
Former DPP denied permission to prosecute Taoiseach and journalist over comments on Ian Bailey case
Robert Sheehan, while working in the Director of Public Prosecution's (DPP) office in 2001, wrote a scathing analysis of the investigation of Bailey for the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier.
A succession of DPPs, along with various senior counsel, repeatedly concluded that Bailey did not have a case to answer for the 1996 murder.
Last Monday, Mr Sheehan applied to Dun Laoghaire District Court for permission to take the prosecution. He alleges Micheál Martin and journalist Senan Molony, who published a book on the case last year, vilified him professionally through comments and passages in the book.
Last September at an event to launch Sophie: The Final Verdict, the Taoiseach asked why Bailey had not been put on trial for the murder. He said he found it 'hard to understand why the system was so convinced by its interpretations of legal principles that it effectively threw its hands in the air and gave up'.
On Monday, Judge Ann Watkin refused to issue the summons against the Taoiseach saying his criticism had been of the 'system', not Mr Sheehan personally.
In relation to Mr Molony, she said she would not issue a summons as the DPP had indicated that the information provided by Mr Sheehan did not disclose a criminal offence that may be put to a jury.
Mr Sheehan claims passages in the book relating to him and comments by Mr Molony in public interviews amounted to harassment in its legal definition. Senan Molony has never initiated any contact with Mr Sheehan nor ever met nor spoke with him in any capacity.
Mr Molony refused to comment when contacted. A spokesperson for Micheál Martin said he had no comment to make.
Mr Sheehan has said he will now consider whether to appeal to the circuit court or take his case to the European Court of Human Rights.
Asked why if he believed he was defamed he had not sued for damages, Mr Sheehan quoted a former chief justice who had pointed out that ordinary people cannot have access to the courts to vindicate their rights because of the cost.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Sunday World
2 days ago
- Sunday World
MMA fighter accused of corruption involving garda bribes is sent for trial
It follows a probe by the anti-corruption unit, and the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) had also directed trial on indictment. MMA fighter Charlie Ward has been returned for trial accused of corruption offences involving "confidential" Garda information and helping to pervert the course of justice. The mixed martial artist, 44, of Acragar, Mountmellick and co-accused Noel Carroll, 57, of Ballyfinn Road, Portlaoise, both Co Laois, appeared at Dublin District Court yesterday when the gardaí served them with books of evidence. It follows a probe by the anti-corruption unit, and the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) had also directed trial on indictment. Charlie Ward News in 90 Seconds - July 26th Judge Gerard Jones granted an order, sending them forward for trial to the Dublin Circuit Criminal Court, which has wider sentencing powers and where the case will be listed for mention on October 16. The defendants, who have yet to enter a plea, did not address the court and were warned by the judge to notify the prosecution within 14 days if they intend to use an alibi. Gardaí must also furnish the defence with copies of interview videos. Legal aid was granted. Earlier, Detective Sergeant Paul Dowling and Kieran Kilcoyne said the two men "made no reply" when charged. The pair face charges contrary to section 5 of the 2018 Criminal Justice (Corruption Offences) Act about requests for information concerning three men. According to the court documents, on March 2, 2022, at an unknown location in the state, both men corruptly requested a gift, consideration or advantage on account of a named garda requesting that confidential information relating to another person be obtained and disclosed. Mr Ward is accused of the same type of offence on February 28, 2022, about Garda information on a second male. Another charge states that on the previous day, Mr Ward corruptly offered the same officer an inducement for doing an act in relation to his employment as a member of An Garda Síochána. Mr Ward is also accused of an offence under section 7 of the Criminal Law Act 1997. That alleges that between October 15 -17, 2019, when another person committed an arrestable offence, namely, perverting the course of justice, that he "did aid, abet, counsel or procure the commission of this offence". It is alleged that on January 26, 2022, at an unknown location, Mr Carroll corruptly requested a gift consideration or advantage on account of the garda seeking confidential information about a search operation at the home of a third named man.


