Sex-abuse priest's promotion draws attacks on Catholic Church
A French archbishop's decision to promote a priest who was sentenced to jail for raping a teenage boy has drawn new condemnation of the Roman Catholic Church for its record on sex abuse.
Victim support groups and traditionalists have expressed outrage over the case of Dominique Spina, who was found guilty of raping a 16-year-old boy in 2006 and sentenced to five years in prison.
Catholic priest promoted out of 'mercy'
The archbishop of Toulouse, Guy de Kerimel, set off the controversy in June when he named Spina as diocesan chancellor, putting him in charge of archives.
The canonical code lays down that the chancellor must be 'of honest reputation and above all suspicion'.
Kerimel said he had acted out of 'mercy' in making the appointment and that he had 'nothing to reproach' the priest for in an 'administrative function'.
In a statement released on Thursday in the face of mounting protests, Kerimel acknowledged the 'incomprehension' and 'questions' among Catholics but said again that without 'mercy' Spina risked a 'social death'.
'This is in no way about downplaying a crime' and the victim must be 'recognised and helped', he insisted.
ALSO READ: Kokstad to Vatican: Local Bishop gets big job from Pope Leo XIV
Because of the sensitivity of the topic, Catholic leaders have been reluctant to speak publicly, but one bishop told AFP, on condition of anonymity, that the appointment was 'a great shame' for the church.
'A priest convicted of serious sexual acts cannot hold a position of responsibility again. We should be able to say that,' the bishop added.
Anger over priest's appointment
In a joint statement, several groups of victims of sexual abuse in Catholic schools expressed their 'deep indignation' and 'anger' at the appointment.
The Catholic media has also lambasted the appointment.
La Croix, a Catholic daily newspaper, said that 'the principle of mercy cannot be used as a hasty justification'.
The traditionalist website Riposte Catholique called the appointment 'unjustifiable' and said the Vatican should intervene.
'Compassion does not consist of rehabilitating a condemned man to a canonical position,' commented the Christian website Tribune Chretienne, known for its conservative line.
ALSO READ: Pope Leo warns AI could disrupt young minds' grip on reality
France's Catholic Church is already reeling from several sexual scandals in schools it runs and accusations of long-term sexual abuse made against Abbe Pierre, once an icon of the defence of the poor, who died in 2007.
The Church has set up two commissions on acknowledging and compensating for the widespread abuses uncovered by an independent inquiry released in 2021.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
17 minutes ago
- eNCA
US migrant raids spark boom for private detention providers
Donald Trump's promise to carry out the largest deportation operation in US history has appalled some Americans. But others are cashing in on the boom in demand for private detention centers. Migrants captured by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents need to be temporarily housed in places like the facility being readied in California City, prior to deportation. "When you talk to the majority of residents here, they have a favorable perspective on it," said Marquette Hawkins, mayor of the hardscrabble settlement of 15,000 people, 160 kilometres north of Los Angeles. "They look at the economic impact, right?" California City is to be home to a sprawling detention center that will be operated by CoreCivic, one of the largest companies in the private detention sector. The company, which declined AFP requests for an interview, says the facility would generate around 500 jobs, and funnel $2 million in tax revenue to the city. "Many of our residents have already been hired out there to work in that facility," Hawkins told AFP. "Any revenue source that is going to assist the town in rebuilding itself, rebranding itself, is going to be seen as a plus," he said. - Boom - Trump's ramped-up immigration arrests, like those that provoked protests in Los Angeles, saw a record 60,000 people in detention in June, according to ICE figures. Those same figures show the vast majority have no conviction, despite the president's election campaign promises to go after hardened criminals. AFP/File | Patrick T. Fallon More than 80 percent of detainees are in facilities run by the private sector, according to the TRAC project at Syracuse University. And with Washington's directive to triple the number of daily arrests -- and $45 billion earmarked for new detention centers -- the sector is looking at an unprecedented boom. "Never in our 42-year company history have we had so much activity and demand for our services as we are seeing right now," Damon Hininger, executive director of CoreCivic, said in a May call with investors. When Trump took office in January, some 107 centers were operating. The number now hovers around 200. For Democratic politicians, this proliferation is intentional. "Private prison companies are profiting from human suffering, and Republicans are allowing them to get away with it," Congresswoman Norma Torres told reporters outside a detention center in the southern California city of Adelanto. At the start of the year, there were three people detained there; there are now hundreds, each one of them attracting a daily stipend of taxpayer cash for the operator. Torres was refused permission to visit the facility, run by the privately owned GEO Group, because she had not given seven days' notice, she said. "Denying members of Congress access to private detention facilities like Adelanto isn't just disrespectful, it is dangerous, it is illegal, and it is a desperate attempt to hide the abuse happening behind these walls," she said. "We've heard the horrifying stories of detainees being violently arrested, denied basic medical care, isolated for days, and left injured without treatment," she added. Kristen Hunsberger, a staff attorney at the Law Center for Immigrant Advocates, said one client complained of having to wait "six or seven hours to get clean water." It is "not sanitary and certainly not... in compliance with just basic human rights." Hunsberger, who spends hours on the road going from one center to another to locate her clients, says many have been denied access to legal counsel, a constitutional right in the United States. Both GEO and ICE have denied allegations of mistreatment at the detention centers. "Claims there is overcrowding or subprime conditions in ICE facilities are categorically FALSE," said Tricia McLaughlin, the assistant secretary at the Department of Homeland Security. "All detainees are provided with proper meals, medical treatment and have opportunities to communicate with their family members and lawyers." - 'Strategy' - But some relatives of detainees tell a different story. Alejandra Morales, an American citizen, said her undocumented husband was detained incommunicado for five days in Los Angeles before being transferred to Adelanto. In the Los Angeles facility, "they don't even let them brush their teeth, they don't let them bathe, nothing. They have them all sleeping on the floor, in a cell, all together," she said. Hunsberger said that for detainees and their relatives, the treatment appears to be deliberate. "They're starting to feel that this is a strategy to wear people down, to have them in these inhumane conditions, and then pressure them to sign something where they could then agree to being deported," she said.
