Ex-NSW Premier likens Israel's actions in Gaza to war crimes committed by Adolf Hitler, Joseph Stalin
Speaking to Radio National, the former NSW premier and Labor heavyweight said Israel was using 'mass starvation against the civilian population as a weapon of war'.
'There's a pattern of behaviour here that really demands comparison with the worst of the last 100 years, of Stalin's Ukraine, of the Warsaw Ghetto, of Mao's Great Leap Forward,' he said.
'Unspeakable cruelty is being visited against babies and children in the enforcement of something not seen in the modern world, that is an advanced state using mass starvation as a weapon of war and giving effect to a genocide.'
Israel has started a 'tactical pause' to allow aid agencies to tackle the hunger crisis in Gaza, but Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said his government was not to blame for the situation, adding there were 'secure routes' for aid.
While he welcomed stronger comments from Anthony Albanese that Israel had 'quite clearly' breached international law by withholding aid to civilians in Gaza, Mr Carr called for further action.
He urged the Prime Minister to follow French President Emmanuel Macron to recognise Palestinian statehood when he attends the United Nations General Assembly in September.
On Sunday, the Labor leader watered down the action, stating there needed to be more detail on how a Palestinian state would function, plus assurances there would be no involvement from Hamas.
'How do you exclude Hamas from any involvement there? How do you ensure that a Palestinian State operates in an appropriate way which does not threaten the existence of Israel?' Mr Albanese told the ABC.
'And so we won't do any decision as a gesture. We will do it as a way forward, if the circumstances are met.'
However Mr Carr said Australia was 'giving the impression that we need the comfort of Britain' before recognising Palestine, and urged Mr Albanese to show leadership and act sooner.
'I just think Australians are ready to see our country to show a flash of independence, strength and maturity by moving with the French and not huddling and waiting for the sanction that Britain would give us when Downing Street finally gets round to it,' he said.
Mr Carr's comments have been criticised internally, with Labor Friends of Israel co-convener Nick Dyrenfurth calling on Mr Carr to 'promptly apologise' for the overly provocative comments.
Dr Dyrenfurth said that while he was 'gravely concerned with the Netanyahu government's actions in Gaza,' there is 'no genocide taking place'.
'Mr Carr is wilfully lying and deliberately stoking community tensions with extremist language and deliberately provoking his former friends in Australia's Jewish community with Nazi slurs,' he said.
The first Muslim MP, and demoted Labor minister Ed Husic also called on Mr Albanese to commit to recognising Palestinian statehood at the United Nations General Assembly, stating France has made the decision without needing prior confirmation on the demilitarisation of Hamas.
'Hamas absolutely has to be held to account, but the Netanyahu government, in the way that they've held Hamas to account and impacted and killed nearly 60,000 innocent Palestinians. That is unacceptable,' Mr Husic told Sky.
He said resolving the conflict in Gaza was also about recognising the 'humanity of Israelis and Palestinians,' Mr Husic added, stating that 'a lot of Israelis suffered deeply on October 7, and a lot of Palestinians have suffered ever since'.
'Bringing peace to them is something that we can all throw our weight behind.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
32 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Tasmania election counting ends with major parties retaining the same number of seats
The Liberals and Labor have kept the same number of seats in Tasmania, as two weeks of counting wrapped up in the state's snap election. Eighteen seats were needed to form a majority government but both parties fell short, the incumbent government secured 14 seats, Labor won 10 and the Greens five and other parties getting six. The final count played out on Saturday in the electorate of Bass in a race between Labor candidate Geoff Lyons and independent George Razay, seeing the independent take the final seat by 674 votes. It was the second time Tasmanians voted within 16 months, after a no-confidence motion in Premier Jeremy Rockliff introduced by Labor leader Dean Winter passed 18-17 in June. Mr Winter claimed the botched roll out of new Spirit of Tasmania vessels, the state of the budget and the controversial Macquarie Point Stadium project were examples of Mr Rockliff's failed leadership. Instead of resigning, Mr Rockliff remained Premier, requesting a snap poll be held to determine his fate instead. Tasmanian Governor Barbara Baker approved the request, deciding there would be no alternative as the Opposition leader refused to put together a minority coalition of his own and the Liberal Party room 'unanimously' supported Premier Rockliff continue in his role. Following the election, the embattled Liberal government won most of the seats but fell short of the 18 required to form a majority government. Party leaders now need support from crossbenchers to form a minority government. The Liberal Party needs support from four crossbenchers to remain in government, while Labor requires support from The Greens and two crossbenchers to form a minority.
ABC News
36 minutes ago
- ABC News
George Razay, Independent opponent to Hobart stadium, wins final Tasmanian seat of Bass
After two weeks of counting, the winner of the final seat in Tasmanian parliament has been determined, leaving both major parties with the same number of seats they held before the election. Independent George Razay, a doctor and City of Launceston councillor, has secured the last seat in Bass in an extraordinarily complicated contest. Labor's Jess Greene has also been elected as the party's second MP in Bass. The result means that Tasmania's next House of Assembly will have 14 Liberal MPs, 10 Labor MPs, 5 Greens, 1 Shooters, Fishers and Farmers member, and 5 independents. When the lower house voted no confidence in premier Jeremy Rockliff in June there were 14 Liberals, 10 Labor members, 5 Greens, 1 Jacqui Lambie Network MP, and 5 members sitting in parliament as independents. Labor has retained two seats in all of the state's seven-member electorates, while the Liberals have lost a seat in Franklin and gained one in Braddon. The Tasmanian Electoral Commission is set to formally declare the elected MPs on Tuesday and return the writs to the governor that afternoon. Both Liberal leader Jeremy Rockliff and Labor Leader Dean Winter are in talks with crossbenchers to form a minority government in Tasmania. Independent Craig Garland has already ruled out offering the Liberals confidence or supply, and says he would vote no confidence in the Rockliff-led Liberals if a motion was put to parliament again. With the Liberals unwilling to work with the Greens, Mr Rockliff requires the support of four of the five remaining crossbenchers to remain in government. If Mr Winter can rely on The Greens to back him into office, Labor needs two more votes to form government. On his website, Professor Razay says he has spent the last "28 years working as a general physician and geriatrician in a busy medical ward at the Launceston General Hospital" and "found it a very satisfying and rewarding occupation". "Politics is no different than medicine, it is about getting the job done, helping, and representing my community with honour and dignity." Professor Razay is also a keen musician and plays the saxophone. He is against what he describes as a "costly new stadium" at Hobart's Macquarie Point. Ms Greene is a former unionist and West Tamar councillor. She fills the void left by retiring Michelle O'Byrne, a former speaker of the house and Labor minister.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Result finalised in Tasmanian seat of Bass after July 19 state election
After two weeks of counting, the winner of the final seat in Tasmanian parliament has been determined, leaving both major parties with the same number of seats they held before the election. Independent George Razay, a doctor and City of Launceston councillor, has secured the last seat in Bass in an extraordinarily complicated contest.
