Labour-run council plans £41m revamp of ‘soon to be obsolete' town hall
A Labour-run council is pressing on with plans to blow £41m on refurbishing a 'soon to be obsolete' town hall.
Cambridge City Council has already committed £4m of taxpayers' money to a consultation for a revamp of the Guildhall.
Yet under Labour's plans to merge two-tier councils into a single unitary authority, Cambridge City may cease to exist from 2028.
Naomi Bennett, Green party councillor, told The Telegraph: 'The project was completely disproportionate even before we knew about the reorganisation plan.
'It's a speculative passion project on a building which may soon be obsolete.'
In December Angela Rayner revealed plans to scrap district councils and create so-called 'super councils'. These unitary authorities would be responsible for all services, rather than duties being split between two town halls.
Cambridgeshire is one of the areas that faces being turned into a super council, meaning Cambridge City and South Cambridgeshire councils would no longer exist, for example.
'The Labour council believes that the office is the natural centre of the new super council. It might be true, but it also might not be. They are gambling with our money, not their own. I don't think that's right,' said Ms Bennett.
The devolution plans have been met with some scepticism, and a recent survey of senior council figures by the Local Government Information Unit found that only one in 10 feel they have been properly consulted on the process of reorganisation. Less than a quarter, 23pc, believed it will solve the local government funding crisis.
Ms Bennett, who worked as an accountant for 30 years before becoming a councillor, said: 'Millions are being spent on the consultation alone. This is not how council tax should be spent. Public money should be a sacred trust but I don't think it is to these councillors.'
Unitary authorities have attracted headlines in recent times as they face serious budget shortfalls. Notable examples include Nottingham City Council, which declared effective bankruptcy in 2023, and Somerset Council, which has been allowed an above-inflation tax raid of 7.49pc.
Cambridge City has agreed upon a 2.99pc rise in tax, the maximum amount a district council is permitted to increase bills.
The council has previously funded services such as public toilets and street cleaning, but are having to cut back: 'Things like this really matter to residents. It's depressing if your town seems dirty and people won't be happy.'
The £41m revamp is part of a larger £83m proposal to renovate the city's civic quarter at a time when councils across the country are slashing public services and increasing tax bills. One in 10 households faces a £3,000 charge for the first time ever.
'It's like a lot of Labour plans. They look good on paper but when you look at the details they don't add up,' added Ms Bennett.
Bridget Smith, the Liberal Democrat leader of South Cambridgeshire District Council and vice chairman of the District Councils' Network, previously told Sky News: 'Unitary and county councils are struggling financially, and in many cases going under, because of the ever-increasing demands of social care.
'It will be no different for these proposed 'super councils'.'
She also said that simply reorganising local government is 'simplistic and naive'.
Mike Davey, leader of Cambridge City Council, said: 'We are a city of regional and national importance, and the Labour administration will be promoting the Guildhall as the centre of any new authority.'
'What's more, the Council has not yet taken a decision to commit funding, which opposition members are well aware of. We have, however, agreed to progress the Civic Quarter proposals to planning over the next year – alongside work to the Guildhall.'
Kevin Hollinrake, Shadow Local Government Secretary said: 'Clearly, this is not a good use of taxpayers' cash. Councils should be focused on delivering services for residents, not spending lavishly on an office they will barely use.'
A Housing Ministry spokesman said: 'While councils are responsible for managing their own finances, we have been clear that they should use taxpayers' money wisely and carefully consider the impact of their decisions.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
17 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Badenoch urges business leaders to ‘get on the pitch' and support Tories
The Conservative leader also appealed to business leaders to support her party, suggesting there was no credible alternative which would represent their interests. Speaking at the FTSE 250+ conference in central London, Mrs Badenoch said: 'My message to business is: I'm on your side, but I need you to be on mine too.' Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch speaking during the Peel Hunt FTSE 250+ conference at the Montcalm Royal London House Hotel in London (Yui Mok/PA) The Tory leader's appearance at the gathering came as the latest gross domestic product (GDP) figures showed the UK economy shrank more than expected, the day after the Government unveiled spending plans prioritising health and defence over the next few years. Speaking to an audience of business and investment chiefs, Mrs Badenoch hit out at Labour's tax rises, including the inheritance tax on family farms and national insurance employer contributions. She added: 'You need to support policies that back enterprise, and you need to challenge those who want more state control. 'Don't just wait for other politicians to do it. 'You need to get on the pitch too.' The Tory leader claimed the UK has 'forgot that business is a good in and of itself, and it pays for everything. It is the source of our prosperity'. Kemi Badenoch said only the Conservative Party is making the argument for business (Yui Mok/PA) Mrs Badenoch added: 'The challenge all of us in this room have now is that many people don't believe this anymore.' People instead believe 'business hoards wealth' and is 'greedy and needs to be taxed more', she said. Mrs Badenoch continued: 'This is a crisis. 'And the question before us is simple: Who has credible solutions? 'And I know many of you will be asking, 'Why should we trust the Conservative Party?' 'And I say because no-one is making the argument for business … except me and my party.' At PMQs I talked about Labour creating an economic spiral. A reminder we have 4 more years of this… — Kemi Badenoch (@KemiBadenoch) June 12, 2025 Labour offers only 'managed decline', she said, before taking aim at Nigel Farage's Reform UK party. Mrs Badenoch appealed to the audience, signalling voters cannot 'allow Farage, with no experience of legislating – he's never in Parliament, let alone government – to just come in'. She added: 'Can you imagine 360 random people suddenly taking over government saying they are going to fix everything? 'We were there for 14 years, sweating and labouring, it was unbelievably difficult. 'How many of you would allow your businesses to be run by people who have never been in that business and say 'Come on in, I'm sure you can fix it'? 'That's what he's offering, it's not real. Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch criticised Reform UK and Nigel Farage (Yui Mok/PA) 'It is a scam, and it's my job to expose that scam.' A Reform UK spokesman said: 'Kemi admits they had 14 years and yet all they achieved was sky high taxes, low growth and open borders. 'The only scam is her telling the British public that the Tories have changed. 'It's the same people and the same old failed ideas. 'Quite simply, the Tory party is irrelevant.'
