Patrick O'Donovan thought he might die after collapsing in Dáil
He said he was 'terrified' when he collapsed in an aggressive fit while speaking in the Dáil chamber in June 2023.
Advertisement
He said on Sunday that, at the time, he did not know whether he was going to live or die.
Mr O'Donovan, who recently revealed to the Sunday Independent that he has a photosensitivity that manifests itself into epilepsy, elaborated on the experience on the Anton Savage Show on Newstalk.
The Arts Minister said he was revealing his disability following criticism around his level of participation at cultural events.
While speaking in the Dáil chamber, he said he started to feel the sensations in his body 'beginning to go' and he started stuttering 'really badly'.
Advertisement
While he has had a stutter on occasion since childhood, he added: 'But this was a really bad one.
'And the next thing, before I knew where I was, all of the power in my limbs was beginning to leave me.'
The situation deteriorated by the second and he ended up lying down on one of the Government benches.
'I could hear everything but I couldn't see anything and I couldn't speak and I had no sensation anywhere.'
Advertisement
Asked if he thought there was a chance he was dying, he said: 'Yeah, I did. I thought this one was so big and was lasting so long, it was so violent and aggressive, that they couldn't get it under control.'
Mr O'Donovan added: 'I've often jokingly said at home that I thought I was going to be a table quiz question: 'Who was the first TD to die in the Dáil chamber?''
Mr O'Donovan said he had lived with the condition for years without it being diagnosed, suffering a number of episodes.
He said it felt like the 'bottom had fallen out' of his world when he was eventually diagnosed, but the confirmation also came with a sense of relief: 'I always knew there was something physically wrong with me, as did my wife because I could feel it.'
Advertisement
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
18 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Every One Still Here by Liadan Ní Chuinn review
The literature of the Troubles is a rich one, from Seamus Heaney's North (1975), Jennifer Johnston's Shadows on Our Skin (1977) and Bernard MacLaverty's Cal (1983), to Eoin McNamee's Resurrection Man (1994), Anna Burns's Booker-winning Milkman (2018), and Louise Kennedy's Trespasses (2022). The latest addition to the corpus, a slim debut story collection by nonbinary Northern Irish writer Liadan Ní Chuinn, shares the brilliance and burning energy of those other books, but there is a fundamental distinction. Ní Chuinn was born in the year of the Good Friday agreement, the 1998 power-sharing deal that delivered peace and brought an end to the Troubles; why, then, should their writing be so obsessed with them? 'I believe, these things, they're the making of us,' a character says at one point. He's talking about a dead friend, but his words might apply to Northern Ireland's past 50 or so years. Throughout the book the violence of that period is shown to persist, the past proving powerfully, inconveniently alive. Tensions flare between those who attempt to ignore that fact and others who insist on it. The narrator of the title story, Jackie, sometimes uses slashes to prevent him having to choose between alternative nouns: 'It looks like a morgue/a nightmare and it smells like a butcher's but with chemicals mixed in.' Ní Chuinn's writing is often terse, blunt, its subject matter better served by urgency than elegance. Jackie is a young man haunted by the internment, before his birth, of his uncle and grandfather – also Jackie – and by loyalists having hijacked his parents' car when his mother was pregnant with him. When Jackie was a boy his father fell ill and appeared to enter a vegetative state. Ní Chuinn, a writer of subtlety despite the polemic that veins these stories, doesn't push hard on the metaphor, but this 'lax and unmoving' figure can be read as a symbol for a Northern Ireland that forgets its history. In fact, as another character – born, like Jackie, after the Good Friday agreement – insists later on, in Northern Ireland the past bears down on the present with such weight that it is an error to even call it history. Ní Chuinn forgoes an epigraph, but a lesser writer, one more in need of underlining their aims, would have reached for Faulkner's lines from Requiem for a Nun: 'The past is never dead. It's not even past.' There is space, though, for other concerns and registers. Novena features Moll, second-generation Irish with a father from East Timor. Her grandmother, who is literally keeping the faith, texts Moll: 'Said special prayer. You should feel it in couple mins.' But the church she attends announces the impossibility of single funerals owing to a lack of priests, and its congregants listen to hymns on CD because 'there is no choir'. In the story Russia, which centres on a brother and sister adopted from that country, a psychic asks her client why he's come. Aren't you supposed to know? he answers. 