MPs call for urgent action over 'toxic' male influencers
A new group of Labour MPs want to pressure the government into a radical rethink of how to steer young men and boys away from the culture of toxic masculinity.
Each of the eight MPs at the meeting picks out different challenges facing young men and boys.
'We have to get away from a political snobbery,' said Shaun Davies, who represents Telford in Shropshire.
'Which is to say that to talk about men's issues and boys issues is somehow anti-women or anti-girls. It absolutely is not.'
Jonathan Brash, a former teacher and now Hartlepool MP said: 'I've been looking at the exclusion rates in secondary school and they're going up and up and up.
'Why are young men no longer fitting into our education system and then what happens when they are pushed out of it?'
Rachel Tayler's North Warwickshire constituency is a former mining area.
She believes a shift in the type of physical work men often do has had an impact: 'Now they're working in massive logistics factories, all with earpods in or on forklift trucks or operating robots. And they don't see anybody or talk to anybody all day long.'
The conversations around masculinity have been sparked, in part, by the hit Netflix drama 'Adolescence', which tells the story of a 13-year-old boy accused of stabbing a female classmate.
Mr Davies said Labour MPs have been pushing for a cross-government approach on issues affecting men long before the TV drama, but admits politicians have to do more.
'There's absolutely a fundamental problem that there is a generation of young boys coming through where there is not an offer for them and they do not have a sense of belonging and that's a moral outrage that we need to address.'
In Bishop Auckland, the local MP Sam Rushworth wants to hear from pupils about the issues raised by Adolescence.
He's invited ITV News to a conversation he's hosting at the school, and there's one name that keeps bring brought up by the pupils: Andrew Tate.
'People take him seriously,' said one girl. 'He's got such an influence on people'.
One boy said Tate and other male influencers just 'popped up' on his social media feed.
'I thought this might help me learn how to make lots of money. But then when I found out what he did, I straight unfollowed him.'
Some of the boys admit talking about emotions is much more taboo than it is for girls.
'We have this idea that we can't open up as much,' said one year ten boy.
'You don't speak to anyone about them,' said another. 'There's no point. Because most of the time it's someone telling you just to man up.'
Away from politicians, one former teacher is trying to help navigate young men through their own adolescence.
Mike Nicholson set up Progressive Masculinity to hold workshops in schools to challenge some of society's expectations of what it means to be a man.
'I noticed while I was a teacher that boys and young men really don't have safe spaces to go and discuss what it can mean to be a man, to explore the potential of masculinity without fear of judgement, without fear of shame or being ridiculed,' he said.
Nicholson said the challenges facing men are not new, but believes the world is now ready to have what he calls 'difficult conversations'.
'I think social media maybe has intensified some of it, but I think these conversations are well overdue.'
So what can be done?
The Labour MPs we spoke to have called for a 'cultural shift' in the way the public and private sector approaches the issues faced by young men and boys.
Campaigners say there needs to be a 'dedicated strategy' across government.
But the challenges are broad, spanning areas such as health, education and the internet.
Even the prime minister, who has taken a keen interest in the challenges raised by Adolescence, admits there 'isn't an obvious policy response'.
And so the fear some gave is that despite the attention of MPs and the public, there is a risk that young men and boys could slip off the agenda.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
a minute ago
- The Independent
If stopping the boats were simple, it would have happened by now
Given the unusually fine weather – coupled with the world's many conflicts, and regions of endemic poverty – it should not come as a great surprise that yet another small boats record has been broken. New Home Office figures show that, since Labour came to power after the general election, more than 50,000 migrants have arrived in the UK via the English Channel. A few weeks ago, the numbers of refugees and economic migrants arriving via the English Channel reached a record rate for the time of year – 25,000 by the end of July, and, thus, the fastest flow since 2018, when such movements were first monitored. The new headline figure is different, and even more 'political'. At this rate, 2025 will set a new record for a calendar year. The political reaction has been predictable. Labour says it is 'unacceptable', while the Tories accuse the government of having 'surrendered our borders'. A little over a year ago, it was the Conservative government admitting the flows were unacceptable, and the Labour opposition laying the charge that the Sunak government had surrendered our borders. Meanwhile, Nigel Farage and Reform UK continue to pretend that solving this complex and intractable problem is simply a matter of willpower and a willingness to break international law and start a naval conflict with France. To borrow a recently fashionable phrase, the Reformists are the least serious people in British politics since… well, they persuaded the nation that Brexit was a good idea. Of course, in some ways, taking the Guinness Book of Records approach to the immigration statistics is playing the old immigration numbers game in an even more unhelpful way. The numbers may be large by recent trends, but they are rarely placed in context. Even a figure of 50,000-plus would, for example, only represent about 4 to 5 per cent of the total of gross, entirely lawful immigration into the UK on work and study visas. Not all will be able to make a successful claim for asylum. If any commit a criminal offence, they are liable to be deported – and much more rapidly under the latest proposals from the home secretary, Yvette Cooper. Contrary to some lurid and confused headlines, asylum seekers are neither responsible for most sexual offences in Britain, nor the same as those predators of Pakistani heritage who