logo
From Defeat To Denial: Rahul Gandhi's Misdirected War On Democracy

From Defeat To Denial: Rahul Gandhi's Misdirected War On Democracy

News18a day ago

Last Updated:
Democracy demands robust opposition, not reckless obstruction. Rahul Gandhi's article, if anything, is a manual on how not to lose gracefully
Rahul Gandhi wrote a piece titled Match-Fixing Maharashtra on June 7, 2025, in The Indian Express, which caught my attention. This article, riddled with speculative accusations and selective facts, demanded a serious response, not because it was grounded in democratic concern, but because it was laced with contempt for constitutional institutions.
Gandhi's allegations, already covered by the Election Commission in extensive detail, deserve critical scrutiny. Not for the sake of rebutting every unfounded claim, but to highlight a dangerous trend: persistent delegitimisation of India's democratic architecture to cover political inadequacy.
The Article That Confuses, Not Convinces
The central motif of Rahul Gandhi's article is clear: if he cannot win electorally, the system must be rigged. This isn't new. When institutions don't echo his voice, he brands them as compromised. It is the same philosophy that fuels his campaign against the judiciary, the Election Commission, and even the growing voter base. His article, while camouflaged as a democratic concern, plays into the narrative of confusion and distrust. It is a textbook case of the fallacy: if you can't convince them, confuse them.
In his haste to cry foul over the Maharashtra Assembly elections, Gandhi overlooked facts already on public record. These facts, when properly understood, dismantle his claims and show that nothing extraordinary occurred except perhaps the electorate's rejection of his politics.
Myth 1: Match-Fixing Elections
Rahul Gandhi's use of the term 'match-fixing" is not only irresponsible, it is inflammatory. By insinuating that elections were rigged without substantiating those claims with legally admissible evidence, he undermined the very institutions that uphold democracy. The Election Commission had, in fact, already addressed the concerns raised. Gandhi's article made no mention of the 60-page letter dated December 24, 2024, sent to his party's legal representative, which responded to all allegations with data.
Moreover, the consistent participation of the opposition in the electoral process, from campaigning to counting, negates the idea of match-fixing. Elections are conducted under the vigilant eyes of polling agents, observers, and the media. Suggesting manipulation without credible proof is not dissent, it's disruption.
Myth 2: Bogus Voters
Gandhi's next point, voter roll inflation, is neither new nor unique to Maharashtra. He finds suspicious the increase of 31 lakh voters in five years and 41 lakh in five months. But these figures fall well within historical trends. Between 2004 and 2009, 1 crore voters were added; between 2014 and 2019, 63 lakh more were enrolled. In 2024, 40.8 lakh new voters were added, including 26.4 lakh young voters, a logical rise given India's demographic dynamics.
Accusing these voters of being bogus is not only defamatory, it is also dismissive of youth participation in democracy. Instead of encouraging voter engagement, Gandhi's statements cast aspersions on millions of first-time voters. That is not a critique; it is contempt.
Myth 3: Last-Hour Voting Surge
Gandhi claimed that a suspicious voting surge occurred in the last hour of polling, suggesting manipulation. But here's the reality: the average polling rate throughout the day was 5.83 per cent per hour. A spike to 7.83 per cent in the last hour is within the bounds of statistical probability, especially since voters present at the booth by 6 pm are legally entitled to vote.
This isn't peculiar to Maharashtra. In the second phase of the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, a 5.75 per cent increase was recorded after 5 pm. Why was this not a problem then? Because the Congress won those seats. What Rahul Gandhi calls an 'issue" arises only when the outcome doesn't suit him.
Myth 4: Constituency-Level Fixing
Rahul Gandhi cherry-picked 12,000 polling stations across 85 constituencies to claim targeted rigging. But if you look deeper, you find a more nuanced reality. In constituencies like Madha, Wani, and Shrirampur, which showed voter surges, candidates from Sharad Pawar's NCP, Uddhav Thackeray's Shiv Sena, and the Congress itself won.
Hence, the data doesn't support his hypothesis that a high last-hour turnout favoured only the BJP-led NDA. The selective use of constituency data is a classic case of misdirection. It is not the data that's flawed, it's the analysis, or rather, the lack of it.
Myth 5: ECI's Complicity
Perhaps the most alarming of all Gandhi's claims is that the Election Commission of India is compromised. Ironically, it was the Congress-led government that, until 2024, unilaterally appointed Chief Election Commissioners. Under Modi, a new committee involving the Leader of the Opposition was constituted as a democratic upgrade.
Rahul Gandhi's angst seems to lie in the very democratisation of a process his party previously monopolised. In his world, reform is acceptable only if it serves the Congress party. Anything else is betrayal.
Politics Of Perpetual Excuses
Rahul Gandhi has, once again, chosen the easier path of blaming systems instead of introspecting on failures. He questions the mandate because he failed to secure it. But elections are not won by slogans or marches; they are won by connection, credibility, and conviction.
His refusal to accept defeat gracefully and to instead vilify every institution that upholds our democracy is dangerous. This is not leadership; it is a tantrum disguised as a revolution.
Conclusion: From Fiction To Fact
Democracy demands robust opposition, not reckless obstruction. Rahul Gandhi's article, if anything, is a manual on how not to lose gracefully. While he fashions himself as a defender of democracy, his words serve only to degrade it.
It is time Rahul Gandhi respects the people's verdict instead of mocking it. And if he wants to be taken seriously as a political leader, he must rise above rhetorical sabotage and begin the difficult journey of real introspection. Until then, his speeches and writings will continue to sound less like statesmanship and more like sour grapes.
The writer is a technocrat, political analyst, and author. He pens national, geopolitical, and social issues. His social media handle is @prosenjitnth. Views expressed in the above piece are personal and solely those of the author. They do not necessarily reflect News18's views.
About the Author
Prosenjit Nath
The writer is an Indian technocrat, political analyst, and author.
tags :
election commission Maharashtra elections Rahul Gandhi
Location :
New Delhi, India, India
First Published:
June 09, 2025, 13:52 IST
News opinion Opinion | From Defeat To Denial: Rahul Gandhi's Misdirected War On Democracy