Sunday World
2 days ago
- Sunday World
Man accused of threatening customer with a hammer while working at Aldi
The court heard Aaron Dempsey had been a member of staff when there was a dispute with the alleged victim, A man has been sent for trial accused of brandishing a hammer while working at a supermarket and threatening a customer. Aaron Dempsey (30) is alleged to have produced the hammer during a dispute at an Aldi in north Dublin. He had a book of evidence served on him when he appeared in Dublin District Court. Judge Michèle Finan sent him forward to Dublin Circuit Criminal Court. Mr Dempsey, of Elm Mount Road, Beaumont, is charged with producing an implement capable of causing serious injury in a manner likely to intimidate. The incident is alleged to have happened at Aldi, Santry Avenue, on June 26 last year. A prosecuting solicitor said the DPP was consenting to the accused being returned for trial to the current sittings of the circuit court. He was remanded on continuing bail Judge Finan gave Mr Dempsey the formal notice that he had 14 days to provide any alibi details to the prosecution. She also ordered the State to furnish the defence with the accused's garda interview video. He was remanded on continuing bail to appear in the circuit court later this month. Previously, the court heard Mr Dempsey had been a member of staff when there was a dispute with the alleged victim, during which 'the accused produced a hammer and threatened the customer'. The DPP had consented to the case being heard in the district court, but Judge Finan refused jurisdiction after hearing the outline of the prosecution's case. The charge is under section 11 of the Firearms and Offensive Weapons Act. Aaron Dempsey. Photo: Paddy Cummins News in 90 Seconds - July 26th

The Journal
2 days ago
- The Journal
Being a first-time TD: 'The hours are mad, if I finish at 9.30pm it feels like a half day'
YESTERDAY WE CAUGHT up with Social Democrats TD Sinéad Gibney on her experience of being a first-time TD, today we hear from the Labour Party's Conor Sheehan. At 32 years of age, the Limerick City TD is one of the youngest representatives in the Dáil. He talks us through the highs and lows, adjusting to hotel living and how he sometimes feels like he's talking to a brick wall. Is life as a TD what you expected? 'In ways it is and in other ways it isn't. I'll never forget the first time I stepped into the Dáil chamber. Sometimes I pinch myself when I'm sitting there during one of the week's set pieces like Leaders' Questions or whatever. 'The thing that struck me was actually how small the chamber is and how small the campus is as well. How often you bump into people the whole time.' Pit and peak Sheehan said he has had 'many highlights' so far. Notably, being on the panel for temporary chairs for the Dáil, which means he is sometimes called on to sit in as chair of the Dáil when Ceann Comhairle Verona Murphy is not available. Other highlights have been working on legislation. 'It's really interesting, you know, doing committee stage in the chamber, and listening to the amendments,' he said. 'The delay in getting committees set up and everything like that was quite frustrating,' Sheehan said, adding that from a legislative perspective, the Dáil really only kicked into business in the last six weeks. He said at the beginning of the term, he felt like a huge amount of the Dáil schedule was dedicated to statements on a variety of topics, a move he feels was done to 'pad' the schedule because there wasn't much legislation coming through from the government. Sheehan said he finds it frustrating at times, as an opposition TD, to see government TDs vote down opposition bills or amendments and instead come back with a reply that is 'generic blather'. 'The thing that really annoys me is when you go in and you do a private member's motion, or you do a debate or whatever, and it's almost like sometimes the minister is coming in to read a pre-prepared reply and isn't actually engaging with you on the substance of the issues you are raising. 'Now, some ministers are better at that than others, but some are very frustrating. You just feel like you're talking to a wall.' Low point? 'The low point for me was all the crap that happened at the start of the year, around the recognition of the technical group and as to whether the [Regional Independents] were in government or opposition. It was totally unnecessary. 'The whole thing was unedifying… I thought it was a waste of everyone's time, and I don't understand why government were so insistent — Like they've created this other members' questions thing at the moment, which is almost like eight minutes of tumbleweed blowing through the Dáil chamber,' Sheehan said. Is there still animosity between the opposition and government since then? 'I think there is some bit of animosity, but I do think that things are thankfully no longer as tense as they were in the early part of the year,' Sheehan said, arguing that this is probably down to the fact the Dáil was busier in its last few weeks. 'Sometimes when you're in a vacuum, things can have a bit of an undue significance.' Advertisement At 32 years of age, Sheehan is one of the youngest TDs in the Dáil. How is he finding the career change from that perspective? 'The first thing I'd say is there are far too few young people in politics, right? 'I would be friendly enough with some of the other younger politicians, there would be people across different parties that I would be very fond of. 'People like Mairéad Farrell in Sinn Féin. She's great. Keira Keogh in Fine Gael, really, really, great. Just decent people that you can talk to about issues. 'There's an awful lot of people who think politics is just constant hand-to-hand combat, but it's actually not like that. An awful lot of the time, you disagree with people on certain things, but you'll agree with them on other things. And I always believe in finding common ground.' On the commute from Limerick, Sheehan opts for the train over driving so that he can get some work done, but he said this means he does a lot of 'pulling and dragging'. 'I'm used to it now, but people always slag me when they see me in Leinster House, because I always have a big, huge suitcase. 'I feel like I should have shares in Irish Rail at this stage. I drove a couple of times, coming down late on a Thursday, leaving Leinster House, snaking onto the Naas Road and just being like uh, when will I actually get home?' Sheehan said what he found tough initially was sleeping in hotels. 'I would go to bed in a hotel and 10 o'clock would become like one or 2 am and I would literally be wide awake in bed and not able to sleep. 'I would just feel out of sorts. Too hot or too cold, or it would be too loud, or I could hear footsteps. All very much first-world problems, but I did find that stuff, until I got into a routine, a bit tough. Whereas now I'm totally used to it.' Another aspect of the gig Sheehan said he finds tough is trying to maintain a healthy diet. 'You're constantly eating on the go, and it's not the most healthy lifestyle in the entire world,' Sheehan said, adding that his diet since becoming a TD has consisted of 'a lot of chips'. 'One of the things I do miss when I'm in Dublin is just being able to cook your dinner. 'Because I'm currently in and out of hotels in Dublin, I suppose I don't get that. But I love the job. It's really been such an enormous honour and privilege.' What I wish I knew Sheehan said the biggest thing any first-time TD has to be careful of is making sure they pace themselves, both mentally and physically. 'The thing about Leinster House is that the working hours are mad. I've often arrived in on a Wednesday morning around 8 am to get maybe an hour's work done before a committee meeting or a briefing at nine, and then I am still there that Wednesday evening at 10 or 11 o'clock at night.' Sheehan said it is rare to finish up any earlier than this on a Tuesday or Wednesday when the Dáil is sitting. 'I remember one Wednesday, about six or eight weeks ago, we got out at twenty past nine, and I felt like I'd had a half day.' Any surprises? 'The amount of people in a similar situation as myself trying to figure everything out. And the amount of decency that's in the Oireachtas.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal