Landowner allegedly overturned ESB machine with tractor while workers trimmed trees near high-voltage line
ESB
machine while workers were trimming trees near high-voltage power lines on his land has agreed in the
High Court
to allow immediate urgent safety works to take place.
Tom O'Shea, of Stellrose, Wheelam, Milltown,
Newbridge
, Co Kildare, had allegedly told ESB workers trimming trees that he would 'pull down the line' if they did not stop working. He then allegedly fetched his own digger and tipped over a tree-cutting tractor with its operator still inside. He then locked his digger and walked towards his farmyard, the court heard.
Mr O'Shea represented himself in court on Friday.
Asked by Mr Justice Brian Cregan why he was refusing to allow the ESB to work on the lines, for which it has a statutory right to enter his land, he said he was in a wider dispute with the electricity company that has not been resolved.
READ MORE
He also claimed the trees themselves are on neighbouring land and believed they could be cut from there.
Stephen Dodd SC, for the ESB, said his client maintains the trees are on Mr O'Shea's land.
Mr O'Shea said he wanted time to respond to ESB and EirGrid affidavits, but Mr Dodd said an order was still required allowing the work to be carried out urgently because of the risk of fire and blackouts.
Mr O'Shea also said the ESB is in breach of planning permission. The judge said the company did not need planning permission for this work and has a statutory right to cut back growth from power lines.
When Mr O'Shea said 'until recently we kept them (trees) trimmed back', the judge said this was not true. Photographs were provided by the ESB to the court, and Mr O'Shea handed other photos in on Friday, but the judge said these were just photos of 'a field and hedges and telegraph poles'.
[
Kildare building site closed by court order to 'reduce risk of injury, or worse'
Opens in new window
]
He told Mr O'Shea that if the ESB was incorrect in what it was doing, he would have a claim for compensation against it. In the meantime, the judge asked whether Mr O'Shea would consent to the injunction preventing him from interfering.
Mr O'Shea said he had dealt with a particular individual in the ESB over the years in negotiations with the company and would like to do so again. Mr Dodd agreed to the judge's request to contact that individual, who now works elsewhere in the ESB, to get them involved.
The judge asked Mr O'Shea if he was prepared not to interfere on the basis that negotiations would take place involving that ESB employee, with which the defendant had 'a rapport'.
Mr O'Shea agreed he would. It was also agreed on the basis of the standard undertaking in injunctions from the ESB to pay damages if the injunction is invalid.
The judge ordered that the negotiations take place over the next three weeks, and that Mr O'Shea remove all obstacles to the land by 4pm Friday and remove locks from a gate. He adjourned the matter to the last week of July.
The court heard earlier this week that Mr O'Shea had previously interfered, in 2009, with tree trimming on land he owns and ultimately was brought before the High Court for breaching undertakings not to do so.
The incident involving the overturned tractor occurred on May 6th last when workers were trying to trim trees near the 110kV Cushaling-Newbridge 110kV overhead lines.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Two men arrested after €750k worth of cannabis plants seized in Drogheda search
Two men have been arrested following a search operation in Drogheda , Co Louth , in which cannabis plants worth more than €750,000 were seized. Gardaí found a large-scale cannabis cultivation factory while searching the premises in Drogheda on Tuesday, August 5th. The men, in their 40s, were arrested at the scene and are currently being detained at Garda stations in the northeast of the country. Investigations are ongoing. The drugs seized are now subject to analysis by Forensic Science Ireland. READ MORE The seizure forms part of Operation Tara, an enhanced national anti-drugs strategy launched by Garda Commissioner Drew Harris in July 2021. The focus of Operation Tara is to disrupt, dismantle and prosecute drug trafficking networks at all levels. Commenting on the investigation, Assistant Commissioner Cliona Richardson said: 'The discovery and dismantling of this sophisticated cannabis cultivation operation will affect the ability of those involved to cause harm in our communities'.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on racist attacks: no place for hate on our streets
