MTA claims subways are safer while pointing finger at Trump admin for bad rep — straphangers still ‘scared s–tless'
'Personally, I'm just getting tired of hearing all this from [US Transportation] Secretary [Sean] Duffy about how unsafe our system is and yet the testimony here is we're bending over backwards to make our system as safe as possible,' MTA board member Gerard Bringmann said during an agency public safety meeting on. 'Apparently they're not getting the message,'
But while transit agency bosses maintain the subways are among the safest urban systems in the US, everyday New Yorkers told The Post it's the MTA that's not getting the message.
4 Felony assaults in the Big Apple subway system are up 9% so far this year over last year, The Post revealed Saturday.
Michael Nagle
Debbie Fuchs, 68, from the Upper West Side has been catching the subway for 30 years, and said crime is worse than ever.
'I'm scared s—tless catching the subway,' Upper West Sider Debbie Fuchs, 68, said Monday. 'I'm always looking around for the crazies. You're never relaxed on the train. I'm afraid of being shoved on the track.
'I don't stand near the edge of the platform. I'll stand by a pole and I'll hang on to it. I don't trust anybody on the subway,' she added. 'Crime on the subway has been getting worse for the past two years.'
Another Manhattanite who asked not to be identified said thanks, but no thanks.
'I used to catch the subway every day. Crime got a lot worse and I stopped catching it entirely,' she said. 'There's enough crime above ground without exposing yourself below ground. I would go back on the subway if I had a great, big bodyguard.'
4 US Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy toured the subways with Mayor Eric Adams earlier this month.
Paul Martinka
4 Big Apple straphangers said they still worry about safety on the subways, despite assurances from MTA officials.
Robert Miller
Duffy has been another critic, and quipped last week that Gov. Kathy Hochul's congestion pricing plan, which aims to push more New Yorkers onto a risky subway system, was 'liberal insanity.'
'She doesn't ride the subway, she's got a detail that drives her around,' Duffy snapped. 'So she may not care about the experience of MTA riders, but she should.'
In a report over the weekend, The Post revealed that felony assaults in the transit system are up 9% so far this year, and a staggering 55% over the same period in 2019, according to NYPD data.
In one of the latest incidents, a 29-year-old man was shoved into the side of a No. 2 train at a station at West 96th Street and Broadway, sending him to Bellevue Hospital with non-life-threatening injuries.
The suspect fled the station and hasn't been to court, law enforcement sources said.
But on Monday MTA Chairman Janno Lieber said crime is under control in the New York City system, which he said is much safer than many other major cities.
4 MTA Chairman Janno Lieber said the New York City transit system remains one of the safest urban systems in the US.
Robert Miller
He said the agency sent Duffy a 20-page report detailing safety and security improvements.
'Contrary to some of the stuff that's thrown around, the MTA on a per capita basis is among the very safest transit systems in the United States,' he said. 'You're nine times more likely to be the victim of a felony crime in the Houston of Minneapolis or Dallas system. I think it's eight times more in the Chicago system. We're not in competition.
'We're not putting anyone down but you have to look at the stats,' he added. 'And by those standards New York is very safe. We have made that point time and time again.'
MTA Police Chief Thomas Taffe said overall crime in the city subways is down 2.2% since March and down 18% so far during this quarter.
