Scientists find 'proof' Jesus didn't feed 5,000 with bread and fish
The famous Bible story tells how Jesus managed to feed a crowd of 5,000 with just five loaves and two fish - but now scientists have come up with a new theory
The biblical miracle of Jesus feeding the five thousand with just five loaves and two fishes is well-known, but scientists now reckon it was a natural phenomenon that caused the event. Researchers have been studying Lake Kinneret, also known as the Sea of Galilee in the New Testament, monitoring oxygen levels in the water and wind speed and direction on the surface.
These devices enabled them to cross-reference results with historical accounts of fish die-offs, events which see the sudden mass deaths of fish in a particular region. According to Answeringgenesis.org, their research found short periods of time when winds across the surface of the lake were strong enough to pull oxygen from its depths.
This would result in a sudden die-off. To someone on shore or in a boat, it would appear as a mass number of fish slowly rising to the surface of the lake, allowing them to 'be easily collected by a hungry populace' as described in The Bible.
They believe when Jesus told his weary disciples, who'd fished all night and caught nothing, to throw their nets on the other side of the lake their success was due to a mass die-off.
Matthew 14:13-21 tells the story: 'Now when Jesus heard this, he withdrew from there in a boat to a desolate place by himself. But when the crowds heard it, they followed him on foot from the towns, reports the Mirror US.
'When he went ashore he saw a great crowd, and he had compassion on them and healed their sick. Now when it was evening, the disciples came to him and said, 'This is a desolate place, and the day is now over; send the crowds away to go into the villages and buy food for themselves.
' But Jesus said, 'They need not go away; you give them something to eat'. They said to him, 'We have only five loaves here and two fish.
"'And he said, 'Bring them here to me'.'Then he ordered the crowds to sit down on the grass, and taking the five loaves and the two fish, he looked up to heaven and said a blessing. Then he broke the loaves and gave them to the disciples, and the disciples gave them to the crowds. And they all ate and were satisfied. And they took up 12 baskets full of the broken pieces left over. And those who ate were about five thousand men, besides women and children.'
However, Biblical scholars have disputed the research, saying in the scripture there was no mention of the fish being 'easily caught'.
And they suggested the scientists needed to re-read the passages discussing the miracle.
The Answering Genesis article added: "Jesus simply took the five loaves and two fish, thanked God, broke the loaves, handed everything to his disciples, and the disciples handed the food out. No fish were caught!".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
Hidden 'fingerprints' found in the Bible after thousands of years rewrite the story of the Ark of the Covenant
Scientists have uncovered hidden patterns in the Bible that challenge ancient beliefs about its origins. Using artificial intelligence, they discovered 'fingerprints' in text throughout the Old Testament, suggesting multiple people wrote the stories. The traditional Jewish and Christian understanding is that Moses wrote the first five books of the Old Testament, including stories about creation, Noah's flood and the Ark of the Covenant. The new study found three distinct writing styles with distinct vocabulary, tone and focus areas, suggesting multiple authors and sources contributed to the books over time. Researchers used AI analyzed for 50 chapters across five books, uncovering inconsistencies in language and content, repeated stories, shifts in tone and internal contradictions. The theory that scripture had multiple authors was first proposed more than 200 years ago, but was dismissed due to religions debate, lack of technology and nuances of biblical text. Thomas Römer, a biblical expert from the Collège de France and co-author of the study, told The Times of Israel: 'There are no authors of the Bible in the modern sense. 'The original versions of the scrolls were continuously reworked and rewritten by redactors who added, altered, and sometimes also omitted parts of the former texts.' The traditional Jewish and Christian understanding is that Moses wrote the first five books of the Old Testament. However, the new study has found evidence suggesting that multiple people may have contributed to these texts. While the Bible portrays Moses as a key historical figure, most scholars today view him as a legendary figure, or at least a composite character, rather than a literal historical person. The Old Testament was written over a period of approximately 1000 years, starting roughly around 1400 BC and ending around 400 BC. It is comprised of 39 books, focusing around God's covenant with humanity, His relationship with the Israelites, and the promise of a Messiah who would bring salvation and redemption. In several books, Moses is attributed to writing some passages. Exodus 24:4 reads: 'Moses wrote down all the words of the Lord' A similar passage is found in Deuteronomy 31:9 that states: 'Moses wrote this law and gave it to the priests...' For thousands of years, Jewish and Christian traditions held Moses to be the author because he is the central figure in the books and was seen as a prophet, lawgiver and leader capable of writing such texts. But the new study could change