South Africa starts a soul-searching 'national dialogue' about poverty, inequality and other issues
The talks, initiated by President Cyril Ramaphosa after calls from civil society, are expected to include most political parties, civic groups and members of the public.
Concerns have been raised over a possible $40 million cost, while there are also questions about whether the dialogue will result in significant changes.
South Africa faces many problems more than 30 years after the end of the apartheid system of white minority rule, including high levels of poverty and inequality, crime, corruption and an unemployment rate of more than 30% — one of the world's worst.
The country is no stranger to national talks, including the multiparty negotiations for a peaceful end to apartheid in the early 1990s.
Here's what to know about the national dialogue, which begins with a two-day convention in the capital, Pretoria.
Why South Africa is holding the talks
Since its first democratic election in 1994, when Nelson Mandela was elected as the country's first Black president, South Africa made progress in de-escalating racial tensions, improving the economy and providing access to millions of its poor Black majority.
However, there are concerns that the country has digressed over the last decade and calls for a soul-searching exercise grew louder after the long-governing African National Congress, or ANC, party lost its majority in the 2024 election, forcing South Africa to form a coalition government.
Ramaphosa announced the dialogue in June.
'The national dialogue must be a place where everyone has a voice. The dialogue will be a people-led, society-wide process to reflect on the state of our country in order for us to reimagine our future," he said.
The participants
South Africans from all walks of life are expected to voice their views at the dialogue, with talks expected to be held in person and virtually.
Ramaphosa has appointed an Eminent Persons Group, which is made up of religious, sports, labor and civic figures who he says reflect the great diversity of South Africa. They include South African rugby captain Siya Kolisi, award-winning 'Black Panther' actor John Kani and former Constitutional Court Judge Edwin Cameron.
Not everyone believes the talks will have a real impact. The Democratic Alliance, or DA, the second-biggest party in the coalition government, withdrew in a dispute with the ANC over the firing of one of its deputy ministers by Ramaphosa. It has also said that the talks are a waste of public money.
The MK Party, the official opposition, has said that it won't participate.
The dialogue will happen in phases and take the form of public discussions in all of South Africa's nine provinces. It's unclear how long the dialogue will last, but a second convention could happen early next year.
Criticism of the national dialogue
Some high-profile foundations have pulled out of this week's opening convention, citing rushed timelines and logistical issues, but they have said they will participate in the rest of the program.
The estimated cost of the dialogue has drawn criticism, although Ramaphosa's office has said that it's not as high as the numbers being put forward.
'If you want to have a real nationwide process, then it is going to cost a lot of money. It's not something that can be avoided,' University of Pretoria political analyst Dirk Kotze said.
The DA party and others have accused the ANC of trying to control the conversation and use it as a platform to campaign before local elections next year.
'I think the message that comes through specifically for the ANC is that they should stand a little bit back and not try to control the process,' Kotze said.
___
AP Africa news: https://apnews.com/hub/africa
Michelle Gumede And Mogomotsi Magome, The Associated Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
2 hours ago
- Washington Post
Eggs, tomatoes, sandwiches: The history of food as protest projectiles
The Roman Emperor Vespasian might not be as well-known as his predecessors Nero and Caligula, but when he died in A.D. 79, he left behind a legacy that included stabilizing the empire, beginning construction of the structure that would become known as the Colosseum — and being the first politician recorded to have been pelted with flying produce. During a visit to Africa, Vespasian was hit by rioters with turnips, according to the Roman historian Suetonius. Suetonius didn't note precisely what had angered the people or how the emperor reacted, but one thing is clear: They were onto something, and some 2,000 years later, the tradition of hurling food in political protest endures. Throughout the centuries, protesters have flung all manner of foods — eggs, pies, tomatoes, even fully composed sandwiches — at the targets of their ire. The latest incident occurred Sunday, when a man turned his Subway sandwich into a projectile and tossed it at a federal law enforcement officer, who was on the streets one day before President Donald Trump announced he would take over D.C. police 'to rescue our nation's capital from crime, bloodshed, bedlam and squalor and worse.' The man has now been fired from his Justice Department job, Attorney General Pam Bondi said, and is facing felony assault charges. Trump has been clear about his concerns over fruits and vegetables flying in his direction. In a 2022 videotaped testimony, Trump said, 'I think that [his guards] have to be aggressive in stopping that from happening,' according to a transcript in a lawsuit that accused Trump's security detail of assaulting protesters who allegedly planned to toss foodstuffs at a 2015 campaign rally. 'Because if that happens, you can be killed if that happens. … To stop somebody from throwing pineapples, tomatoes, bananas, stuff like that, yeah, it's dangerous stuff.' There are no prominent accounts of politicians being assassinated, or even maimed, by flying food. And pineapples? The bulky tropical treats would make terrible projectiles — and how many of them would one need to lug around, anyway, to ensure a successful attack? Bananas, too, are an unlikely missile. On tomatoes, though, Trump does have a point. Just hours after the news of Trump's fruit fears emerged in 2022, then-newly reelected French President Emmanuel Macron was pelted with a hail of cherry tomatoes when he appeared at an open-air market in a Parisian suburb. Macron, however, survived the onslaught, thanks in part to an umbrella someone nearby hoisted to shield him. Here's a rundown of foods that protesters have aimed at politicians and others: On Sunday, FBI agents were already on the ground in Washington, helping local law enforcement deal with crime, but Trump had not yet taken control of the city's police force or sent in the National Guard. Still, the presence of federal officers on the U Street NW corridor was enough to allegedly set off Sean Charles Dunn, who according to a federal court filing yelled obscenities at Metro Transit Police and U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers. He allegedly called them fascists, too. Then came the sandwich toss seen 'round the city: Dunn allegedly turned his Subway sandwich into an overhand fastball, aimed directly at an officer's chest. He fled on foot, only to be arrested sometime later. Jeanine Pirro, U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia, announced Wednesday that Dunn was being charged with felony assault. At a Thursday news briefing, Bondi said Dunn, a Justice Department employee, had been fired. The charge drew immediate ridicule on a subreddit for D.C., where commenters suggested Pirro could have accused Dunn of 'assault with a deli weapon' or 'assault with a breadly weapon.' Dunn became an instant hero to some: His protest was quickly turned into graffiti art, ready to share on social media. 'The gyro we deserve,' noted one commenter. Rotten produce, particularly tomatoes, has historically been associated with theatrical performances more than political ones. (The popular movie-reviewing site Rotten Tomatoes plays on the trope.) A bon mot that is often attributed to playwright Oscar Wilde — that when a rotten cabbage fell at his feet onstage, he apocryphally addressed its sender, quipping 'every time I smell it, I shall be reminded of you' — was perhaps inspired by an actual event from 1895. The angry father of Wilde's lover arrived at a performance of his hit play 'The Importance of Being Ernest' with a bouquet of vegetables he meant to throw, although he was turned away by police. And an actor in a New York Times story from a dozen years earlier was described as being 'demoralized by tomatoes' during a lackluster performance. It's unlikely, however, that tomatoes were thrown at Shakespeare's Globe Theatre, as is sometimes described, since tomatoes weren't introduced in Europe until much later. Plenty of politicians, too, have been targeted by tomatoes (which are technically a fruit, not a vegetable, something the lawyers in the Trump deposition actually discussed in a very enjoyable aside.) Former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin was spared from a splat during a book signing at the Mall of America when the man lobbing the fruit at her from a balcony in 2009 missed; in 2012, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's motorcade in Egypt was hit. And while Trump's fear of lethal tomatoes (maybe he's been watching too many B movies?) is overestimated, they can hurt — particularly if you're whacked with a hard, unripe specimen. One of the rules of La Tomatina — the festival in Bunol, Spain, where participants sling tomatoes at one another in celebration — is that you smash the tomatoes before throwing them at another person, to lessen the impact (and maximize the squish?). Egging is a long-standing tradition, carried on by middle-schoolers and political activists alike. As with tomatoes, the rotten variety has more impact (i.e. stench). In 2022, a trucker convoy protesting outside the home of a Democratic state lawmaker in Oakland, California, was met with a volley of eggs, many tossed by kids annoyed by the intrusion of the big rigs. The origins of the practice go back centuries. In the 1871 novel 'Middlemarch,' a man's ill-fated run for Parliament includes a scene in which a mocking crowd pelts his image — and him — with eggs. Over the years, prominent U.S. politicians have taken shellings: Eggs were lobbed at Vice President Richard M. Nixon at several stops on his 1960 presidential campaign; Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-Massachusetts) was similarly greeted on the presidential trail in 1980. President Bill Clinton took an incoming oeuf in 2001 during a trip to Poland. And California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger should probably win the title for most-agreeable target for his reaction to getting hit in the (considerable) shoulders during his 2003 campaign. He defended the egging as part of free speech and joked that the perpetrator 'owes me bacon now.' A pie to the face is a quintessential comedic stunt, and it's all the more primally satisfying when the object is a person of importance. The visual gag was popularized in vaudeville and in silent movies, and on-screen pieing became a cinematic staple, with practitioners such as Charlie Chaplin, Laurel and Hardy, and the Three Stooges. Many a political mug has been mashed into a pie, some the work of collectives such as the Biotic Baking Brigade and Pie Kill, which targeted the rich and powerful with pastry. The pie-to-the face roll call includes San Francisco Mayor Willie Brown, New York Mayor Abraham Beame, Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan (D-New York), Agriculture Secretary Dan Glickman and Watergate plumber G. Gordon Liddy. A 2004 book by the Biotic Baking Brigade called 'Pie Any Means Necessary' offered practical advice for aspiring piers (selecting the right variety, aim and the like) as well as history and ruminations on the deeper meanings behind the prank, which it deemed a 'creative tool in the toolbox of resistance.' 'Pie-throwing utilizes carnival humor,' according to an essay in the book, 'unsettling the authority and control that those in power try to project.' 'Milkshaking' is a relatively more recent innovation. That could be because the milkshake itself has a shorter history than other commonly employed protest foods. It became a phenomenon employed against right-wing figures in the United Kingdom as Britain considered leaving the European Union. One protester tossed a banana-and-salted-caramel milkshake at Brexit leader Nigel Farage. Other targets included anti-Islam activist Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, known as Tommy Robinson, and anti-feminist political commentator Carl Benjamin, who was hit by a creamy treat on at least four occasions. A point against the practice is the cost, relative to, say, the moldy, leftover contents of one's produce drawer. But it has the advantage of being visually appealing — the sight of a suit-wearing stiff coated in sticky, drippy dairy is quite photogenic. And as The Washington Post reported at the time, 'attackers sipping shakes are far less conspicuous than bystanders clutching eggs.' The tossing of ribbons of pasta is more specific to a part of the world that's very much in the news now. In Russia and Ukraine, the expressions 'hang noodles over your ears' reportedly is akin to 'pulling one's leg' or deceiving them. In the midst of the 2014 Ukrainian crisis, in which the country's pro-Kremlin president was ousted, protesters threw piles of spaghetti at the Russian consulate in Odesa, essentially accusing the Russian media of inaccurate coverage.
