If FBI really wants to solve the Gardner art heist, it should include the public
A weekly SCOTUS explainer newsletter by columnist Kimberly Atkins Stohr.
Enter Email
Sign Up
"Three Mounted Jockeys," left, and "La Sortie du Pesage," right, by Degas
Advertisement
"The Concert" by Vermeer
REUTERS
While crowdsourcing has its risks — in the Marathon case, it
Advertisement
The ongoing FBI investigation has mainly focused on a small cohort of criminals from the Boston area with ties to organized crime. As told to Murphy, Kelly's theory is that two petty criminals — George Reissfelder and Leonard DiMuzio — planned to make some quick money and did not understand the gravity of the crime.
With help from one security guard — Richard Abath — they got inside the museum. Kelly also believes the mastermind was Carmello Merlino, a mob associate who ran a repair shop in Dorchester. Reissfelder and DiMuzio died within 18 months of the heist. Merlino, convicted of another crime, died in prison in 2005. Abath, who died in 2024, insisted he had nothing to do with any of it.
"Chez Tortoni" by Manet
AP/Associated Press
Stephen Kurkjian — a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, former Globe colleague, and author of 'Master Thieves: The Boston Gangsters Who Pulled Off The World's Greatest Art Heist' — believes the key to recovering the art is about getting people to understand what it means to Boston and the art world at large.
'The city of Boston has changed immensely since thugs like these roamed the city. If we are deserving of the belief that we are a world-class city, then we've got to trust that the people will respond to a public appeal, of getting those masterpieces back to where they belong, in Mrs. Gardner's museum,' he told me.
Noting that one of the stolen paintings was Rembrandt's only seascape, a biblical tableau called 'Storm on the Sea of Galilee,' Kurkjian said that at one point the museum tried to convince the Vatican or the pope to make a public appeal to get the paintings returned. But Rome declined.
Advertisement
"The Storm on the Sea of Galilee" by Rembrandt
AP
While papal intervention might help, what is really needed are regular citizens who understand what 'Mrs. Gardner's museum' represents — the idea that beauty is something to be shared with everyone, no matter their wealth or social status. When Isabella Stewart Gardner died in 1924, she left a museum
With its peaceful courtyard and rooms filled with treasures, it's a magical place. But it will take more than magic — or another book — to return the missing artwork to its home. It's going to take someone who knows what really happened to trust the FBI enough to share the information — and that means the FBI has to trust the public enough to share what it knows.
Joan Vennochi is a Globe columnist. She can be reached at
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
New Orleans mayor indicted over allegations of trying to hide relationship with bodyguard
New Orleans Mayor Federal Charges NEW ORLEANS (AP) — New Orleans Mayor LaToya Cantrell was indicted Friday in what prosecutors called a yearslong scheme to hide a romantic relationship with her bodyguard, who is accused of being paid as if he was working even when they met alone in apartments and traveled to vineyards for wine tasting. Cantrell faces charges of conspiracy, fraud and obstruction, less than five months before she leaves office due to term limits. The first female mayor in New Orleans' 300-year history was elected twice but now becomes the city's first mayor to be charged while in office. 'Public corruption has crippled us for years and years,' Acting U.S. Attorney Michael Simpson said, referring to Louisiana's notorious history. 'And this is extremely significant.' Cantrell's bodyguard, Jeffrey Vappie, was already facing charges of wire fraud and making false statements. He has pleaded not guilty. A grand jury returned an 18-count indictment Friday that added Cantrell to the case. They're accused of exchanging encrypted messages through WhatsApp to avoid detection and then deleting the conversations. The mayor and Vappie have said their relationship was strictly professional, but the indictment portrayed it as 'personal and intimate.' App captured dreamy chats The mayor's office didn't immediately respond to a phone message or email from The Associated Press seeking comment on the charges Cantrell hasn't sent out a message on her official social media feed on X since July 15, when she said the city was experiencing historic declines in crime. In a WhatsApp exchange, the indictment says, Vappie reminisced about accompanying Cantrell to Scotland in October 2021, saying that was 'where it all started.' Cantrell and Vappie used WhatsApp for more than 15,000 messages, including efforts to harass a citizen, delete evidence, make false statements to FBI agents, 'and ultimately to commit perjury before a federal grand jury,' Simpson said. They met in an apartment while Vappie claimed to be on duty, and she arranged for him to attend 14 trips, Simpson said. The trips, he added, were described by her as times 'when they were truly alone." New Orleans taxpayers paid more than $70,000 for Vappie's travel, the prosecutor said. Together on an island Authorities cited a September 2022 rendezvous on Martha's Vineyard, a trip Cantrell took instead of attending a conference in Miami. Vappie's travel to the island was covered by the city to attend a separate conference. 'The times when we are truly (traveling) is what spoils me the most,' the mayor wrote to him that month. Simpson said Cantrell lied in an affidavit that she activated a function on her phone that automatically deleted messages in 2021 when she really didn't active that feature until December 2022, a month after the media began speculating on the pair's conduct. When a private citizen took photos of them dining together and drinking wine, Cantrell filed a police report and sought a restraining order, Simpson said. Vappie retired from the police department in 2024. Mayor has her defenders Cantrell and her remaining allies have said that she's been unfairly targeted as a Black woman and held to a different standard than male officials, her executive powers at City Hall sabotaged. Simpson, however, shook off claims that any of it played a role in the investigation. 'It's irrelevant that it's romance or that it's female,' he told reporters, adding that the allegations were 'an incredible betrayal of people's confidence in their own government.' Cantrell, a Democrat, has clashed with City Council members during a turbulent second term and survived a recall effort in 2022. 'This is a sad day for the people of New Orleans,' Monet Brignac, a spokesperson for City Council President JP Morrell, said as news of the indictment spread. In 2014, former New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin was sentenced to 10 years in prison for bribery, money laundering, fraud and tax crimes. The charges stemmed from his two terms as mayor from 2002 to 2010. He was granted supervised release from prison in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic. As she heads into her final months in office, Cantrell has alienated former confidants and supporters, and her civic profile has receded. Her early achievements were eclipsed by self-inflicted wounds and bitter feuds with a hostile city council, political observers say. The mayor's role has weakened following voter-approved changes to the city's charter meant to curb her authority. Earlier this year, Cantrell said she's faced 'very disrespectful, insulting, in some cases kind of unimaginable' treatment. Her husband, attorney Jason Cantrell, died in 2023. —- Hollingsworth reported from Mission, Kansas. Ed White in Detroit contributed to this story. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Oklahoma County Sheriff's Office, OSBI wrap up investigation into State Superintendent Ryan Walters
