Shooting death of pet dog, Scooby, could cost Fresno County taxpayers $2 million
The fatal shooting of a beloved pet is expected to cost Fresno County's taxpayers at least $2 million after an appeals court ruling upheld a lower court's decision that sheriff's deputies violated the owner's rights and unnecessarily killed the dog.
In 2023, a jury awarded Veronica Ordaz Gonzalez and her boyfriend, Jose Ramos Santiago, $800,000 in damages after Fresno County sheriff's deputies entered their home without consent and shot 4-year-old Scooby while investigating a case of vandalism. The county appealed the decision to California's Fifth District Court of Appeals, but lost last Wednesday.
In addition to the damages, Ordaz Gonzalez was awarded nearly $830,000 in attorney fees in August 2023. The Fresno County Superior Court ruled deputies violated the Bane Act, a civil code meant to protect against threats, intimidation, an inference of threat or coercion.
Ordaz Gonzalez's attorney, Nolan Kane, estimated that the total paid out by the county for the case would eclipse $2 million, with appeals court fees expected to be at least $400,000.
'I'm all for law enforcement protecting us and doing things properly, but this instance seemed to be a family dispute,' Kane said. 'Certainly there are some circumstances where they need to hurry, but they rushed here and acted unnecessarily.'
In a statement, the office of Fresno County Counsel, which represented the county and the sheriff's department, said 'the county understands the sensitivity of the case.'
'However, it remains convinced that the officers acted appropriately in response to a threat,' the statement read. 'The county respectfully disagrees with the court's decision.'
The lawsuit stems from a reported vandalism case that dates back to June 3, 2018.
A couple had called police to report that their son had vandalized their car, resulting in $500 worth of damage, according to the lawsuit.
The couple told authorities that their son, Jesus Ramos, frequented an address on South Lind Avenue in Fresno, according to the lawsuit.
Deputies spotted a man they believed was Ramos at the home on South Lind Avenue, which was being rented by Ordaz Gonzalez and Santiago. Ordaz Gonzalez, her father, Roberto, and brother Omar Perez were inside the home along with Santiago, who was sleeping, according to court documents. Ramos was not at the home.
'This started because a [suspect] damaged his parents' car with an act vandalism that cost about $500,' Kane said. 'My clients didn't even know who this person was.'
One of the deputies spoke to Ordaz Gonzalez through a front screen door and asked her to step outside and identify herself. Ordaz Gonzalez said she would only exit to meet the deputy at the back door, according to court documents.
The deputy went to meet her at the back door. The deputy believed that by doing this, she had given consent to enter the property, according to court records.
Another deputy eventually grabbed Ordaz Gonzalez, twisted her arm and handcuffed her, according to court documents.
Ordaz Gonzalez claimed she asked the deputies to show her a warrant, which they didn't produce. The deputies, in court documents, did not recall being asked for a warrant.
Eventually, police brought a K-9 unit to the home. Authorities tied Scooby to a tree in the front yard before they led the police dog onto the property, according to court documents.
As police searched the home for Ramos, Scooby got loose from the front yard and ran toward the back of the house, where he was shot by a deputy. The dog walked to the porch and died there without receiving any aid, according to the lawsuit.
Kane said that his clients tried to settle with the county for $250,000, but the county countered with only $7,500 and was not willing to offer a larger settlement.
'It was something along the lines of them thinking we were too far apart to find a compromise,' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
28-05-2025
- Yahoo
Teenagers didn't expect attention after saving family from Whitesboro fire
When a family's garage caught fire and threatened their house, there was no hesitation by a group of teenagers to run towards danger. A garage fire in Whitesboro on May 17 could have turned out a lot different were it not for the actions of Aiden Kane, Morgan Randall, Tyler Sodj and, Donato Jellenich. And according to Kane, it was sheer luck they were in the area in the first place. Kane, 17, is a junior at Whitesboro High School. He said he was attending the Whitesboro Junior Prom with his girlfriend, Randall, and his friends Sodja and Jellenich. 'We left the prom a little early because to go to One Genny [in New Hartford],' Kane explained. 'We got a few appetizers with our friends before heading to Donato's house to get changed out of our prom clothes. And on the way, Morgan saw [the garage] burning. None of use would have seen it if it weren't for her.' Once they realized what was happening, Kane said they spun the car around and drove to the house on Cavanaugh Road in Marcy. 'Everyone jumped out of the car,' Kane said. 'Donato immediately called 911, Tyler ran towards the garage to check it out and I ran up to the door and started pounding on it.' Without even thinking, Kane grabbed the two daughters and ran across the street with their father. 'You're okay, you're okay, you're okay,' Kane kept repeating as he carried the girls to safety. A large boom could be heard as Kane was carrying the girls and, as they reached the other side of the street, Kane told them to get behind the car, only for another explosion to sound. Kane commended his girlfriend for her actions, saying Randall comforted the girls, helping calm them down and wipe away their tears in what was a confusing and terrifying moment. When asked how they reacted so quickly, Kane credited his father. 'My dad was a police chief and EMS chief, and I've even been on a few calls with him,' Kane said. 'I knew we had to get the family out, especially when the garage was exploding.' At the time, Kane said he wasn't thinking about much other than getting the family to safety Once the fire departments arrived and handled the blaze, Kane said he and his friends were given the go-ahead to go home — and that's exactly what they did. And it was only then that it finally hit them what happened. 'We were talking about it in the car and at the house for a while,' Kane said. But eventually, the shock and adrenaline wore off, and the group enjoyed the rest of their post-prom night, blissfully unaware just how much attention they'd get on Monday. Once the news media started tracking them down and learning that the fire department were calling them heroes. 'You know, it felt good to know we did something good for someone else, but we never expected it to get attention,' he said. Kane said the four of them were surprised to go to school on Monday and hear their classmates and teachers talking about what they did. It even hit Kane at his place of work. 'It was even on television at [One Genny],' Kane said. 'There were a ton of people congratulating me while I was working.' When asked about his future plans, Kane said he was going to college for cybersecurity and taking a job as a waiter to pay the bills. But ultimately, Kane said he plans to attend the New York State Trooper Academy and hopes to become a state trooper. This article originally appeared on Observer-Dispatch: Mohawk Valley teen speaks after he and friends save family from fire
