RFK Jr removes all current members of CDC vaccine advisory committee
By
Sarah Owermohle
and
Meg Tirrell
, CNN
US Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr.
Photo:
AFP / Andrew Caballero-Reynolds
US Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr has dismissed an expert panel of vaccine advisers that has historically guided the federal government's vaccine recommendations, saying the group is "plagued with conflicts of interest."
The entirety of the 17-member Advisory Committee on Immunisation Practices, which advises the US Centres for Disease Control and Prevention on the vaccine schedule and required coverage of immunisations, will be retired and replaced with new members, Kennedy announced in a Wall Street Journal op-ed. The HHS secretary has authority to appoint and dismiss ACIP members, who typically serve four-year cycles. But removing the entire panel prematurely is unprecedented.
Kennedy said that a number of the panel's members - traditionally paediatricians, epidemiologists, immunologists and other physicians - were "last-minute appointees" of the Biden administration. "Without removing the current members, the current Trump administration would not have been able to appoint a majority of new members until 2028," he wrote.
ACIP members are not political appointees. However Kennedy, a longtime critic of federal vaccine policy and vaccine safety, argued that the current group is rife with conflicts of interest and has not been transparent in its vaccine recommendations. ACIP recently considered narrowing the recommendations for Covid-19 vaccinations among children.
Kennedy had previously pledged to Sen. Bill Cassidy, a Republican from Louisiana and chairman of the Health, Education, Labour and Pensions Committee, that he would consult with the senator on filling key roles on vaccine advisory boards, and that he would maintain the ACIP without changes, according to a February speech Cassidy delivered when he voted in favour of Kennedy's confirmation as HHS secretary.
"Of course, now the fear is that the ACIP will be filled up with people who know nothing about vaccines except suspicion," Cassidy said in a post on X on Monday. "I've just spoken with Secretary Kennedy, and I'll continue to talk with him to ensure this is not the case."
The move "raises serious questions," Republican Sen. Susan Collins of Maine said Monday. "It seems to me to be excessive to ask for everybody's resignation."
The committee is scheduled to meet on 25-27 June to discuss vaccinations for Covid-19, RSV, influenza, HPV and meningococcal disease. HHS said the meeting will still take place, giving the agency roughly two weeks to fill its advisory panel.
"Appointing people this fast means they were not properly vetted, and there is no real time to check conflict of interests issues," Dorit Reiss, a professor of law at UC Law San Francisco, told CNN. "This will not restore trust in vaccines, and is not designed to do so."
Other health leaders and institutions quickly spoke in defence of the CDC's advisory committee.
Dr. Richard Besser, president and CEO of the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and former acting director of the CDC, said the committee had guided US health agencies for more than 60 years and he had relied on its advice during his own 30-year career as a paediatrician.
"This decision will make it far more difficult for paediatricians and other providers to care for their patients. The idea that ACIP has failed to scrutinize vaccines being given to pregnant women and babies is absolutely absurd," Besser said.
"Nobody has done more than Secretary Kennedy to sow unwarranted doubt about the safety and effectiveness of vaccines, and this decision demonstrates a complete lack of caring about the health and safety of every American."
Dr. Bruce A. Scott, president of the American Medical Association, said in a statement that's Kennedy's decision undermines trust and "upends a transparent process that has saved countless lives. With an ongoing measles outbreak and routine child vaccination rates declining, this move will further fuel the spread of vaccine-preventable illnesses."
Dr. Tina Tan, president of the Infectious Diseases Society of America, said the committee members were highly qualified and Kennedy's allegations about the integrity of ACIP were "completely unfounded and will have a significant negative impact on Americans of all ages."
"Unilaterally removing an entire panel of experts is reckless, shortsighted and severely harmful."
One just-dismissed ACIP member told CNN they did not receive a termination notice until after Kennedy's op-ed published.
"I've never seen anything this damaging to public health happen in my lifetime," the adviser said.
"I'm shocked. It's pretty brazen. This will fundamentally destabilise vaccination in America."
