Federal Court reserves verdict on appeals by six men convicted of DPP's murder
Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat, who led a three-man panel, said the bench needed time to decide on the appeals and would set a date for the decision later.
Also on the panel were Court of Appeal President Tan Sri Abang Iskandar Abang Hashim and Federal Court judge Datuk Rhodzariah Bujang.
The panel resumed hearing the appeals filed by former pathologist Colonel Dr R. Kunaseegaran, 62, money lender S. Ravi Chandran, 54; and unemployed persons, R. Dinishwaran, 33; A.K. Thinesh Kumar, 32; M. Vishwanath, 35; and S. Nimalan, 32.
The proceedings follow earlier hearings held on March 13 and April 23 this year.
The six appellants were found guilty and sentenced to death by the Kuala Lumpur High Court in July 2020 for the murder of Morais, 55.
The Court of Appeal dismissed their appeals on March 14 last year and upheld the convictions and death sentences. They subsequently appealed to the Federal Court.
The murder took place at a location along Jalan Dutamas Raya Sentul and Jalan USJ 1/6D, Subang Jaya, between 7 am and 8 pm on September 4, 2015.
Morais was last seen leaving in a Proton Perdana Car from his Menara Duta condominium, Kuala Lumpur, to his office at the Attorney-General's Chambers in Putrajaya. His body was found in a concrete-filled drum at Persiaran Subang Mewah, Subang Jaya, on September 16 of the same year.
During the proceedings today, Deputy Public Prosecutor Datuk Yusaini Amer Abdul Karim urged the court to reject the submission by Nimalan's lawyer to adopt the 'dual crimes principle' applied in Singapore for cases involving a single incident.
He said the principles laid down in the Singapore cases of Daniel Vijay Katherasan and others v PP (2010) and PP v Azlin Bte Arjunah and others (2022) are not binding on Malaysian courts as they would make it more difficult to prove crimes committed by groups and could result in offenders escaping punishment.
Yusaini said there was forensic evidence linking Nimalan to the crime and that he was also the one who provided information that led to the discovery of the drum containing the victim's body.
He said a plastic bag recovered from the vehicle driven by Nimalan was found to contain the deceased's DNA, while a T-shirt contained DNA from Nimalan, Ravi Chandran, and the deceased.
'Based on all the evidence presented, we submit that the sixth accused (Nimalan) clearly acted in furtherance of a common intention to commit the murder,' said Yusaini.
In response, lawyer Amer Hamzah Arshad, representing Nimalan, urged the court to consider the dual crime principle as evidence showed that the discussion held a day before the incident only discussed abducting Morais and not killing him.
He said Nimalan should not have been charged with murder, but only with abduction or disposing of evidence. — BERNAMA
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malaysian Reserve
2 hours ago
- Malaysian Reserve
Chinese national assaults KLIA immigration officer
A CHINESE national was arrested at the Kuala Lumpur International Airport (KLIA) Terminal 1 yesterday for behaving aggressively and injuring an immigration officer during departure checks. According to Bernama, the incident occurred at around 7.40pm where the woman alongside a man and two children were at the immigration counter. The officer discovered that they had no entry records and referred the case to a supervisor for further review. A statement issued by the Border Control and Protection Agency (AKPS) explained that the suspect became upset when she was told to allow other passengers to proceed while her documents were being examined. The Chinese national then allegedly shouted abusive words at the officer, yanked her headscarf and pushed her head against a pillar in front of the counter. 'A minor scuffle broke out, and the suspect refused to calm down despite being instructed to do so. AKPS enforcement officers then called in the Aviation Security Team (AVSEC) to control the situation,' it said. The incident left the officer with swelling in her left eye, a headache on the right side of her head and body aches. She was then sent to Cyberjaya Hospital for treatment and to obtain a medical report. A police report has been filed and the suspect is currently in police custody for investigation under Section 186 of the Penal Code for obstructing a public servant, Section 332 for causing injury to a public servant and Section 353 for using criminal force against a public servant. AKPS stressed that it will not tolerate any form of violence, abuse or threats against officers on duty and expects the suspect to face appropriate legal action. Meanwhile, the Immigration Services Union Peninsular Malaysia (KPISM) strongly condemned the physical and verbal attack on the female officer. President Ajeet Singh stated that such actions undermine the sovereignty of Malaysian law and reminded tourists that they must respect the laws of any country they visit. 'Immigration officers are the frontline defenders of the nation's sovereignty. Assaulting them while on duty is not only an uncivilised act, but also tarnishes the nation's image and jeopardises security at international entry points,' he said in the statement. —TMR
Malaysiakini
2 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
Fear of losing faith in our society
COMMENT | It's quite scary to think about the incident that happened to former economy minister Rafizi Ramli's son and wife. How they were assaulted and then his son was attacked with a syringe is just something too absurd to think that it could happen in Malaysia, isn't it? It's the kind of thing that makes you want to throw your hands up in the air and ask, "What the hell is wrong with us?" Then again, I've been around for a while now, watching Malaysian politics unfold, and I've seen a lot. Political theatrics, mudslinging, character assassinations - it's all part of the show.
