logo
New plans for controversial Appleby statue submitted

New plans for controversial Appleby statue submitted

Yahooa day ago

REVISED plans for a controversial artwork in Appleby have been submitted to Westmorland & Furness Council.
The application to install the Gypsy Stallion sculpture is now proposing to site it on land off Roman Road after the original application was rejected in April.
According to the decision notice issued by the council the proposed 2.1-metre-tall sculpture, originally planned on the River Eden, would have 'eroded the neutral and harmonious relationship between the built and natural environment in this part of the town'.
The council said the siting of the Gypsy stallion sculpture would visually compete with surrounding listed buildings including the Grade I listed Church of St Lawrence and the Grade II listed St Lawrence's Bridge.
After the plans were refused the decision notice from the council stated: 'While the cultural intention of the proposal is fully acknowledged and respected, no compelling justification has been provided for locating the sculpture in this specific, highly sensitive position.
'It is considered that the commemorative aim could reasonably be delivered in an alternative location without resulting in such harm, and the public benefit is not sufficient to outweigh the identified heritage impact.
'Furthermore, the proposal would undermine the inclusive and neutral amenity value of a well-used public space, with a significant number of local representations raising concerns about the impact of the sculpture's symbolic presence on community cohesion, emotional comfort and the shared use of the site.'
According to the artist's statement submitted with the application, outside the fair week, 'very little tangible evidence' exists of the 'central importance' of the fair to the town and its Gypsy and Traveller visitors.
It adds the Gypsy and Traveller community would like to donate a public sculpture to the town of Appleby to make this 'crucial' part of the town's heritage more visible.
The statement reads: 'It celebrates our history, culture and horses, and is intended as a thank you to the town for hosting an event that is like a spiritual pilgrimage for us.'
Ward councillor Andy Connell (Appleby and Brough, Lib Dems) has commented on the proposal and said: 'This is a much better option than the previously proposed site on the riverbank, and has the support of at least some local previous objectors.
'It will be a striking and handsome feature at the main entrance into the town. Allusion to the annual Appleby Horse Fair won't be to everyone's taste; but it happens and the town is renowned for it.'
However, a spokesman from the Appleby Fair Communities Group, said: 'Many of the issues raised, and reasons for refusal, in the original application remain unresolved and still relevant, particularly the distress that this statue will cause to many local residents.
'For a significant portion of the community, the Appleby Fair is not a celebration but a source of disruption, anxiety, and hardship. Installing a permanent statue commemorating the event is highly likely to deepen these feelings and worsen community division.
'The group behind this statue have shown themselves to be tone deaf and either have not listened to the original feedback or simply don't care.
'It appears they have ignored what many residents said and simply re-submitted their application for a different location, which I find quite bullish.
'The statue itself is little more than a Trojan horse — a supposed gift designed to impose an identity on the town that many do not recognise as their own, stamping ownership where none has been earned. It is certainly noteworthy that funding and effort can be readily found for a statue, with strong advocacy to ensure its installation, yet there seems to be no similar energy spent on funding the event itself.
'Instead, the expectation remains that local taxpayers will shoulder the burden. This is particularly jarring at a time when many residents are struggling to afford basic necessities, such as heating, while council tax continues to rise. The contrast is striking and unjust.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

New plans for controversial Appleby statue submitted
New plans for controversial Appleby statue submitted

