Report does not mention it was pilot error: Pilot Federation President on AI-171 crash report
Captain Randhawa dismissed the claims as baseless and vowed to take action against the publication.
Captain CS Randhawa emphasised that the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau's (AAIB) preliminary report makes no mention of the pilots turning off the switches controlling fuel flow to the engines.
"Nowhere in the report has it been mentioned that the fuel control switch was turned off due to the pilot's mistake. I condemn the article. They said it was the pilot's mistake. They have not read the report properly, and we will take action against them through FIP," Captain CS Randhawa told ANI.
He further urged people not to comment on the AAIB's preliminary report, as this may create fear among commuters about air travel.
"We had issued a press statement yesterday that no channel, commentator or president of any agency should give such an opinion that has no basis. The detailed report will take time; till then, people are giving their own opinions without any basis, which is not right," Captain Randhawa added.
"Neither the report nor the Civil Aviation Minister has said that it was pilot error.You must relate this to the incident of ANA NH985, which occurred on January 17, 2019. At the time of landing, when the pilot selected thrust reversers, both engines shut down without the pilot moving the fuel control switch.
I am quite clear that this is a repetition of the TCMA (Throttle Control Malfunction Accommodation) malfunction, and this needs a thorough investigation of the TCMA. Boeing has not taken any action yet and has not even tried to issue a directive that all these aircraft should be checked for TCMA functions. Secondly, there is not a single pilot in the investigation committee," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
3 hours ago
- Indian Express
‘Conditions ripe for catastrophic failure': House panel sounds air safety alarm
In the backdrop of the Air India Express AI 171 crash in Ahmedabad this year, a Parliamentary panel has sounded an unusually sharp warning on the state of India's aviation safety architecture, flagging multiple systemic lapses and calling for urgent reforms. The Standing Committee on Transport, Tourism and Culture, chaired by JD(U) Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Kumar Jha, presented its 380th report on 'Overall Review of Safety in the Civil Aviation Sector' in both Houses of Parliament on Wednesday. While the report itself does not mention the AI 171 crash, committee members discussed it extensively during deliberations and summoned officials of the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) to depose on investigative delays and coordination lapses. 'The rapid expansion of India's civil aviation sector has stretched its regulatory and operational infrastructure to the limits,' the report observes, warning that persistent deficiencies and capacity gaps create 'conditions ripe for a catastrophic failure'. With passenger traffic projected to cross 300 million annually by 2030, the panel warns that unchecked fleet expansion, fatigued workforces, unresolved safety gaps, and outdated infrastructure could converge into 'conditions for future disasters.' Chairman Jha said the report is intended as a 'roadmap for urgent reforms' to restore public confidence. During deliberations, MPs grilled AAIB officials on delays in AI 171's preliminary report and failures to act on earlier safety recommendations, underscoring how the Ahmedabad tragedy continues to shape India's aviation safety priorities. At the heart of the report is a scathing critique of the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), India's principal aviation regulator. The committee warns that the DGCA is 'grossly understaffed to meet international obligations' and risks failing future audits by the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) unless vacancies are filled on priority. Out of 1,063 sanctioned posts, only 553 are filled. Nearly 45% of technical staff are on deputation, leading to 'high attrition and institutional memory loss,' weakening regulatory continuity. India's latest ICAO audit placed it below the global average for effective safety oversight. The panel cautions that, without reform, India could face 'international restrictions on carrier operations', directly affecting the country's growing aviation market. The committee reiterates its long-standing demand to grant DGCA full administrative and financial autonomy and to decouple recruitment from UPSC so the regulator can offer competitive salaries and attract technical experts. The panel devotes significant attention to Air Traffic Control Officers (ATCOs), warning that fatigue among controllers poses a direct and ongoing threat to airspace safety. Evidence before the committee revealed that ATCOs at busy airports like Delhi, Mumbai, Bengaluru, and Hyderabad routinely work prolonged, fatiguing shifts. Many airports operate with merged control sectors at night due to shortages, placing excessive pressure on remaining staff. Calling this practice 'institutionalised overwork,' the panel has demanded an immediate end to exemptions from mandatory duty-time limitations and recommended the creation of a scientifically designed Fatigue Risk Management System (FRMS) for ATCOs. The report also urges a comprehensive airport-wise staffing audit and a significant expansion of ATC training capacity. Currently, training centres accommodate just 210 officers at a time, causing new recruits to wait months before deployment. The report highlights a serious enforcement gap in DGCA's safety oversight, revealing that 3,747 safety deficiencies remain unresolved as of April 2025 — including 37 Level I deficiencies that pose immediate safety risks. The committee criticises DGCA's approach as 'procedural formality without effective deterrence', saying that without strict enforcement, safety findings 'lose their purpose.' It has recommended: After examining four helicopter crashes during the 2025 Char Dham Yatra and 23 