Opposition Leader Sussan Ley doubles down on calls to revoke Australia's recognition of a Palestinian state
On Monday, Albanese revealed the government will join France, the UK, and Canada in recognising Palestine at a United Nations General Assembly meeting in September.
More than 140 of 193 UN member states already recognise Palestine, including European Union member states Spain and Ireland.
On Wednesday, Ley took aim at Albanese's plan, calling out widespread Palestinian support for Hamas.
'It's clear from the reports that are now emerging that this recognition from the prime minister is unconditional,' Ley said.
'There were several conditions placed on it notionally, but they can't reasonably be met.
'One of them is Hamas will be dismantled and taken out of any general election. Clearly, that is not possible, which is why the Coalition has made it very clear we oppose this.
'There can be no recognition without peace. They can be no reward for terror. We will reverse this decision because, ultimately, this is not in the interests of the Palestinian people. It is not in the interests of peace in the region, which we all want.
'We all want the war to end. The suffering to end. Gazans to be fed and the hostages to be released.'
Barr raised statistics of Palestinian support for Hamas, recently published by The Palestinian Centre for Policy and Survey Research, an independent think tank in the West Bank.
An overwhelming 77 per cent of respondents opposed the disarmament of Hamas and about two-thirds opposed the expulsion of Hamas military leaders from the Gaza Strip if this was made a condition for stopping the war.
But Barr pressed Ley on the 'credence' of the polling, given the conditions Gazans are currently living in.
Ley replied: 'What does the Prime Minister mean when he says recognise Palestine? Is it the Gaza strip, where, as you say, the terrorists are in control and the war is raging and the hostages are still trapped in tunnels?
'Is it the West Bank? Where some of these figures show strong support for Hamas? What does it mean? What we know is, it will not bring peace.
'It will not make the world a safer place. It will not help deliver aid to those who desperately need it.'
Ley argued Albanese needed to stay focused at home. She said while Australians care deeply about what is happening overseas, domestic problems are still weighing heavily on ordinary Aussies.
'(Australians) are struggling right now with the basics. His first duty should be to them,' Ley said.
Barr then referred to Ley's calls, just a few weeks ago, for Albanese to meet Trump, saying it could be considered a 'confusing message' given Ley is now pivoting to a domestic agenda.
Ley replied: 'He has clearly been distracted for weeks, with respect to Palestinian recognition. That is not going to make the world a safer place or free the hostages. It is not going to deliver aid and not going to deliver the two-state solution.
'Meanwhile, Australians are struggling ... He is focusing on overseas matters, which aren't even in Australia's interests.'
Barr argued domestic cost-of-living pressures are coming under control, with a third rate cut this year.
Ley disagreed, saying: 'Australian families are still paying $1800 more for their mortgage. The RBA, while delivering welcome relief to mortgage holders, has said productivity and growth are weak.
'That means, living standards in Australia are going to decline further.
'We've already had the biggest drop in the developed world. These forecasts indicate that it is going to drop further.
'Now, I know people see this as a macro-economic discussion. But there are children sleeping in cars, getting out of those cars fully-dressed in their school uniforms. Parents who can't afford to put a roof over their heads.
