China detains female erotica writers in pornography crackdown
BEIJING--Police in China have detained dozens of young women authors in a genre of gay erotica widely known in Asia as 'boys' love' during a nationwide crackdown on online pornography, lawyers and activists familiar with the cases say.
The detentions since March have triggered debate on social media about the limits of free speech and the apparent sexist nature of the crackdown, while stirring sympathy for the authors, many of whom hail from low-income backgrounds.
'I just wanted to earn some money to ease my family's financial burden,' one author of such works wrote in a May 25 post on microblogging platform Weibo before it was deleted.
'I never imagined that 300,000 clicks and 4,000 yuan in royalties accumulated by those obscure words over time would become criminal evidence,' she added, referring to a sum equivalent to about $560.
Police detained the women in the northwestern city of Lanzhou for violating a 2004 obscenity law that can carry jail terms of more than 10 years or life, though legal scholars want it overhauled to reflect changes in internet usage.
The writers, all aged in their 20s and early 30s, published their work on Haitang Literature City, a niche pay-to-read online platform specializing in the erotic fiction genre, popular with women, that features relationships between men.
The website is censored in China and can only be accessed by using virtual private network (VPN) software.
One author detained in April earned royalties of less than 10,000 yuan ($1,400) that supplemented her income from a series of menial jobs, said her defense lawyer, who sought anonymity for fear of police retaliation.
'In a country that emphasizes socialist morality, people's concept of sex is influenced by the prevailing culture, so of course it is linked to freedom of speech,' the lawyer said.
'If these things cannot be written now, wasn't 'Dream of the Red Chamber' also obscene at the time?' they asked, referring to a famous 18th-century Chinese novel.
Some authors may face trial as soon as this autumn if prosecutors decide to press charges, the lawyer added.
Lanzhou police did not reply to a request for comment.
In 2021, China's state media regulator called for the removal of content depicting 'abnormal sexual relationships,' a year after the official People's Daily condemned boys' love novels as 'poison' that could 'mislead young people on gender'.
Reuters was unable to confirm the number of women detained, although lawyers say some were later released on bail. None could be reached for interviews and family members declined to speak, citing safety threats.
In recent weeks, several have written social media posts about their experiences, only for these to be deleted later.
One described being detained by police in front of her university classmates. Others said police interrogated them about their sex lives and sexual orientation.
More than a dozen Chinese lawyers have publicly offered pro bono aid to authors and Haitang readers summoned by police.
China cracks down periodically on content it deems 'immoral', ranging from LGBT-themed social media accounts to 'vulgar' livestreamers and influencers who 'flaunt wealth.'
A crackdown on gay erotica last year saw more than 50 Haitang authors detained or fined by rural police in the eastern province of Anhui, according to lawyers.
One well-known author was jailed in December for 4-1/2 years for earning 1.8 million yuan ($250,000) by publishing 'obscene works,' a court judgment posted online by her husband showed. The user did not respond to a request for comment.
But the latest group of detained authors made just a few thousand yuan from their work, said an activist familiar with several cases who declined to be identified for safety reasons.
In informal conversations, the defense lawyer said, Lanzhou court officials have called the stories 'disgusting and perverted' for their depiction of LGBT relationships.
'These websites are extremely niche and can only be accessed by insiders, whereas vulgar online content involving gambling, porn and minors is everywhere on short-video apps and social media,' one user wrote on the RedNote platform.
Its 'Haitang' hashtag drew more than 205 million views and 1.8 million posts before it was censored in June.
'Men who write pornographic fiction enter the China Writers' Association, whereas women who do the same go to jail,' runs a popular RedNote meme.
Many users said some perpetrators of rape, molestation and domestic violence received lighter sentences than writers of erotica.
'An authoritarian government can only use a one-size-fits-all approach to arrest authors,' feminist activist Li Maizi said of the anti-pornography campaign.