Yahoo

timea day ago

  • Yahoo

New plans for controversial Appleby statue submitted

REVISED plans for a controversial artwork in Appleby have been submitted to Westmorland & Furness Council. The application to install the Gypsy Stallion sculpture is now proposing to site it on land off Roman Road after the original application was rejected in April. According to the decision notice issued by the council the proposed 2.1-metre-tall sculpture, originally planned on the River Eden, would have 'eroded the neutral and harmonious relationship between the built and natural environment in this part of the town'. The council said the siting of the Gypsy stallion sculpture would visually compete with surrounding listed buildings including the Grade I listed Church of St Lawrence and the Grade II listed St Lawrence's Bridge. After the plans were refused the decision notice from the council stated: 'While the cultural intention of the proposal is fully acknowledged and respected, no compelling justification has been provided for locating the sculpture in this specific, highly sensitive position. 'It is considered that the commemorative aim could reasonably be delivered in an alternative location without resulting in such harm, and the public benefit is not sufficient to outweigh the identified heritage impact. 'Furthermore, the proposal would undermine the inclusive and neutral amenity value of a well-used public space, with a significant number of local representations raising concerns about the impact of the sculpture's symbolic presence on community cohesion, emotional comfort and the shared use of the site.' According to the artist's statement submitted with the application, outside the fair week, 'very little tangible evidence' exists of the 'central importance' of the fair to the town and its Gypsy and Traveller visitors. It adds the Gypsy and Traveller community would like to donate a public sculpture to the town of Appleby to make this 'crucial' part of the town's heritage more visible. The statement reads: 'It celebrates our history, culture and horses, and is intended as a thank you to the town for hosting an event that is like a spiritual pilgrimage for us.' Ward councillor Andy Connell (Appleby and Brough, Lib Dems) has commented on the proposal and said: 'This is a much better option than the previously proposed site on the riverbank, and has the support of at least some local previous objectors. 'It will be a striking and handsome feature at the main entrance into the town. Allusion to the annual Appleby Horse Fair won't be to everyone's taste; but it happens and the town is renowned for it.' However, a spokesman from the Appleby Fair Communities Group, said: 'Many of the issues raised, and reasons for refusal, in the original application remain unresolved and still relevant, particularly the distress that this statue will cause to many local residents. 'For a significant portion of the community, the Appleby Fair is not a celebration but a source of disruption, anxiety, and hardship. Installing a permanent statue commemorating the event is highly likely to deepen these feelings and worsen community division. 'The group behind this statue have shown themselves to be tone deaf and either have not listened to the original feedback or simply don't care. 'It appears they have ignored what many residents said and simply re-submitted their application for a different location, which I find quite bullish. 'The statue itself is little more than a Trojan horse — a supposed gift designed to impose an identity on the town that many do not recognise as their own, stamping ownership where none has been earned. It is certainly noteworthy that funding and effort can be readily found for a statue, with strong advocacy to ensure its installation, yet there seems to be no similar energy spent on funding the event itself. 'Instead, the expectation remains that local taxpayers will shoulder the burden. This is particularly jarring at a time when many residents are struggling to afford basic necessities, such as heating, while council tax continues to rise. The contrast is striking and unjust.'

Penrith school could get new extensions with new classrooms
Penrith school could get new extensions with new classrooms

