Tauranga flood map update a ‘win' for landowners, developers after court case
The maps deemed 30,400 properties at risk of flooding - thousands more than under the previous modelling.
An independent hearing panel heard submissions on the plan change and the decision to approve it was notified in April 2022.
Twenty parties took three appeals to the Environment Court. The cases were settled in mediation, avoiding a hearing.
Tauranga 's Urban Task Force (UTF), which represents property owners, developers and businesses, was one appellant.
The UTF cited significant errors and inaccuracies, claiming the maps did not show the most up-to-date flooding information.
The task force also believed the plan change would hurt property values across the city.
Through the court process, the council agreed to keep the flood maps updated so they could be relied upon by developers and landowners.
UTF chairman Scott Adams, managing director of development company Carrus, said all parties generally accepted there were technical errors and issues with the mapping.
'[The] council has accepted through the appeal that a site-specific technical assessment on flooding will now prevail over the indicative maps that are currently shown on the council's online GIS [mapping tool] layer.'
'This is a significant win for the UTF on behalf of property developers and landowners,' Adams said in a statement.
'They can now get a simple stormwater engineering assessment to override the mapping. This will be particularly useful where there are errors with the flood modelling and map outputs.'
The council also agreed that whenever its stormwater model was updated using more up-to-date or site-specific information, this would prevail over the indicative flood hazard areas depicted in its GIS layer.
Other concerns raised by UTF about how roadworks might affect flooding were also addressed in the new consent provisions issued by the Environment Court.
Advertise with NZME.
Adams said roads were designed to help carry stormwater during major floods.
UTF's concern was if the council improved roads – like raising the height or adding engineering features – it could cause floodwater to spill onto nearby properties or reduce the ability of stormwater to flow along the roads, he said.
Because of this, Plan Change 27 was altered and neighbours must now be notified if roadworks could cause flooding on their properties.
Policies have also been updated to focus on reducing flood risks, rather than just managing activities. The goal was to ensure that activity still maintained suitable overland flows that water takes during floods, instead of restricting the activities themselves.
The Environment Court consent order was signed off by Judge Kelvin Reid in March.
The council approved the plan change at a meeting last week. It would become operative on May 13.
City planning team leader Janine Speedy said the process started after Tauranga had significant flooding events in 2005, 2010, 2011 and 2013.
The council then looked at how it could better manage risk from flooding, Speedy told the meeting.
An integrated stormwater project was started, and Plan Change 27 was the regulatory response for this, Speedy said.
Prior to 2020, the council didn't have any flooding rules in the City Plan and Plan Change 27 introduced those rules, she said.
The council had an ongoing flood modelling programme to ensure its information was up to date, Speedy said.
Councillor Glen Crowther said it was helpful to have the issues dealt with through the legal process.
It was important to get it right and there was a lot of effort put into it to ensure that happened, he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
17 hours ago
- Scoop
Patrick Reynolds Welcomes Progress On K-Rd Development
'I am very pleased to see the Environment Court has done the clearly positive thing and approved the proposed building for the empty site at 538 Karangahape Rd by James Kirkpatrick Group' says Patrick Reynolds, City Vision candidate for the Waitematā and Gulf ward. 'This is an ideal location : it is surrounded by many currently struggling hospitality businesses on both Ponsonby and Karangahape Rds, who will be very happy to invite the 800 new office and retail tenants of this project to the area, within easy walking distance to the future Karanga-a-Hape Station, on many bus routes, and the growing cycleway network. Such a high-quality new building will support further growth in an area perfectly suited for it. It sets such a high standard, that it should lead to a dynamic new reshaping of the area.' 'Urban concentration is essential, as is high environmental performance and quality architecture. These are the bottom line for urban development. Not just nice to haves, but core tasks in successful city shaping. Building up in the right places to a high design standard is essential, enabling this type of building is a key role for Council.' 'If I'm elected Waitematā and Gulf Councillor, I will actively encourage more high quality developments like this one. It's important that Auckland Council doesn't get in the way of progress that creates new, well-designed future-focused living and working options for Aucklanders in the most appropriate locations.'
