Maine judge won't wait for supreme court to start releasing people from jail
May 13—A Maine judge says she will not wait for the state supreme court to rule on an appeal before she moves forward with releasing people from jail and dropping charges against those who have unconstitutionally gone too long without a lawyer.
In doing so, Superior Court Justice Michaela Murphy said the state would have one more week to find jailed defendants a lawyer before they get released.
Murphy wrote in her order this month that she plans to resume the process soon, but no date was scheduled with the Kennebec County Superior Court, where the case is being heard, as of Tuesday morning.
Murphy ruled in January that the state's public defense agency is violating the Sixth Amendment by not providing Mainers with criminal charges with continuous legal representation.
She announced in March that she intended to start holding a series of hearings in April to identify and release anyone who has waited more than two weeks without a lawyer. She also planned to dismiss charges against defendants who had waited more than 60 days for a lawyer. Once released, they would still be on strict bail conditions. Any charges dropped could be filed again once a lawyer is available, Murphy said.
Advocates for domestic violence survivors and other crime victims have shared their concerns with this latest development, saying it puts many at risk. A lawyer for the state urged Murphy to wait for the Maine Supreme Judicial Court's opinion on more procedural grounds, arguing that Murphy was using the wrong legal procedure for this kind of a case.
Murphy's hearings will follow the "writ of habeas corpus" process. Habeas cases are typically filed on behalf of individual defendants who say they're being jailed illegally — in this case, the law's application would be unprecedented because it will potentially provide habeas relief to a large, yet-to-be-determined number of people, all at once.
"Where a writ has been granted, the purpose of habeas corpus — to swiftly secure the liberty of a person wrongfully detained — would be defeated if the delays resulting from an appeal could pause the discharge of a wrongfully detained person," Murphy wrote in her most recent order.
The ruling results from a lawsuit the American Civil Liberties Union of Maine first filed against the state's indigent defense system in 2022, which has been amended several times to account for a growing crisis of people who are entitled to a lawyer but don't have them. An emergency law recently took effect, allowing the state to hire more public defenders and judges to appoint more private attorneys to cases that need them.
"This order shows the court recognizes the urgency of this crisis because no person should be incarcerated or dragged through months of criminal legal proceedings without an attorney," said ACLU of Maine Legal Director Carol Garvan in a statement. "The court's decision underscores the importance of habeas corpus protections, which entitle people to a speedy process to challenge unlawful restraints on their liberty. Any time the state chooses to restrict a person's freedom, it is the state's responsibility to ensure a fair and speedy process. That constitutional requirement cannot be indefinitely put on hold because the state has filed an appeal."
A spokesperson for the Office of the Maine Attorney General, which is representing the state and the Maine Commission on Public Defense Services, said they don't comment on pending litigation.
This story will be updated.
Copy the Story Link
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
21 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Pro-Palestinian activist detained in West Bank
The son of a Pro-Palestinian activist has said he "remains in the dark" after she was detained in the occupied West Bank. Deirdre Murphy, who lives in Swansea, has been held in custody since 31 May when she was arrested in a southern part of the territory. The 70-year-old, originally from Cork, Ireland, had been volunteering with the pro-Palestinian activist group International Solidary Movement (ISM) at the time of her arrest. The Israeli government has been approached for comment. Torsten Bell, Labour MP for Swansea West, said he would do everything he can "to support a swift and just resolution" after raising concerns about Ms Murphy's access to legal representation. The West Bank - the land between the eastern edge of Israel and the western side of the River Jordan - is home to an estimated three million Palestinians. Israel has occupied the West Bank - which Palestinians want as part of any future state - since the Six Day War of 1967, and is continuing to build settlements in the area. Israel and the Palestinians: History of the conflict explained Why are Israel and Hamas fighting in Gaza? What we know about killings near US-Israeli backed Gaza aid site These are regarded as illegal under international law although Israel rejects this position. While Israel has military control of the West Bank, the Oslo Accords of 1995 gave the Palestinian Authority some administrative and security control over certain areas. Ms Murphy's son Dale Ryan told Radio Wales Breakfast his mother was "doing OK" but he remained "in the dark" about when he would see her again. She was arrested last Saturday before being taken to Ben Gurion Airport in Tel Aviv, according to her son. He said she was then moved to Givon Prison in Ramla where she has been held since 3 June. "She was detained after being accused of being in a military zone," said Mr Ryan. "Her and another woman, Susanne Björk, who are there with the ISM, were being questioned by the army." According to Irish broadcaster RTÉ, the pair were complying with the order before Israeli settlers, wearing military uniforms, called the police. Mr Ryan, who lives on the Gower peninsula, said his mother was brought to a hearing on Wednesday "without any representation." "There is a lawyer acting on her behalf. Because it's not a trial, they would have been there more as a witness, but she was denied access to her lawyer." said Mr Ryan. Mr Ryan said he had not "personally" spoken to his mothers since the arrest - instead receiving updates from her lawyer and ISM. "My mother is quite a resilient person," he said. "But as the days go on, she is becoming