Family of Katie Allan back bid to remove Crown immunity
It concluded that a breach of the Health & Safety Act "materially contributed" to their deaths, but the prison system is protected from legal action by Crown immunity meaning Polmont or any other prison couldn't be found criminally responsible.
The Scottish Government has said it would scrap that immunity, which has previously been removed from the NHS and the police, but would need permission from Westminster to do so.
On Wednesday Labour MP Blair McDougall will present a bill calling for Crown immunity to be removed from prison estates.
The bill is being backed by Ms Allan's parents, with Mr McDougall their local MP.
Linda Allan told the BBC: "We've always said justice for us would be the removal of Crown immunity. There's no meaning in losing a child but it would be a legacy for us.
"It means that in death Katie has done something good. That her death hasn't been meaningless.
"It means that perhaps her death might save the lives of other people in the future.
"If you look for example at the police service, when it lost Crown immunity, safety standards started to increase in terms of cell custody and police stations.
"So you would hope the same would happen across the prison estate."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Rhyl Journal
22 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
Trump brands Khan a ‘nasty person' as Starmer jumps to Mayor's defence
The US President said he was 'not a fan' of London's Labour Mayor, when asked if he will visit the UK's capital city. Speaking to reporters at his Turnberry golf resort in South Ayrshire, Mr Trump said: 'I'm not a fan of your mayor. 'I think he's done a terrible job, the Mayor of London … a nasty person.' The Prime Minister intervened to say: 'He's a friend of mine, actually.' Mr Trump went on to add: 'I think he's done a terrible job. But I would certainly visit London.' In response to comments made by Mr Trump during a press conference on Monday, a spokesperson for the Mayor said: 'Sadiq is delighted that President Trump wants to come to the greatest city in the world. 'He'd see how our diversity makes us stronger not weaker; richer, not poorer. 'Perhaps these are the reasons why a record number of Americans have applied for British citizenship under his presidency.' This is not the first time the president has hit out at Sir Sadiq after he previously branded him a 'stone cold loser' and challenged him to an IQ test. Sir Sadiq has also previously described Mr Trump as 'a poster boy for racists'.
Scotsman
36 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Why Remainer Keir Starmer has every reason to thank Donald Trump and Brexit
Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Life is full of rich ironies but few thought last year Sir Keir Starmer would have every reason to thank President Trump 2.0 and Brexit. As the Prime Minister considers the political waves he is now floundering in, he needs every straw he can reach out and grasp if his prospects are to improve so Labour is not sunk at the next election. A new splinter party formed by Jeremy Corbyn, the former Labour leader – twice proudly championed by Starmer in the 2017 and 2019 elections – now threatens him from the left. Economic prospects are looking bleak, with faltering growth causing thoughts of recession to resurface. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Inflation remains stubbornly around three per cent, public borrowing is increasing and tax revenues are below expectations while the most generous taxpayers continue to leave the country for more affordable climes. Both junior and resident doctors are about to strike in England and Wales, unemployment is rising and new hires are falling. Ed Miliband's rush to net zero is seeing refineries close in Grangemouth and Lincolnshire with countless other industries being priced out of existence. Keir Starmer and his wife Victoria Starmer with US President Donald Trump at Trump Turnberry (Picture: Brendan Smialowski/pool) | POOL/AFP via Getty Images A turbulent world Meanwhile, Starmer's pledge to end the influx of people being trafficked across the Channel is on trend to see the highest number of illegal landings since the Normans in 1066. As tensions in some towns and cities rise, a fear of summer riots is now taking hold of authorities, causing at least one special police unit to be established to monitor signs of unrest in social media. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad That's just the Home Front. The need to try and resolve the wars in the Middle East and Ukraine continues to dominate international affairs, masking the continued threat of China's expansionist strategies. For all Starmer was a devout advocate of remaining in the European Union back in 2016, then supported having a second referendum (while being against another in Scotland), and is now trying his best to reset relations with the EU that has seen him give away fishing rights worth £12 billion until 2038, it is to the altar of Brexit that he must kneel down and pray in thanks. It was only through Brexit that he has been able to deliver VAT on independent schools, bring forward the nationalisation of the British railway network, continue to ban entry to Britain by EU criminals who have served a year or more in jail, give preference to British companies for public sector contracts – and many other controversial policies Labour has embraced sovereign control to deliver. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Cultish adherence to increasing energy costs Even in trade, the tired regurgitation of the discredited Office for Budget Responsibility summary of counterfactual estimates (by definition unprovable) suggesting a 4 per cent loss in UK GDP by the end of the decade were shown last week to be doom-mongering. The latest Office for National Statistics figures revealed, while UK goods exports had dipped compared to pre-Covid expectations, there was no significant difference between EU and non-EU export trends – meaning the root cause of our problems are the uncompetitive cost of making anything here and poor productivity levels. The stats suggest our real problem is the cultish adherence to driving up energy costs – industrial and domestic – so we no longer make as many cars, produce less metal, extract less oil and gas (down from 53 million tonnes in 2019 to 34 million in 2023), and so on. We cannot export things we no longer make. Anything to do with energy costs, from commuting to construction, is likely to be in decline. Fortunately Brexit has allowed the UK to have better trade deals with Japan, Australia, Singapore, Peru, Vietnam and just last week Starmer signed off a trade deal with India – a prize that the EU has failed to achieve in over 15 years of negotiating. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Now Starmer is able to crow about the great US-UK deal he has struck with The Donald, all because of the Brexit he so religiously castigated. Whatever one thinks of Donald Trump's policy of using muscular tariffs to bring about a change of attitudes among the many free-riding European nations who live off the US taxpayers' defence dollars, the fact is indisputable – the UK has fared better than the EU. Were we in the EU we would have met its fate – not one obtained by Starmer's government. EU's non-tariff barriers For instance, Ireland's baseline tariff to export into the US is the EU's tariff of 15 per cent and will be 50 per cent higher than the UK's 10 per cent. It is the same for every other EU member. The EU has accepted its trade with the US results in too large a surplus and requires rebalancing. Strangely it does not admit to this being a problem with the UK, where again it runs a large surplus in goods. We are not imposing tariffs on the EU yet all sorts of impediments to trade are erected by the EU through non-tariff barriers and Brexit punishments, such as the obstinacy to agree to cultural access visas. Note how no such regulations are imposed upon the US – so why does the EU insist on applying them on us? Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The EU had previously threatened a trade war with Trump. But following the reaction to the EU-US deal in European capitals – 'scandalous… a disaster… with not one concession from the American side…' said leading European politician Guy Verhofstadt – the truth about its exaggerated influence is apparent. Our US deal could still improve yet, with President Trump promising to look at the issue of Scotch whisky. When our single malts were collateral damage in the EU's trade war with Boeing (over EU subsidised loans to Airbus), it cost our distilleries £500m in lost sales. If being outside the EU allows us to make a successful case for avoiding whisky tariffs, Remainer politicians like Starmer and John Swinney will no doubt claim a victory – but it will be Trump and Brexit we have to thank.
The Sun
36 minutes ago
- The Sun
Labour admits Brexit helped UK get better trade deal with Trump as EU leaders say he ‘ate von der Leyen for breakfast'
LABOUR has conceded that Brexit Britain helped secure a better trade deal with America than Brussels. Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds insisted there was 'absolutely no doubt' the UK was better off being separated from the European Union. 1 The comments come as EU products heading Stateside will be subject to a 15 per cent levy while UK goods will only face a 10 per cent surcharge. He told Sky News: 'All of the trade negotiations that we've got use the fact that we are not part of the customs union anymore, I'm absolutely clear of that. I think we can make the best of that.' When asked if he would label it as a benefit to exiting the EU, he said: 'I'm absolutely clear, I've said in Parliament many times, this is a benefit of being out of the European Union, having our independent trade policy, absolutely no doubt about that.' Foreign Secretary David Lammy said back in April that Brexit had nothing to do with securing a better deal for escaping the worst of Donald Trump's tariffs. Mr Reynolds also said there is "more to do" on UK steel when it comes to the UK-US trade deal. The UK secured zero tariffs on steel but the US hasn't enacted it yet as they have concerns over how it would actually work. He said "it's really important to have the president here" and the visit offers "a chance to do a bit of business". He added: "We were very happy to announce the breakthrough that we had a few months ago in relation to sectors like automotive, aerospace, which are really important to the UK economy. "But we always said it was job saved, but it wasn't job done. There's more to do. "The negotiations have been going on on a daily basis since then. There's a few issues to push a little bit further today. "We won't perhaps have anything to announce a resolution of those talks, but there's some sectors that we still need to resolve, particularly around steel and aluminium, and there's the wider conversation about what the US calls its reciprocal tariffs." Donald Trump and Sir Keir Starmer have agreed to work together on the deal following their meeting in Scotland, Number 10 said. Meanwhile, EU chief Ursula von der Leyen has been blasted over her negotiations for the deal which is worse than the UK pact. Viktor Orban, the Hungarian leader, said: ' Donald Trump ate von der Leyen for breakfast.' France Prime Minister Francois Bayrou said it was a 'dark day' for the submission to the US.