The National
38 minutes ago
- The National
UK accused of 'actively participating in genocide' by training IDF
The news came in response to a written question in Westminster by Labour MP for York Central Rachael Maskell, who asked "when the last time was that a member of the Israel Defense Forces was trained by the UK armed forces". The National reported how Armed Forces Minister Luke Pollard admitted that the UK was "currently" training IDF soldiers in the UK, in a response published on Wednesday. Pollard said: 'As part of routine defence engagement with Israel, the UK is currently training a limited number of Israel Defense Forces personnel on UK-based training courses.' READ MORE: Convoy of 1500 arrives in Libya en route to Gaza to break Israel's blockade on aid The Scottish Greens have now accused the UK Government of "direct, active participation in the genocide of the Palestinian people". The party's co-leader, Patrick Harvie, said Labour were now tied to "every bomb dropped, every home destroyed, every child killed" by Israel. Patrick Harvie (Image: PA) Harvie (above) said: 'The UK is actively training members of the Israeli military while they carry out a brutal assault on Gaza. This is nothing short of disgraceful. "This goes beyond complicity - it is direct, active participation in the genocide of the Palestinian people. Every bomb dropped, every home destroyed, every child killed is a crime that the UK Government is now tied to." Harvie said that the Scottish Greens have "been clear from the start" that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. READ MORE: Absurdity' of UK position on Israel while still supplying arms called out by SNP MP "Tens of thousands of people, most of them women, children and the elderly, have been killed and entire communities have been wiped out. Hospitals, schools, and refugee camps have been targeted," he added. "This is not self-defence - it is the destruction of a people through murder and forced displacement." Harvie continued: "It is appalling that instead of taking action to end the violence, this Labour UK Government are training the Israeli war machine that is committing these crimes. "Training soldiers who are part of these atrocities is a betrayal of every principle of human rights and international law. It must stop now. 'We repeat our calls for an immediate ceasefire, an end to UK participation in genocide, and full accountability for war crimes. Scotland must stand on the side of peace and justice - not with those who commit and support these horrific acts. READ MORE: Scottish Government demands immediate release of Madleen crew detained by Israel "All those who are participating in these atrocities must be brought to justice.' The admission comes despite the Labour Government sanctioning two Israeli ministers – Itamar Ben-Gvir, the security minister, and Bezalel Smotrich, the finance minister. The UK Government has also continued to send military equipment to Israel, and has declined to block exports of parts for F-35 fighter jets despite evidence that they have been used in Gaza. Further, the Government has continued sending spy plane flights over Gaza in missions they say are run to provide Israel with information that could help to recover hostages held by Hamas. The UK Government has been contacted for comment.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Rachel Reeves's secret plan to save her job
By the end of this spending review period in 2028-29, the Government will supposedly have saved £27.7bn, slightly larger than a black hole. The annual saving for that year is predicted to be £13.8bn, more than doubling Reeves's fiscal headroom, which has been rapidly dwindling as borrowing costs surge and growth forecasts are downgraded. Only published on Wednesday, these figures couldn't have been factored into either of the Office for Budget Responsibility's forecasts produced for this Labour government. So, where does this free money, sourced neither from the taxpayer nor lenders, come from? There are certainly commendable ideas within it, such as renegotiating contracts with external providers, using fewer temporary agency staff and, thankfully, calling time on a raft of consultants. Dig a little deeper, however, and these 'efficiency gains' start to look more and more ludicrous, and surely unquantifiable. Apparently, we can calculate the millions of pounds to be saved from the Department for Education 'getting maximum value from every pound of public money'. We know that 'using digital technology more effectively' will add to Treasury coffers, and 'improving efficiency' is apparently enough to put a pound figure on. We have factored in savings from hiring fewer temporary workers in the NHS, which will be achieved by 'reducing sickness absence'. There is no detail how this might happen, but Office for Value for Money chairman David Goldstone, the man behind such great efficiency hits as HS2, has implicitly signed off forecasts based on people being sick less next year. Nobody tell the soldiers, but part of the Ministry of Defence's £105m 'energy efficiency' savings will come from installing low-flow toilets. HMRC's plan to save £1.3bn is largely comprised of using computers a bit more, while nearly every department is convinced they can quantify the benefits of AI. At least these come with some semblance of possibility; the Department for Culture, Media and Sport is going to save £14m by 'merging websites' and restructuring its marketing team. It remains to be seen whether Rachel Reeves will indeed hold the document aloft in the autumn to declare her 'iron-clad' fiscal rules have been met, although it would be strange to leave billions of pounds of no-strings money on the table.
