Former DPP denied permission to prosecute Taoiseach and journalist over comments on Ian Bailey case
Robert Sheehan, while working in the Director of Public Prosecution's (DPP) office in 2001, wrote a scathing analysis of the investigation of Bailey for the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier.
A succession of DPPs, along with various senior counsel, repeatedly concluded that Bailey did not have a case to answer for the 1996 murder.
Last Monday, Mr Sheehan applied to Dun Laoghaire District Court for permission to take the prosecution. He alleges Micheál Martin and journalist Senan Molony, who published a book on the case last year, vilified him professionally through comments and passages in the book.
Last September at an event to launch Sophie: The Final Verdict, the Taoiseach asked why Bailey had not been put on trial for the murder. He said he found it 'hard to understand why the system was so convinced by its interpretations of legal principles that it effectively threw its hands in the air and gave up'.
On Monday, Judge Ann Watkin refused to issue the summons against the Taoiseach saying his criticism had been of the 'system', not Mr Sheehan personally.
In relation to Mr Molony, she said she would not issue a summons as the DPP had indicated that the information provided by Mr Sheehan did not disclose a criminal offence that may be put to a jury.
Mr Sheehan claims passages in the book relating to him and comments by Mr Molony in public interviews amounted to harassment in its legal definition. Senan Molony has never initiated any contact with Mr Sheehan nor ever met nor spoke with him in any capacity.
Mr Molony refused to comment when contacted. A spokesperson for Micheál Martin said he had no comment to make.
Mr Sheehan has said he will now consider whether to appeal to the circuit court or take his case to the European Court of Human Rights.
Asked why if he believed he was defamed he had not sued for damages, Mr Sheehan quoted a former chief justice who had pointed out that ordinary people cannot have access to the courts to vindicate their rights because of the cost.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
2 hours ago
- Sunday World
Woman charged with impeding apprehension of driver allegedly involved in Stephen's Day hit-and-run
Nicole Fallon (35) is the second person to be charged following the deaths of husband and wife Anthony Hogg and Georgina Hogg Moore. A Dublin woman has been charged with impeding the apprehension or prosecution of a driver who was allegedly involved in a fatal hit-and-run that claimed the lives of a couple of St Stephen's Day. Nicole Fallon (35) is the second person to be charged following the deaths of husband and wife Anthony Hogg and Georgina Hogg Moore in Blanchardstown last Christmas. Mr Hogg, 40, and his wife Georgina, 39, were struck while crossing a road near Blanchardstown Shopping Centre at around 5.45pm on December 26, 2024. The couple, married with children, lived in the nearby Whitestown area. John Halpin (45) is currently before the courts charged with dangerous driving causing the deaths of the couple, as well as failing to offer assistance at the scene. John Halpin is charged with dangerous driving News in 90 Seconds - Tuesday, July 29 Both Mr Halpin and Ms Fallon were further charged when they appeared before Blanchardstown District Court on Tuesday. The court heard they are facing trial in the circuit court after the DPP ruled the allegations were too serious for the district court. Judge David McHugh adjourned the cases to September for the service of the book of evidence. Ms Fallon, with an address at Whitestown Avenue in Blanchardstown, is charged with unlicensed and uninsured driving at Whitestown Avenue in Blanchardstown on December 26, 2024. Detective Garda Niamh Crowe gave evidence of further charging Ms Fallon with two new charges. It is alleged that Ms Fallon, knowing or believing that another individual committed an offence, namely dangerous driving causing death, did "without reasonable excuse an act with intent to impede the apprehension or prosecution of the said person". The second new charge alleges Ms Fallon did an act with intent to impede the apprehension or prosecution of a person while "knowing or believing that person had breached their duties in relation to the occurrence of an accident with intent to escape civil or criminal liability". Garda Shane Wood gave evidence to Blanchardstown court of further charging Mr Halpin with four new charges. Mr Halpin is accused of failing to stop a vehicle, which was allegedly involved in causing injury to Mr Hogg and Ms Hogg Moore. He is also charged with failing to offer assistance to the couple with the intent to escape civil or criminal liability. Gda Crowe and Gda Wood said gardai had no objection to bail being extended to the new sheets. Gardai said the DPP had directed trial on indictment in the circuit court on the charges. Defence solicitors Tertius Van Eeden and Aoife McNicholl said there was consent to an adjournment to a date in September. The accused have not yet indicated how they intend pleading to the charges.
