South Korea's top court rejects 'Baby Shark' copyright claim
South Korea's Supreme Court has dismissed a 30 million won (about $21,600 or €18,454) copyright claim over the viral children's song "Baby Shark."
US composer, Jonathan Wright, claimed the 2015 hit "Baby Shark" by South Korean education startup SmartStudy, now known as The Pinkfong Company, copied a song he released in 2011.
But the court ruled Thursday Wright's rendition wasn't original enough to qualify for protection, upholding earlier decisions.
Pinkfong's "Baby Shark" exploded globally after its 2015 release and now has more than 16 billion views on YouTube.
Wright, known as Johnny Only, recorded his version in 2011, four years before Pinkfong's version.
'Baby shark' based on traditional melody popular at US summer camps
Both songs are based on a traditional melody that has been popular at children's summer camps in the United States for many years.
South Korean courts cleared Pinkfong of copyright infringement in 2021 and reaffirmed the decision in 2023. The Supreme Court upheld both rulings.
"The Supreme Court accepts the lower court's finding that the plaintiff's song did not involve substantial modifications to the folk tune related to the case to the extent that it could be regarded, by common social standards, as a separate work," it said in a statement.
Pinkfong said the court's ruling confirmed "Baby Shark" was "based on a traditional singalong chant that has entered the public domain."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Saath Nibhana Saathiya actress Mazel Vyas reacts to Supreme Court's ruling on stray dogs; says 'Most shelters are already overcrowded and underfunded'
Mazel Vyas , currently seen in the gripping action series Hunter 2 alongside Suniel Shetty who was also seen in Saath Nibhana Saathiya as Meera Modi and became famous has stepped into the spotlight for a cause close to her heart — the welfare of stray dogs. In light of the recent Supreme Court decision mandating the relocation of all stray dogs in Delhi to shelters, Mazel has expressed her concern over what she calls a 'deeply complex and emotional issue.' The ruling, which has sparked widespread debate, aims to address the growing number of incidents involving aggressive strays — some tragically resulting in harm to children. While the intention behind the move may be rooted in public safety, many animal lovers, activists, and citizens argue that the lack of infrastructure makes this decision unviable and potentially harmful. 'I understand the fear and anger when innocent lives are lost or harmed,' Mazel shares. 'But simply shifting all stray dogs to shelters without a long-term plan or basic facilities is not the answer. Most shelters are already overcrowded and underfunded. This could lead to even more suffering.' Mazel advocates for a more balanced and humane solution. 'Mass sterilization and vaccination drives should be the priority,' she says. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Local Summer Sale: 75% Off Installation in Tracy LeafFilter Gutter Protection Learn More Undo 'We also need to differentiate between aggressive dogs and those that coexist peacefully in neighborhoods. The truly aggressive ones can be rehabilitated or moved to secure environments, but not all strays deserve to be locked away.' She also emphasizes the role of communities in caring for street dogs. 'Many strays are fed and looked after by locals. Forcing them into shelters where conditions are often poor is unfair — both to the animals and the people who care for them.' The issue has indeed divided public opinion. While safety remains paramount, voices like Mazel's urge the government and courts to look beyond a blanket solution. A more compassionate, well-planned approach could protect both people and animals — without sacrificing one for the other. Saath Nibhana Saathiya 2: After Devoleena Bhattacharjee, Mohammad Nazim to join the show
Hindustan Times
9 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
'Apoorva Mukhija has no concern for the fact that I'm hurt': Sufi Motiwala reveals why they are not friends anymore
Apoorva Mukhija and Sufi Motiwala became friends on the reality show The Traitors, and they even collaborated on a storytime video on her YouTube channel. However, many noticed that Sufi did not include any mention of Apoorva in his latest Instagram reel. The two of them are among a select few content creators who were in Australia for a Stranger Things event. Sufi has now clarified the speculation about their friendship and admitted that they are no longer friends. Sufi Motiwala has broken his silence on the comments about his bond with Apoorva Mukhija. What Sufi said about The Rebel Kid Sufi took to his Instagram Stories and wrote, 'No more lies. I've received a lot of texts saying that I've taken clout from Apoorva and I've left her. I've literally never collaborated on a reel with her and have been on her YouTube twice, both of which were her content pieces entirely. So no I'm not sorry I didn't use her for clout (incase u forgot we were on the same show without knowing each other I don't need her clout) I wanted to be friends with Apoorva not the rebel kid when there was no accountability constantly for how I was being treated I distanced myself." Sufi via Instagram Stories. 'I'm not friends with her anymore' He added, "I even requested her to ask her audience to calm down because they've been abusing me for no reason. Sadly this person who called me her best friend has no concern for that and or the fact that maybe I'm hurt. THAT is why I'm not friends with her anymore. Keep it cute keep it moving.' He concluded, 'Idc about anything u think I'm a horrible person ok. But I have worked my a** off to build myself to where I am and I won't let a bunch of children discredit that by spreading misinformation.' Apoorva has not spoken about this matter on her social media accounts as of yet. Both Apoorva and Sufi became close friends during their stint on The Traitors. Sufi had previously supported Apoorva after another contestant, Sudhanshu Pandey, criticised her for using abusive language and her behaviour towards others on the show. Even during the controversy of India's Got Latent, Sufi had stood in support of Apoorva after she received heavy backlash and media scrutiny.