Yahoo
28-05-2025
- Yahoo
Teenagers, on way home from prom, lauded as heroes for helping family evacuate from fire
Correction: The Whitesboro junior prom was held May 17. The story was updated with the correct date Three teenagers are being lauded as heroes by the Maynard Fire Department for their quick action when a family's garage caught fire and threatened to do the same to the home. Maynard Fire Chief Jared Pearl said a group of teenagers were leaving the Whitesboro High School Junior Prom on May 17 when they saw the fire. 'Three young gentlemen were dropping off their dates after the Whitesboro Junior Prom, traveling along Cavanaugh Road, and they came across the garage fire, and by then, it was fully involved,' Pearl said. UPDATE: Teenagers didn't expect attention after saving family from Whitesboro fire Pearl said the teenagers were Aiden Kane, Tyler Sodja and Donato Jellenich. The garage was detached from the building, and Pearl said the fire was so hot that it was melting the house's siding. And the family had no clue, as they were all on the other side of the house, away from the fire. It was by sheer luck that one of their dates lived across the street. '[Kane] ran across the street and banged on the door and told them what was happening,' Pearl said. A father and his two daughters were inside the building. Pearl said Kane helped the girls across the street, where they were comforted by Morgan Randall. Meanwhile, Sodja checked the garage, and Jellenich called 911. Pearl said there's a belief that the younger generations are more laid back, however, these teenagers showed different in their composure and fast-thinking actions. 'If they didn't do this, if they didn't get everyone out and call 911, it may have been three to four minutes before we got there,' Chief Pearl said. 'And by then, the house would have been fully involved.' 'They saved this family,' he concluded. Development: Utica to celebrate grand opening of Harbor Point on June 5. What to know More: Two more Marcy COs turn down plea deal in Robert Brooks case, will instead face trial And after speaking with the youths, Pearl only had more praise. 'They were nothing but humble,' the chief said. 'They don't look at themselves as heroes. But they saved this family, and it could have gone the other way within minutes. It's outstanding.' The Maynard Fire Department arrived on the scene shortly after the call went out and was joined by Whitesboro Fire Department. They were able to put the fire out quickly enough. 'For a horrible situation, it came together well,' Pearl said. 'And it's all because of these young kids.' This article originally appeared on Observer-Dispatch: Whitesboro High School prom students alert family to house fire
Yahoo
23-05-2025
- Yahoo
Man, 50, charged with moving meth between Oahu and Maui
Federal prosecutors want a 50-year-old Maui man held without bail after he allegedly smuggled pounds of methamphetamine between Oahu and Maui using Mokulele Airlines. Frank William Keliihanui Kane Jr. of Lahaina was charged Monday by federal criminal complaint with possession with intent to distribute a controlled substance, being a felon in possession of a firearms and ammunition, and possession of a firearm in furtherance of drug trafficking. Since March, agents with the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration, Homeland Security Investigations and officers with the Maui Police Department have been investigating Kane for the 'distribution of crystal methamphetamine ' on Maui, according to a complaint filed Monday. 'Multiple sources of information provided intelligence ' that Kane smuggled 'pound quantities ' of crystal methamphetamine from Oahu to Maui on Mokulele flights, according to an affidavit authored by a DEA agent. Kane is scheduled for a detention hearing today. Assistant U.S. Attorney Aislinn K. Affinito is prosecuting the case. On May 9, federal agents secured a search warrant to use global positioning system technology to track Kane's mobile phone. On May 16, federal agents tracked Kane's movements from Daniel K. Inouye International Airport until he arrived at Kahului Airport. Kane was watched by law enforcement as a friend picked him at the curb and took him home. Kane was later seen picked up by a brown To yota Tacoma and driven to a park in Kahului. There Kane got out and met a man on a bicycle, and an exchange took place, according to court documents. Kane was later seen driving his white Tacoma to a gym to lift weights. When he left the gym, he was pulled over on Honoapiilani Highway near Kapoli Street in Wailuku. Kane was ordered to get out of the car and told that he was the subject of an 'ongoing narcotics investigation.' Kane then signed two MPD forms waiving his right to an attorney and allowing police and federal agents to search his person, vehicle, bags within the vehicle, digital devices and home. Before the searches, Kane allegedly admitted that he had a camouflage duffel bag in the truck that contained several ounces of cocaine, two 'ghost ' guns and ammunition. He also told law enforcement officers that there was a black duffel bag in the truck that contained a pound of crystal methamphetamine. Police and federal agents seized the two bags and found a little more than a pound of methamphetamine, 171.78 grams of cocaine and a digital scale. A 9mm ghost gun handgun with two loaded magazines and a ghost gun rifle with two magazines and 100 rounds of ammunition were also found. In March 2021, Kane was awaiting trial for habitually operating a vehicle under the influence of an intoxicant when he was arrested again for habitual impaired driving and was ordered by a judge not to drive and to wear a device to continuously monitor alcohol in his system, according to The Maui News. Kane has convictions in 2007, 2011 and 2021 for habitual operating a vehicle under the influence of an intoxicant and was sentenced to over one year of imprisonment. He has a lifetime revocation of his driver's license. He has three prior felony convictions and 33 prior convictions in state court dating back to 1997. They include five misdemeanor convictions for cruelty to animals.