fatigued, and probably a bit anxious about the whole situation." Mr Ryan said his mother has some chest problems, which is "concerning for us", and he is desperate to "know she is in good health." According to an ISM press release, Ms Murphy has been involved as an activist in the region for over two decades and has been based in Swansea since the 1980s. "She went to Palestine in 2004 after setting up a fundraiser where we walked around the Gower in four days," according to Mr Ryan. He said she wanted to "contribute" to the aid and facilities that were being developed at the time. "In the last few years she has spent a lot of time in Masafer Yatta," he added, which according to the press release, is where she got arrested. Ms Murphy's lawyer, Noa Dagoni told the BBC that the handling of the case has been "deeply troubling". "Since her detention at Givon prison, Ms. Murphy has been unable to contact me, despite multiple requests on my part and efforts from her side – the reasons for that remain unclear," she said. She said Ms Murphy had requested legal counsel for "the detention review tribunal hearing as well as representation during the hearing itself". But Ms Dagoni said that apparently "no actual access" had been granted which would "constitute a serious and unlawful violation" of Ms Murphy's rights. Ms Murphy's local MP Bell said "hundreds of constituents" had contacted him with their concerns. "I've been in touch with Deirdre's family and am liaising with both the Irish government, who are providing consular support, and the UK Foreign Office, who have offered their assistance and stand ready to help further." He said he was "particularly concerned" that Ms Murphy may not have legal representation. "We all want to see Deirdre released as soon as possible," he added. The Irish Embassy Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade said it was "aware of the case and is providing consular assistance." It added that "the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade does not comment on the details of individual cases." The Foreign Office said: "We have not been approached for consular assistance, but our staff stand ready to support British Nationals overseas 24/7." Additional reporting by Shazia Ali Gaza now worse than hell on earth, humanitarian chief tells BBC Israeli military recovers two hostages' bodies in southern Gaza Trauma is every day here, says UK nurse in Gaza
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Proposed tax increases spark clash in Maine Legislature
Jun. 5—AUGUSTA — Lawmakers and advocates clashed over proposed tax increases Thursday as the debate over the state budget heats up in the closing days of the session. Progressive activists and some Democrats gathered at the State House and urged lawmakers to increases taxes on the wealthiest Mainers to help close a budget gap. But Republicans reiterated at a separate press conference that they will oppose any budget that includes tax increases. And Gov. Janet Mills, who has proposed a series of targeted tax increases and program cuts in her budget, has said she would not support any broad-based tax increases. Lawmakers are facing a budget squeeze as they try to pay for programs and commitments created in previous budgets, as state revenues flatten. Senate Minority Leader Trey Stewart, R-Presque Isle, said Democrats are responsible for the budget deficit because they have repeatedly passed majority budgets without Republican support. "They own this," Stewart said. "They set up three majority budgets in a row. They have run out of your money, and now they want to raise taxes on Maine people. We're not going to vote for it. But if they want to jump over that cliff, that's on them." Historically, lawmakers have sought to pass two-year state budgets with a bipartisan supermajority, so the funding can become available at the start of the fiscal year on July 1. Budgets passed by a simple majority, which the Democrats have done in recent years, don't become effective until 90 days after adjournment. Most of the budget negotiations have been taking place behind the scenes among Democrats, who are balancing Mills' proposed budget with their own priorities. More than 100 bills passed by the Democratic majority await funding. Earlier this session, Democrats used their majorities to pass an $11.3 billion continuing services budget over Republican objections. It includes funding to cover 55% of public education costs and provides $122 million to help stabilize MaineCare. But that budget doesn't include at least $122 million in additional funding needed to support MaineCare — Maine's Medicaid program — in the second year of the budget. The continuing services budget does not include $285 million in additional spending originally proposed by Mills, who also has proposed $156 million in tax increases, including increasing taxes on cigarettes, online streaming service and other areas. Mills has also proposed cutbacks, which include eliminating state funded food assistance for noncitizens, cutting two crisis receiving centers planned for Aroostook and Kennebec counties and stopping planned increases in child care worker stipends and cost-of-living increases for direct care workers. Mills also proposed reforms to the state's General Assistance program aimed at reducing costs. The governors said the changes would return the program to its original mission as a last resort safety net, rather than an ongoing housing assistance program. Advocates argued that increasing taxes on wealthy residents and corporations could raise millions of dollars to avoid the cuts proposed by Mills and support other vital programs. Maura Pillsbury, tax policy analyst for the Maine Center for Economic Policy, urged lawmakers to pass LD 1089, which would increase taxes on incomes over $1 million to fund public kindergarten through 12th grade education, and LD 1879, which would increase the tax rate on large corporations to support agricultural businesses. "These are reasonable, responsible steps to balance our budget and protect critical services, like child care, health care and food assistance, and not balancing the budget on the backs of vulnerable Mainers through harmful cuts," Pillsbury said. Amended versions of each of those bills have been advanced by the Taxation Committee and face floor votes in the