Parents 'elated' after judge rules schools must provide single-sex toilets
Parents in the Scottish Borders say they feel "elated" after a judge ruled that Scottish schools must provide single-sex toilets for pupils.The local authority had installed only gender neutral toilets at the new Earlston Primary School, which recently opened.Sean Stratford and Leigh Hurley complained to the council about the policy at the school their son had previously attended, but it was rejected.The council conceded that they had a legal obligation to provide male and female facilities at the Court of Session in Edinburgh on Wednesday.
The local authority said it had accepted the argument prior to the hearing and therefore did not defend itself in court.The move comes after judges at the UK Supreme Court last week unanimously ruled that a woman is defined by biological sex under equalities law.
Ms Hurley said she had felt "very emotional and very tearful" since the conclusion of the case."It's felt bittersweet," she told BBC Scotland News."It should never have come this far, we should never have had to do a judicial review."We're grateful to the legal minds that supported us and we're thankful that we got the result that we got."
'It's the law'
Mr Stratford said he was "delighted" but still felt "a bit of anger as to the way we were treated".He added: "It was very clear, and we pointed it out to them that it was very clear. "It's the law. This could have been dealt with at such an early stage."
Ms Hurley said she found out through working at the school that children were allowed to play on the sports teams that matched the gender they identified with.She asked more questions about this policy in the summer of 2023 and discovered that the toilets in the new school would be gender neutral. She said the school had failed to consult parents on this.As well as Earlston, Jedburgh Grammar Campus - also in the Scottish Borders - only has gender neutral toilets.Three new schools being planned and built by Scottish Borders Council are designed to have gender neutral toilets.Wednesday's judgement ruled that mixed-sex schools must have single-sex toilets, but they can have gender neutral toilets in addition to that.BBC Scotland News understands that the Scottish government is confident that the vast majority of schools in Scotland already offer single-sex lavatories.
'Confusing' guidance
Ms Hurley said she received "confusing" guidance from the school after she raised concerns. She said she did not understand how the guidance would work.She added: "We just thought there should be so much more of a holistic approach and I just wanted to understand how we can support everybody."Mr Stratford said they had requested risk and equality impact assessments on the council's decision, but they felt "dismissed" and "treated like we were imbeciles".He said in his view, the law was clear but the council kept referring to Scottish government guidance.
Ms Hurley said it would be better to have three spaces that included a gender neutral option."We just couldn't understand why you had to take away the boy's space and the girl's space," she said. "We didn't understand the need for it."She said the case had cost "a lot of money", but they received some financial backing from For Women Scotland, as well as other donors they did not name."I think we're at a point where schools need more support from the government on this," she added. "You have to get it right for every child."Scottish Borders councillor Julie Pirone said the local authority would be reviewing the toilet provision in all its schools to ensure all children felt safe."It's not a huge review but we need to get it right," she added. "I expect it to be small and minor changes of what we've got because our new schools are absolutely fantastic facilities. "But this will make us pause and have a little rethink on the provision we've got and make sure they fit in with the legislation and the ruling we've had this week."After the court ruling, the Scottish government said it would carefully consider the implications of the judgement.A spokesperson added: "Local authorities have statutory responsibility for the school estate, including provision of toilets."The Scottish government is committed to ensuring that our Transgender Guidance for Schools remains up to date and fit for purpose."As with any significant legal or policy developments, we will consider whether the guidance requires to be updated to reflect upon these."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edinburgh Reporter
an hour ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Sarah Boyack to step down at the election
Sarah Boyack MSP said she will step down at next year's Scottish parliamentary election. Lothians MSP Sarah Boyack who was first elected to The Scottish Parliament in 1999 has announced she will step down at the next election. Ms Boyack has campaigned on many issues, from bus passes to trying to rid the city of 'party flats'. In recent weeks she managed to persuade the First Minister to give her an assurance that the Scottish Government will look at the relatively small amount of cash needed to ensure that Filmhouse will be able to complete all four cinemas before opening at the end of the month. Sarah said: 't has been the honour of my life to serve my community in the Scottish Parliament, but I've decided not to stand in next year's election. 'I am proud of what I achieved both in government & as a local MSP, from introducing free bus passes for the over 60s andnational parks, to pushing the successful campaign to secure a new eye hospital for Edinburgh. 'I am excited to campaign for Scottish Labour in the 2026 election and I will continue to support action to tackle our housing & climate emergencies after my time in Holyrood is done. 'It's been a privilege to serve the people of Lothian.' Labour MSP, Foysol Choudhury, said: 'Sarah has been an outstanding representative for Edinburgh and the Lothians over the past 25 years. A thoughtful and determined voice in Scottish politics, she has led vital portfolios including Culture, Transport, and Net Zero, always standing up for local communities and causes with conviction. Her dedication and leadership have left a lasting impact across the country. 