OKLAHOMA CITY (KFOR) — The Oklahoma County Sheriff's Office (OCSO) and the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation (OSBI) have concluded the investigation into State Superintendent Ryan Walters and are turning over their findings to the Oklahoma County District Attorney's Office. OCSO was asked to investigate the allegations by two board members who said that they saw nude women on a TV inside Walters' office during a July state school board meeting. On Tuesday, August 5, House Speaker Kyle Hilber said that a third-party cybersecurity company performed a forensic analysis on the situation and compiled a 32-page report. The report said that the TV was displaying a movie channel that played two movies between 10 a.m. and 1 p.m. on July 24 that had moderate sex and nudity in them. Hilbert: R-rated Jackie Chan movie likely source of nude images seen playing on Walters' TV Hilbert, in a statement, said the finding suggested that the movie playing on Walters' office TV was The Protector, a 1985 R-rated thriller filled with violence, drug use, and multiple scenes of full nudity, followed by the 2017 film, The Foreigner, another R-rated film. On Friday, OCSO posted to social media, announcing they concluded their investigation and will now be turning their findings over to the District Attorney's Office. OSBI has also said that they turned over the investigation to the DA's office. 'OSBI, in conjunction with OCSO have turned over the investigation to the DA's office,' said Hunter McKee with OSBI. It is unclear at this time what the findings are at this time, as both departments have handed over the case to the Oklahoma County District Attorney's Office. 'After a thorough investigation, our office is now turning over its findings to the Oklahoma County District Attorney's Office. Because the case is now in the hands of the DA, we can't discuss the specifics of our findings. At the closure of this case in its entirety, we will discuss the case more in depth,' said Oklahoma County Sheriff Tommie Johnson III in a statement. The District Attorney's Office told News 4 on Friday that there is no timeline as to how long the review will take. 'The DA met with the investigators today. Now our office will review the investigation to determine if charges will be filed or not. There is no timeline on how long that will take,' said Brook Arbeitman, director of communications with the Oklahoma County District Attorney's Office. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Solve the daily Crossword
New York Post
38 minutes ago
- New York Post
Trump administration backs off demand to replace DC police chief — but directs cops to follow federal immigration laws
WASHINGTON — The Trump administration on Friday reversed course and agreed to leave the Washington, D.C., police chief in control of the department, while Attorney General Pam Bondi, in a new memo, directed the District's police to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement 'notwithstanding' city law. Bondi's new order Friday came after officials in the nation's capital sued to block President Donald Trump's takeover of the Washington police. On Thursday night. his administration escalated its intervention into the city's law enforcement by naming a federal official as the new emergency head of the department. The attorney general's new order represents a partial retreat for the Trump administration in the face of intense skepticism from a judge over the legality of Bondi's earlier directive that sought to put the police force under the full control of the federal government. But Bondi also signaled the administration would continue to pressure D.C. leaders to help federal authorities aggressively pursue immigrants in the country illegally, despite city laws on the books that limit cooperation between police and immigration authorities. Advertisement 3 DC Mayor Muriel Bowser, left, and DC Attorney General Brian Schwalb leave court on Friday after suing over the Trump administration's attempt to sideline the district's police chief. AP 3 Chief Pamela Smith will remain in place as the administration backed away from the order. Getty Images The District of Columbia's police chief said Trump's earlier move to sideline her would threaten law and order by upending the command structure. 'In my nearly three decades in law enforcement, I have never seen a single government action that would cause a greater threat to law and order than this dangerous directive,' Chief Pamela Smith said in a court filing. Advertisement The two sides sparred in court for hours Friday before U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes, who is overseeing the lawsuit. She indicated the law likely doesn't grant the Trump administration power to fully take over city police, but it probably does give the president more power than the city might like. 'The way I read the statute, the president can ask, the mayor must provide, but the president can't control,' said Reyes, who was nominated to the bench by Democratic President Joe Biden. The judge asked the two sides to hammer out a compromise, and promised to issue a court order temporarily blocking the administration from naming a new chief if they couldn't agree. An attorney for the Trump administration, Yaakov Roth, said in court that the move to sideline Smith came after an immigration order that still held back some aid to federal authorities. He argued that the president has broad authority to determine what kind of help police in Washington must provide. Advertisement 3 Protesters mass outside the Metropolitan Police Department in DC on Friday. AP Washington officials were pushing in court to halt U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi's order Thursday to put the head of the Drug Enforcement Administration, Terry Cole, in charge of Washington police. The police takeover is the latest move by Trump to test the limits of his legal authorities to carry out his agenda, relying on obscure statutes and a supposed state of emergency to bolster his tough-on-crime message and his plans to speed up the mass deportation of people in the United States illegally.