In recent weeks there has been a disturbing uptick in reports of violent attacks targeting ethnic minorities, particularly affecting members of Ireland's Indian community. Members of that community have spoken of rising verbal abuse and assaults on Irish streets, leading them to feel unsafe. Many such incidents remain unreported to the Garda Síochána, though details have surfaced on local WhatsApp groups. The situation has left many people feeling increasingly vulnerable as they go about their daily lives in what was once seen as a welcoming environment. And last weekend the Indian embassy warned its citizens to take extra precautions for their own security. Indians have become Ireland's fastest-growing immigrant group, with thousands receiving residence permits in the past three years alone. In a relatively short period, the community has grown to become the largest non-white ethnic group in the country, contributing significantly to various sectors of the economy. Particularly notable is the valuable contribution of Indian professionals to the health service and technology industries, where their expertise is in high demand. But many now report feeling a sense of threat. The Garda has responded to the reports of violence with statements emphasising its commitment to addressing the problem. But some victims, especially those who have lived in Ireland for many years, believe that things are getting worse. They point to an increase in hostile, racially charged encounters on the streets, fuelled in part by poisonous rhetoric on social media. All of this forms part of a broader, worrying trend that has seen public spaces and public discourse become sites of escalating toxicity. READ MORE Reports suggest that many perpetrators are minors, complicating the issue of legal accountability. While recently passed hate crime legislation now makes it possible to treat racial animus as an aggravating factor when sentencing, the effectiveness of this as a deterrent remains to be seen. The debate on regulating hate speech remains contentious, as evidenced by last year's controversy over proposed legislation on the issue, which was ultimately abandoned. But alongside legislation and enforcement, civil society and individual citizens also have a role to play in rejecting those who carry out these reprehensible acts. It is concerning that in some cases, bystanders have witnessed assaults but failed to intervene or report them. However, there have also been instances where members of the public have come to the aid of victims and brought the assaults to public attention. Such solidarity sends an unequivocal signal that racist violence is unacceptable. It is everybody's shared responsibility to ensure that no one feels unsafe because of their ethnicity or the colour of their skin.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Man jailed for three months over ‘unprovoked' attack on woman jogging in Dublin
The victim of a random 'unprovoked' attack was kicked in the stomach, knocked to the ground and left in pain after she went jogging in Dublin , a court has heard. Hoyda Hamad, a Syrian national of no fixed abode who has used multiple identities, was jailed for three months on Wednesday over the incident on East Wall Road, Dublin 3, on the morning of July 26th last. It happened 18 days after he received a suspended sentence for an earlier theft. A barber by trade, the 35-year-old was charged with a section 2 assault, which carries a six-month sentence, as well as with providing a false or misleading name and address to a member of An Garda Síochána and with using threatening, abusive, or insulting words or behaviour. READ MORE Hamad pleaded guilty last week and as such the woman did not have to attend the hearing or give evidence. . Court Sergeant Olyn Murphy outlined the prosecution's evidence on behalf of investigating officer, Garda Ruth Redmond. Judge Patricia Cronin, at the sentence hearing at Cloverhill District Court, heard the incident happened at about 10.05am when the defendant assaulted the woman 'by kicking her in the stomach, causing her to fall back on the ground', and Hamad was verbally abusive towards her. She also suffered a back injury, a swollen finger and her head was 'throbbing' after the attack. Gardaí attended the scene and Hamad gave a false name and date of birth before being arrested and brought to a station to be charged. Judge Cronin noted he had two sets of previous convictions, one under the name Hamad with two theft convictions, which led to the imposition of a two-month sentence, suspended for one year, in Wexford District Court on July 8th. That term could now be activated. He also committed several other crimes under a different name: three for vehicle theft and driving offences, one for drug possession, another for burglary, one trespass and another for failing to provide a passport as required. That resulted in a 10-month prison sentence from Cork District Court on July 31st last year. In a mitigation plea, the defence counsel asked the judge to note that Hamad had pleaded guilty at an early stage, which was valuable given the moving victim impact statement, which was not read aloud during the hearing. He had been remanded in custody on the date of the incident. Judge Cronin said the victim's statement was eloquent and outlined the psychological and physical injuries, 'significant impact' and the life changes the woman made since the attack. Sentencing, the judge took into account Hamad's plea and previous convictions and that he had none under the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act or similar public order matters. The three-month term was imposed on the assault charge, with the two remaining offences taken into consideration.