'Since my own election, Sarah has been a tremendous support to me always ready with guidance, encouragement, and a listening ear. In many ways, she supported me like a big sister, and I will always be grateful for the kindness and wisdom she so generously shared. She has long been a respected and influential figure in our Parliament, and her presence will be deeply missed.' Gregor Poynton, Labour MP for Livingston, said: 'Sarah Boyack has been a tireless and passionate champion for Edinburgh, the Lothians, and for Scotland throughout her remarkable career. 'From her ground-breaking work as a Scottish Minister to her dedicated work with communities across the region, including West Lothian and the Almond Valley constituency, Sarah has always put people first. 'Her decision to stand down will not have been easy, but she can look back with real pride on a record of delivering for the Lothians in government and opposition alike. Sarah will be greatly missed at Holyrood and in our party, but I know she will continue to make an invaluable contribution to our movement and our country in the years ahead. 'I wish Sarah all the very best for the future and thank her for everything she has done for our region and for Scottish Labour.' We have loads of photos of Sarah in our library – here is just a selection. Sarah Boyack MSP at Pedal on Parliament 2023. Photo © 2023 Martin P. McAdam Like this: Like Related
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
UK Government promises Edinburgh festivals new investment
He pledged that the Government would work to ensure the city's festivals - which date back to the aftermath of the Second World War - remain at the 'pinnacle' of the global culture scene in the face of growing competition. Read more: He said it was essential for the UK and Scottish governments to work together to tackle concerns over the cost of accommodation for performers and public transport provision during the festivals. Mr Murray said the Government wanted to build on initiatives like an official partnership recently been formed with the Royal Edinburgh Military Tattoo to help promote Scotland around the world. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray at the Filmhouse cinema in Edinburgh, which the UK Government has helped refurbish and restore ahead of its reopening this month. (Image: Ian Georgeson) He stressed the importance of investing in the city's cultural infrastructure, including venues like the Filmhouse cinema, which will reopen next week. The Government has provided the bulk of the funding for a £2m revamp of the Filmhouse, the historic home of the Edinburgh International Film Festival. Edinburgh's festivals have been running since were forced to shut down suddenly in October 2022 after the financial collapse of their operator. The Government has also committed £2m to an ongoing restoration of the King's Theatre, one of the Edinburgh International Festival's key venues, which will reopen next year. The cast of Pentheselia, which was staged at last year's Edinburgh International Festival. (Image: Newsquest) A further £10m has been pledged for a project that will create Edinburgh's first new purpose-built concert hall for a century, which will also host festival performances from 2029. Other major infrastructure projects expected to require funding in the next few years include a refurbishment of Leith Theatre, which was last open permanently in the early 1980s, and an overhaul of the Ross Bandstand, which opened in West Princes Street Gardens in 1935. The work nearing completion at the Filmhouse, which screened its first films in 1979, involves the refurbishment of its café-bar, box office and foyer spaces, while its screening rooms will reopen with a reduced capacity, but with more leg room and more comfortable seats. The Government has provided £1.5m for the project, which was instigated by a group of former Filmhouse employees. A crowdfunding campaign they launched in September 2023 has raised more than £330,000 to date after it was backed by stars including Jack Lowden, Brian Cox, Alan Cumming, Emma Thompson, Dougray Scott, Kate Dickie and Timothy Spall. Speaking during a visit to the Filmhouse, which is due to reopen on June 27, Mr Murray said: 'The Filmhouse is a cultural institution, not just for Edinburgh but for the whole of Scotland. 'It has been refurbished after group of film-lovers who had been involved in the Filmhouse came together after it closed to say: 'We are not going to let this go.' 'Their dreams have come alive and it will reopen for film lovers from all over the world. 'I think the UK has a real role to play in cultural institutions like this. 'They are not just about arts and culture, they are about economic development, jobs, education, skills. 'When you talk to people who have been involved in the Filmhouse project, they've been ushers, they've sold popcorn and they've worked in the box office. 'This is about our cultural heritage. It is really important for both the UK and Scottish governments to invest in these institutions like the Filmhouse and the King's Theatre. 'There is a whole list of things in Edinburgh and right across Scotland of things that have to be done. 