'The psychic says: Everyone, no word of a lie, every single person says that. You've, none of youse, you've no concept of how this works.' Ní Chuinn's humour flashes brighter for its infrequent use. The same story describes a series of anonymous protests at a museum. Flowers of remembrance are being left at exhibits containing human remains: the preserved corpse of an ancient Egyptian, a Viking skull, a stone age woman's bones. This broadens the book's preoccupation with the past while simultaneously, in the manner of Heaney's bog poems, linking ancient instances of violence with the sectarian murders committed within living memory. Not everyone is willing to have such connections pointed out. In the closing story, Daisy Hill, a young man's obsession with the Troubles exasperates his family. 'I'm sick of this, right, Rowan?' his cousin Shane says. 'It happened, right? It happened, two sides, either side, both, it happened, it stopped.' Rowan rejects not only the urge to leave the past behind, but Shane's characterisation: 'I hate that, says Rowan. It's not both sides, it's not either side, it's this huge fucking army, it's this huge fucking state, this government that does whatever it wants, that just, that, they can kill us, and kill us.' Reading this book as the Israeli state kills unprecedented numbers of Palestinian civilians in Gaza feels particularly difficult, but also valuable – or as valuable as reading can be in the circumstances. Ní Chuinn's stories are unpredictable and memorable. While they contain the stuff of plots – family secrets, abuse, fraudulent fertility clinics and human trafficking – these aren't their true subjects, and they almost entirely lack the resolution provided by that familiar short-story trait, the epiphany. Rather than accounts of revelation, these are reports from the knotty midst of things. They describe entanglements that cannot be ignored or consigned to history. Sign up to Bookmarks Discover new books and learn more about your favourite authors with our expert reviews, interviews and news stories. Literary delights delivered direct to you after newsletter promotion Daisy Hill ends with a threnody subtitled The Truth, nine pages detailing more than 50 murders of Northern Irish civilians by British soldiers. Ní Chuinn quotes a Conservative government minister's contemporary praise for the impartiality and professionalism with which British soldiers performed their duties. 'The British state,' Ní Chuinn writes, correcting the record, 'kills and it kills and it kills and it kills.' This extraordinary book's final words – 'nobody is ever charged' – jam open the door to a past many would prefer to remain shut away. Every One Still Here by Liadan Ní Chuinn is published by Granta (£14.99). To support the Guardian, order your copy at Delivery charges may apply.
BreakingNews.ie
39 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Judge upholds trespass conviction against anti-immigrant activist
Philip Dwyer trespassed at a direct provision centre for International Protection (IP) applicants at Inch in Co Clare where residents were being besieged by protesters outside the property, a court has heard. At Ennis Circuit Court on Monday evening, Judge Francis Comerford upheld the trespass conviction imposed on prominent anti-immigrant activist, Mr Dwyer at Magowna House on May 18th 2023. Advertisement Described in court by his counsel Anne Doyle BL as a 'Citizen Journalist', Mr Dwyer (56) of Tallaght Cross West, Tallaght, Dublin 24 was appealing the district court trespass conviction imposed in March and Judge Comerford also affirmed the district court fine of €500. Mr Dwyer told the court that he was at Magowna House to ask questions in his role as a journalist. Judge Comerford said that Mr Dwyer 'might be entitled to make inquiries and go to someone's door, but he went well beyond it here". At the time, there were protests at Magowna House where 29 International Protection applicants were being accommodated and there were blockades on local roads which were attracting media attention. Advertisement Judge Comerford said that a group of people here came to seek refuge 'and were brought by the State to a relatively isolated, rural location where they were alone and away from a lot of resources and facilities'. He said: 'And in effect, they were besieged in the premises they were brought to. It was made absolutely clear to them that they weren't welcome and there were protesters outside the property and there were bales of hay blocking access to prevent others joining them.' Judge Comerford said that the big difference between Mr Dwyer and protesters outside was that he did come inside the property where the other protesters didn't. Judge Comerford said that he accepted the evidence of the manager of Magowna House at the time, Ahlam Salman, who said that Mr Dwyer's presence on the property made her feel 'afraid'. Advertisement