inflicted their appalling crimes on young girls for most of the last two decades. They were not responsible for the Southport murders; and they are mostly quite anxious to go to work, even if it is illegal for them to do so. The economic case for migration also stands. Despite an uptick in unemployment, there is a labour shortage in many parts of the UK, and it is almost as bad as it has ever been since Brexit in agriculture and the hospitality, health, social care and leisure sectors. A policy of 'net zero' migration, as advocated by Reform UK, would cause chaos in care homes, on farms and elsewhere, and inflict grievous damage to the economy. Those who want to reduce regular, lawful, documented and visa-based migration, such as Mr Farage, need to come up with some better ideas about how the demographically challenged and ageing British nation can undergo the renaissance they so cynically promise. Ministers have a duty to take on the myths and legends of irregular migration. But they are also under an obligation to 'stop the boats', something all parties actually agree about: this trade in human misery is dangerous and, indeed, unacceptable. Politically, Labour may have given the impression before the last general election, analogous to the way it approached economic policy, that fixing the problem of irregular migration would be easier than it has turned out to be. That is not to decry its efforts. Sir Keir Starmer was perfectly sincere in his belief, based on past experience as director of public prosecutions, that the criminal gangs engaged in human trafficking are susceptible to the same methods as gangs involved in terrorism and drug peddling. He was also right to rebuild cooperation with European neighbours, as with the 'one in, one out' deal with France and changes in German law to make obtaining and running the boats more difficult. Yvette Cooper seems fully aware of the need to stop using so-called 'migrant hotels', and to clear the huge backlog of cases left behind by the Sunak administration – people supposedly destined for Rwanda who were never going to get there because the Rwanda scheme was so small. Without condoning the ugly violence and vicious Islamophobia that disfigures too many local demonstrations, it is plain that the public is impatient with the lack of tangible progress. It is unfortunately not yet clear that Labour is making the requisite moves to 'smash the gangs' and 'turn the page and restore order to the asylum system so that it operates swiftly, firmly, and fairly'. The best thing that Sir Keir and Ms Cooper can do in these circumstances is to level with the electorate and explain why this intractable challenge will have to take time, and that they will do whatever is necessary to get the numbers radically lower. If stopping the boats were as easy as some claim, it would have happened by now. Nonetheless, the government needs to provide more evidence of progress, if only to counter the propaganda and misinformation so widespread on social media. In short, the public would like to hear about record-low numbers of small boat arrivals.
Glasgow Times
3 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
JD Vance expected to host Robert Jenrick during UK trip – but not Tory leader
Mr Jenrick has been invited to meet the US vice-president before a drinks event on Tuesday, it is understood. A Conservative spokesman said the party leader's team had spoken to Mr Vance's but that 'scheduling' had proved difficult. Both sides have played down the notion of a snub, the Telegraph reported. Shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick (Yui Mok/PA) Former leadership contender Mr Jenrick has strayed well beyond his justice brief in recent months, building a prominent social media presence with campaigns on a range of issues, from the impact of immigration on housing to tackling fare-dodgers on the London Underground. He and the vice-president have voiced similar concerns about the erosion of freedom of speech, as well as opposition to equality, diversity and inclusion initiatives. It comes after Mr Vance joined David Lammy at Chevening, the Foreign Secretary's grace-and-favour country estate in Kent, last week. The vice-president, who has also been tipped for a future leadership bid, described the Labour Cabinet minister as his 'good friend' but said there were 'disagreements' between the US and the UK governments on how best to respond to the humanitarian crisis and war in Gaza. A Liberal Democrat source claimed Mrs Badenoch was 'losing out to her leadership rival' while 'she messes up her efforts to mimic Nigel Farage and drag the Conservative Party ever further to the right'. 'Bungling Badenoch strikes again – JD Vance has apparently joined the electorate in giving Kemi the cold shoulder,' they said.
South Wales Guardian
6 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
JD Vance expected to host Robert Jenrick during UK trip – but not Tory leader
Mr Jenrick has been invited to meet the US vice-president before a drinks event on Tuesday, it is understood. A Conservative spokesman said the party leader's team had spoken to Mr Vance's but that 'scheduling' had proved difficult. Both sides have played down the notion of a snub, the Telegraph reported. Former leadership contender Mr Jenrick has strayed well beyond his justice brief in recent months, building a prominent social media presence with campaigns on a range of issues, from the impact of immigration on housing to tackling fare-dodgers on the London Underground. He and the vice-president have voiced similar concerns about the erosion of freedom of speech, as well as opposition to equality, diversity and inclusion initiatives. It comes after Mr Vance joined David Lammy at Chevening, the Foreign Secretary's grace-and-favour country estate in Kent, last week. The vice-president, who has also been tipped for a future leadership bid, described the Labour Cabinet minister as his 'good friend' but said there were 'disagreements' between the US and the UK governments on how best to respond to the humanitarian crisis and war in Gaza. A Liberal Democrat source claimed Mrs Badenoch was 'losing out to her leadership rival' while 'she messes up her efforts to mimic Nigel Farage and drag the Conservative Party ever further to the right'. 'Bungling Badenoch strikes again – JD Vance has apparently joined the electorate in giving Kemi the cold shoulder,' they said.
