Inside proposed $20K settlement after Davidson County Schools student suspended for alleged ‘racially motivated comment'
The plaintiff's motion for settlement approval offers insight into the proposed settlement that will be heard in court in early July. While the filing says both parties have agreed to the settlement, it will not be final until a judge approves it.
Forsyth County Board of Commissioners rejects $32 million request from Winston-Salem/Forsyth County Schools
According to the document, the district would pay the family $20,000, which will help to cover the costs of the student's new school.
The school district would remove 'all reference to racial bias in [the student's] school record.' However, the district would leave the suspension unchanged due to the 'class disruption caused by the comments at issue.'
The board would issue a public apology for 'mischaracterization of racial bias in [the student's] school records,' and a former member of the school board would issue an apology 'for additional inappropriate conduct after the suspension.'
Dean McGee, senior counsel for Educational Freedom at the Liberty Justice Center, said in a statement, 'On Friday, we filed a motion asking the court to approve a settlement that would resolve this matter. Because [the student] is a minor, a court hearing is required before the settlement can become final. We'll have more to say after that hearing, but we're pleased to take this important step toward clearing our client's name.'
A spokesperson for the school district previously said they are unable to comment due to pending litigation.
The incident happened on April 9, 2024, at Central Davidson High School.
'On April 9, my son received a write-up stating that he violated a board of education policy by using or making a racially motivated comment, saying that an alien needs a green card,' the boy's mother, Leah McGhee, said.
The lawsuit claims the teen left class to go to the bathroom. He missed some of the lesson, and when he came back, the word 'aliens' was used during class discussion.
The student reportedly asked if 'aliens' referred to 'space aliens or illegal aliens who need green cards' and the teacher said to 'watch your mouth.'
According to the suit, a Hispanic male classmate then threatened to beat the student up. That same day, the 16-year-old received a three-day out-of-school suspension.
'I cannot appeal this suspension since it is less than 10 days. Racism is only a three-day suspension with no appeal when it should be a top-tier punishment,' Leah McGhee said.
The 16-year-old is no longer enrolled at the school because, according to the lawsuit, he received threats and was harassed about this situation.
The student's parents, Leah and Chad McGhee, filed a lawsuit on behalf of their 16-year-old son and called on the school to reverse the suspension and remove it from the student's record.
The lawsuit argues that the words 'alien,' 'illegal alien' and 'green cards' are common terms used in both state and federal law. It goes on to say the punishment was too harsh and his comment should have been protected under his First Amendment rights of free speech.
'There is nothing inappropriate about saying aliens need green cards, and there certainly isn't a case for racism due to the fact that alien is not a race,' Leah told the school board in May 2024.
The McGhee family asked the courts to require a public apology from the school board, reverse the suspension, remove it from the student's record, remove unexcused absences because of the suspension, remove all references from his record that he used racially motivated, inappropriate, or insensitive language in class and monetary damages determined during trial.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
17 hours ago
- Politico
Abbott blasts Crockett, Democrats over redistricting critiques
But in an interview with host Shannon Bream, Abbott dismissed Crockett's concerns. 'The problem that Democrats have in the state of Texas is Hispanics, Black voters and other voters, they have learned now that the ideas that Democrats stand for are contrary to the ideas that the Hispanic community and Black community stand for.' Crockett's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment. This weekend is not the first time the two Texans have lobbied insults at each other. Earlier this year, Crockett called Abbott, who uses a wheelchair, 'Governor Hot Wheels' and a 'hot ass mess.' Though she denied she was mocking Abbott's disability, her words drew swift condemnation. Abbott responded by saying Democrats 'have no vision, no policy' and have nothing but hate to offer. The latest remarks come as Republicans in the state rush to follow President Donald Trump's directive for a new congressional map, one that could secure as many as five new congressional seats for the GOP. The directive has drawn backlash from Democrats nationwide, with many arguing the map is designed to silence voters of color. In the first draft of the new map publicly released last month, voters of color in Tarrant County were split among multiple neighboring Republican districts, according to The Texas Tribune. The area is now represented by Democrat Rep. Marc Veasey, who is Black. The shape of the 35th District in Central Texas was also changed, despite being created after a court ordered the state to protect the voting rights of people of color. That district is represented by Democrat Rep. Greg Casar, who is of Mexican descent. Abbott on Sunday said that in the maps the Republican-led legislature is drawing, four of the new seats will be predominantly Hispanic seats. The demographic, he added, 'are now voting for Republicans.'
