Will Catholic cardinals pick another outsider like Francis to be pope?
By Joshua McElwee
VATICAN CITY (Reuters) - When Cardinal Jorge Bergoglio was elected in 2013 as Pope Francis, he was a near total Vatican outsider. He had never been a Vatican official, instead spending decades in local ministry. And he came from Argentina, the first pope from the Americas.
As the world's Catholic cardinals meet this week to discuss who should succeed Francis, the deliberations may boil down to a simple choice:
Do they want another outsider? Or is it time now for an insider, someone more familiar with the Vatican's arcane ways of operating?
"Pope Francis... shifted the Church's attention to the outside world," said John Thavis, former Rome bureau chief for the Catholic News Service, who covered three papacies.
"Some cardinals will now be tempted to pick an insider, someone with the skills to manage church affairs more carefully and quietly than Francis did."
Francis, who died on April 21 aged 88, focused much of his papacy on outreach to places where the Church was not traditionally strong.
Many of his 47 foreign trips were to countries with small Catholic populations, such as South Sudan, Iraq and the United Arab Emirates, and he was especially committed to Catholic-Muslim dialogue.
He was also known for giving freewheeling press conferences, where no topics were off the table and the pope might respond to a query with an unexpected quip.
Asked about the Catholic ban on birth control in 2015, Francis reaffirmed the ban but added that Catholics don't have to have children "like rabbits".
The late pope's unusually open style attracted criticism from some Catholics, but also global interest. His funeral on Saturday and a procession through Rome to his burial place at the Basilica of St. Mary Major attracted crowds estimated at more than 400,000.
German Cardinal Reinhard Marx, one of the leading Catholic prelates in Europe and once a senior adviser to Francis, said the cardinals who will meet in a secret conclave to elect his successor would not be looking for a "functionary".
"We do not need a manager," Marx told reporters. "What's essential is that it be a courageous person... People around the world need to be comforted, lifted up."
Other cardinals are expressing sharp disagreement.
"We need to give the Church back to the Catholics," Italian Cardinal Camillo Ruini told the Corriere della Sera newspaper.
Ruini, who is 94 and too old to enter the conclave, said Francis sometimes appeared to favour those who were distant from the Church, "at the expense" of devout faithful.
Others argue that it is precisely a more managerial pope that is needed at this time to tackle the Church's financial woes, which include a widening budget shortfall and growing liabilities for its pension fund.
CARDINALS' SPEECHES
The cardinals are meeting daily this week to discuss general issues facing the 1.4-billion-member Church before those under the age of 80 enter the conclave on May 7.
As they meet in what are called "general congregations," individual prelates can offer speeches to give their vision for the future of the global faith.
In 2013, Bergoglio, then archbishop of Buenos Aires, offered a short reflection at one such meeting, saying the Church needed to do a better job of opening itself up to the modern world. This, by many accounts, proved decisive for his election.
"Bergoglio gave the speech which led the cardinals to believe that the Holy Spirit had made its choice," said Austen Ivereigh, a biographer of Francis who also wrote a book with the pope in 2020.
"The choice that (Bergoglio) gave them, and the proposal for what the next pope should do, just struck them very, very forcefully," said Ivereigh.
It remains to be seen whether any cardinal can give such a compelling speech this week.
Francis made a priority of appointing cardinals from countries that had never had them, such as Myanmar, Haiti and Rwanda, and many of the roughly 135 cardinals expected to enter the conclave do not know each other well.
They may be looking at Francis as a model and choose another outsider. Or they may look at Francis' own predecessor, Pope Benedict XVI - a consummate insider who worked as a senior Vatican official for nearly two decades before becoming pontiff.
Thavis said he thought the large crowds who came to mourn Francis might affect the cardinals' decision.