Taffe said there are now more than 135,000 surveillance cameras across the transit system, including trains, subways, bridges and tunnels — 17,000 more than in February 2024.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Weeping relatives, friends gather at wake to remember NJ mom and daughter killed in head-on crash with illegal migrant
More than 150 mourners gathered Saturday to remember the mother and her 11-year-old daughter tragically killed in a head-on crash with an allegedly drunk illegal immigrant driver. Sobbing and weeping relatives and friends — many of them, donning shirts with images of Maria Pleitez and little Dayanara Cortes' beaming faces — lined up outside the Lakewood Funeral Home in Howell to pay their respects at a somber wake. At one point, a mourner who'd been crying uncontrollably leaned over the 42-year-old mother's open casket, and repeated the phrases '¡Qué fuerte!' ('How terrible' in English) and 'Porque?,' the Spanish word for 'Why?,' over and over again. Advertisement 3 Over 150 people gathered at the Lakewood Funeral Home in Howell, New Jersey, to pay their respects to remember the mother and her 11-year-old daughter, tragically killed in a head-on crash. Leonardo Munoz Among those grieving the two devastating deaths was Dayanara's father and her friend, also 11, who was injured in the July 26 crash and is recovering. Pleitez was driving the two girls to a Wawa to get milkshakes at around 11:20 p.m. in Lakewood when Raul Luna-Perez, 43, slammed his Dodge Durango into the mom's Nissan Sentra, according to local prosecutors. Advertisement She was killed instantly, and Dayanara, who was sitting in the front passenger seat, died soon after arriving at the hospital. Luna-Perez was charged with two counts of vehicular homicide and assault by auto. Charges could be added once prosecutors receive the results of an alcohol blood level test. 3 Maria Pleitez and her daughter Dayanara Cortes were fatally struck by an alleged illegal immigrant, Raul Luna-Perez, 43, who was drunk while driving. Advertisement The Mexican immigrant, who was in the US illegally, had been arrested twice this spring for DUI in Red Bank, NJ — something Pleitez's niece bemoaned at the wake. Maria del Carmen Pleitez told The Post her aunt was a hardworking, cat-loving, doting US citizen who immigrated from El Salvador 24 years ago. 'She was a happy person,' Pleitez, 39, said. 'She would come to a place, or she would come to our homes, and just bring happiness. She was never angry, never sad. She always had the strength to continue going, and that's what hurts, because the guy had two DUIs already.' 3 Family and friends at the wake donned shirts and images of Pleitez and Cortes. Leonardo Munoz Advertisement Maria Pleitez spent years working in the painting department of Superior Promotional Bags, a Toms River promotional products supplier, the niece said. 'She was the head of the family,' Maria del Carmen Pleitez said. 'She was bringing up her two daughters. She had her own apartment, her own place, and she never asked her help for anything. We loved her.' Pleitez's 16-year-old daughter, who stayed home, is heartbroken, she said. 'It's so hard. We still feel like we can't digest everything. Like, you wake up in the morning, you think it's not true.'
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
Adams trashes $14 M NYC Council-approved law to provide free garbage bins: 'Ax to grind'
NYC homeowners might not be getting the free garbage cans the City Council promised – as legislators and Mayor Eric Adams literally fight over trash. Adams revealed this week he won't sign off on $14.5 million in taxpayer dough to give away hundreds of thousands of specially secure bins to New Yorkers as part of his war on NYC rats. The bins are supposed to go to owners of one- and two-family homes with the city refunding those who already purchased them, provided they are enrolled in the state's School Tax Relief (STAR) program. The giveaway was supposed to begin Friday under legislation sponsored by Yusef Salaam (D-Manhattan) that the Council unanimously approved in February with a veto-proof majority. 3 Mayor Eric Adams is snubbing a new law that is supposed to provide owners of one- and two-family home with city-issued bins. Instead, Council members this week were told to come up with the $14.5 million on their own — enough to cover about 265,000 one-and two family households, by NYC Independent Budget Office estimates. The City Council has its own taxpayer-funded budget that it uses to pay staff, fund pet projects in their district and for other initiatives. It was the latest salvo fired in an ongoing feud between the city's executive and legislative branches, which also this week included Adams vetoing a City Council measure that would have blocked Bally's from opening a Bronx casino and another that would decriminalize illegal vending. 3 'The mayor has an ax to grind,' said Council Minority Leader Joann Ariola (R-Queens). Ron Sachs – CNP for NY Post A vast majority of NYC property owners will be required to use city-issued bins with secure lids by June 2026. They range in cost from $43.88 for 25-gallon containers to $53.01 to 45-gallon bins — a tab the Council believes should be picked up by the city for many New Yorkers. Reps for the mayor said the Council should have addressed the bill's funding before agreeing last month on a new $115.9 billion budget for this fiscal year – especially since Adams previously complained the trash-bin giveaway plan was fiscally irresponsible. But Adams has an obligation to abide by the new law, and the Council believed the money for the bins was covered by $32 million of permanent new funding he set aside for the Department of Sanitation to keep NYC clean, some members said. 'The mayor has an ax to grind … This was never supposed to be funded by the City Council,' said Council Minority Leader Joann Ariola (R-Queens). '[Adams] is putting up the middle-finger to middle-class taxpayers.' 3 The trash-bin giveaway was supposed to begin Friday under legislation sponsored by Yusef Salaam (D-Manhattan) Matthew McDermott 'Homeowners in the STAR program are predominantly seniors and one of the most vulnerable groups in the city. That's why the … legislation to provide free garbage bins to these residents was so important,' said Councilwoman Lynn Schulman (D-Queens). 'The city must take care of its most precious constituents.' Salaam did not return messages. Liz Garcia, an Adams spokeswoman, said 'it is unfortunate that the City Council irresponsibly passed an unfunded law and then did not prioritize funding for it during our recent budget negotiations.' 'We will continue to work to provide the most affordable options to New Yorkers and send the rats packing out of our city,' Garcia said.