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'Unlike BJP or Left': On Siddaramaiah's 'Maha Kumbh' defence, Rahul Gandhi asks Karnataka government to take responsibility for Bengaluru stampede
'Unlike BJP or Left': On Siddaramaiah's 'Maha Kumbh' defence, Rahul Gandhi asks Karnataka government to take responsibility for Bengaluru stampede

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

'Unlike BJP or Left': On Siddaramaiah's 'Maha Kumbh' defence, Rahul Gandhi asks Karnataka government to take responsibility for Bengaluru stampede

Fans gather in large numbers during RCB's felicitation ceremony after they win the Indian Premier League (IPL) 2025, in front of Vidhana Soudha, in Bengaluru, Karnataka. (PTI) NEW DELHI: Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and party president Mallikarjun Kharge have expressed strong displeasure over the Karnataka government's association with the IPL victory celebrations of Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB), during which 11 people were killed in a stampede outside the Chinnaswamy Stadium on June 4, news agency PTI reported on Tuesday, June 10. At a meeting held at the party's new headquarters in New Delhi on Tuesday, Kharge and Rahul pulled up chief minister Siddaramaiah and deputy CM DK Shivakumar, saying the government should have been more sensitive. Rahul Gandhi reportedly told the two leaders that "human lives are of great value" to the Congress and that the administration must be responsive, unlike the BJP in Uttar Pradesh or the Left government in Kerala. Rahul Gandhi told the chief minister and PCC president that human lives are of great value to the Congress party and the government has to be responsive towards people, "unlike the BJP government in Uttar Pradesh or the Left government in Kerala where no responsibility was taken for the loss of lives during the Kumbh and Sabarimala tragedy respectively," a source was quoted as saying by the news agency PTI. The Congress leadership also reminded the state government to maintain a clear pro-people approach and avoid lapses that could tarnish its image, the PTI report said. Meanwhile, after meeting with Congress leadership, Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah said that the Kumbh Mela incident should be discussed before Bengaluru stampede. "We discussed the recent tragic incident and explained the measures we have taken. A magisterial inquiry is underway, and a judicial commission has been appointed, led by retired Justice Michael Cunha. Five police officers have been suspended, intelligence officers have been transferred, and the political secretary has been relieved. We explained these actions, and there is a consensus that the measures taken are appropriate. The Kumbh Mela incident should be discussed first before addressing this issue. I am not using the Kumbh Mela deaths to defend this incident. When people die, it is human to feel sorrow. This incident should not be politicised." The Congress government in Karnataka has faced sharp criticism from the opposition BJP and JD(S), with both parties holding the chief minister and his deputy directly responsible for the tragedy and demanding their resignation. They have also sought a special Assembly session to discuss the incident. The stampede occurred on June 4 near the Chinnaswamy stadium in Bengaluru, where a large number of people had gathered to participate in the RCB team's IPL victory celebrations. The stampede led to 11 deaths and injured 56.