eNCA
17 minutes ago
- eNCA
Motor rally accident kills three spectators in France
Three spectators died in central France on Saturday after a car driven by a 22-year-old woman racer veered off the road during an auto rally, authorities said. The driver of the modified Peugeot 208 that hit the spectators and her 51-year-old woman co-driver were taken to hospital but their lives were not in danger, prosecutors said. The accident occurred near the town of Ambert in central France around 11 am on Saturday. Two men died at the scene and prosecutors later announced that a third man, airlifted to hospital, succumbed to his injuries. The three killed were two brothers, aged 70 and 60, and a 44-year-old man, according to the public prosecutor's office, which opened an investigation into involuntary manslaughter. Several people who witnessed the accident, were in shock, and nine people were taken to a psychological support unit set up in the nearby village of Saint-Just. "This is a tragedy for the world of racing," Joel Mathurin, the top government official for the department of Puy-de-Dome, told reporters at the scene. The road at the accident site is flanked by cornfields. Several hours after the crash, pieces of plastic and glass fragments were visible near the scene, according to an AFP journalist. Regional prosecutor Laure Moisset said the impact was "very violent." "Today, we have three families mourning the loss of loved ones in this accident," she said. When asked about the possibility that the victims were in an area closed to the public, Moisset said she preferred to "be cautious." "It is still a little too early to be precise," she added. "The race was extremely well organised," she added. Initially, the prefect had said that the spectators hit by the car were in a restricted area marked off by red tape. The areas reserved for the public are marked with green tape. - 'Violent crash' - Organised since 1965, the motor rally attracted 167 teams for its 32nd edition. In the rally held last year, a race marshal died. In a short statement after the accident on Saturday, the rally organisers said that the race was halted at 10:49 am. AFP | Sylvain Thizy All spectators were asked to leave the scene and the event's award ceremony was cancelled. Dozens of firefighters and police were dispatched to the scene. The investigation was "in its early stages," the prosecutor said. The Peugeot 208 car was to be examined. The road where the accident took place, almost a straight line according to the authorities, has been closed. The mayor of Saint-Just, Francois Chautard, said the rally passed through his village in recent years. He said he had seen the "dented" car when it was being towed away. "I think the crash was violent," he said. By Sylvain Thizy With Marine Laouchez In Lyon
Eyewitness News
8 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Indian police arrest man running 'fake embassy'
NEW DELHI - Police in India have arrested a man accused of running a fake embassy from a rented house near New Delhi and duping job seekers out of money with promises of overseas employment. Harsh Vardhan Jain, 47, was operating an "illegal West Arctic embassy by renting a house" in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, which neigbhours the capital, local police said. Jain, according to police, claimed to be the ambassador of fictional nations "like West Arctica, Saborga, Poulvia, Lodonia". He allegedly used vehicles with fake diplomatic plates and shared doctored photos of himself with Indian leaders to bolster his claims. "His main activities involved acting as a broker to secure work in foreign countries for companies and private individuals, as well as operating a hawala (money transfer) racket through shell companies," the police said in a statement following his arrest earlier this week. He is also accused of money laundering. During a raid on Jain's property, police said they recovered $53,500 in cash in addition to doctored passports and forged documents bearing stamps of India's foreign ministry. AFP was unable to reach Jain or his representatives for comment. Westarctica, cited by the police as one of the countries Jain claimed to be representing, is a US-registered nonprofit "dedicated to studying and preserving this vast, magnificent, desolate region" of Western Antarctica. In a statement, it said it had appointed Jain as its "Honorary Consul to India" after he had made a "generous donation". "He was never granted the position or authority of ambassador," it added.