New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
Fighting gun violence in NYC starts with getting criminals and illegal weapons off the streets
Last week, New York was struck by an act of senseless violence when four innocent people were murdered, and another was seriously injured, in an act of cold blood in a Park Avenue office building. As a city, we are in shock. As your mayor, I am heartbroken. The outpouring of grief I have seen and shared in this past week has been devastating. Families and entire communities have been shattered, and we, once again, have to ask why. As we have seen time and time again, the availability of guns in this nation is a major factor in the deaths of these four innocent New Yorkers. When guns are on the streets and in the hands of anyone with a few hundred dollars, the danger expands from states that have lax gun laws to anywhere in America. That is what is so frightening about these kinds of crimes. The victims could have been any of us. A mother about to leave the office on her way home from work, a daughter going to grab drinks with a group of friends, or a security guard just doing his duty. One of the souls we lost was NYPD Detective Didarul Islam, a husband and father who was protecting his community and providing for his family. He put his life on the line and made the ultimate sacrifice, and he died as he lived: a hero. New York City is built on our commitment to public safety and the courage of our NYPD officers who truly are New York's Finest. Their dedication to protecting each and every New Yorker is what makes everything else we do as a city possible. As a former police officer myself, I know the risks they take and how hard they work — I know the commitment to the higher calling they have answered. I cannot overstate my gratitude for the officers who rushed to the scene and prevented further catastrophe. From the start of this administration, we have made public safety our number one focus, our North Star. We put thousands more officers on our streets, committed over $485 million to our new 'Blueprint for Community Safety,' and invested a record $86 million in our CMS violence prevention groups. We have also focused relentlessly on bringing down gun violence. Since the beginning of this year alone, the NYPD has taken over 3,100 illegal firearms off the streets, and since we came into office three years ago, we have now seized more than 22,800 illegal guns. Each illegal gun we take off our streets is saving lives and damming up one more river that leads to the sea of violence. It is a weapon that no longer threatens the lives of our family, our friends, or our neighbors. I have said it before, and I will say it again: Every New Yorker must be safe and feel safe, confident that their city is looking out for them and their families no matter where they live. We must get criminals off our streets and illegal guns out of their hands. We must enforce our laws, prosecute wrongdoers, and fight recidivism. How the shooting unfolded Reports of the shooting at 345 Park Ave. start coming in around 6:28 p.m. Shane Tamura, 27, is seen getting out of a black BMW between 51st and 52nd streets with an M4 rifle. He enters the lobby and turns right, where he shoots police officer Didarul Islam, 36, dead. Tamura guns down a woman cowering behind a pillar in the lobby, sprays more bullets and walks toward the elevator bank — where he shoots dead a security guard crouching at his desk. One more man reports being shot and injured in the lobby. He was in critical but stable condition. The gunman allows a woman to walk out of the elevators unharmed before heading up to the 33rd floor, where building owner Rudin Properties' offices are located, 'and begins to walk the floor, firing as he traveled.' One woman is shot and killed on that floor before Tamura shoots himself in the chest. It's unclear how long the mayhem lasted. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch posted on X at 7:52 p.m.: 'The scene has been contained and the lone shooter has been neutralized.' There is no room for compromise when it comes to the safety of our citizens. It's why I was the co-chair of Mayors Against Illegal Guns, and it's why I have prioritized fighting ghost gun retailers to remove illegal, untraceable weapons from our streets. Gun violence is not a New York problem — it is an American problem. New York City has some of the strictest gun laws, yet the rest of America has not kept up. We cannot prioritize guns over the lives of our brothers and sisters, and we cannot keep responding to senseless gun violence with just vigils. Americans have seen enough violence, have shared enough thoughts and prayers; we must take action. And our response to this tragedy must be worthy of the memories of those we have lost. As your mayor, I will continue to call for common-sense gun reform on a national level and to work with every agency and every community to keep New York the safest big city in the nation. I am thinking of all the families impacted by last week's tragic shooting, and of all the needless shootings we continue to see across our nation, and am recommitting myself to fighting gun violence every way I can. May Aland Etienne, Julia Hyman, Didarul Islam, and Wesley LePatner's memories be a blessing.
