CCI found global ad agencies colluded on fees, document shows
HighlightsThe Competition Commission of India discovered that global advertising agencies engaged in price-fixing by coordinating commission structures charged to advertisers. Surprise raids were conducted by the Competition Commission of India at the offices of major advertising agencies, including GroupM, Interpublic, Publicis, and Dentsu, as part of an investigation into alleged cartel behavior. The investigation is expected to have significant implications for India's advertising market, which is valued at $18.5 billion, following recent industry changes such as the merger between Walt Disney and Reliance's media assets.
India's antitrust body found that global ad agencies breached laws by coordinating on commissions they charge advertisers, prompting the watchdog's raids on advertising and media companies in March, according to a document which sheds new light on the investigation into the media sector.
The
Competition Commission of India
conducted surprise raids in March at the local offices of ad agencies WPP-owned
GroupM
, Interpublic, Publicis and Dentsu and at the offices of an Indian broadcasters' body and an association of advertising companies.
A CCI document dated February 7 and seen by Reuters on Friday sheds new light on allegations that three separate cartels operated through three different industry groups: the Indian Society of Advertisers (ISA), Advertising Agencies Association of India (AAAI) and Indian Broadcasting and Digital Foundation (IBDF).
Before the raids, the CCI document said, it reviewed evidence that showed the alleged misconduct was prevalent since at least 2023, and advertising agencies exchanged commercially sensitive information on WhatsApp groups and agreed to adhere to pre-decided commission structures.
"AAAI and its members are in contravention" of competition laws, the CCI noted in its initial review, while ordering the investigation which triggered the March raids, the document said.
AAAI also often organised virtual meetings among members to align on prices and responses to be shared with clients, and discussed "retaliatory action" against members who don't follow such guidelines, the document said.
The group "also fixed the formula for fee in case of fee-based service to advertisers," CCI said.
The groups - AAAI which represents GroupM, Dentsu and Publicis, ISA which counts dozens of Indian and foreign companies as members, and the IBDF group of broadcasters - did not respond to Reuters queries.
The CCI also did not respond to a request for comment.
The CCI does not publicly disclose any details of price fixing investigations. Reuters reported in March that the allegations relate to collusion between media buying agencies and broadcasters, and the case was triggered after Dentsu made disclosures under a whistleblower-type federal programme.
The raids cast a shadow on India's fast-growing media and broadcast sector which counts Reliance-Disney and Sony as top players, and could alter how ads are priced and sold in the country.
Detailing the allegations, the CCI document said the advertisers "established a buyer's cartel", while the broadcasters who provide channels separately engaged in "collective action to refrain from giving discounts" to clients.
Another cartel "exists in the media segment of advertising agencies and attempts are underway" to establish a cartel in its creative business segment, the CCI added.
The three industry groups also "coordinate their activities and indulge in collective negotiations ... on issues which should ideally be negotiated independently," it added.
"The respective industry association appear to evolve guidelines, advisories or negotiation parameters ... to secure the commercial interests of their members," it added.
In recent weeks, AAAI privately asked its members to avoid discussions over pricing during meetings, where the group's legal adviser must be present, Reuters has reported.
The investigation comes amid major shifts in India's advertising landscape following last year's $8.5 billion merger between Walt Disney and Reliance's Indian media assets, which is estimated to have a 40% share of the ad market in TV and streaming segments.
India is the world's eighth-biggest ad market, where revenues stood at $18.5 billion last year, GroupM estimates.
The CCI investigation is likely to continue for several months before final findings are issued.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
38 minutes ago
- Mint
Indian airlines having more planes provide rationale for investments: AI chief Campbell Wilson
New Delhi, Jun 1 (PTI) Indian carriers having more planes in their fleets provides businesses a rationale to invest in the country's aviation space as there will be a local market as well as an export market for services and support, according to Air India chief Campbell Wilson. In an interview to PTI, Wilson said there is a lot of interest in India and a lot of people are keen to partner with Air India. "There is an air about India". The country's aviation industry directly employs 3,69,700 people and generates USD 5.6 billion of GDP. When indirect, induced and tourism impacts are included, the total rises to 7.7 million jobs and USD 53.6 billion of GDP (1.5 per cent), as per global airlines' grouping IATA, which is holding its annual general meeting in India after a gap of 42 years. "There is a lot of confidence people are drawing from the transformation of Air India but also Indian aviation. (People are more) willing to invest in India. "The fact that there is going to be a much more sizeable Indian-domiciled fleet gives all sorts of businesses a rationale to invest because there is a local market in addition to an export market for services and support. So, surely the interest is coming and I think the benefits will accrue in the years to come," the Air India CEO and MD said. More than 2,500 civil aircraft are expected to come into India in the next 20 years. Air India and IndiGo have placed orders for more than 1,000 planes in recent years. The Tata Group-owned Air India is also in the middle of a five-year transformation plan. Wilson also stressed that there is a healthy competition in India among airlines. While emphasising that there is an air about India, Wilson, who has been helming Air India for nearly three years, also said the country is having an increasing say and an increasing share of voice at the OEMs (Original Equipment Manufacturers). "The biggest aircraft orders in history have been made by the Indian carriers in the last couple of years. India is a large market and by far, the fastest growing large market in the world," he said. On Friday, IATA Director General Willie Walsh said India's place in global aviation has changed dramatically, particularly over the last decade. The country has seen record aircraft orders, impressive growth, and world-class infrastructure developments, he added. The International Air Transport Association (IATA) represents about 350 airlines comprising over 80 per cent of the global air traffic.