"The cardinals witnessed an outpouring of love and respect for Francis," he said. "It's one more reason why the ability to connect with people will weigh more than managerial skills as they make their choice."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Business Insider
34 minutes ago
- Business Insider
US gives conditions for Rwanda-DR Congo peace deal
The United States has set forth critical conditions for facilitating a peace agreement between Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), with a key demand being the complete withdrawal of Rwandan troops from eastern Congo before any formal deal can be signed. The United States has proposed conditions for a peace agreement between Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo Washington is pressuring Rwanda to end military activities in the region to facilitate a sustainable resolution to ongoing conflicts. The U.S. is leveraging mineral investments in the DRC for strategic peace efforts, aiming to stabilize the region and counter foreign influences. Sources familiar with the ongoing negotiations indicate that the United States is exerting significant pressure on Rwanda to cease its military activities in the DRC and conflict-ridden region, which has long been destabilized by armed groups and foreign interventions. This diplomatic effort, led by the U.S., aims to de-escalate hostilities and pave the way for a sustainable resolution to the violence. According to Reuters, a draft version of the proposed peace agreement explicitly states that Rwanda must remove all troops, weapons, and military equipment from Congolese territory as a condition for finalizing the deal. The report has been verified by four diplomatic sources, who confirmed to Reuters that it was authored by U.S. officials. This document marks a substantial step beyond the earlier declaration of principles signed by the foreign ministers of both countries in April during a ceremony in Washington, attended by U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio. That earlier agreement committed the parties to resolving their security disputes in a manner that respects each nation's territorial integrity and sovereignty, but did not include specific withdrawal demands. US leverages mineral access for peace Several months ago, the United States launched a major mineral deal in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) as part of a broader strategy aimed at securing a peace agreement between the DRC and neighboring Rwanda. This move emphasized Washington's deepening diplomatic and economic involvement in a region long plagued by conflict, particularly in the eastern provinces, where immense mineral wealth has historically fueled violence and foreign intervention. The proposed agreement, which would open access for U.S. and allied companies to Congo's rich deposits of critical minerals such as cobalt, coltan, lithium, and gold, is being positioned not simply as an economic transaction, but as a calculated geopolitical instrument. The rationale behind it is straightforward: establishing peace and stability in the region would not only unlock large-scale investment but also curb the expanding influence of global competitors, especially China, in Africa's strategic resource sectors. Rwanda has been accused of backing the M23 rebel forces, while Kigali maintains that the Democratic Republic of Congo is collaborating with armed groups hostile to Rwanda's national security. Political momentum for the peace process gained traction with a high-level visit by President Donald Trump's Adviser for African Affairs, Massad Boulos, who traveled to the region to meet with both Congolese and Rwandan officials. ' You have heard about a minerals agreement. We have reviewed the Congo's proposal. I am happy to announce that the president and I have agreed on a path forward for its development, ' Boulos said following his meeting with Congolese President Félix Tshisekedi in Kinshasa. By linking the withdrawal of foreign troops, particularly those from Rwanda to prospects for peace and economic growth, the United States aims to simultaneously address regional security challenges and promote development.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
US Marines arrive in LA; California governor warns 'democracy under assault'
By Brad Brooks, Phil Stewart, Idrees Ali and Dietrich Knauth LOS ANGELES (Reuters) -Hundreds of U.S. Marines arrived in the Los Angeles area on Tuesday under orders from President Donald Trump, ratcheting up tensions in America's second largest city as California's governor warned "democracy is under assault." Trump's extraordinary measures of sending National Guard and Marines to quell protests, which broke out in response to his immigration raids, fueled demonstrations for a fifth day in Los Angeles, and sparked protests in several other cities. As Trump and California Governor Gavin Newsom traded fulminations, the city's mayor said the protests were limited to about five downtown streets, but declared a curfew for parts of the downtown area due to violence and looting. Police said multiple groups stayed on the streets in some areas despite the curfew and "mass arrests are being initiated". Police earlier said that 197 people had already been arrested on Tuesday - more than double the total number of arrests to date. Democratic leaders have raised concerns over a national crisis in what has become the most intense flashpoint yet in the Trump administration's efforts to deport migrants living in the country illegally, and then crack down on opponents who take to the streets in protest. "This brazen abuse of power by a sitting president inflamed a combustible situation, putting our people, our officers and even our National Guard at risk. That's when the downward spiral began," Newsom said in an a video address. "He again chose escalation. He chose more force. He chose theatrics over public safety. ... Democracy is under assault." Newsom, widely seen as preparing for a presidential run in 2028, has called the deployments an illegal waste of resources. He and the state sued Trump and the Defense Department on Monday, seeking to block the deployment of federal troops. Trump in turn has suggested Newsom should be arrested. Trump, voted back into office last year largely for his promise to deport undocumented immigrants, used a speech honoring soldiers on Tuesday to defend his decision. He told troops at the Army base in Fort Bragg, North Carolina: "Generations of army heroes did not shed their blood on distant shores only to watch our country be destroyed by invasion and third-world lawlessness." "What you're witnessing in California is a full-blown assault on peace, on public order and on national sovereignty, carried out by rioters bearing foreign flags," Trump said, adding his administration would "liberate Los Angeles." UNREST IN THE STREETS Demonstrators have waved the flags of Mexico and other countries in solidarity for the migrants rounded up in a series of intensifying raids. Homeland Security said on Monday its Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) division had arrested 2,000 immigration offenders per day recently, far above the 311 daily average in fiscal year 2024 under former President Joe Biden. Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass on Tuesday announced a curfew for one square mile (2.5 square km) of downtown Los Angeles that will run from 8 p.m. to 6 a.m. locally (0300 to 1300 GMT) for several days. With five minutes until the curfew took effect, hundreds of protesters faced police with their hands raised, chanting "peaceful protest." Even so, state and local officials have called Trump's response an extreme over-reaction to mostly peaceful demonstrations. Bass emphasized at a press conference the distinction between the majority of demonstrators protesting peacefully and a smaller number of agitators she blamed for violence and looting. A curfew had been considered for several days but Bass said she decided to impose one after 23 business were looted on Monday night. "When these peaceful rallies end, and the protesters head home, another element moves in: opportunists, who come in under the cover of a peaceful protest to ravage and destroy," Council member Ysabel Jurado, who represents the area, told reporters. As the mayor and the council member spoke, police and protesters were engaged in skirmishes outside. In what has become a daily ritual, police forced demonstrators away from the streets outside the Metropolitan Detention Center, where many detained migrants are held. Multiple groups of protesters snaked through downtown Los Angeles, monitored or followed by police armed with less lethal munitions. Protests also took place in other cities including New York, Atlanta and Chicago, where demonstrators shouted at and scuffled with officers. Some protesters climbed onto the Picasso sculpture in Daley Plaza, while others chanted that ICE should be abolished. Christina Berger, 39, said it was heartbreaking to hear about children who are afraid of being separated from their families due to immigration raids, adding, "I just want to give some hope to my friends and neighbors." MARINES AT THE READY About 700 Marines were in a staging area in the Seal Beach area about 30 miles (50 km) south of Los Angeles, awaiting deployment to specific locations, a U.S. official said. A U.S. official said there were 2,100 National Guard troops in the Los Angeles area on Tuesday, more than half the 4,000 to be activated. The Marines and National Guard troops lack the authority to makes arrests and will be charged only with protecting federal property and personnel. Even so, California Attorney General Rob Bonta told Reuters the state was concerned about allowing federal troops to protect personnel, saying there was a risk that could violate an 1878 law that generally forbids the U.S. military, including the National Guard, from taking part in civilian law enforcement. "Protecting personnel likely means accompanying ICE agents into communities and neighborhoods, and protecting functions could mean protecting the ICE function of enforcing the immigration law," Bonta said. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Tuesday posted photos on X of National Guard troops accompanying ICE officers on an immigration raid. Trump administration officials have vowed to redouble the immigration raids in response to the street protests.


New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Trump vows to ‘liberate Los Angeles' – slams ‘Third World lawlessness' and ‘rioters bearing foreign flags' in speech to US troops
President Trump on Tuesday vowed to 'liberate Los Angeles' from 'Third World lawlessness' on night five of the anti-ICE riots raging through downtown LA in a fiery speech to US troops. Trump, defending his decision to deploy the National Guard and US Marines to the City of Angels amid violent riots, argued that without the reinforcements, LA would be 'burning' like it did when wildfires swept through Southern California in January. 'Generations of Army heroes did not shed their blood on distant shores only to watch our country be destroyed by invasion and third-world lawlessness, like is happening in California,' Trump told soldiers during a speech at Fort Bragg in North Carolina. 'As commander in chief, I will not let that happen.' Advertisement 6 President Donald Trump stands on stage during a speech in front of service members at Fort Bragg in North Carolina on June 10, 2025. REUTERS 6 Masked protesters line up in front of National Guard troops during protests in Los Angeles on June 10, 2025. Barbara Davidson/NYPost The president declared that the 4,000 Guardsmen and 700 Marines he dispatched to Los Angeles will 'protect federal law enforcement' carrying out his mass deportation order 'from the attacks of a vicious and violent mob.' Advertisement 'If we didn't do it, there wouldn't be a Los Angeles. It would be burning today just like the houses were burning a number of months ago,' Trump argued, referring to the wildfires. 'Within the span of a few decades, Los Angeles has gone from being one of the cleanest, safest, and most beautiful cities on Earth to being a trash heap with entire neighborhoods under the control of transnational gangs and criminal networks,' the president said. 'It's horrible.' 'As the entire world can now see, uncontrolled migration leads to chaos, dysfunction, and disorder.' 'Very simply, we will liberate Los Angeles and make it free, clean, and safe again,' Trump pledged. 'It's happening very quickly.' Advertisement 6 An American flag burns on the ground during protests in the streets of LA on June 8, 2025. AFP via Getty Images Protesters have been clashing with local police and federal authorities in Los Angeles since Friday. The unrest was sparked by Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids targeting criminal illegal immigrants in the sanctuary city, where officials, including Democratic Mayor Karen Bass, refuse to go along with Trump's immigration crackdown. 'What you're witnessing in California is a full-blown assault on peace, on public order and on national sovereignty, carried out by rioters bearing foreign flags,' Trump said. Advertisement 6 Protesters wave a Mexican flag in front of riot police outside a federal building in Los Angeles on June 9, 2025. AFP via Getty Images 6 Vulgar graffiti is spray-painted on the exterior of an Apple store looted during the LA Riots on June 10, 2025. REUTERS Mexican and Palestinian flags have been a ubiquitous presence in the demonstrations and violent rioting that have plagued the city for the last five days. Sen. Tom Cotton (R-Ark.) argued in a Wall Street Journal op-ed that the presence of foreign flags arguably makes the LA riots 'worse' than the unrest that broke out in Minneapolis in 2020 after the death of George Floyd in police custody. The senator called on Trump to consider invoking the seldom-used Insurrection Act of 1807, which would allow US troops to conduct law enforcement activities, to quell the rioting. 6 Mounted police and other riot units enforce a curfew on the streets of Los Angeles on June 10, 2025. Getty Images After Trump's speech, Bass announced that a curfew would go into effect in parts of downtown Los Angeles in response to the violence and looting. 'We reached a tipping point,' Bass said at a news conference, declaring a local emergency after 23 businesses were vandalized Monday night.