Daily Express
4 hours ago
- Daily Express
Expel, don't harbour bullies
Published on: Sunday, August 17, 2025 Published on: Sun, Aug 17, 2025 Text Size: SCHOOL bullying and violence have long plagued Malaysia despite nationwide outrage and repeated calls for action. Policy gaps and inconsistencies undermine efforts, allowing such behaviours to persist in learning institutions. The horrendous bullying incidents at the National Defence University of Malaysia (UPNM), one of which led to the death of a navy cadet and another causing severe injuries to a junior student, highlight the extremity of violence in educational settings. Concerningly, bullying cases now dominate news cycles, from teenagers attacked over jealousy to disputes over behaviour. The recent death of Zara Qairina, a Form One schoolgirl, has sparked renewed public debate on Malaysia's pervasive bullying culture. In the first 10 months of 2023, the Ministry of Education (MOE) recorded 4,994 bullying cases, up from 3,887 cases in 2022. Cyberbullying has also become a prominent problem, with Malaysia ranking second in Asia for cyberbullying in 2020, according to Unicef. Bullying has lifelong health ramifications for both victim and perpetrator. A systematic review found that bullying inflicts psychological harm, leading to emotional distress, loneliness, anxiety, depression, and suicidal ideation. Verbal bullying through ridiculing and name-calling remains the most prevalent due to its low risks, yet it is among the most damaging to adolescents' mental health, as it erodes victims' social identity. To cope, adolescents may turn to smoking, alcohol, or illegal drugs. In the worst case, bullying drives victims to attempt suicide. Liew et al. (2023) found that 6.9% of Malaysian school-going adolescents attempted suicide, with a four–fold risk among bullying victims compared to non-victims. Globally, being bullied at least once in the past 30 days is linked to more than triple the suicide risk. The longer the bullying continues, the greater the odds of an attempt. Although suicide among Malaysian adolescents is less prevalent than in other Asian countries, the low rate likely reflects under-reporting due to cultural, religious, and legal factors. Section 309 of the Penal Code criminalises suicide attempts, punishable by imprisonment or a fine. Bullying is also closely linked to peer aggression, exposure to violent content, and involvement in physical attacks (Wan Ismail et al., 2014; Tan et al., 2019; Sabramani et al., 2021). It often co-occurs with other conduct problems that may predict future criminal behaviour (Ganesan et al., 2021). Playing the bully can lead to behavioural problems, depression, and academic difficulties that persist into young adulthood. Sabramani et al. (2021) reported that 79.1% of Malaysian participants have been involved in bullying, with the majority as bully-victims (48.4%). Bully-victims often become bullies themselves due to weak support systems, prompting retaliation or redirection of frustrations toward more vulnerable peers. This dual role worsens their psychological challenges, as they endure both the trauma of being bullied and the strain of their own aggression. Such cases underscore the need for early victim intervention to break the cycle, alongside rehabilitative measures tailored for bully-victims. Given the substantial time adolescents spend at school, the school environment and teachers are pivotal in shaping students' experiences. Unesco notes that bullying is 7% more likely in schools with poor disciplinary climates and 12% higher where teachers treat students unfairly. Worryingly, teachers can also be perpetrators, exposing students to aggression and corporal punishment—still legal in Malaysia. Conversely, teacher guidance and support are essential in prevention, with a 49% to 53% likelihood of reducing student involvement in bullying. Adolescents also reported higher life satisfaction when supported by teachers, even after experiencing bullying (Chong et al., 2023). Unlike Singapore, China, and the Philippines, Malaysia has no state-level anti-bullying laws and no statutory definition of bullying. Current measures include the Guidelines for Bullying and Sexual Harassment Management and 2024 amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code and Penal Code outlawing acts that cause distress, fear, or harassment. Yet experts stress the need for specific laws, noting disproportionate punishments for verbal and non-verbal bullying. Tackling school bullying in Malaysia requires enforcement mechanisms as strong as its prevention strategies. Policies must deliver deterrence, ensure fair investigations, and close the loopholes that allow cases, especially in elite schools, to be suppressed. Emir