News24
4 hours ago
- News24
Maponya Mall clashes; New SA team heads to Washington: Today's top 7 stories in 7 minutes
News24 brings you the top 7 stories of the day. Graphic: Sharlene Rood News24 brings you the top stories of the day, summarised into neat little packages. Read through quickly or listen to the articles via our customised text-to-speech embassy delegates Afrikaner 'refugee resettlement' project to a Kenyan church - The US government is delegating its refugee resettlement project, linked to claims of genocide against Afrikaners in South Africa, to Church World Service in Nairobi, Kenya. - This shift comes as the US government increases its claims against South Africa, which Pretoria has criticised as being based on lies. - The US embassy states that RSC Africa manages refugee processing in South Africa, but the US Citizenship and Immigration Services decides on refugee status. Soweto mall forced to close following protest, murder of e-hailing driver - Maponya Mall in Soweto closed after residents blocked roads due to taxi violence. - The closure follows an attack on e-hailing drivers that resulted in one death and two injuries. - Residents feel unsafe due to escalating tensions between e-hailing and other taxi drivers. Pieter du Toit | Fires everywhere: Rogue general courting Iran must be reined in - South Africa faces international and domestic crises due to diplomatic failures, including a rogue general's visit to Iran and strained relations with the US. - The US State Department issued a critical human rights report, and a bill to review relations with South Africa is progressing in the US legislature. - President Cyril Ramaphosa's National Dialogue faces challenges, with key foundations withdrawing and tensions arising between his office and that of the deputy president. Govt mulls big changes to auto subsidies, as BMW boss warns of existential crisis in SA - The South African government is considering changing auto sector subsidies to encourage more local content in vehicle and component manufacturing. - Local component producers are pushing for higher tariffs on imported vehicles and components to protect the local industry, while BMW warns of an 'existential crisis' for SA car manufacturing. - The government is also working with ITAC to investigate the impact of imports on the auto sector, as cheaper cars from China and elsewhere flood the local market. Sefa Karacan/Anadolu via Getty Images New SA team heading to White House, says Mashatile, as 100k auto jobs hang in the balance - A new government delegation will be sent to the US to address trade issues and potential tariffs impacting South Africa's auto industry. - The Eastern Cape, a key hub for SA's auto manufacturing, faces significant job losses if trade disputes with the US are not resolved. - The delegation, led by Ministers Parks Tau and Enoch Godongwana, aims to negotiate better trade terms to maintain competitiveness in the US market. Former Springbok, legendary WP coach Dawie Snyman dies - Former Springbok Dawie Snyman, who played 10 Tests between 1972 and 1977, has died at the age of 76 after being diagnosed with leukemia. - Snyman was known for his versatility as a flyhalf and fullback, and notably featured in the Springboks' 1976 series win against the All Blacks. - After his playing career, Snyman became a successful coach for Western Province, leading them to a record five consecutive Currie Cup victories from 1982-1986. - Several major airlines are banning the use of power banks in-flight due to the risk of lithium-ion battery fires, which are difficult to manage in a sealed aircraft cabin. - While South African airlines still generally allow in-flight use of power banks, rules vary and can change, and international flights often have stricter restrictions. - To stay safely charged, passengers should check airline restrictions, charge devices before boarding, use in-seat USB power when available, and use certified power banks.
News24
5 hours ago
- News24
Presidential spokesperson Vincent Magwenya addresses the media
X/@DonaldDavhie Cyril Ramaphosa's spokesperson, Vincent Magwenya, is hosting a media briefing on Thursday. He is expected to answer questions about the National Convention, General Rudzani Maphwanya's comments on Iran, and US tariffs. Join us live at 17:00.