Mint
38 minutes ago
- Mint
Air India in talks with Boeing, Airbus for ‘major' 200 narrow-body aircraft order: Report
NEW DELHI (Reuters) -Tata Group's Air India is in talks with Airbus and Boeing for a major new aircraft order including some 200 extra single-aisle planes, topping up a mammoth deal in 2023 as the former state carrier pursues a multi-billion revamp, industry sources said. The order discussions, which two of the sources said could involve hundreds of airplanes in total spread across various sizes, expand on previously reported discussions for a further batch of large wide-body aircraft, they told Reuters. Air India, Boeing and Airbus all declined comment. Word of a potential new blockbuster order from India's flag carrier emerged as global airline bosses gathered in the world's fastest-growing aviation market for an industry summit to be addressed by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday. Air India placed a then-record order for 470 planes from both suppliers in 2023 and another 100 Airbus jets last year. The back-to-back plane orders come at a time when aircraft manufacturers are scrambling with supply chain issues leading to severe delays in aircraft delivery and a looming jet shortage. Getting new planes is crucial for Air India, which has suffered from years of under-investment under government ownership and is now undertaking an ambitious modernisation plan to recapture market share lost to global rivals. The exact number of narrowbody jets under the new order was not immediately clear but two sources put it in the hundreds and one said it involved a provisional total of 200 narrow-body planes, which are the workhorse of aviation fleets worldwide. (Reporting by Tim Hepher, Aditi Shah, Rajesh Kumar Singh; Editing by Elaine Hardcastle and Sophie Walker)
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
RBI likely to cut repo rate by 25 bps on June 6 amid low inflation, say experts
NEW DELHI: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is likely to announce a third consecutive 25 basis points (bps) rate cut on June 6, amid easing inflation and global economic uncertainty driven by US tariff actions. With consumer price inflation remaining below the 4 per cent median target, experts believe the move would support growth during a period of external volatility, according to a PTI report. The Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), the RBI's rate-setting panel, will begin deliberations on the next bi-monthly policy on June 4. The decision is scheduled to be announced on Friday, June 6. Following 25 bps repo rate cuts in both February and April, which brought the key policy rate down to 6 per cent, the six-member MPC, led by RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra, also changed its policy stance from 'neutral' to 'accommodative' in April. The central bank has now reduced the policy repo rate by a cumulative 50 bps in 2025 so far, prompting multiple banks to lower their External Benchmark Lending Rates (EBLRs) and Marginal Cost of Funds-Based Lending Rates (MCLR). "We do believe that given the rather benign inflation conditions and the liquidity situation which has been made very comfortable through various measures of the RBI, the MPC would go in for a 25 bps cut in the repo rate on the (June) 6th. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch vàng CFDs với sàn môi giới tin cậy IC Markets Tìm hiểu thêm Undo The commentary on both growth and inflation will be important as there are expectations of revisions in their forecasts for both the parameters," said Madan Sabnavis, chief economist, Bank of Baroda. He also expects the RBI to provide detailed insight into global factors affecting the Indian economy, especially in light of the expiration of US tariff relief in July. ICRA's chief economist, Aditi Nayar, also projects continued monetary easing through the year, as CPI inflation is forecast to remain below 4 per cent for most of the fiscal. "A 25 bps rate cut is expected next week, followed by two more cuts over the subsequent two policy reviews, taking the repo rate to 5.25 per cent by the end of the cycle," she said. The RBI's annual report, released on Thursday reiterated the central bank's plan to manage liquidity operations in line with the prevailing monetary policy stance, ensuring sufficient liquidity for the productive sectors of the economy. The government has mandated the RBI to maintain CPI-based retail inflation at 4 per cent, with a flexibility band of plus or minus 2 per cent. Assocham Secretary General Manish Singhal also supported the case for easing, citing multi-year low inflation and overall positive macroeconomic indicators. "Though the INR is likely to come under depreciation pressure in the short term, especially if global interest rates (e.g. in the US) remain elevated, its impact will depend on the changes in global risk appetite, crude oil prices and the Fed's own monetary stance. We emphasize the importance of strategic patience over aggressive easing, given the current environment of steady growth and manageable inflation," said Singhal. Echoing similar sentiments, Signature Global founder and chairman Pradeep Aggarwal expressed hope that the RBI would offer relief to homebuyers with a rate cut. "Given that several scheduled commercial banks have been reducing their lending rates following the previous two RBI MPC outcomes, another rate cut at this juncture would act as a catalyst for increased housing demand across segments. As a result, both first-time homebuyers and investors are likely to be encouraged to enter the real estate market, further strengthening demand across the sector," Aggarwal said. Also read: RBI slaps Rs 54.78 crore in penalties on banks and NBFCs for compliance lapses in FY25 An article in the RBI's May Bulletin highlighted that domestic bond yields have declined to multi-year lows, aided by back-to-back policy rate cuts and liquidity-enhancing measures. The report noted that monetary and credit conditions are evolving in line with the RBI's accommodative policy approach, aiming to bring inflation in line with targets while bolstering growth. India's GDP growth is estimated to have dipped to a four-year low of 6.5 per cent in FY 2024–25. Meanwhile, retail inflation in April 2025 eased to 3.16 per cent- the lowest year-on-year print since July 2019. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
