logo
Bob Carr says Aukus a ‘colossal surrender of sovereignty' if submarines do not arrive under Australian control

Bob Carr says Aukus a ‘colossal surrender of sovereignty' if submarines do not arrive under Australian control

The Guardian19-03-2025

Australia faces a 'colossal surrender of sovereignty' if promised US nuclear-powered submarines do not arrive under Australian control, former foreign affairs minister Bob Carr has said, arguing the US is 'utterly not a reliable ally' to Australia.
'It's inevitable we're not getting them,' Carr told the Guardian, ahead of the release of a report from Australians for War Powers Reform that argues the multibillion-dollar Aukus deal had been imposed upon Australia without sufficient public or parliamentary scrutiny.
'The evidence is mounting that we're not going to get Virginia-class subs from the United States,' Carr said, 'for the simple reason they're not building enough for their own needs and will not, in the early 2030s, be peeling off subs from their own navy to sell to us.'
Under 'pillar one' of the planned Aukus arrangement, it is proposed the US would sell Australia between three and five of its Virginia-class nuclear-powered submarines in the early 2030s before the Aukus-class submarines were built, first in the UK, then in Australia.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
However, the US has already forecast it might not have capacity to spare any of its Virginia-class boats, the Congressional Research Service instead floating a proposal in which: 'instead of … them being sold to Australia, these additional boats would instead be retained in US Navy service and operated out of Australia'.
Carr said that alternative would leave Australia without Australian-flagged submarines and no control of when, and to where, those boats were deployed.
'It involves the total loss of any sovereign submarine capacity and, more than that, a colossal surrender of Australian sovereignty in general.'
Australia, Carr said, needed to look past the 'cheerful flag-waving propaganda' of the proclaimed Aukus deal, saying the alternative likely to be presented by the US would leave Australia 'totally integrated in American defence planning and we'll be hosting even more potential nuclear targets'.
Australians for War Powers Reform, a group that advocates for parliamentary oversight of the decision to send Australian troops to war, launched a report on Thursday morning arguing that the Aukus deal – signed by the Morrison government in 2021 and adopted by its Albanese-led successor – had been instituted without any public or parliamentary scrutiny.
'The public and the national parliament have been kept in the dark every step of the way,' the report argues.
'The Aukus pact has become a textbook example of how to disenfranchise the community, providing almost no transparency or democracy in a sweeping decision which will affect Australia for decades.'
Aukus and the Surrender of Transparency, Accountability and Sovereignty argues the multi-decade, multibillion-dollar Aukus deal was presented to the Australian public without any discussion, consultation, and without parliamentary debate. The current forecast cost of 'pillar one' of Aukus – to buy US Virginia-class submarines and build Aukus subs – is $368bn to the 2050s.
The report raises concerns over vague 'political commitments' offered by Australia in exchange for the Aukus deal, as well as practical concerns such as where and how nuclear waste would be stored in Australia.
'Aukus has no legitimate social licence because the public has been shut out of the process, and as a result, scepticism and cynicism have increased.'
Dr Alison Broinowski, AWPR committee member and a former Australian diplomat, said Australia's agreement to the Aukus deal was manifestation of a structural flaw in Australia's democracy, where decisions to go to war, or to make consequential defence decisions, were not subject to parliamentary scrutiny or public debate.
Broinowski said Aukus was acutely significant because of its size and potential consequence 'and yet the same failure to be frank with the people characterises every government this country has had, during every war there's been'.
She argued Australia had no control over Aukus. 'We don't know what Trump's going to do and we have no control over what he does. And so we're left hoping for the best, fearing the worst and with absolutely no way of controlling or influencing what happens, unless we first get ourselves out of Aukus.'
The Australian Submarine Agency's Aukus strategy, released this month, said the optimal Aukus pathway would see US boats sold to Australia 'from the early 2030s'. The strategy argues Australia's acquisition of conventionally armed nuclear-powered submarines would represent 'one of the most consequential endeavours' in Australia's history, 'at a time when our nation faces the most challenging strategic circumstances since the second world war'.
'An Australian submarine industrial base capable of delivering a persistent, potent and sovereign multi-class submarine capability is vital to the defence of Australia.'
Welcoming a rotation of US marines to the Northern Territory this week, the defence minister, Richard Marles, said the Australian defence force continued to work closely with the US: 'The power of our alliance with the United States is a testament to our shared dedication to fostering a secure, stable and inclusive Indo-Pacific.'
But Carr, the foreign affairs minister between 2012 and 2013, said the Aukus deal highlighted the larger issue of American unreliability in its security alliance with Australia.
'The US is utterly not a reliable ally. No one could see it in those terms,' he said.
'[President] Trump is wilful and cavalier and so is his heir-apparent, JD Vance: they are laughing at alliance partners, whom they've almost studiously disowned.'
Carr said America had been fundamentally altered by Trump's second administration and that American leadership of a rules-based international order was 'not returning'.
'The speed of America disowning allies to embrace a new world order where it cuts deals with Russia and China has been so astonishing that people are struggling to grasp it, especially in this country, where people just cannot contemplate a world where America treats so lightly its alliance with Australia.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Greta Thunberg deported from Israel after military intercepts Gaza-bound aid boat
Greta Thunberg deported from Israel after military intercepts Gaza-bound aid boat

NBC News

time5 hours ago

  • NBC News

Greta Thunberg deported from Israel after military intercepts Gaza-bound aid boat

Greta Thunberg was deported from Israel on Tuesday, the country's foreign ministry said, the day after she and other activists were detained while trying to deliver a symbolic shipment of aid to Gaza by sea. In a post on X, the Israeli foreign ministry said that Thunberg, 22, had 'just departed Israel on a flight to Sweden' via France, and shared images her sitting on a plane. That came after the ministry said in a statement that a number of people detained by Israel aboard the intercepted British-flagged yacht Madleen had arrived at Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion International Airport to 'return to their home countries.' Thunberg was among 12 activists undertaking the journey to attempt to circumvent Israel's aid blockade of Gaza when they were stopped by the Israeli navy and brought ashore at the port of Ashdod. The foreign ministry statement added that those activists who refused to sign deportation papers and leave Israel would be brought before a judicial authority 'to authorize their deportation.' Adalah, the legal center for Arab minority rights in Israel, said in a statement Monday that it had met with 11 of the 12 people detained following the Madleen's interception before some of them, who consented to deportation, flew out of Tel Aviv. It said at least four people had been deported or were being deported from Israel, while eight remained in detention at Givon Prison in Ramla and planned to contest their deportation before an Israeli tribunal. They were expected to appear before the Immigration Detention Review Tribunal on Tuesday morning. The Madleen, dubbed the 'Freedom Flotilla' by activists, departed Sicily earlier this month in a bid to break Israel's naval blockade which has been in place since 2007, when Hamas rose to power in the Gaza Strip, and deliver aid to Palestinians. The vessel departed as Israel allowed a trickle of aid into Gaza after lifting a widely-condemned blockade that had barred the entry of food, medicine and other vital supplies for more than two months. In a post on X, an account run by Israel's foreign affairs ministry said that more than 1,200 aid trucks had entered Gaza from Israel 'within the past two weeks,' with just over 10 million meals distributed from aid sites run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, the group tasked with distributing food in the enclave under a controversial new system. Gaza has a population of around 2.1 million people, so those meals over the course of two weeks would equate to roughly a third of a meal per day for each member of the population. Before the war, more than 500 trucks had been entering Gaza daily, according to the British Red Cross and other humanitarian groups. Thunberg, a climate activist, said the mission was essential amid global silence on Israel's actions in Gaza. The Madleen was also carrying Thiago Ávila, a Brazilian activist and politician; Rima Hassan, a French member of the European Parliament; and Baptiste André, a French doctor who traveled with the group to assist passengers injured in any potential confrontations with Israeli forces. Adalah said Ávila and Hassan were among the eight people still detained, with André among those deported. The yacht was intercepted Monday, with video posted by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition showing the activists onboard raising their hands as lights flashed from boats surrounding the vessel. Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz said he had instructed the military to 'screen the October 7 massacre video to the flotilla passengers upon their arrival at Ashdod Port.' Israel launched its offensive in Gaza following the Hamas-led Oct. 7 terror attacks, in which some 1,200 people were killed and around 250 taken hostage in a major escalation in a decadeslong conflict. Since then, more than 54,000 people have been killed in Gaza, including thousands of children, according to the Palestinian health ministry in Gaza.