Video footage made by Mr Dwyer was played to the court where he can be heard saying that he has arrived at a "people trafficking centre". In the footage shown in court, Mr Dwyer can be heard saying 'These are all foreign people telling me what I can't do in my own country'. Mr Dwyer can be seen addressing a Ukrainian man wearing a fluorescent jacket asking: 'Do you think Irish people are stupid? Do you think we are all idiots? I wouldn't blame you, to be honest with you.' He asks later: 'What is your problem? You are not in Ukraine, this is my country…What are you hiding? I am just asking questions on behalf of the people of Ireland…. The people in this country are very concerned about this.' Advertisement After seeing some men believed to be IP applicants staying at the centre, Mr Dwyer asks: 'Why are these people covering their faces….This is Ireland. This is my country.' Counsel for the State, Sarah Jane Comerford BL (instructed by State Solicitor for Clare, Aisling Casey) said to Mr Dwyer that his words "had a menacing undertone" to those he spoke on the property. In response, Mr Dwyer said: 'I wasn't menacing to anybody.' He said: 'I 100 per cent stand over those comments. We all have to respect one another. I tried to be respectful when I went in there." He said: 'I was treated very badly. I was treated with hostility…I felt quite intimidated as well. That is part of the job." He went on to tell the court: 'I have thousands of viewers, sometimes hundreds of thousands.' Counsel for Mr Dwyer, Anne Doyle BL said that she was not instructed by her client not to enter any mitigation concerning penalty 'as my client stands by his actions'. Ms Doyle said that 'he maintains that he was working in the course of his duties and does not accept the verdict'.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Taoiseach ‘hopeful' of EU-US deal as tariff deadline pushed back
The Taoiseach remains 'hopeful' that the EU can reach a deal with the US on tariffs, as the Trump administration pushed back a deadline for increased rates. Micheál Martin said both sides continue to negotiate the 'fine detail' of future arrangements. Advertisement White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt announced on Monday that US President Donald Trump would be delaying an increase to the baseline 10 per cent tariff rate to August 1st. President of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen. Photo: Carl Court/PA. Countries had been working to a Wednesday deadline to make a new deal with the Trump administration. Speaking to the media after a phone call with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen on Monday, Mr Martin said: 'We remain hopeful that the US and the European Union can agree an outline agreement or framework principle agreement this week. 'There's still a number of issues to negotiated, nothing has been rejected, definitively. Advertisement 'But what it does illustrate, though, that even if a framework agreement is arrived at, there would be a lot of negotiations subsequently. 'So therefore, whilst it would create some degree of clarity in terms of where we are in the short term, there would still be a number of issues outstanding in respect of that trade issue between the European Union and the United States and indeed between other countries.' Mr Martin said he supported the Commission's position that an agreement should be reached to provide certainty to consumers, businesses and industry. US Ambassador to Ireland Edward S Walsh with Tanaiste Simon Harris. Photo: Brian Lawless/PA. Asked if he expected a 10 per cent baseline tariff to remain in place, the Taoiseach said: 'There are certain realities that probably will emerge from this that will have impact – and are having impact – on a number of sectors. Advertisement 'But at least it gives us some sense of the landscape that we have to deal with.' After the tariff deadline was pushed back, Tánaiste Simon Harris said this would give further time for the EU and US to reach an agreement in principle on a 'mutually beneficial agreement that works for both sides'. In a statement, he said: 'However, it remains the position of the EU and the Irish Government that we would like to conclude discussions on a trade agreement before August 1.' Mr Harris added: 'I remain cautiously optimistic about reaching agreement in principle on a Framework Agreement. Advertisement 'I want to be clear that while it is likely there will be some form of tariffs going forward, their imposition even at a lower rate is bad for consumers, jobs, economic growth and investment.' World Trump seeks to pressure trading partners to make d... Read More Ireland has consistently called for zero-for-zero tariffs in as many areas as possible. The remaining uncertainty around pharmaceuticals remains a significant cause of concern. Mr Harris said: 'My hope is that in the coming days and weeks both sides can work intensively and constructively to bring about an agreement.' Advertisement