Yahoo

time5 days ago

  • Yahoo

Penrith school could get new extensions with new classrooms

A PENRITH school could get new extensions and alterations if the plans are approved by Westmorland & Furness Council's Eden local area planning committee next week. Members are due to meet at the town's Voreda House on Wednesday (June 11) to consider the planning application for Beaconside C of E Primary School in Hutton Hill. It is being considered by councillors because the application is from the council and the recommendation to grant planning permission is contrary to the recommendation of Penrith town council. According to the report concerns have been raised regarding the number of available staff car parking spaces and the increase in traffic at normal school drop-off and pick-up times. The report states: 'The highway authority consider that the level of parking is in line with the guidance set out in the Cumbria Development Design Guide, and they do not object to the proposed increase to the size of the school.' According to the report the full planning application for extensions and alterations to the existing school to allow for an increase to the existing Published Admission Number (PAN) from 73 to 90 which would provide an additional 119 pupil places from reception year to year six. The report states: 'This application proposes two new single storey classroom extensions. The first is for two new Key Stage 1 (KS1) classrooms measuring 63 square metres internal floor space each with a total new building gross internal area of 155.7 square metres. 'This extension will be located at the west edge of the school next to the staff car parking area and will be 26 metres from the road, Hutton Hill/Brent Road. 'The second, for Key Stage 2 (KS2), will have three classrooms measuring 55 square metres each, along with staff space, toilets and plant room, with a new build gross internal area of 269 square metres. 'The extension will be located in the southern section of the school where the existing storage unit and library bus are positioned but they will be relocated elsewhere within the school grounds.' In a response from the town council it states that it recognises the importance of educational development and that Beaconside School has been chosen as the school where growth will occur. It adds: 'It also believes that the application fails to adequately address several significant concerns related to the transport statement and travel plan relating to topography of the town, highway safety, public transport access and compliance with the relevant national and local planning policies. 'There is concern that the amount of parking for staff, 33 spaces, based on Cumbria County Council's Parking Standards is insufficient for 70 FTE staff.' The town council also raised concerns relating public transport within Penrith because the buses do not run at times corresponding with start and finish times at the school. The council received three letters of objection which raised concerns including: The road infrastructure surrounding the school cannot cope with the existing levels of traffic; There is already a major problem with the huge number of pupils who arrive and depart by car which are parked on the roadside and footpaths that impede visibility; That additional vehicles will be extremely unsafe for children, parents and local residents; Suggest an environmental impact assessment and ongoing monitoring of the traffic levels in the local area; Suggests that a wider impact assessment is carried out to ensure the expansion of the school does not result in other local primary schools becoming unsustainable. And there was one letter of support which supported the requirement for extra capacity in the school especially with the huge volume of new houses being built around Penrith. The report states: 'However, concern is with the volume of additional traffic that the proposed development will create. 'Suggest that the use of school buses and walking buses be developed which would be more sustainable.'

Here's How Audra McDonald Reacted to Patti LuPone Saying She's ‘Not a Friend'
Here's How Audra McDonald Reacted to Patti LuPone Saying She's ‘Not a Friend'

Yahoo

time7 days ago

  • Yahoo

Here's How Audra McDonald Reacted to Patti LuPone Saying She's ‘Not a Friend'

Audra McDonald has responded to Patti LuPone's recent disses. Shortly after LuPone said that her fellow Broadway legend was 'not a friend,' citing a past 'rift' between them, McDonald told Gayle King for CBS Sunday Morning, 'If there's a rift between us, I don't know what it is.' More from Billboard Is Rose from 'Gypsy' the Greatest Role in Broadway History? That's What Tony Awards History Suggests The Amity Affliction Cover Turnstile's 'Holiday' for 'Like a Version' Mariah Carey Celebrates 20 Years of 'The Emancipation of Mimi': Stream It Now 'That's something that you'd have to ask Patti about,' the Private Practice star continued. 'I haven't seen her in about 11 years, just because I've been busy, just with life and stuff. I don't know what rift she's talking about, you'd have to ask her.' McDonald's response comes days after LuPone made her feelings quite clear in a New Yorker profile published Monday (May 26). The subject first came up as LuPone was recalling a kerfuffle with Broadway's Hell's Kitchen, which was located next door to her own Broadway play The Roommate. LuPone had asked Shubert Organization head Robert Wankel to step in after sound from the Alicia Keys-created musical kept bleeding over from their neighbors, after which Hell's Kitchen star Kecia Lewis posted a video on Instagram calling LuPone's actions 'bullying,' 'racially microaggressive' and 'rooted in privilege.' When The New Yorker's Michael Schulman pointed out that McDonald had shown support for Lewis' video in the comments, LuPone replied, 'Exactly.' 'And I thought, You should know better,' LuPone continued at the time. 'That's typical of Audra. She's not a friend.' That's when the publication noted that the two stage icons had previously 'had some long-ago rift,' about which LuPone didn't want to disclose details. When pressed for her review of McDonald's current portrayal of Rose in Gypsy on Broadway — a role LuPone played and won a Tony for in a 2008-09 revival — LuPone simply stared at the writer pointedly for 15 seconds. Watch McDonald address LuPone's remarks below. Best of Billboard Chart Rewind: In 1989, New Kids on the Block Were 'Hangin' Tough' at No. 1 Janet Jackson's Biggest Billboard Hot 100 Hits H.E.R. & Chris Brown 'Come Through' to No. 1 on Adult R&B Airplay Chart

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store