David Lammy urged to intervene as Madleen seized by Israel
David Lammy urged to intervene as Madleen seized by Israel

The National

time5 hours ago

  • The National

David Lammy urged to intervene as Madleen seized by Israel

Israel has said it has begun to deport 12 activists whose Gaza-bound aid boat was seized in the Mediterranean on Monday. Israel's Foreign Ministry shared a photo of crew member Greta Thunberg on a plane, saying that she was heading for France before continuing to Sweden. The Madleen was also carrying French member of the European Parliament, Rima Hassan. Adalah, a legal rights group in Israel representing Thunberg and the other activists, said the Swede, two other campaigners, and a journalist had agreed to be deported, but other activists who refused deportation were being held in detention, with their case set to be heard by Israeli authorities. READ MORE: Freedom Flotilla gives statement as Israel 'illegally seizes' Madleen Apsana Begum, who was suspended from Labour after she voted against keeping the two-child benefit cap last year, has written David Lammy saying it is a "matter of urgency" that the UK upholds its responsibilities to protect UK-flagged ships. She added the UK must fulfil its obligations under international law and protect those on-board to prevent "unlawful interference, such as threats or use of force by a foreign power". Her letter said: "A UNHRC report into Israel's interception of a similar aid vessel in 2010 set out evidence of 'wilful killing' and an 'unacceptable level of brutality', concluding that a 'serious of violations of international law, including international humanitarian and human rights law were committed by Israeli forces during the interception of the flotilla and during the detention of passengers in Israel prior to deportation'. (Image: House of Commons) "It was particularly disturbing that in 2010, nine of those on board the ship were killed, and 30 more were wounded." She went on: "I urge you as Foreign Secretary to take immediate action to ensure that Israel, the UK's ally, ceases any hostility towards this UK unarmed civilian vessel, acts in accordance with its international obligations and ensures the human rights and safety of everyone on board." Israeli naval forces seized the boat early on Monday about 125 miles off Gaza's coast. It had been in international waters sailing under a UK red ensign, meaning it was under UK jurisdiction. After being illegally seized, the boat arrived in the Israeli port of Ashdod on Monday evening. The activists were attempting to deliver a "symbolic" amount of aid to Gaza in defiance of Israel's naval blockade to highlight the humanitarian crisis there. READ MORE: 'Good case' Israel breached international law with Madleen seizure Israel's Foreign Ministry tried to portray the voyage as a public relations stunt, saying on social media that 'the 'selfie yacht' of the 'celebrities' is safely making its way to the shores of Israel'. Sabine Haddad, a spokesperson for Israel's Interior Ministry, said the activists who were being deported on Tuesday had waived their right to appear before a judge. Those who did not will face one and will be held for 96 hours before being deported. French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot said on Tuesday that one of the detained French activists signed an expulsion order and will leave Israel on Tuesday for France. The other five refused. He said all the activists received consular visits. Adalah said that Israel had 'no legal authority' to take over the ship because the group said it was in international waters and it was headed not to Israel but to the 'territorial waters of the state of Palestine'. Amnesty International said Israel was flouting international law with the naval raid. Heidi Matthews, a professor specialising in international criminal law at York University in Toronto, Canada, told The National that as the naval blockade on Gaza is 'unlawful', there are several points of law that the Israeli forces have breached by capturing the Madleen. As well as France and Sweden, citizens of Brazil, Germany, the Netherlands, Spain and Turkey were on board the Madleen. The Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC), the activist group operating the yacht, said in a statement on Monday night that it expected any of the passengers who refused the deportation orders to be transferred to Ramle prison, near Tel Aviv. The FFC said the Madleen was carrying baby formula, food, medicine. Israel says its blockade on Gaza is necessary to prevent weapons from reaching Hamas fighters there. On Sunday, Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz warned that Israel would act against any attempt to breach the blockade. The FFC has argued that the sea blockade is illegal, characterising Katz's statement as an example of Israel threatening the unlawful use of force against civilians and "attempting to justify that violence with smears". The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office has been contacted for comment.