After communal tensions in Assam's Dhubri, minister calls it ‘symptom of demographic transformation'
After communal tensions in Assam's Dhubri, minister calls it ‘symptom of demographic transformation'

Indian Express

time2 hours ago

  • Indian Express

After communal tensions in Assam's Dhubri, minister calls it ‘symptom of demographic transformation'

The discovery of suspected cattle remains near the premises of a temple in Western Assam's Dhubri town has led to the flaring of communal tensions and the arrest of 10 people. District authorities said the situation was brought under control as of Tuesday afternoon. However, a Cabinet minister in Assam's BJP government has called the issue a 'symptom' of 'calculated demographic transformation of entire regions of India'. Dhubri district is located along the state's border with Bangladesh. According to Dhubri DC Dibakar Nath, the tensions began with the discovery of suspected 'cow meat' near the premises of a Hanuman temple in Dhubri town on Sunday. On Monday, demonstrations were held in the town and they later escalated to stone pelting. Police used tear gas to disperse the crowd and bring the situation under control. On Monday night, the district administration imposed prohibitory orders throughout Dhubri town, citing 'a likelihood of breach of peace and public tranquillity in the areas falling under the jurisdiction of Dhubri police station due to communal tension, riot risk, violent protests, etc'. The administration had ordered the closure of all shops and markets in the town, disallowed the assembly of more than five people in any public areas, and banned any rallies or demonstrations. DC Nath told The Indian Express that the situation stabilised as of Tuesday evening and that the prohibitory orders were withdrawn. 'Things have come under control with the prohibitory orders and the sufficient deployment of police and CRPF, and we have been able to revoke the order this afternoon. We have formed peace committees in all critical areas and are engaging with the community through them. Ten people have been arrested in connection with Sunday's incident and the investigation is ongoing,' he said. The developments have also led to political discourse, with Assam Cabinet minister Ashok Singhal saying in a post on X: 'What is happening in Dhubri today isn't sudden. It's the direct result of decades of ignored patterns, deliberate policies, and the political silence of the Indian National Congress and AIUDF in pursuit of vote-bank politics. The forced demographic imbalance, once ignored as a 'local issue', now stands as savages hell-bent on the annihilation of the Hindu faith and our way of life, posing a serious threat to Assam and the rest of India.'

Tripura Congress leader's father, brother arrested after he makes ‘derogatory' comments about CM
Tripura Congress leader's father, brother arrested after he makes ‘derogatory' comments about CM

Scroll.in

time2 hours ago

  • Scroll.in

Tripura Congress leader's father, brother arrested after he makes ‘derogatory' comments about CM

The Tripura Police on Monday arrested the father and brother of Congress leader Shahjahan Islam after he allegedly made derogatory remarks about Chief Minister Manik Saha and Bharatiya Janata Party minority wing leader Jashim Uddin, reported The Indian Express. The arrests came hours after Islam's home in Agartala was allegedly attacked by a mob. His father and brother, Khairul Islam and Najrul Miah, have been remanded to judicial custody till June 23, according to Maktoob Media. The BJP has alleged that Khairul Islam and Najrul Miah assaulted party workers who had gone to their home to protest against Shahjahan Islam's allegedly derogatory remarks. The Hindutva party also filed a police complaint against the Congress leader. In a video posted on social media, Shahjahan Islam was said to have criticised the police and state government for failing to act against miscreants who allegedly disrupted livestock slaughter during the Muslim festival of Bakri Eid on Saturday, reported Maktoob Media. He also allegedly called Saha and the BJP minority leaders 'cheats' and asked members of the Muslim community to boycott them. Bakri Eid, also known as Eid-al-Adha, commemorates the spirit of sacrifice and entails the slaughtering of livestock. The Congress leader was referring to the incident when a cow was allegedly slaughtered in public in the Chhanban area of Gomati district's Udaipur on Saturday, reported The Indian Express. Two persons were detained in connection with the slaughter. There are no restrictions on cattle slaughter in Tripura. However, the Agartala Municipal Corporation has asked meat vendors to get registered as part of its plan to stop uncontrolled public slaughtering of animals, according to The Indian Express. This is in line with the Tripura High Court's judgement from February 2022. The court had directed the state government to prohibit the sale of meat in public places and streets. Billal Miah, the BJP minority wing president in Tripura and the complainant against Shahjahan Islam, alleged that the Congress leader had made 'obscene comments' about the chief minister. 'On one hand, there has been an attempt to malign the state government and on the other hand, there is a conspiracy to create unrest among communities,' Billal Miah was quoted as saying by The Indian Express. Meanwhile, in his statement to the police, Islam claimed that he was attacked by a mob upon returning home on Sunday night. He alleged that some persons were brandishing firearms and wanted to murder him, but failed.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store