incidents since 2021, the committee described India's regulatory structure for helicopter operations as 'confused and dangerous.' At present, several high-risk helicopter services, including pilgrimage operations, are managed by state agencies like the Uttarakhand Civil Aviation Development Authority (UCADA) with limited DGCA oversight. Calling this 'a fractured and ambiguous regulatory command structure,' the panel has recommended: A uniform national framework to bring all helicopter operations under rigorous central supervision. Mandatory terrain-specific training and certification for pilots operating in mountainous regions. A dedicated oversight cell within DGCA to continuously monitor high-altitude helicopter operations nationwide. The report flags a troubling rise in runway incursions, which occurred at a rate of 14.12 per million movements in 2024 — well above the safety target of 9.78. Similar overshoots were noted for loss-of-situational-awareness events and near mid-air collision (AIRPROX) incidents. Despite frequent reviews by the Occurrence Review Board, these events persist, suggesting that lessons from investigations are not translating into operational improvements. The committee recommended mandatory root-cause analyses for every runway incursion and focused remedial programmes for high-risk airports, along with faster installation of fog navigation systems and Instrument Landing Systems at functional airports. The report warns that a punitive regulatory culture is undermining safety by discouraging open reporting. Citing instances where individual ATCOs were fined up to `25 lakh, the committee called for aligning penalties with 'just culture' principles, which distinguish between honest mistakes and negligence. It also recommended creating a legally backed whistleblower protection framework to ensure anonymity, prevent victimisation, and promote a more transparent reporting ecosystem. MRO dependence and strategic vulnerabilities The panel expressed alarm over India's 85% dependence on foreign Maintenance, Repair and Overhaul (MRO) facilities, noting that airlines spend `15,000 crore annually overseas on heavy checks and overhauls. Calling this a 'strategic vulnerability', the report warns that geopolitical disruptions or supply chain shocks could ground India's fleet. Recommendations include: The report criticises the Airports Authority of India (AAI) for lacking a dedicated Member (ATC) on its Board — a recommendation pending since 2006. Calling this absence a 'serious governance failure,' the committee argues that excluding ATC expertise from strategic decision-making 'endangers systemic safety planning.'
United News of India
3 days ago
- United News of India
Biometric enrolment of Myanmar and Bangladesh refugees continues in Mizoram amid challenges
Aizawl, Aug 17 (UNI) Mizoram continues its biometric enrolment process for refugees from Myanmar and Bangladesh, with officials in 11 districts having successfully enrolled 3,073 refugees so far. Despite facing a range of challenges—including technical difficulties and poor internet connectivity in remote areas—officials have been pressing ahead with the enrolment under the 'Foreigners Identification Portal & Biometric Enrolment' (FIP&BE) system, though progress has been slow. While collecting data from refugees in designated relief camps has proven relatively straightforward, the task is far more complicated for those living in private homes, with relatives, or in rented accommodations. Officials have stressed the importance of assistance from local village councils and civil society leaders to help identify and enrol these refugees. A representative from Lawngtlai district in southern Mizoram noted that even in the relief camps, the enrolment process has been hindered by the movement of children who have been sent to continue their education in district headquarters and even in Aizawl, the state capital. These children have had to be temporarily excluded from the data collection, further complicating the process. The biometric process not only collects fingerprints and other biometric data but also includes gathering biographical details such as names, addresses, and employment history both in their home countries and within Mizoram. Although temporary identity cards have already been issued to many refugees, officials are re-enrolling them to verify their current status and ensure accurate records. In Champhai district, which borders Myanmar and has the highest number of refugees, officials reported that 177 refugees have been enrolled so far. Despite over 13,500 refugees being sheltered in the district, progress has been hampered by technical issues with the fingerprint collection machines. The enrolment process only resumed on August 9 after the state home department provided two new machines, which allowed officials to restart the data collection. According to official figures, over 32,000 refugees from Myanmar and more than 2,400 from Bangladesh are currently residing in Mizoram. While Myanmar refugees are scattered across all 11 districts, the majority of the refugees from Bangladesh—mostly from the Chittagong Hill Tracts—are concentrated in southern Mizoram, particularly in Lawngtlai district. Smaller groups can also be found in Lunglei district and in Thenzawl town of Serchhip district in central Mizoram. In Lawngtlai district alone, more than 2,000 refugees from Bangladesh have found shelter, with additional refugees living in Thenzawl (266 people) and Khawmawi village in Lunglei district (63 people). UNI ZS SSP
News18
3 days ago
- News18
Families Demand Transparency And Accountability In Air India Crash Investigation : Attorney Mike
Families Demand Transparency And Accountability In Air India Crash Investigation : Attorney Mike Last Updated: India Videos | US attorney Mike, representing 85 families, tells CNN News18 victims' kin face bureaucratic hurdles in compensation & demand transparency. He calls AAIB's report 'speculative' and warns against unfairly blaming pilots, urging release of full FDR & CVR data. n18oc_india News18 Mobile App -