Scots climate activist speaks on capture of Gaza aid boat
Scots climate activist speaks on capture of Gaza aid boat

The Herald Scotland

time5 hours ago

  • The Herald Scotland

Scots climate activist speaks on capture of Gaza aid boat

He said: 'A lot of my friends are involved with the flotilla, so I came to support them. I wanted to be there physically and to obviously help with logistics and anything I could. 'The aid that I was primarily helping with was from locals in Catania, which was incredibly moving. We had so much donated from the locals, more than we could fit in the boat, so that was donated to the local refugee shelter.' Dylan Hamilton, pictured at COP28. (Image: Dylan Hamilton) Dylan described his emotions as the UK-flagged yacht left the safety of Sicily and set out across the Mediterranean. He said: 'We followed the boat out of the harbour. But then obviously we came back and it was quite an odd feeling. 'It was quite a difficult week because you know something is going to happen, you know, roughly when it will happen, but you don't know what.' Early on Monday morning, members of the Israeli military boarded the vessel, detaining 12 passengers including well-known climate activist Greta Thunberg. The campaigners were taken to Ashdod Port in Israel, where they were shown video footage of the October 7th Hamas terror attacks, which killed around 1200 Israelis. 'The raid happened a bit earlier than I expected,' Dylan said. 'They were still in international waters, around 150 miles from Gaza. 'They've been in touch with lawyers in Israel who support the cause but we didn't hear anything from them for 18 hours.' Dylan added: 'It's been an incredibly difficult experience. I'm very, very worried that the people that I love are in custody with a genocidal army, but then that is a daily experience for Palestinians. 'They don't get to sit like me at home, completely safe and worry about it. They worry about their families while they wait for another evacuation order as the bombs fall around them.' Greta Thunberg was among 12 activists who were detained. (Image: Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs/X) Another boat organised by the 'Freedom Flotilla Coalition', dubbed the 'Conscience', was alleged attacked by drones in international waters off the coast of Malta last month. Dylan believes the presence of high-profile campaigners prevented the Madleen from suffering a similar fate. 'It has obviously been the boat's protection because when they had a media blackout, they got bombed before they ever left. And whereas this time we've had all of this media and international attention, and as far as we know, nobody's been hurt on the boat.' In a post on X early Tuesday morning, the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs said the activists were in the process of being deported. The post read: 'The passengers of the 'Selfie Yacht' arrived at Ben Gurion Airport to depart from Israel and return to their home countries. Some of the 'Selfie Yacht' passengers are expected to leave within the next few hours. 'Those who refuse to sign deportation documents and leave Israel will be brought before a judicial authority, in accordance with Israeli law, to authorize their deportation. Consuls from the passengers' home countries met them at the airport.' Read more: Palestine demo held over 'unlawful' detention of activists on UK-flagged yacht 'Children are seeing corpses in the street': Aid worker describes Gaza devastation Glasgow Film Theatre praised by pro-Israel lobby group over BDS vote Dylan said he hopes the widespread media attention will help people understand what people in Palestine are experiencing. He told The Herald: 'I think this has moved people because it is familiar faces that they know, especially Greta, but ultimately I hope that that translates into a deeper understanding of what Palestinians have gone through. 'The point of the mission was to feed Palestinians and try and ensure that we can do as much as we can to limit the starvation. But ultimately the key goal is to free Palestine. 'This should never have been a possible position, one country should not be able to do this to another and that's the central focus.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store