'When you read the latest Anglicare report that said there's $33 left over for someone who is on the minimum wage after they pay rent, their groceries, and their transport costs — that isn't a cost of living crisis, that's a cost of survival crisis.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
17 minutes ago
- West Australian
Australian news and politics live: Ley accuses PM of ‘making a mess' on Palestine after Hamas cal him a ‘hero'
Scroll down for the latest news and updates. Disturbing new details have surfaced following the horrific discovery of the bodies of 39-year-old pregnant woman Athena Georgopoulos and her 50-year-old partner Andrew Gunn in their Mount Waverley home. A disagreement over a dog may have sparked the chilling double homicide, the Herald Sun reports. Mr Gunn, known locally as 'Morph,' was rarely seen without his beloved German Shepherd, Dragon, and according to locals, rising tensions between Mr Gunn and accused killer Ross Judd had begun to centre around the dog. The couple's bodies were found inside their Adrienne Crescent unit around 9.55pm on Monday. Mr Gunn was allegedly decapitated with his head mounted on a spike, in what was described by police as an 'unimaginably horrific crime scene'. Read more. Rising construction costs and rental increases may prove to be stumbling blocks for further rate cuts from the Reserve Bank. The latest data from Cotality shows there are concerns for housing inflation and its knock-on effects off the back of rental re-acceleration picking up in state capitals for the first time in two years. The capital city rental value index has increased by three per cent to July 2025, up from 2.7 per cent a month before, according to Cotality's August monthly housing chart pack. Read the full story. Opposition Leader Sussan Ley has intensified her criticism of Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's plan to recognise Palestine at the United Nations next month, after Hamas publicly praised the move as showing political 'courage.' Ms Ley has argued the prospect of a lasting peace was getting 'further and further away' by the day, and that conditions tied to the recognition, including removing Hamas from influence in Palestine, were almost 'impossible' to meet. 'It doesn't bring about a two-state solution, it doesn't make the world a safer place,' Ms Ley told Nine. 'Anthony Albanese is making a real mess of this... On the same day, a listed terror organisation calls our Prime Minister a hero, while our closest ally, the US, says that these actions are going to make peace in the region less likely. 'Remember, the Prime Minister used justification for this decision by saying Hamas would not be involved? And I saw the Treasurer yesterday saying, oh, Hamas will have no role in a future Palestinian state. Really? As if we can control these things? 'The question now is for the prime minister to say, if you have made this conditional, and you keep saying you have, whereas it looks to me to be completely unconditional, what are you going to do now, especially now that Hamas has hailed you as a hero?'
Sky News AU
17 minutes ago
- Sky News AU
'Ashamed': Albanese government's decision to recognise Palestine branded 'absolute worst' foreign policy move after Hamas praise
The Albanese government's decision to recognise Palestine has been branded 'foreign policy at its absolute worst', after the announcement was praised by Hamas and criticised by the United States' top diplomat. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has claimed the government's decision to recognise Palestine at an upcoming United Nations meeting would help to 'isolate Hamas'. However, this was called into question on Wednesday when the listed terrorist organisation released a statement endorsing the move and praising Mr Albanese's 'political courage'. Speaking to Sky News Australia on Wednesday evening, veteran foreign affairs editor Greg Sheridan said it was shameful to see an Australian prime minister receiving such praise. 'I'm ashamed that an Australian Prime Minister is being lavishly praised by the most bloodthirsty, sick, sadistic, sexualized, sadistic terrorist group in the world, who praise his courage and say that he has advanced their cause,' Mr Sheridan said. The veteran journalist and foreign editor at The Australian said the Albanese government had achieved something unique in the nation's history, being both praised by a terrorist group and criticised by a key ally. 'On the same day it has been lavishly praised by the worst terrorist group in the world… the United States Secretary of State, Marco Rubio, a long-time friend of Australia, (and) very responsible, seasoned internationalist US Senator… says that Albanese is engaged in worthless populism for domestic politics,' he said. 'He could have been a lot tougher on it than that. 'Yet according to Albanese, Marco Rubio knows nothing about the Middle East… and Hamas knows nothing about what's in Hamas interests. Albanese and Penny Wong know everything - they've apparently dealt a death blow to Hamas and earned the thanks of the free world. 'I mean, this is Australian foreign policy at its absolute worst. When you are loved by the terrorists and you are making your closest allies pull their hair out in frustration, you are on the wrong course.' Asked about the growing number of countries who have announced plans to recognise Palestine at the September meeting of the UN, Secretary Rubio said such moves were 'largely meaningless'. 'It's symbolic, and they're doing it primarily for one reason, and that is their internal politics, their domestic politics,' he said. 'The truth of the matter is that the future of that region is not going to be decided by some UN resolution. It's not going to be decided by some press release by prime minister or president from some country. It's going to be decided on the ground, fact. 'All these statements are meaningless… They're not going to change anything.' The federal Coalition also lashed out at the decision on Wednesday, with shadow foreign minister Michaelia Cash saying it was a 'sad day for our nation'. 'Prime Minister Anthony Albanese should hang his head in shame after being praised today by the terrorist group Hamas for his decision to recognise a Palestinian state,' Senator Cash said in a statement. 'Mr Albanese has emboldened a terror group who murder civilians in cold blood and still hold 50 Israeli hostages in tunnels under Gaza. 'All Australians should be appalled at the massive propaganda victory Mr Albanese has handed Hamas on a platter.' However, Australia is not alone in announcing plans to recognise Palestine. French President Emmanual Macron, United Kingdom Prime Minister Sir Kier Starmer and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney have all recently announced similar plans.