On the conflict of interest allegations, the panellist told CNN, "Kennedy knows better. ACIP has the most rigourous conflict of interest policy of any organization that I know of."
The adviser said providers are no longer going to rely on the CDC vaccination schedule, and will need to create a parallel committee to ACIP that they can trust.
One effort, the Vaccine Integrity Project, launched earlier this year due to concerns that US health leadership was casting unfounded doubt on the safety of well-studied vaccines. Among the project's considerations: whether there's a need for a new independent body to evaluate vaccine safety and effectiveness.
"The firing of the ACIP represents one of the darkest days in modern public health," Dr. Mike Osterholm, the Vaccine Integrity Project founder said. "Mr. Kennedy has no interest in science or saving lives. We have entered into a dangerous time for the health of the country."
-CNN
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

RNZ News
15 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Curfew imposed on LA amid intense protests
An overnight curfew has come into force in the downtown part of LA to try and end days of demonstrations and stop any vandalism or looting. The mayor has also declared a local emergency and expects the curfew, which runs from 8pm to 6am, to last several days. The city is reeling after days of intense protests against immigration raids led to some clashes between demonstrators and police. CNN's Michael Yoshida spoke to Lisa Owen. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.

RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Curfew will go into effect in downtown Los Angeles tonight, Marines arrive
LA Mayor Karen Bass Photo: PATRICK T. FALLON A curfew for certain parts of downtown Los Angeles will be enacted tonight following days of protests that have, at times, turned violent. At a news conference, LA Mayor Karen Bass said she was seeking guidance on how long the curfew should be in place but said it will likely be in effect for a few days. "I will consult with elected leaders and law enforcement officials tomorrow on the continuation of the curfew but we certainly expect for it to last for several days," Bass said. The area of downtown Los Angeles where the curfew will take place is 1 square mile. The total area of the city is 502 square miles, she noted. The curfew will be in effect from 8 pm Tuesday to 6 am Wednesday. Anyone not deemed exempt who is within the designated curfew area will be "subject to arrest," according to LA Police Department Chief Jim McDonnell. "The curfew is a necessary measure to protect lives and safeguard property following several consecutive days of growing unrest throughout the city," McDonnell said. Who is exempt from the curfew? Protest arrests significantly increased over the course of a few days, McDonnell said. On Saturday, 27 people were arrested. Forty were arrested on Sunday and 114 people were arrested Monday. Authorities took 197 people into custody on Tuesday. "Following several consecutive days of growing unrest throughout the city since Saturday, we've seen a concerning escalation and unlawful and dangerous behavior," McDonnell said. He broke down Tuesday arrests by location, indicating that 67 people were taken into custody after "unlawfully occupying" the 101 Freeway. "Let me be clear that this behavior, blocking freeways, city streets and on ramps, refusing to comply with lawful dispersal orders and interfering with public safety operations, is dangerous, unlawful and won't be tolerated," McDonnell said. - CNN

RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
US Marines arrive in LA on Trump's orders, against governor's wishes
By Brad Brooks , Phil Stewart , Idrees Ali and Dietrich Knauth , Reuters US Marines with 2nd Battalion, 7th Marine Regiment, 1st Marine Division, who were placed in an alert status over the weekend to support US Northern Command's mission, rehearsing nonlethal tactics in the greater Los Angeles area. Photo: JUAN TORRES / US MARINE CORPS / AFP Hundreds of US Marines arrived in the Los Angeles area on Tuesday under orders from President Donald Trump, who has also activated 4000 National Guard troops to quell protests in the city despite objections from California Governor Gavin Newsom that the deployments are politically motivated. The city has seen five days of public protests since the Trump administration launched a series of immigration raids on Friday. State officials said Trump's response was an extreme overreaction to mostly peaceful demonstrations . About 700 Marines were in a staging area in the Seal Beach area about 50km south of Los Angeles, awaiting deployment to specific locations, a US official said. The Marines do not have arrest authority and will protect federal property and personnel, according to military officials. There were approximately 2,100 Guard troops in greater Los Angeles on Tuesday, with more on the way, the