coming days. It's unclear what changes the committee recommended, since the amendments are not yet posted. Advocates also support bills to overhaul of the state tax code to shift the burden more to higher income earners, which passed last year but vetoed by Mills, and increasing taxes on real estate sales over $1 million. Rep. Cheryl Golek, D-Harpswell, said her proposal for a millionaire's tax is modest compared to a proposal approved by voters in 2016 to add a surcharge to incomes over $200,000 and would correct "massive injustice in the tax system." "Today, I am asking that our richest share a slice of bread to those who turned the dough and made the loaf for them to eat," Golek said. Our economy shouldn't be balanced on the backs of the working class. Hard-working Mainers are struggling to pay their bills, yet we continually ask more of the most vulnerable among us by cutting vital programs and services instead of making our tax code more fair." Copy the Story Link
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
New Jersey Democrats propose $430M plan to defray electricity price increases
Gov. Phil Murphy announces a plan to give ratepayers $100 minimum to defray a sudden, sharp increase in electricity prices in Newark on June 5, 2025. (Courtesy of the governor's office) New Jersey will send ratepayers at least $100 to defray the impact of a steep rise in electricity prices that took effect this month, top Democrats announced Thursday. The $430 million program, which is not yet approved by state energy regulators, would provide each of the state's 3.9 million ratepayers with $100, with an additional $150 for low- and moderate-income residents. 'We're taking this step today because the fact is the people of New Jersey are being battered by the rising cost of energy, and by the way, this is not unique to New Jersey,' Gov. Phil Murphy said at a press conference in Newark. 'You can look all around the country right now, and certainly all around this region to see that we are not alone. Wholesale electricity prices are up multiples of what they were even a year ago today.' Christine Guhl Sadovy, president of the state Board of Public Utilities, suggested residents enrolled in the state's winter termination program would be eligible for the $150 payment. That program bars utility shutoffs between Nov. 15 and March 15. Officials were deliberating a second $100 payment but had not reached a decision as of Thursday afternoon, Murphy said. It was not immediately clear when or how the benefits would be paid. Murphy suggested they could come in September or October but cautioned that the timeline is hazy as the aid still needs approval from the Board of Public Utilities, whose next meeting is set for June 18. Lawmakers' announcement comes just days after electricity prices rose by roughly 20% at the start of June, pushed upward by the results of price-setting auctions held in July and February, and as hot weather pushed temperatures to roughly 90 degrees in much of the state Thursday. It also comes as all 80 seats in the state Assembly — which Democrats control by a 52-28 majority — are on the ballot in the fall (the primaries are on Tuesday). Funding for the payments would come from the state's Clean Energy Fund, the state's share of Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative money, and the Solar Alternative Compliance Payment, which is paid by electricity suppliers that are unable to meet the state's renewables standard. Some progressive groups took exception to the funding sources. 'We appreciate that the governor and lawmakers are taking seriously the strain high energy costs place on families, but how we deliver relief matters. Diverting funds from RGGI and the Clean Energy Fund risks weakening the very programs that lower long-term costs, strengthen our grid, and create local jobs,' said Alex Ambrose, a policy analyst for New Jersey Policy Perspective. Richard Henning, president of the New Jersey Utilities Association, a trade group that includes the state's four electric distribution companies, said the organization supported the proposal. The price of electricity rose sharply after being roughly level for more than a decade as supply tightened and demand shot upward, driven higher by power-hungry artificial intelligence data centers proposed throughout the footprint of PJM Interconnection, the grid operator for New Jersey, 12 other states, and the District of Columbia. Democrats have blamed PJM for the price spike, charging yearslong delays in its interconnection queue had depressed supply by leaving projects, including 79 in New Jersey, without a line into the grid. 'We in the Legislature have a tone of outrage that New Jersey is being held hostage,' Sen. John Burzichelli (D-Gloucester) said. Murphy said he and legislative leaders would meet with PJM CEO Manu Asthana next week. Republicans have blamed the Murphy administration's renewables-heavy energy plan and the sunsetting of some existing fossil fuel plants for the increases. They and some Democrats have said the state should pursue a more diverse energy mix to stall further price hikes. 'It simply delays the pain to avoid political fallout in an election year,' Sen. Tony Bucco (R-Morris), his chamber's minority leader, said of the plan announced Thursday. 'This is not relief, it's a cover-up. Trenton Democrats are once again trying to deflect the consequences of their own failed energy policies.' Legislators and regulators are considering other methods of reining in energy prices. The Board of Public Utilities is fielding proposals that could delay electricity price increases, leaving ratepayers with deferred balances they would be responsible for paying later. Guhl-Sadovy declined to comment on the status of that proposal or the effect Thursday's announcement would have on it. In recent weeks, legislators have advanced bills that would change how state regulators set utilities' profit margins, require they study data centers' impact on energy rates, and create a new rate-setting process for data centers, among others. 'Like so many states across the country, we recognized early on that the rates would not be sustainable, more importantly, that they just certainly weren't fair. That's why we went to work,' said Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin (D-Middlesex).