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Nod for plan to turn quarry into sections
A plan to turn a quarry into more than 500 new residential sections can go ahead, the Environment Court having given its qualified consent for plan change 21. Fulton Hogan sought the plan change to rezone 120ha of land at Parkburn Quarry, about 12km from Cromwell, to allow a range of urban zoning, as the quarry is nearing the end of its life. In February last year, the panel of two independent commissioners, Gary Rae and Rosalind Day-Cleavin, together with Central Otago district councillor Ian Cooney, heard Fulton Hogan wanted to convert its Parkburn Quarry, which borders Pisa Moorings to the west, into 543 lots for residential settlement. There would also be a retail area and industrial zone. In September Central Otago district councillors accepted the recommendation of the independent hearings panel to allow the plan change. However, a late appeal was received in November from Pisa Village Development Ltd, on the final day of the appeal period, centring on two pieces of land owned by the appellant which would be affected by the plan change decision. Central Otago Mayor Tamah Alley said the secret was out — Central Otago was the place to live and work, which was putting huge pressure on the region's housing stock. However, it was important there was a coherent plan for development. A big part of the council's work was to ensure land was available for development but not in a ''higgledy-piggledy mess''. As towns grew and expanded into what was rural, vineyard or orchard land it was important to make sure the expansion was in keeping with the reasons people came here in the first place, Mrs Alley said. The Environment Court decision ordered the district council to amend its district plan with conditions related to water and wastewater treatment and access to SH6. Most of the development in the low-density residential area will not go ahead until the Cromwell wastewater treatment plant has been upgraded, the Cromwell and Pisa Moorings water schemes combined and a regional council water-take consent issued. An alternate option would be to have relevant consents obtained to privately service the area with a communal supply designed to enable connection to a public network when available. There is also a restriction on the distance from SH6 construction will be allowed. In the low-density residential and medium-density residential zones there could be up to 559 sections once NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi approves changes to SH6 including a left-turn lane and priority-controlled intersection or single land roundabout. Further expansion of the subdivision would depend on greater changes being made to access from SH6, including a dual-lane roundabout. At the consent hearing in February HWR, an Invercargill-based company, which operates a quarry to the north of the Fulton Hogan site, supported the plan change. Bonisch Consultants planner Christine McMillan said HWR was also considering what to do at the end of its quarry's life and intended to repurpose it similarly.
NZ Herald
3 days ago
- NZ Herald
New York's business elite is tapping funding to try to thwart the Democratic nominee for mayor
A month after Mamdani's primary victory stunned New York's business elite, its leaders have begun cranking open a powerful gusher of outside spending to try to stop the man whose socialist policies they fear could sour the city's business climate. But with fewer than 100 days to go, they are still very much searching for a unified plan that could work. On Tuesday, the men whose companies run the Seagram Building and Hudson Yards joined the call for one anti-Mamdani super PAC, while leaders of a different super PAC invited donors to a US$1000-per-person fundraiser scheduled for today. 'Fighting Mamdani is expensive,' the organiser, Betsy McCaughey, a former Republican lieutenant governor, wrote on the invitation. 'But allowing him to win will cost you more.' All told, there are already at least five groups jockeying to claim a reservoir of potentially tens of millions of dollars — each with their own leaders and goals. Several more groups are said to be in various stages of formation, including a campaign to register and mobilise anti-Mamdani voters that is likely to be run by Lisa Blau, an investor married to the chief executive of Related Cos., the developer of Hudson Yards. Others involve Republican allies of United States President Donald Trump and a reality TV star who is a friend of Mayor Eric Adams. Corporate leaders — some of whom already contend that Mamdani's past support for defunding the police, which he has disavowed, could destabilise the city — may only find more motivation to donate to defeat him after a deadly shooting in midtown Manhattan sent the staff of the NFL, Rudin Management, and Blackstone into lockdown. 'This tragedy is not just a moment of mourning; it's a call to reject policies that would make our city even more vulnerable,' said Jared Epstein, a real estate executive who co-hosted a fundraising call with 200 potential donors for New Yorkers for a Better Future last week. It remains far from clear if the anti-Mamdani forces can find a successful path, especially when the opposition is divided among several more moderate candidates: Adams; former Governor Andrew Cuomo; Curtis Sliwa, the Republican nominee; and Jim Walden, a lawyer. Dora Pekec, a spokesperson for the Mamdani campaign, predicted that the donors, whom she described as 'Maga billionaires who spent millions trying to defeat Zohran in the primary', would again fail. 