imported chikungunya cases in mainland France, Dr Diana revealed. Even more worrying, there have been 12 local transmission episodes in several regions of southern France - meaning people were infected by mosquitoes in Europe, not while travelling. A case has also been detected in Italy, while the WHO says suspected cases have cropped up in other parts of the continent. Last year, Europe saw a sharp surge in mosquito-borne diseases - including dengue, West Nile, and malaria - with some infections doubling in just 12 months. In places where people have little or no immunity, up to three-quarters of the population can become infected, the WHO warned. "The case fatality rate is less than one per cent, but when you start counting millions of cases, that one per cent can be thousands," Dr Diana said. 7 The WHO warned chikungunya could soon affect billions across the globe Credit: Getty How concerning is this outbreak? Though tactics adopted by authorities in China hark back to lockdown measures five years ago, chikungunya "does not pose the same level of pandemic threat as a virus like Covid-19", according to Prof Tom Solomon, director of The Pandemic Institute in Liverpool. Dr César López-Camacho, from the Jenner Institute at the University of Oxford, added: 'It is extremely unlikely to cause a pandemic in the traditional sense, as chikungunya does not spread from person to person. "However, it can cause large regional outbreaks, especially when introduced to mosquito-rich, low-immunity settings, like what we are probably seeing in China." The risk to the UK from this outbreak is "currently low" as Aedes mosquitoes, which tend to carry the virus, aren't widespread here. "But we do need to watch closely, as climate change and global travel are expanding the range of these mosquitoes, and with it, the viruses they carry," Dr López-Camacho warned. 'It is also important that genetic sequencing of the virus in this outbreak is carried out. "In past outbreaks, mutations have helped chikungunya adapt to new mosquito species. "If the virus has changed, we need to ensure current vaccines still offer protection." Brits travelling to China amidst the outbreak should "be cautious", the disease expert said. He continued: "The US Centre for Disease Control and Prevention has issued a Level 2 travel alert, recommending travellers use insect repellent, wear long sleeves, and stay in screened or air-conditioned accommodation. "Travellers returning from affected areas who develop fever and joint pain should seek medical attention and mention their recent travel." People travelling to high-risk areas where outbreaks of the virus often occur can get vaccinated against chikungunya at a travel clinic. But Prof Solomon noted: "There have been reports of serious side effects in people over the age of 65. "As such, the vaccine is currently recommended for travellers under 65 visiting high-risk areas."
STV News
5 hours ago
- STV News
More than half of Scots experience side-effects from medication, survey finds
Scotland's body for healthcare improvement has encouraged the public to take park in a scheme that tracks the side-effects of medications. Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) made the plea after revealing that just 10% of Scots who experience adverse effects to prescribed medicines are reporting them to the Yellow Card scheme. The statistic was taken from a study which sampled 560 individuals across the country, asking them about medicine safety, long-term health problems, pre-conception health and care. The report recommended more awareness surrounding the Yellow Card scheme, which is run by the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), to improve on underreporting of side-effects of various drugs. About 57% of sample members said they had experienced a side-effect or unintended effect from a medicine. Those who had experienced side-effects were asked if they had spoken to anyone about what they experienced. Of these, 84% had spoken to a doctor, nurse or pharmacist, 29% had spoken to family and friends and 10% had reported it through the Yellow Card scheme. Laura Fulton, chief pharmacist with HIS, said: 'The Yellow Card scheme collects and monitors information on suspected safety concerns involving healthcare products, of which medicines are a significant contributor. 'This is extremely important as it flags side-effects that previously have not been reported, for example. It is vital to improve our understanding of medicines and safeguard patients. 'I would encourage patients, members of the public and healthcare professionals to proactively utilise the Yellow Card scheme and report any concern as soon as they can. 'This will undoubtedly help others both now and in the future.' Professor Simon Maxwell, medical director of the Yellow Card Centre Scotland, said: 'I am pleased that HIS report recognised the important role that the Yellow Card scheme has played, and will continue to play, in safeguarding public health in Scotland. 'Since its inception in the 1960s in the wake of the thalidomide disaster, the scheme has been helping to shine a light on important but less common side-effects to medicines that have not been fully clarified at the time of regulatory approval. 'That was particularly evident following the rapid approval of the Covid-19 vaccines in 2021. 'Although the ability to report side-effects to the scheme was originally restricted to medical professionals, any member of the public can now report, and those reports are making a growing contribution to the scheme. 'I welcome the report's focus on increasing public awareness of the scheme as a mechanism whereby all citizens can all make a contribution to medicines safety.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