Time of India
9 hours ago
- Time of India
Apoorva Makheja aka Rebel Kid's ex hints she cheated on him amid fallout with Rida Tharana and Sufi Motiwala – all we know!
Social media creator Rebel Kid, also known as Apoorva Mukhija, is once again making buzz. Known for her quirky content, appearances on Karan Johar's reality show The Traitors, and the movie Nadaaniyan, she recently became the center of online discussions following a friendship fallout with fellow creator Sufi Motiwala, this following her popular fallout with Rida Tharana. Friendship fallout with Sufi Motiwala Apoorva and Sufi, who became friends during The Traitors, which was released in June 2025. They featured in each other's Instagram stories, collaborated on Rebel Kid's YouTube videos, and shared fan-made reels celebrating their friendship. However, the duo recently seemed to drift apart. When invited by Netflix for Wednesday 2 in Sydney, both creators avoided tagging each other in posts, sparking online chatter that even reached Reddit. Sufi addressed the situation on his Instagram stories on August 17, writing: What he said 'NO MORE LIES. I wanted to be friends with Apoorva Mukhija, not the Rebel Kid. When there was no accountability for how I was being treated, I distanced myself. I even requested her to ask her audience to calm down because they were abusing me for no reason. Sadly, this person who called me her best friend has no concern for that or for the fact that I might be hurt. THAT is why I'm not friends with her anymore. Keep it cute, keep it moving.' At the time of writing, Motiwala and Tharana, both have unfollowed Rebel Kid on Instagram. Ex claims she cheated Amid the friendship drama, Rebel Kid's ex, Utsav Dahiya, also made buzz. The two had dated in early 2023 before announcing their breakup on January 31, when Rebel wrote: 'Most of you all guessed it already, but Utsav and I are not together anymore. I can't wait for the slut-shaming, gold-digging gossip threads on me now. But lesson learned, agla jiju reveal shaadi pe karungi ab.' Following their split, Mukhija continued sharing content that allegedly appeared to hint at Dahiya being in the wrong, ranging from lighthearted videos with Anupam Mittal to calling her ex-partners 'ghatiya log,' which drew significant backlash toward him. However, as the India's Got Latent controversy surrounding Mukhija cooled down, Dahiya posted a video on August 17 hinting that Apoorva cheated on him. His song, titled 'Cute Little Red Flags,' also references a phrase Mukhija frequently uses in her videos. The caption of the post read, 'Ab agar koi aur bakwaas karega toh main seedha receipts nikalunga. Never try to gain sympathy by fabricating lies or pushing false narratives just to make content and assassinate someone's character online. Having a big following doesn't give you the right to bully your way by rage-baiting your audience and unleashing them on others. Truth doesn't need 'followers'; it stands on its own. Toh tum chalao apna ghar kalesh se, but kisi ke baare mein jhoot bolna band karo. Baki logo ko life mein dhanke kaam karne do. Grow up, kid.'
