Tesla and Mahindra: A drive in parallel universes
Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M) group chairman Anand Mahindra welcomed Tesla's India entry with a friendly 'Competition drives innovation, and there's plenty of road ahead' post on X. His confidence is not misplaced. In the most recent quarter, M&M surpassed Hyundai to become India's second-largest automaker by volume.
But his aplomb obscures a more fundamental truth: Tesla and M&M operate in two entirely different markets - not segments. Indeed, in automotives, they belong to two parallel universes. Their vehicles, customers, pricing, and value propositions are so distinct that the two brands are unlikely to ever compete directly in India.
It's a common fallacy to treat the Indian automobile market as a single, homogenous entity. In reality, it is bifurcated into two sharply distinct sectors: a mass-market, value-conscious segment that forms more than 99% of volumes, and a narrow, high-end luxury segment that is economically and behaviorally different.
While Tesla, M&M, and Indian EV market leader Tata Motors, are loosely grouped under the electric vehicle (EV) banner, that's where the similarities end. Tesla is entering at the very top of the pyramid, with its first offering in India priced at over ₹ 60 lakh (more than twice what the most expensive EV from Tata Motors costs). That places it squarely in the ultra-premium category alongside German brands like Mercedes-Benz, Audi, and BMW. By contrast, EVs from M&M and Tata Motors are tailored for cost-conscious customers and are promoted for their cost-saving benefits like lower running costs compared to petrol and diesel vehicles.
No one will buy a Tesla in India to save on fuel bills. The US company's brand promise revolves around performance, tech-savvy design, and global cachet. M&M's promise, like that of Tata Motors, is rooted in practicality and affordability. The distinction is critical.
In 2023, the entire luxury car segment in India accounted for just over 51,000 vehicles. That's a number Tesla sells in the US every month. It sold 657,000 units in China last year, despite growing competition from domestic giant BYD. By contrast, Tata Motors sold over 61,000 EVs in India last year. Clearly, Tesla cannot win the volume game in India simply because at its price points, volumes simply don't exist.
Tesla's India ambitions are often rationalized in terms of geopolitical strategy. The country offers a hedge against an increasingly protectionist China, and the tag of being one of the few remaining 'unconquered' markets of scale. But while India may be the world's third-largest car market, it is not one for luxury EVs.
There is also little reason to believe that the Indian government will bend over backward for Tesla. Unlike in the past, when market access was often traded for manufacturing commitments, today's policy approach is more guarded. Import duties are unlikely to be slashed, and Tesla will have to adhere to conditions like local sourcing and production.
The government's stated target of 30% EV penetration by 2030 will be achieved primarily through sub- ₹ 15 lakh vehicles, which is the domain of Indian carmakers, and increasingly of Chinese companies like BYD. Tesla has no product in this space and, more importantly, no roadmap to get there.
Despite promises of a $25,000 EV, Tesla has repeatedly deprioritized its commitment to produce an affordable EV. Five years ago, Elon Musk announced it would arrive in three years, only to go back on his promise in 2022. Today, Tesla's focus has shifted to the robotaxi platform. The message is clear: affordability is not the current focus.
India's car market is not just small at the top, it is fiercely cost-conscious at every level. According to a recent Crisil Ratings report, used car sales in the country are expected to grow at twice the pace of new car sales in FY26. Significantly, the average age of used cars has declined to just 3.5 years, a strong indicator that consumers are looking for newer vehicles at lower price points.
Maruti Suzuki chairman R.C. Bhargava recently noted that only the top 12% of Indian households can realistically afford a car. The other 88% struggle to afford even the entry-level models. This reality further underlines the irrelevance of Tesla's pricing strategy in the Indian context.
Tesla's India foray is unlikely to ruffle feathers at M&M or disrupt the broader market. If anything, it will reinforce the market's duality of a high-end niche for brands like Tesla, and a mass-market battlefield where the real action takes place. Anand Mahindra and his team can rest easy: Tesla's India drive is on a completely different highway.a
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Deccan Herald
26 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
India's GDP could slow down to 6% in FY26 if US levies 50% tariff: Moody's
On August 6, the US announced an additional 25 per cent tariff on all Indian imports, in addition to an existing 25 per cent duty, taking the total duty to 50 per cent effective August 27.