Sky News AU
17 minutes ago
- Sky News AU
CSIRO ‘cherry pick' data to support renewables, sideline cheaper black coal energy expert claims
Centre for Independent Studies senior policy analyst Zoe Hilton has claimed the CSIRO performed a "shocking cherry pick" by claiming renewables were the lowest cost new build energy generation technology. The agency's GenCost report found black coal cost $111 per megawatt hour at the lowest end of annual forecasts while backed-up wind and solar was $116 MWh under the cheapest model, despite the corresponding media release claiming renewables were cheaper. Energy Minister Chris Bowen repeated that claim, using it to justify the Albanese government's push to drastically reshape Australia's energy grid with battery-backed renewables. However, Ms Hilton argued CSIRO's report 'very clearly shows' black coal is the cheapest new build generation technology. 'They don't look at brown coal though, just saying that, but $111 per megawatt hour, you can see on that chart it's very clear that black coal wins. It is cheaper than all of the 60, 70, 80, 90 per cent variable renewable energy shares,' she told Sky News Australia. 'Then when you look at the midpoints of those ranges as well. Coal is cheaper than 90 per cent wind and solar when it is integrated into the grid and that's very important because 90 per cent of wind and solar is what we're building.' The energy expert then took aim at the discrepancy between the report's findings and the corresponding media release, accusing the CSIRO of misleading the public by withholding key information . 'This is quite a shocking cherry pick,' she said. 'They call their GenCost report transparent and then they say in their own report that their modelling for the renewables integration costs is not suitable for general release. "We've asked time and time again for them to release this modelling… apparently, it's so embarrassingly bad that they can't even release it.' Ms Hilton also claimed the CSIRO had deliberately framed its 2030 analysis to favour renewables. 'The way that they do that is they say: 'Oh, well, by 2030, we will have built all of these things that support renewables.' So things like Snowy 2.0, which is at $12 billion and counting and more pumped hydro projects, a lot more batteries,' she said. 'A whole bunch of transmission projects, which are going to be more billions of dollars that are added onto consumer bills. All of that, everything that is built before 2030, they just assume: 'Okay, it's going to be free, and we don't have to count that in the renewables cost.' 'They also assume very pessimistic assumptions for coal. So they assume that instead of building the same type of plant that we've built time and time again in Australia. We would have to build an advanced ultra supercritical plant. 'A plant like that, that they assume with unprecedented steam temperatures and pressures that hasn't been built anywhere else in the world.' In addition, Ms Hilton noted the CSIRO had not considered brownfield projects, which involve upgrading coal plants on an existing site and could save 'a lot of money' on roads, transport and infrastructure. 'They assume we have to build on a greenfield site, and so all of those extra costs, like a train line to get the coal to the coal plant, all of is added in and that pushes up the price of coal,' she said. 'Then you look at the coal fuel prices, they cherry pick those as well, because they have a number of different values for the low and the high ranges, and they take the average of the low values and the absolute maximum of the high values. 'It's this very asymmetrical way that they choose fuel prices and that ends up having the coal high price range be much higher than realistically it should be.'