official said. California sued Trump and the Defense Department on Monday , seeking to block the deployment of federal troops, then on Tuesday sought an immediate ruling on the narrow issue of their participation in police enforcement. The judge set a hearing on that question for Thursday. California Attorney General Rob Bonta told Reuters the state was concerned about allowing federal troops to protect personnel, saying there was a risk that could violate an 1878 law that generally forbids the US military, including the National Guard, from taking part in civilian law enforcement. "The federal property part I understand - defending and protecting federal buildings," Bonta said. "But protecting personnel likely means accompanying ICE agents into communities and neighbourhoods, and protecting functions could mean protecting the ICE function of enforcing the immigration law." US Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Tuesday posted photos on X of National Guard troops accompanying ICE officers on an immigration raid. Photos from today's ICE Los Angeles immigration enforcement operation. Marines are trained for conflicts around the world - from the Middle East to Africa - and are also used for rapid deployments in case of emergencies, such as threats to US embassies. Some units also learn riot and crowd control techniques. Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass. Photo: AFP Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass emphasised at a press conference that the unrest has been limited to a few downtown blocks and she was considering a curfew for downtown Los Angeles to stem violence in the area, including looting of stores. She drew a distinction between the majority of demonstrators protesting peacefully in support of immigrants and a smaller number of agitators she blamed for violence and looting. She said she planned to call Trump on Tuesday. "I want to tell him to stop the raids," she said. "I want to tell him that this is a city of immigrants." Trump has justified his decision to deploy troops by describing the protests as a violent occupation, a characterization that Newsom and Bass have said is grossly exaggerated. Speaking to reporters in the Oval Office, the president said LA would be "burning right now" if not for the deployments, and that Guard troops would remain until there is no danger. Trump left open the possibility of invoking the centuries-old Insurrection Act, which would allow the military to take part directly in civilian law enforcement. Photo: AFP/ETIENNE LAURENT The protests since Friday have been largely peaceful, but there have been scattered clashes, with some demonstrators throwing rocks at officers, blocking a highway and setting cars ablaze. Police have responded with "less lethal" munitions such as pepper balls, as well as flash-bang grenades and tear gas. The Los Angeles Police Department said it arrested more than 100 people on Monday, raising the regional total since Saturday to more than 180. On Tuesday, police holding shields and wearing helmets formed a line close to protesters hoisting banners with slogans such as "When injustice becomes the law, resistance becomes duty." Protests have concentrated outside the Metropolitan Detention Center, where many detained migrants are held. The Trump administration has vowed to intensify immigration raids in response. Protests have taken place in other cities including Chicago, where on Tuesday about 100 protesters marched through downtown, blocking traffic and carrying signs calling for ICE to be abolished. Christina Berger, 39, said it was heartbreaking to hear about children who are afraid of being separated from their families due to immigration raids, adding, "I just want to give some hope to my friends and neighbours." Fireworks explode around police officers in riot gear during a protest in response to federal immigration operations in the Little Tokyo neighborhood of downtown Los Angeles, on 9 June, 2025. Photo: FREDERIC J. BROWN / AFP Business owners in LA's Little Tokyo neighbourhood - where some of the most intense clashes between police and protesters occurred late on Monday - were washing graffiti off storefront windows and sweeping up litter on Tuesday. Every building on Little Tokyo's main streets was hit with graffiti, except for a public defender's office that stood untouched. Frank Chavez, 53, manager of an office building in the neighbourhood, was sweeping glass shards from an entrance door that had been shattered after midnight by a young masked man wielding a skateboard, according to security video that Chavez showed a Reuters reporter. "I agree with what the protesters are defending - they're standing up for the Latino community," Chavez said. "But there are a few carrying out vandalism and violence, and that must be stopped." Chavez and other business owners said they did not support the immigration raids and felt Trump's response was only fanning the flames. - Reuters