'They should implement a rating system to protect these creators rather than simply erasing them.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yomiuri Shimbun
8 hours ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
Ghost Story Boom Triggered by Social Conditions; Experts Theorize Why People Are Drawn to Ghost Stories
Ghost stories, called 'kaidan' in Japanese, are enjoying a quiet boom in the country. Live performances by popular ghost storytellers attract large crowds, and paperbacks featuring ghost stories are regularly published. Experts say that the boom has been fueled by YouTube and anxiety about the future of society. Popular after COVID-19'I'll share a somewhat strange story.' In March, ghost storyteller Murakami Rock, 47, began speaking slowly to customers under dim, purple-red lighting at Thriller Night, a bar in Tokyo's Kabukicho district that features live ghost storytelling. Murakami's performance opened with a description of a strange experience he heard about from a man in his the story, the man moves into a new apartment in Tokyo and starts to experience strange things in it a few days later. The apartment, which was built on land that had been vacant for nearly 50 years, has something very wrong with it. At one point, the story takes a spine-chilling turn. Murakami's skillful storytelling captivated the audience, who found themselves screaming in terror. The bar's main attraction is that customers can enjoy ghost stories while drinking alcohol. The interior is decorated with eerie Western dolls, skeletons and other creepy items, creating a spooky atmosphere. Every day, the bar attracts many customers wanting to hear ghost stories told live, giving it a reputation for providing 'amazing experiences.' Murakami, who said he was a 'struggling actor,' became a storyteller specializing in ghost stories in 2014. His popularity got a boost thanks to performances that he streamed on YouTube beginning in 2021 during the COVID-19 pandemic.'The response was huge,' Murakami said. 'As soon as the pandemic subsided, the bar started getting many customers.' He is now a highly sought-after ghost storyteller, getting requests to perform from all over the country. The publishing industry is also enjoying the ghost story boom. Takeshobo Co., for example, publishes the 'Takeshobo Kaidan Bunko' (ghost story paperback) series, releasing five books a month. The series specializes in ghost stories that are based on the authors' own experiences or the accounts of others. Yoriko Ogawa, deputy editor-in-chief, explains that ghost-themed videos and ghost story gatherings have become popular since the pandemic. 'Many readers are impressed by the fact that the people who experienced the events actually exist, which gives the events a sense of realness and authenticity,' Ogawa said. Ghost story culture in EdoThe history of ghost stories in Japan started many years ago. Some ghost stories are already found in 'Konjaku Monogatari-shu,' a collection of old tales from the Heian period (794 to late 12th century). Ghost story culture flourished during the Edo period (1603-1867). Some ghost stories were adapted into kabuki plays that gained popularity among common people. 'Yotsuya Kaidan' (The ghost story of Yotsuya) based mainly on rumors that spread in Edo, now Tokyo, is among those stories. According to Prof. Yoshiyuki Iikura, a folklorist at Kokugakuin University who is knowledgeable about ghost stories, death was a frequent occurrence in everyday life during the medieval period due to wars and epidemics. In the era of peace that followed, death became more of a distant concept. As a result, people began to be scared by ghost stories, which relate to death, and even enjoy them for entertainment. Prof. Iikura said: 'Ghost stories didn't flourish during times of war. People only started enjoying them when there was no more immediate threat to their lives.' Many ghost stories from the Edo period, such as 'Yotsuya Kaidan,' feature oppressed women who become ghosts and seek revenge against powerful men. 'Although society in the late Edo period was stable, there was a sense of stagnation, and common people were anxious about the future,' Prof. Iikura said. 'They sought to vent their frustrations through ghost stories.' 'Real-life ghost stories' in 1990s People today may share a mindset of using ghost stories to distract themselves from anxiety. Ghost story researcher Yuki Yoshida, 44, says that the recent boom began in the 1990s, when 'school ghost stories' became popular in books and films. Then 'real-life ghost stories' based on personal experiences emerged and went mainstream. The collapse of the bubble economy, which filled people with anxiety about the future, coincided with the growing popularity of ghost stories. 'Ghost stories depict a mysterious and unstable world,' Yoshida said. 'That's why they resonate with unstable social climates and easily attract people.' He added, 'They evoke a certain sense, suggesting that this world is not the only one, that there might be another world out there.' Awe of deceased in disaster areas Ghost stories have also become an important bridge, connecting the memories of deceased loved ones with the feelings of those living today. Prof. Kiyoshi Kanebishi, an expert of disaster sociology at Kwansei Gakuin University, compiled a book titled 'Yobisamasareru Reisei no Shinsaigaku' (Awakened Spirituality in Earthquake Disaster Studies) with his seminar students and had it published by Shin-yo-sha Publishing Ltd. while working at Tohoku Gakuin University. The book includes accounts of ghost sightings in areas affected by the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake. In Ishinomaki, a city in Miyagi Prefecture affected by the disaster, several taxi drivers said they had 'ghost' passengers after the earthquake. A common thread in these narratives is that the people involved felt Lemore awe or kindness toward the ghosts than fear. Some people have visited the locations where the ghosts are said to have appeared in hopes of sensing the presence of their missing loved ones. 'In disaster-affected areas, ghosts are treated thoughtfully,' Prof. Kanebishi said. 'Unusual phenomena involving the appearance of deceased people are viewed as relatively common events.' One possible reason for the emergence of ghost stories is that the unprecedented quake resulted in a huge number of missing people. Many surviving families have had difficulty sending their loved ones off to the afterlife and calming their souls. 'The feelings of the families of missing people have not settled down,' Prof. Kanebishi said. 'I want people to understand that those in disaster-affected areas have a different perception of ghost stories from the typical perception involving curses and evil spirits.'