'When the doors open at the Filmhouse, people will realise that it is is the kind of thing we have to be putting funding into.' The UK Government has not traditionally supported Edinburgh's festivals, with their public funding coming from the Scottish Government, its agencies Creative Scotland and EventScotland, and Edinburgh City Council. However there was a significant breakthrough two years ago when the then Conservative Government agreed to provide £8.6m for the Edinburgh International Festival and the Fringe. Around £1m has been invested in a "Keep It Fringe Fund," which is supporting 180 artists and companies from across the UK to bring work to the festival this summer, while £6m is ringfenced for a new headquarters for the Fringe Society, the arts charity which oversees the event. It was announced in April that the Scotland Office had formed an official partnership with the Tattoo, which will celebrate its 75th anniversary this year. Announced during the Tartan Week celebrations in New York, the deal will see the Tattoo represented in key 'Brand Scotland' trade missions around the world. The UK Government is now part of a new 'Festivals City Leadership Group,' which was instigated by the city council to help shape the future of Edinburgh's major cultural events over the next five years. Mr Murray pointed out that Edinburgh's festivals had faced competition from festivals within the UK, including in Brighton and Manchester, and as far afield as Australia. He added: 'We are world leaders in festivals in culture in Scotland. Everybody across the world knows that. But we are not alone in having festivals. They have been replicated across the UK and overseas. 'What we are doing in Edinburgh is very much unique and world-leading. But it is going to take a lot of effort to keep them there, so have to work with the festivals to make sure they stay right at the pinnacle of the international cultural scene. 'They are not just Edinburgh's festivals. They are international festivals which happen to be in Edinburgh and we are very lucky to have them here. 'I want to work with the festivals make to sure they don't just stay as they are, but that they can flourish and develop.' Mr Murray, who has been an Edinburgh MP since 2010, suggested the Government wanted to recognise and capitalise on the full range of benefits delivered from Edinburgh's festivals, which were valued at £407m to the economy in 2023. He told The Herald: 'Our cultural organisations are really good door-openers for all sorts of things to do with trade and diplomacy, and to bring people here to enjoy themselves, and to invest, live and work here. 'The festivals are cultural institutions that we should nurture. 'We need to bring new money into them, but there are a whole host of structural things around the festivals that need to be dealt with, for example the cost of accommodation for people coming here, transport and connectivity, and pushing the festivals out of the centre of Edinburgh into more of our communities. 'We are working with them to make sure that we can put in place not just funding, but also the regulatory environment to make sure they can thrive. "It is about both governments working together. We should be working together to make sure we get maximum back for the taxpayer buck when when it is going into these kind of cultural institutions.' Mr Murray said he fully supported calls for Edinburgh's festivals to secure a share of the city's new tourist tax, which will be applied to all bookings in the made for next summer on or after October 1 this year. He added: "The visitor levy is about having visitors contributing a bit into the city in order for the city to give a bit back. That should be going into culture, public realm and connectivity.'
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Scots primary school head under fire after branding Union flag 'offensive or sectarian'
The letter which leaked on social media showed the head raising concerns about the UK's national flag being displayed at an event for parents and guardians. A major row has erupted at a Scots primary school after its headteacher branded the Union flag"potentially offensive or sectarian" i n a letter to parents. The letter which leaked on social media showed the head raising concerns about the UK's national flag being displayed at an event for parents and guardians. As the Scottish Daily Express reports, the incident unfolded at Cross Arthurlie Primary School in East Renfrewshire with the correspondence signed by the headteacher Fiona MacDonald. The official school communication has now gone viral sparking a response from Scots Tory politicians who branded the letter"daft". The criticism has forced council chiefs into an apology over the letter, with education bosses sorry for any "offence and upset" that has been caused. In the letter, the head told families of P7 leavers that the use of a Union flag in images may have been a "mistake." Writing. "Thank you for coming along last night to make the P7 leavers a special event in the life of the school. The children looked fantastic and had a great time. 'Unfortunately the use of the Union flag with staff images on caused some upset at the beginning of the evening. As a school we promote inclusion and acceptance, actively working against potentially offensive or sectarian messaging. Although we recognise this was not the intent we are concerned that others within or beyond the school community may consider that this is something we would encourage. 'I hope this helps everyone understand where mistakes have been made and we can move on enjoying the rest of the end of term celebrations.' East Renfrewshire Council confirmed that the letter is genuine. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. Former Scottish Tory leader Jackson Carlaw, who represents Eastwood in East Renfrewshire, blasted the comments as "deeply offensive." He said: "Let me be clear – to equate the Union Flag with sectarianism is totally unacceptable and deeply offensive to people both locally and across Scotland. 'Having spoken with a senior official at @EastRenCouncil this morning, I expect an urgent response, resolution, and retraction. As a start, the council must issue an unconditional apology. Our national flag is not up for debate – it is a symbol of our tradition, unity as a nation and hope for so many.' A East Renfrewshire spokesperson said: 'It was not the school's intention to imply the Union flag is sectarian and both the Head Teacher and the council apologises for any offence and upset that has been caused to pupils, parents and carers and the wider community. 'All educational establishments in East Renfrewshire should be spaces that are focused on learning, unity, and pride in a diverse British society. We expect our schools to foster an ethos of respect for diverse perspectives and national identity.'