this long-held history. The AI examined patterns in word usage, word frequency, phrases and sentences structures as these are subtle linguistic 'fingerprints' that can reflect different authors or schools of scribes. Beyond confirming the styles, the team extended their AI method to study nine other biblical sections with disputed authorship. These included well-known stories such as the creation narrative, Noah's flood and the Ark of the Covenant accounts. According to the Bible, the Ark of the Covenant was built by the Israelites shortly after they fled Egypt around the 13th century BC. Moses then placed the Ten Commandments inside. The AI algorithm compared these chapters' word usage to the three known styles, revealing new affiliations and helping clarify long-standing scholarly debates. Researchers said this new technique could revolutionize the study of ancient texts, helping to solve other authorship mysteries beyond the Bible, such as texts like the Dead Sea Scrolls or historical documents where authorship is uncertain. The three writing styles were first found when Biblical scholars noticed certain sections of the Old Testament had different vocabulary, themes and ways of writing. The first style, known as the Deuteronomic (D) corpus, focuses on laws, obedience, and clear commands. The second, the Deuteronomistic History (DtrH), narrates Israel's history, emphasizing moral lessons based on faithfulness, and the Priestly (P) style highlights rituals, priesthood and sacred spaces with formal and detailed language. Thomas Römer, a biblical expert from the Collège de France and co-author of the study, told The Times of Israel: 'Deuteronomy refers to the last book of the Torah/Pentateuch. 'There is a wide consensus that the first version of this scroll was written down in the 7th century BCE. The core of this first version was the laws that stipulate that the God of Israel had chosen only one place [Jerusalem] for the sacrificial cult.' He explained that Deuteronomistic History was also re-worked several times. And the Priestly Writings include several texts in Genesis, Exodus and Leviticus. 'These texts were written for the first time around 520 BCE in the context of the reconstruction of the Second Temple,' Römer said. 'The priestly authors and redactors want to show the importance of rituals and the different types of sacrifices.'
Daily Mirror
3 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Bible's plague of locusts explained as scientists discover horrifying reality
Tel Aviv University researchers may have solved an age-old mystery recorded in the Bible - the reason behind locusts forming devastating swarms that have been destroying crops and causing famines since ancient times Researchers at Tel Aviv University have cracked an ancient enigma mentioned in the Bible - what causes locusts to form massive swarms that destroy crops. The team focused on what triggers these usually solitary and harmless insects to drastically change their behaviour and gather into vast migrating swarms, a phenomenon that has puzzled scientists and agriculturalists for ages. These devastating swarms have been destroying crops and causing famines since biblical times, with the Book of Exodus describing locusts as the eighth of ten plagues inflicted on Egypt, where the Israelites were held captive. "They will cover the face of the ground so that it cannot be seen. They will devour what little you have left after the hail, including every tree that is growing in your fields," the scripture recounts. The Tel Aviv University researchers discovered that the gut bacterial composition of a locust, known as the microbiome, undergoes significant changes when the insect becomes part of a larger group, reports the Mirror US. A type of bacteria called Weissella, which is nearly non-existent in the microbiome of solitary locusts, becomes prevalent during the insect's "gregarious phase," which is when they swarm, according to the study's findings. Scientists used a custom-built model to monitor changes in the Weissella bacteria and discovered that swarming enabled the bacteria to spread and infect a large number of locusts, providing a clear evolutionary advantage. Prof. Amir Ayali, who led the study, said: "Our findings do not prove unequivocally that the Weissella bacteria are responsible for the swarming and migration of locusts. The results do however suggest a high probability that the bacteria play an important role in inducing this behaviour - a new hypothesis never previously proposed." Ayali noted the study's findings could have significant implications for the "countless people, animals, and plants all over the globe" still threatened by locust outbreaks. "We hope that this new understanding will drive the development of new means for combating locust outbreaks." Locust swarms can devastate crops and lead to famines. Over the past three years, large areas of Africa, India, and Pakistan have been severely affected by locust swarms. According to Locust Watch, a division of the United Nations' Food and Agriculture Organization, the Desert Locust (Schistocerca gregaria) "is the most destructive migratory pest in the world. "They are ravenous eaters who consume their own weight per day, targeting food crops and forage," it said. A single swarm has "the capacity to consume the same amount of food in one day as 35,000 people," the group added. In 2013, a swarm entered Israel from Egypt. The study from Tel Aviv University was released last month in the peer-reviewed science journal, Environmental Microbiology.