Newsweek
a day ago
- Newsweek
Donald Trump's Approval Rating Suddenly Slides With Conservatives
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. President Donald Trump's approval rating has suddenly dropped among conservative adults, new polling has shown. According to a series of polls by The Economist/YouGov, the president's net approval rating has declined by 15 percentage points from July to August. Why It Matters During his presidency, Trump's popularity has fluctuated. Key issues, including his tariff policy and his handling of the Jeffrey Epstein case, have caused voter discontent. Conservatives are one of Trump's key voting bases. Losing their support could be damaging for the Republicans, especially when voters head to the polls in the November 2026 midterms. What To Know Prior to Trump's approval rating declining, it had increased steadily since May. It was net +67 percent then, and +68 percent in June. It then increased by 12 percentage points to +80 in July before falling to a new low in this time period, to +65 percent. Speaking to Newsweek, analysts suggested that his falling popularity was because of his trade and immigration policies, while other analysts previously pointed to factors like the Epstein scandal. Meanwhile, other general polls have suggested support for Trump is declining. According to a YouGov poll for British newspaper The Times, the proportion of people who disapprove of Trump's job performance has increased from 52 percent in April to 57 percent in July. President Donald Trump answers questions from reporters at the Eisenhower Executive Office Building on the White House campus on August 5, 2025. President Donald Trump answers questions from reporters at the Eisenhower Executive Office Building on the White House campus on August 5, 2025. AP Photo/Alex Brandon Newsweek analysis also revealed that Trump's approval rating is positive in 18 of the states he won in the 2024 election, and negative in 13. However, his approval rating has increased among liberals in the past month. Another poll showed Trump gaining more traction with Hispanic voters, a crucial demographic that traditionally supports Democratic candidates. What People Are Saying Heath Brown, an associate professor of public policy at City University of New York, told Newsweek: "The recent poll numbers are likely tied to two factors. First, many Republican voters are skeptical about the president's signature trade policies. Recent polling suggests that a sizable percentage of Republicans believe the tariffs are hurting the U.S. economy, and this is likely driving down support overall for the president. "Second, the most radical aspects of the administration's immigration policies, including many of its punitive deportation actions, are not supported by many Republicans. As these actions have gotten more attention, it seems likely that some Republicans have lost faith in the president." Mark Shanahan, who teaches American politics at the University of Surrey, previously told Newsweek: "Trump's second term has been less of a honeymoon, but more of a divorce from half the country: one where he's got to keep the house, the kids and just about all of the assets. From day one of his rule by executive order he has never sought to bring the USA together and, indeed, has exploited differences to highlight how he's delivering on his campaign commitments, not least through DOGE [Department of Government Efficiency], through his clampdown on immigration and through his America First foreign policy." "Public services are already beginning to creak thanks to the actions of Musk and his cohort, and tariffs are driving up prices at home, while the economic benefits of the One Big Beautiful act have yet to be felt. And around all this, the whiff of Epstein is tainting the president's achievements." What Happens Next Whether Trump's standing among conservatives falls enough to impact Republicans in the November 2026 midterm elections remains to be seen. His popularity among all different demographics will likely fluctuate as his presidency continues.
USA Today
2 days ago
- USA Today
Gov. Greg Abbott targets El Paso Rep. Vince Perez in Texas redistricting arrest push
A state representative from El Paso is facing an arrest warrant after Gov. Greg Abbott ordered the detention of 'delinquent Texas House lawmakers' who fled the state to block a redistricting vote that could give Republicans more seats in the U.S. House of Representatives. State Rep. Vince Perez, D-El Paso, said on Monday, Aug. 4, the warrant for his arrest stems not from a crime, but from a moral stand against what they call a "racially engineered" redistricting map. The redistricting push comes at the behest of President Donald Trump, who is looking to maintain Republican control over the U.S. House ahead of the 2026 midterm election. Congressional districts are usually redrawn when the U.S. Census is taken every decade. Perez also argues that the proposed map would dilute Hispanic representation and unfairly favor White voters. Despite facing an arrest warrant, he vows to keep fighting for fair representation for El Paso and all Texans. "For the first time since the Civil Rights Movement, we're facing a reality where political power is blatantly distributed along racial lines. White Texans, who make up 40% of our state, would control 70% of all congressional seats, leaving the majority Black, Hispanic, and Asian Texans fighting over what's left," Perez said in a news release. More: GOP map would strip Fort Bliss, El Paso airport from US Rep. Veronica Escobar's District 16 Greg Abbott orders arrest of Democratic lawmakers Abbott instructed Texas law enforcement to arrest Democratic lawmakers who left the state in an effort to prevent a vote on a redistricting plan that could increase Republican representation in the U.S. House. 'Texas House Democrats abandoned their duty to Texans,' Abbott said in a news release Monday, Aug. 4. 'By fleeing the state, Texas House Democrats are holding hostage critical legislation to aid flood victims and advance property tax relief. There are consequences for dereliction of duty." In El Paso, the proposed map would move Fort Bliss and the El Paso International Airport out of Texas Congressional District 16, which U.S. Rep. Veronica Escobar currently represents. Those areas would be shifted into Texas Congressional District 23, represented by U.S. Rep. Tony Gonzales, R-San Antonio. "Greg Abbott's unfailing loyalty to Donald Trump is greater than his loyalty to Texans," Escobar, D-El Paso, said in a text message to the El Paso Times. "Instead of focusing on helping grieving families who lost everything in the floods, instead of preparing our state for the next emergency, he's doing the bidding of a president who is afraid of his voters and wants to rig the next election." "I'm grateful to all our Texas Democrats working to defend our democracy and fighr these illegal maps and know that countless Texans stand with those leaders being threatened by Abbott." Rep. Joe Moody stays behind Among the state Democrats who did not flee Austin was state Rep. Joe Moody, D-El Paso, who voted against Abbott's move to issue arrest warrants against other lawmakers. "I fought these corrupt maps in committee and will continue fighting them every chance I get," Moody wrote in a statement. "Republicans aren't even hiding it — they've admitted these maps are meant to silence voices and votes. Trump is destroying our economy, our communities, and our way of life to serve himself, so he knows he'll lose Congress if he doesn't cheat. And now the governor is threatening to arrest and remove elected representatives who are using legal, legitimate ways to stand against that." Moody offered support for fellow Democrats who left Austin in a bid to "protect all Texans' votes" and called out Abbott for attempting an illegal power grab. "As for the governor's threats, while Trump is trying to steal a future election with his maps, our governor wants to steal elections that already happened last year," he said. "It's not just immoral — it's illegal. He can't declare vacancies, absolutely can't fill them, and no honest person could claim a legislative tactic long used by both sides is a crime. It's disgusting, fascist nonsense." "We need a democracy that works for the people again, one we can all trust," Moody continued. "I won't quit fighting fascism on all fronts until that dream is a reality again." Adam Powell covers government and politics for the El Paso Times and can be reached via email at apowell@