'New Yorkers are ready to turn the page on endless corruption and backroom deals,' she said. Mamdani, 33, has moved to meet his critics face to face. He has scheduled a meeting with Jed Walentas, the Two Trees executive who leads the Real Estate Board of New York, and the board's president, James Whelan, according to two people involved in the effort. It will follow meetings with other corporate executives whom he has tried to mollify. A recent poll paid for by the board showed only long-shot paths to victory for Cuomo and for Adams, who opted out of the Democratic primary after the Trump Administration abandoned his federal corruption indictment. The poll, which has not been previously reported, showed that more than 60% of New York voters view the mayor negatively, and more than 50% view Cuomo negatively, according to two people briefed on the survey. In a city where Democrats outnumber Republicans six-to-one, those numbers bode poorly for anyone challenging Mamdani. Three political consultants who have either started independent expenditure groups or have advised donors looking to fund one said they warned donors that the likelihood of defeating Mamdani is slim unless either the mayor or former governor drops out. Some of the city's wealthiest political donors appear to be holding their powder, at least for now. 'I tell everybody, don't get excited,' said John Catsimatidis, a billionaire Republican businessman, who has hosted events for Adams and Cuomo. 'Let's wait a few weeks.' Still, many of the city's business class see Mamdani, who wants to raise taxes on corporations and the wealthy to expand social services, as an existential threat and want to start fighting now. 'I'm 100% sure that this is not a money-lighting-on-fire session,' said Jason Haber, a prominent real estate broker and a longtime Democratic activist who led the fundraising call for New Yorkers for a Better Future with Epstein. His real estate listings include a US$23 million penthouse near Gramercy Park. 'Every single one of his plans will hurt the very people that he thinks it will help.' There is early evidence of cross-pollination. Both Blau and her husband, Jeff Blau, attended the call for New Yorkers for a Better Future. Lisa Blau pitched the real estate crowd on her group, whose non-profit structure she noted would allow donors to avoid timely disclosure requirements, two attendees said. And Hank Sheinkopf, a veteran Democratic consultant in the city, started his own group, Protect the Protectors, ostensibly to do the same work. In an interview, Sheinkopf disparaged other consultants for leading donors astray, but also acknowledged he was working with both McCaughey and former police commissioner Ray Kelly's PAC, Save NYC, and the pro-Adams super PAC, Empower NYC. 'The usual gaggle of members of the political industrial complex are going to grab as much cash as they can,' he said. Fix the City, a super PAC that spent US$22m for Cuomo's losing bid in the Democratic primary, plans to continue operating as a pro-Cuomo, anti-Mamdani vehicle. Empower NYC was the first super PAC directly supporting Adams, who has taken extraordinary steps to court big donors, including allowing billionaire financiers Bill Ackman and Daniel Loeb to vet his campaign manager. Abe George, a friend of Adams' and its chair, said he hopes to raise US$15m for the mayor. 'This guy survived Covid and the migrant crisis,' George said in an interview. 'Crime is down, jobs are up.' Eleonora Srugo, a friend of Adams' who stars in Netflix's Selling the City, filed paperwork this week to start another, Save the City PAC. Initially, Burger also argued for strategically supporting Adams. 'We need one of these two candidates to drop out of the race by mid-September,' Burger wrote in an email to associates. 'Tactically, we think spending money to try to move Adams in the polls helps accomplish this' by either boxing out Cuomo if Adams rises in popularity, or by persuading Adams to drop out of the race if he does not. During the meeting to promote New Yorkers for a Better Future, Aby Rosen, whose RFR Holding LLC owns the Seagram Building, took issue with that approach, according to two meeting participants. Organisers gave assurances the group would be candidate-agnostic. Rosen and Burger declined to comment for this story. Mamdani, for his part, has at least two super PACs supporting him. One has yet to report much fundraising. The other, New Yorkers for Lower Costs, has raised more than US$100,000 since the primary. This week, the group is launching a merchandise store. 'Freeze the Rent' beer koozies will retail for US$6 a pop. 'The only faction that Adams and Cuomo have successfully consolidated are Trump donors, which only deepens their unpopularity with an overwhelmingly Democratic electorate,' said Bill Neidhardt, spokesperson for New Yorkers for Lower Costs. New Yorkers for a Better Future, which only formed in July, appears to be having the most success with donors so far. Jeff Leb, an operative behind it, said he had already raised millions, though he would not give a precise total. Ricky Sandler, a financier who co-hosted Tuesday's event with Burger, has pledged US$500,000. (The pledge was first reported by Hell Gate, a local news site.) 'This isn't just another election fight; it's a stand against a risky ideology,' Leb said. 'Civic, community, and business leaders across the city aren't about to hand New York's future over to an extremist.' This article originally appeared in The New York Times. Written by: Dana Rubinstein and Nicholas Fandos Photograph by: Scott Heins ©2025 THE NEW YORK TIMES