Sunday World
6 hours ago
- Sunday World
Farmer accused of harassing young couple for months tears up charge sheets in court
'Mr Greene said 'these are not charges of law. This is a spiritual law matter' and he proceeded to tear up the charge sheets.' A Clare farmer has been charged with harassing a neighbouring young couple seeking to move into their new home near the village of Inagh. At Ennis District Court today, Jim Greene (55) of Ballyhea North, Inagh has been charged with the harassment of couple, Robert Foley and Ciara O'Flynn on dates between February 17th to May 5th this year at Ballyea North, Inagh contrary to Section 10 of the Non Fatal Offences against the Person Act 1997. Mr Greene is also facing an arson charge that on a date unknown between April 2nd and April 15th 2025 at Ballyea North, Inagh did commit criminal damage by fire a number of items and all household contents to the value of €16,743 at Ballyea North, Inagh. Jim Greene at Ennis Court News in 90 Seconds - Tuesday, July 29 Giving evidence of arrest, charge and caution, Garda Bríon Dolan told the court that when charged and cautioned before court on Tuesday, Mr Green tore up the three charge sheets in front of him. Garda Dolan told the court in reply to caution 'Mr Greene said 'these are not charges of law. This is a spiritual law matter' and he proceeded to tear up the charge sheets.' Sgt John Burke said that the DPP has instructed that the case go forward to the circuit court on indictment and a Book of Evidence is required. In a separate harassment case of a former neighbour against Mr Greene before the court today a Book of Evidence was served in the case. In that case, Mr Greene is charged with harassing John O'Brien at Ballyea North, Inagh on dates between January 27th 2024 and February 18th this year contrary to Section 10 of the Non Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. Solicitor for Mr Greene, Tara Godfrey asked Judge Alec Gabbett that the legal aid certificate be extended for an updated psychiatric assessment but Mr Greene from the custody suite in the court asked Ms Godfrey to stop addressing the court on his behalf as 'it is a spiritual law matter and that is it'. Mr Greene has been on remand in custody at Limerick prison since May 7th. At a court hearing in May where Judge Gabbett refused bail, the judge said that the couple, Robert Foley and Ciara O'Flynn in question have been 'driven so demented' by the actions of Jim Greene that they have been forced to take out a circuit court injunction against him. Mr Greene is already accused of the burglary at the home of the two at Ballyhea North, Inagh on dates between April 2nd and April 15th last. Garda Dolan told the court at the contested bail hearing that for the month of March, Mr Greene had his car parked on the roadway and a very narrow lane leading to the couple's home which blocked access to their home which they have a mortgage on. Garda Dolan said that Mr Greene blocking access has meant that the couple have been unable to move into a property they purchased late last year. During the contested bail hearing, Garda Dolan said that it will be further alleged that subsequently Mr Greene emailed the new home owner's solicitors to say that he was 'God's Enforcer' acting under spiritual policeman's law which he feels entitles him to enter the property and buildings to investigate witchcraft and Voodoo'. Solicitor for Mr Greene, Tara Godfrey previously said that Mr Greene has no history of criminal behaviour. Ms Godfrey said that Mr Greene is a farmer with a small land-holding and has animals to look after.
Sunday World
7 hours ago
- Sunday World
Suspended sentence for drug dealer caught with €114k of cocaine not too lenient, court finds
Mohamed Adeagbo (24) of Highfield, Ballincollig, County Cork, pleaded guilty to having cocaine for sale or supply at a time when its street value exceeded €13,000 The Court of Appeal has ruled that a fully suspended sentence was not unduly lenient for a man who was being paid €500 per week for his role in the supply of drugs when he was caught with €114,000 worth of cocaine. Mohamed Adeagbo (24) of Highfield, Ballincollig, County Cork, pleaded guilty to having cocaine for sale or supply at a time when its street value exceeded €13,000, at his home address on April 25, 2022. He also pleaded guilty to a money-laundering charge that on April 22, 2022, at the address at Highfield Park, he possessed the proceeds of criminal conduct, namely €1,530 in cash, while knowing that it was the proceeds of criminal conduct. He was sentenced to three and a half years for the drug offence, fully suspended, with a concurrent one-year sentence on the second charge, also fully suspended by Judge Helen Boyle at Cork Circuit Criminal Court last November. Lawyers for the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) launched an appeal earlier this month, arguing that Adeagbo's sentence was unduly lenient. The DPP said there were no wholly exceptional circumstances that could warrant fully suspending the three-and-a-half-year sentence. Imelda Kelly BL, for the DPP, said that Adeagbo had been detected with 1.6 kilos of cocaine with a value of €114,000, as well as a quantity of cannabis and cash totalling €1,530. She pointed out that the gardaí said the 24-year-old had been actively involved in the supply of drugs, for which he was receiving €500 per week, and an iPhone had been seized from his home containing offending messages, the barrister said. Ms. Kelly argued the sentencing judge had erred by placing excessive weight on the mitigating factors and failing to give sufficient consideration to the principles of deterrence. Adeagbo's barrister Alice Fawsitt SC said that her client had been a 21-year-old with no life experience, who came from a family of limited means and displayed no trappings of wealth. In dismissing the appeal at the Court of Appeal today, Mr Justice Brian O'Moore said Adeagbo had satisfied the judge that he was drug free at the time of sentencing, had complied entirely with everything that was asked of him by the Probation Service and had done his 'level best' to get himself back on track. 'The sentencing judge was quite entitled, in those truly exceptional circumstances, to fully suspend the sentence imposed on Mr Adeagbo,' Mr Justice O'Moore said. The judge said the headline sentence of five years was not in dispute and the reduction of that sentence by 18 months, given the signed plea of guilty, was 'in no way inappropriate'. 'The suspending of the balance of the sentence did not form a substantial or gross departure from what was an appropriate sentence in the circumstances,' he said. Cocaine. Stock image News in 90 Seconds - Tuesday, July 29