Yomiuri Shimbun
14 hours ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
Canada Airdrops Aid into Gaza, Says Israel Violating International Law
Aug 4 (Reuters) – Canada said on Monday it delivered humanitarian assistance through airdrops to Gaza, which has been under a devastating Israeli military assault for almost 22 months, with Ottawa again accusing Israel of violating international law. 'The (Canadian Armed Forces) employed a CC-130J Hercules aircraft to conduct an airdrop of critical humanitarian aid in support of Global Affairs Canada into the Gaza Strip. The air drop consisted of 21,600 pounds of aid,' the Canadian government said in a statement. The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation reported that it was Canadian Armed Forces' first humanitarian airdrop over Gaza using their own aircraft. The Israeli military said 120 food aid packages for Gaza's residents were airdropped by six countries, including Canada. The other five were Jordan, the United Arab Emirates, Egypt, Germany and Belgium. Canada said last week it plans to recognize the State of Palestine at a meeting of the United Nations in September, ratcheting up pressure on Israel as starvation spreads in Gaza. Canada also said on Monday that Israeli restrictions have posed challenges for humanitarian agencies. 'This obstruction of aid is a violation of international humanitarian law and must end immediately,' Canada's government said. The Israeli embassy in Ottawa had no immediate comment. Israel denies accusations of violating international law and blames Hamas for the suffering in Gaza. Israel cut off food supplies to Gaza in March and then lifted that blockade in May – but with restrictions that it said were needed to prevent aid from being diverted to militant groups. President Donald Trump also claimed Hamas militants were stealing food coming into Gaza and selling it. However, Reuters reported late last month that an internal U.S. government analysis found no evidence of systematic theft by Hamas of U.S.-funded humanitarian supplies. Israel says it is taking steps for more aid to reach Gaza's population, including pausing fighting for part of the day in some areas, allowing airdrops and announcing protected routes for aid convoys. The latest bloodshed in the decades-old Israeli-Palestinian conflict was triggered in October 2023 when Hamas attacked Israel, killing 1,200 and taking about 250 hostages, Israeli tallies show. Gaza's health ministry says Israel's subsequent military assault has killed over 60,000 Palestinians. It has also caused a hunger crisis, internally displaced Gaza's entire population and prompted accusations of genocide at the International Court of Justice and of war crimes at the International Criminal Court. Israel denies the accusations.
Japan Today
18 hours ago
- Japan Today
Justice Department to open grand jury probe into Obama officials, source says
FILE PHOTO: Former U.S. President Barack Obama attends the 60th Presidential Inauguration in the Rotunda of the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Monday, Jan. 20, 2025. Julia Demaree Nikhinson/Pool via REUTERS/File Photo By Sarah N. Lynch and Kanishka Singh U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi has directed federal prosecutors to launch a grand jury probe into allegations that members of Democratic former President Barack Obama's administration manufactured intelligence on Russia's interference in the 2016 elections, a source familiar with the matter said on Monday. The Justice Department said late last month it was forming a strike force to assess claims made by Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard about "alleged weaponization of the U.S. intelligence community." Republican U.S. President Donald Trump has leaped on comments from Gabbard in which she threatened to refer Obama administration officials to the Justice Department for prosecution over an intelligence assessment of Russian interference. Fox News first reported that Bondi personally ordered an unnamed federal prosecutor to initiate legal proceedings and the prosecutor is expected to present department evidence to a grand jury, which could consider an indictment if the Justice Department pursued a criminal case. The report cited a letter from Bondi and a source. A DOJ spokesperson declined to comment. Last month, Trump accused Obama of treason, alleging, without providing evidence, that the Democrat led an effort to falsely tie him to Russia and undermine his 2016 presidential campaign. Trump won the 2016 election against Democrat Hillary Clinton. A spokesperson for Obama had denounced Trump's claims, saying "these bizarre allegations are ridiculous and a weak attempt at distraction." Gabbard had declassified documents and said the information she released showed a "treasonous conspiracy" in 2016 by top Obama officials to undermine Trump, claims that Democrats called false and politically motivated. An assessment by the U.S. intelligence community published in January 2017 concluded that Russia, using social media disinformation, hacking, and Russian bot farms, sought to damage Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign and bolster Trump, who won that election. The assessment determined the actual impact was likely limited and showed no evidence that Moscow's efforts actually changed voting outcomes. Russia has denied it attempted to interfere in U.S. elections. © Thomson Reuters 2025.