India Today
26 minutes ago
- India Today
US tariff surge could stall India's manufacturing momentum, warns Moody's
India's goal to become a global manufacturing powerhouse could take a hit, thanks to a sharp rise in tariffs from the US. A recent report by Moody's Ratings has warned that the recent decision by the US to double tariffs on Indian exports may reduce India's competitiveness, especially in the electronics Thursday, US President Donald Trump signed an Executive Order that adds a 25% tariff on Indian goods. This move comes in response to India's continued import of oil from Russia, which Washington sees as going against efforts to isolate Moscow over the Ukraine war. The new tariffs will apply to goods imported into the US 21 days after the order was says the wide tariff gap between India and other Asia-Pacific countries could hurt India's recent progress in attracting global manufacturers. This could slow the country's manufacturing growth and weaken its position in the global supply chain. India's annual GDP growth may slow by about 0.3 percentage points, Moody's warned, with Goldman Sachs offering a similar ratings agency added that if the issue isn't resolved quickly, India's annual GDP growth may slow by about 0.3 percentage points, with Goldman Sachs offering a similar real worry, however, lies in the long-term impact. India could lose its manufacturing momentum just when it has started gaining attention as an alternative to China. The tariff hike could push global companies to look at other countries in the region for setting up their factories and supply tariffs may have long-term effects, possibly weakening India's position in global manufacturing. This calls for strong diplomatic and economic moves to reduce the damage and protect future now, all eyes are on how India adjusts its trade policies to tackle the challenge.(Disclaimer: The views, opinions, recommendations, and suggestions expressed by experts/brokerages in this article are their own and do not reflect the views of the India Today Group. It is advisable to consult a qualified broker or financial advisor before making any actual investment or trading choices.)- EndsTune InMust Watch
Hindustan Times
26 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
India's GDP could slow down to 6 pc in FY26 if US levies 50 pc tariff: Moody's
Moody's Ratings on Friday said India's GDP growth is likely to slow down by about 30 basis points to 6 per cent in the current fiscal if the US implements 50 per cent tariffs from August 27. On August 6, the US announced an additional 25 per cent tariff on all Indian imports. (Shutterstock) However, resilient domestic demand and the strength of the services sector will mitigate the strain on India, Moody's said, adding that India's response to high US tariffs will ultimately determine the effect on its growth, inflation and external position. On August 6, the US announced an additional 25 per cent tariff on all Indian imports, in addition to an existing 25 per cent duty, taking the total duty to 50 per cent effective August 27. The White House said the measure responds to India's continued purchase of Russian oil. "Should India continue to procure Russian oil at the expense of the headline 50 per cent tariff rate on goods it ships to the US, which is currently its largest export destination, we project that real GDP growth may slow by around 0.3 percentage points compared with our current forecast of 6.3 per cent growth for fiscal 2025-26 (ending March 2026)," Moody's said. The 50 per cent tariff on India compares with the 15-20 per cent duty for other Asia-Pacific countries. India and the US have been negotiating a bilateral trade agreement (BTA) since March, with an aim to more than double the bilateral trade in goods and services to USD 500 billion by 2030 from the current USD 191 billion. So far, five rounds of talks have been completed. For the sixth round, the US team is visiting India from August 25. They are aiming to conclude the first phase of the agreement by fall (October-November) this year. The two sides are also looking at an interim trade deal before the BTA. Moody's said countries in Asia-Pacific are vying for a greater share of trade and investment flows amid a restructuring of supply chains triggered by US policy shifts. "Beyond 2025, the much wider tariff gap compared with other Asia-Pacific countries would severely curtail India's ambitions to develop its manufacturing sector, particularly in higher value-added sectors, such as electronics, and may even reverse some of the gains made in recent years in attracting related investments," Moody's said. Since 2022, India has increasingly ramped up its crude oil imports from Russia as demand from the latter's traditional offtakers dried up amid sanctions tied to its invasion of Ukraine. "India has been able to procure at least some of its purchases of Russian oil at below global prices, which has helped insulate India's inflation from the pass-through of global commodity price movements, while preempting pressures on its current account deficit," Moody's said. India's imports of Russian crude rose to USD 56.8 billion in 2024 from USD 2.8 billion in 2021. Moody's said India retains sufficient foreign-reserve currency buffers to weather external volatility. "The magnitude of the drag on growth from tariff obstacles will influence the government's decision to pursue a fiscal policy response, although we anticipate the government will adhere to its focus on gradual fiscal and debt consolidation," said the US-based rating agency.