Research recommends: Automatic expulsion with mandatory rehabilitation before re-entry. For serious or repeated bullying, students should be immediately removed from their current school. Re-enrolment in any mainstream institution should only be permitted after completing a certified behavioural intervention programme. A centralised MOE registry should track offenders to ensure compliance and prevent quiet transfers that bypass accountability. Independent investigation panels for serious cases. Establish regional inquiry boards consisting of MOE officials, legal representatives, and independent child rights advocates to oversee severe incidents. This reduces internal cover-ups, particularly in institutions with influential stakeholders, and ensures impartial decision-making. Enact comprehensive anti-bullying legislation: Define physical, verbal, relational, and cyberbullying in law. Require all MOE-registered institutions to have enforceable anti-bullying policies, detailing penalties, safe reporting procedures, and clear timelines for response. Evidence shows such laws reduce victimisation, depression, and suicidal behaviours among students. (Rees et al., 2022). Secure and direct reporting channels. All institutions must maintain anonymous, tamper-proof reporting systems, online portals or physical drop boxes, directly linked to investigation bodies. Malaysia's existing anti-bullying portal should be replaced with a dedicated national platform that automatically connects victims to police, counsellors, and child protection services, as Emir Research has recommended previously (see 'Child Bullying—When Will it End?'). Whistleblower protection and anti-interference laws. Criminalise any attempt to intimidate, bribe, or obstruct a bullying investigation. Protect students, teachers, and staff who report incidents from retaliation, with legal immunity where appropriate. School-based mental health screening and counselling. Psychological challenges, including depression, anxiety, low self-esteem, and loneliness, are both causes and effects of bullying (Sabramani et al., 2021; Ariani et al., 2025). Conduct bi-annual screenings to identify at-risk students. Partner with certified mental health professionals to deliver evidence-based interventions, focusing on both victims and perpetrators to break cycles of violence. Prevention and rehabilitation education. Embed bullying prevention in the national curriculum, including conflict resolution, empathy-building, and media literacy. Develop targeted rehabilitation programmes for offenders, with monitored reintegration into school communities. Educator training and accountability. Weak teacher training is a serious risk factor for bullying (Gusfre et al., 2023). Require teachers to complete specialised training in classroom management, non-violent discipline, early detection of bullying, and proper incident reporting. Establish consequences for staff who fail to act on reported cases. Strengthen on-campus security. Deploy trained security personnel and wardens in schools and dormitories, with daily patrols in known hotspots such as bathrooms and secluded areas. Parental and community engagement. Engage parents in early-warning and prevention initiatives and collaborate with NGOs, youth groups, and faith-based organisations to extend anti-bullying campaigns into communities. Mandatory transparency reporting. Require all schools to publish anonymised quarterly data on bullying incidents, investigation outcomes, and measures taken, consolidated into an annual national report by the MOE. Without decisive enforcement and sustained prevention, victims will remain voiceless in the very institutions meant to safeguard them, while perpetrators, often shielded by influence or inaction, continue without consequence. Breaking this cycle demands more than statements of concern: Malaysia must pair strict, enforceable laws with independent oversight, embed mental health and rehabilitation into the heart of its education system, and close every loophole that allows bullying to be minimised or ignored. Failure to act decisively will not only invite more preventable tragedies but also deepen public distrust in the nation's commitment to protect its children. Only by holding every school, teacher, parent, and student accountable can we create learning environments where safety is non-negotiable and respect is the norm. Dr Margarita Peredaryenko and Avyce Heng. (Part of the research team at Emir Research, an independent think tank focused on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research). The views expressed here are the views of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of the Daily Express. If you have something to share, write to us at: [email protected]