Daily Mail
4 days ago
- Daily Mail
Man who 'died' for 45 minutes during surgery reveals what he saw... it made him question everything
A man who died on the operating table for 45 minutes during his surgery has claimed he saw Jesus standing over him who showed him heaven. Mike McKinsey, from California in the US, experienced the terrifying near-death experience while undergoing surgery to have his appendix removed. In what doctors described as 'the worst case they'd ever seen, the procedure took an unexpected turn, leaving him temporarily 'dead'. This means a person's heart has stopped beating and they've stopped breathing, but they may still be able to be revived. In Mr McKinsey's case, doctors were forced to perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation, or CPR, to restart his heart and bring him back to life, he revealed in a recent viral video posted on the YouTube channel Coming Home. Once 'clinically dead', he said he saw Jesus who he described as looking 'like an Arab man'. Wearing a white robe, the holy figure had 'wavy brown hair' and 'dark greenish-blue eyes', that he said 'looked right into' his soul. When he reached out to take the hand Jesus offered him, he said he was transported to a meadow. He recalled being barefoot in nothing but his surgical gown, standing on 'perfectly manicured' grass—with heightened senses allowing him to take in the moment. Then, as he adjusted his eyes to the white, he said to his right was a bight light which 'all of a sudden starts sending these beams.' 'I felt the surgical room is now replaced with this beautiful warm feeling. All of a sudden somebody is pulling a curtain from my right to my left. 'The white whatever it was—the white fog or veil or the just whiteness gets pulled to the side and now I'm looking at this beautiful scenery.' He described standing on a hill above little flowers with soft petals that moved like they were dancing in the wind—which confused him as there was no wind. 'There's one big gold dome like a capital and there's other smaller gold domes—I mean the city's huge. It is miles apart,' he said. There was 'the most beautiful' sunset he had ever seen and then he noticed one of the tubes 'of white' hit the top of a tree. 'It was like it had a diamond on it because when that thing hit the top of the tree it burst into hundreds of tiny little light streaks. 'Pretty soon the whole mountain is lit with these bursting white beams of light and they kept' which he described as being like 'a big giant firework show. When he looked at the source of the light, he said: 'Jesus says to me "it's the glory of the lord".' This was when he said he knew he couldn't die, and was brought him back to the surgery room. The first thing he remembers is the doctor asking him if he remembered his name or where he was. This was when he realised there were five other people in the room dressed in scrubs and he heard someone say 'he's back'. He realised he must have been resuscitated when he saw a crash cart next to him with one of the resuscitation paddles 'kind of laying aside' and 'chords hanging down'. 'It was obvious somebody had used it. Someone was over there putting them back together—and I thought, oh boy, I did die' he said. He spent 12 days in hospital losing two and a half stone, as he was initially on a liquid diet for six days, before being eventually allowed to eat banana. Mr McKinsey first began to experience health problems in August 2024, when he started to suffer stomach issues while at a wedding, but it wasn't until three days later he went to hospital. It was at the hospital in Ventura, an hour-and-a-half drive to west of Los Angeles, he discovered his appendix had burst—which can be life-threatening. He recalled the medical staff starting the IV, rolling him down the corridor, and saying goodbye to his wife. While, he also doesn't say whether his heart stopped and if so for how long, it is possible to be clinically dead for 45 minutes and survive with a defibrillator. The phenomenon of near-death experiences has fascinated people and experts for millennia, but until recently there had been no scientific explanation. In 2023, Dr Jane Aspell a professor of cognitive neuroscience at Anglia Ruskin University revealed recent research shed light on how the brain generates the experience of one's self—and what happens when it goes wrong. 'There is now strong evidence that out of body experiences, and related experiences, are caused by abnormal functioning in parts of the brain that process and combine signals from our bodies. She explained it may be caused by damage to a vital part of the brain responsible for processing senses and balance. This could explain why those who have come close to death, taken drugs or suffered from a brain injury are among those who have reported out of body experiences. Such accounts have detailed cases of sufferers floating above their body that is lying down beneath them just after a traumatic event or accident. The professor explained recent research shed light on how the brain generates the experience of one's self—and what happens when it goes wrong. The right side of the temporal parietal junction, which sits just above the ear is associated with out of body experiences, Dr Aspell explained. This part of the brain is active during social functions, and needed to process empathy and memory. It also draws on the senses of vision, sound and touch to create a coherent feeling of the self inside the body. Part of the temporal parietal junction, called the vestibular cortex, acts as the balance system in our ears, helping us know where we are in relation to gravity. The vestibular cortex could offer further explanation on out of body experiences, Dr Aspell believes. If this area is not working properly, 'the experience of being one single body might therefore be disrupted,' explained Dr Aspell. If the brain cannot combine information from this balance system with other senses, it can give the feeling of floating above your own body, explained Dr Aspell.
